Military opposition to investing in submarines before WWI - "no place to put survivors"

Somewhere I heard that, before WWI, military bureaucrats objected to spending on submarines. They thought subs would be useless in warfare because "there's nowhere to keep the survivors". Any documentation this is true? It "smells" wrong to me.

1 Answers 2016-05-30

How did American soldiers in WW2 communicate with the french population?

Did a significant amount of the soldiers speak french? Did the french population speak english?

As far as I have understood, being multilingual was not as widespread during WW2 as it is today, yet there are often pictures popping up from WW2 where US soldiers communicate with the french natives, and I am wondering how easily this happened.

Same question goes for German, Dutch and so on as well... Basically any non-english language.

2 Answers 2016-05-30

The Normandy during and after D-Day: asking for reading recommendations

I will spend my holiday in Étretat, France, and I'd like to read about the greater Normandy region and what it was like during the chaotic events following D-Day - maybe even visit some places of interest. Peeking at the wiki book recommendations, I don't see anything particular to that subject, so I'd welcome any insight.

2 Answers 2016-05-30

How common was it in Europe during the medieval ages to not be religious?

2 Answers 2016-05-30

Did medieval knights lift any sort of weight to purposely build strength?

For example did they use small logs to act as a barbell etc.

2 Answers 2016-05-30

How long would it take to build a roman wall against barbarian populations ?

I was thinking, how long would it take to build a typical roman wall like the ones we find in the UK. I realize that it depends on how long it is. But was there usually more troops in the area when the building was done ? How did it work exactly ? Where was the material acquired ?

Thanks!

1 Answers 2016-05-30

At what point is it acceptable to refer to the Eastern Roman Empire as the "Byzantines" ?

I'm really confused about the Byzantine Empire, and I must confess that I'm not really knowledged about it. I believe that I have often read that it is sometimes an exageration to call the Eastern Roman Empire the "Byzantines", as they refered to themselves as Romans, but I see the word used quite a lot, by historians as well.

In this spirit : at which point (in history) is it acceptable, if it does indeed make a difference, to refer to them as the Byzantines ? And of course, why ?

Furthermore, if you have any more infos on the distinction between "Roman Empire" / "Byzantine Empire", I'm all in.

Thanks all !

1 Answers 2016-05-30

How did the Red Cross supply American POWs with American products in German occupied Europe?

Yesterday I was overjoyed to find this interview with my Grandfater talking about his time in Luftstalg-1, it made me wonder how the Red Cross supplyed POWs with American products in Nazi occupied Europe. https://youtu.be/vrprPykwBHM

1 Answers 2016-05-30

What job did you have while studying history in college?

[deleted]

8 Answers 2016-05-30

Are there any known ancient philosophers who talk about Genghis Khan and the way he went about ruling?

Thus far i have only accumulated a short list of relatively modern books written about Khan. Does anyone know quality quotes or translations from the book, 'The Secret History of the Mongols' that provides knowledge about his reign and the way that he went about things? I am also searching for sources that show how he was able to maintain and expand his power throughout his reign. Hence far i have a list of maps depicting his movement throughout Mongolia and the ways in which he expanded.

Any help is appreciated!

4 Answers 2016-05-30

How prominent were archers in ancient India?

reading on their epic/myth, it seem that, unlike most other places where most heroes use swords, the greatest heroes and deities of ancient India myths were archers like Arjuna, Abhimanyu, Eklavya, Karna, Bhishma, Drona, Parashurama Rama, and Shiva.

I wonder if it because in India archer were prominent and effective, and thus, more highly regarded than swordman?

2 Answers 2016-05-30

Prior to early modernity, were the Romans unique in being able to turn lads from common backgrounds (as opposed to self-equipped rich guys) into professional infantrymen?

The US Marine Corps can take some dirt poor kid from West Virginia or the South Bronx and turn him into a full-fledged US Marine in under a year, which if you think about it, is quite a feat. Was Rome the only other power, prior to the onset of early modernity (when plate armor became useless against bullets and large standing armies became the rule), who could do that?

What am I missing here?

Edit: yikes! Didn't mean to tag this as "childhood." I think it did it automatically?

2 Answers 2016-05-30

Why did White Russians and Soviet troops fight together in the Xianjiang invasion?

The Wikipedia article about the Soviet invasion of Xianjiang in 1934 (to prop up a pro-Soviet warlord) mentions that Soviet and White Russian troops fought together, and even jointly occupied cities.

What motivation did these two bitter enemies have for joining forces? How did Soviet propaganda explain this to their troops? What was the eventual fate of these White Russians - did they join forces with the Nazis/Japanese after Barbarossa?

2 Answers 2016-05-30

Romans and Lead - how much did they actually know?

I ask because of conflicting mentions (though admittedly mostly in passing) of how Romans perceived lead.

In a SciShow episode on lead, the host mentions that ancient Romans would use lead as an artificial sweetener for their wine, as the metal binds to the same taste receptors as sugar. But I've recently gone to a museum exhibit about Pompeii, where they had a display about women's beauty products from Roman times, and the display mentioned that Roman women used lead-based skin powders "despite knowing how dangerous lead was to health".

Did the Romans really sweeten their wine with lead? Did they ever figure out it was suicidal to do so? And did roman women really use lead-based beauty products while knowing the risks to their lives?

1 Answers 2016-05-30

Freedom of movement before WWI...?

One of my uncles once told me that his Great Father (my Great Great Father) when was young (I suppose that was between 1880-1910) traveled in different parts of Europe (Central and South Eastern, Italy, Greece, Turkey) without much difficulty. Occasionally he had to show his passport, but there were generally no barriers to movement.

Can you tell me something more about this phenomenon? Was it because the role of the different governments at the time was not so expanded and intrusive in the life of individuals, or was is because of the big powers that dominated Europe during that period that made borders irrelevant?

1 Answers 2016-05-30

I once read that Hitler did not want Spain to join the second world war because he thought Franco was incompetent. Is this true and what examples of his incompetence are there?

2 Answers 2016-05-30

What are the oldest British families for which we have a record? Can some of them trace their ancestry to the pre-Norman era?

I know most of the people in Great Britain have ancestry among the pre-Norman population (and among the pre-AngloSaxon and pre-Roman, apparently genetic studies have shown that the 'original' population never really was eliminated). But I'm asking about those (presumably noble) families who might actually trace their linage based on some written proof, land claims etc.

2 Answers 2016-05-30

What turned human society into a patriarchal one instead of a matriarchal one?

There's a more or less patriarchal dominance in societies(varies with region & time/age), but what facilitated this?

2 Answers 2016-05-30

Memorial Day in the United States and Civil Wars around the World

The American Civil War and how both sides have honored their dead have been relatively controversial. Especially with the rise of the Lost Cause around the turn of the century.

In other countries around the world, have their been equally controversial celebrations or memorializations of the losing side? Off the top of my head I am thinking of the Irish insurrections that have occurred over the years but i would be curious if anyone had other insight.

2 Answers 2016-05-30

I often hear the humans can outrun/outwalk a horse over long distances What was a typical daily/weekly travel range of pre-mechanized cavalry unit vs that of an infantry unit? Is there any work that compares these numbers between different cultures?

1 Answers 2016-05-30

Where did the idea that Stepmothers are evil orginate? What is the oldest mention of an evil stepmom?

3 Answers 2016-05-30

Given the barbarity of both world wars, what restricted various actors from using chemical and biological agents in WW2 (especially E. front)?

2 Answers 2016-05-30

Why were there so many historical-themed, often patriotic, realist paintings produced from the 1870s to 1890s?

Such as Reply of the Zaparozhians, La Rendición de Granada, and The proclamation of the German empire.

Were they produced as propaganda, or did the artists of the time just take an interest in the history of their nations?

1 Answers 2016-05-30

[Serious] How old is the oldest fart joke?

Looking at this thread/post, I wondered how much of old art had really dirty jokes. And then the universal laugh, the fart joke. I wanted to know the oldest recorded fart joke.

2 Answers 2016-05-30

HEAT vs APDSFS use differences in Late Cold War-Modern Era?

Clarification:
After Composites and ERA became norm, HEAT effectiveness is greatly diminished. Why still the HEAT is effective(and used) by tank forces when APDSFS is in use?
For lighter targets or because it has the HE part that causes additional damage?
Maybe cost?

edit:I mean that the HE causes damage outside the vehicle(nearby infantry and/or hardware on vehicle) not more damage inside,also I know about the DU fire starting properties in APDSFS' when it penetrates.

1 Answers 2016-05-30

4231 / 7255

Back to start