I have always been told that Heian-Kyo was built with references to the then Tang Dynasty's capital Chang'an, though I often did not see any supporting evidences following such claims. Looking at maps found online, they do share some resemblance in the squares and grids dividing the city, but that sort of layout is not exactly outlandish.
If such modelling did exist, was it an isolated incident only unique to Heian-Kyo, or was it something common during that period of time?
1 Answers 2021-12-15
The vast difference in size and strength would surely result in them being killed?
Or perhaps swordsmanship would balance out the fight?
What was really expected of these young boys when it came to close quarter fighting?
1 Answers 2021-12-15
2 Answers 2021-12-15
Alternatively, am I misunderstanding the argument? It was mentioned while my professor discussed marriage among peasants in Reformation Europe.
2 Answers 2021-12-15
So I was reading How Rome Fell by Adrian Goldsworthy when I came across this line, “Pertinax’s son, who had been too young and unimportant to be worth killing in 194, died now, because he could not resist making a pun referring to the murder of Geta.” (Goldsworthy 71) and stopped. Two questions really. First and obviously did this actually happened. And two what was the dreaded pun that earned Pertinax’s son his PUNishment.
1 Answers 2021-12-15
In the 1500s the Spanish Tercios were some of the best organized, equipped, and disciplined soldiers in all of Europe. Truly a modern and capable fighting unit.
However they seemed to face a lot of struggles in the Thirty Years War, especially against Sweden. They seemed to lose relevance after that, until by the early 1700s they weren’t that formidable anymore.
What caused this gradual decline of the Tercio? Why couldn’t they modernize and keep with the times?
1 Answers 2021-12-15
To clarify - I recognize the type of aircraft may affect the difficulty of return as well as the theatre. I'm mostly interested in the most unlikely of returns becoming successful, whether, however unlikely, that of a Japenese pilot somehow returning after being shot over Midway only to see their home carrier in flames, or that of a bomber pilot shot down carrying out Operation Chastise over German industrial heartland making it back across the Channel. A reconnaisance pilot going a few kilometers too far, or a close air support pilot landing in a forest just behind a frontline. What are their stories?
I can't quite find any successful return stories but I'm sure there must be some really interesting cases of avoiding enemies across hundreds of kilometers of land, and sometimes perhaps water that make for an interesting answer.
1 Answers 2021-12-15
I'm writing this story that takes place in a world very inspired by the Roman Empire, and there's supposed to be a child of a father who's been out at war for a few years. Could something like that feasibly happen in Roman times? What would happen to the mother, or the kids?
2 Answers 2021-12-15
This post is an attempt to find some answers as a follow-up of me having this long debate about Arabs and niqab. As I was trying to make a full picture of the origins of niqab, I'm getting a bit lost when trying to track down the location/ culture where the face-veil firstly appear.
The oldest historical proofs that mention this custom/ necessity seem to be found in the Ancient Greek, around 700-500 B.C in form of some terracotta depicting women wearing face-veils (authors Lloyd Llewellyn-Jones and Caroline Galt). Another someway proof (some say that it is a face-veil) is the brief mention of Kamal Dib in an interview with some Canadian magazine (https://ottawasun.com/2015/09/26/the-history-of-the-niqab) where he says, quote: " They found a statue of two young women from Iraq going back 5,000 years. Both of them had covers on their head ", but I cannot find any evidence of this statue on the internet.
There is a statue of Inanna, the Sumerian goddess, depicting her with a veil, but not a face veil - around 4000B.C. More than that, in the same area, the Hammurabi law (around 1700BC) and the Assyrian law (around 1100BC) also bring into discussion the veil, but again, it is a head veil.
As per Kamal Dib observation in the interview, I was also expecting that the face-veil got to be an outfit element based on the need to cover/protect from the weather or climate of the local area. Following this logical path, I was expecting that the face-veil (along with head veil) to be something that was part of the individual's headgear as he was living in harsh conditions, as Arabs do (sand storms, heat etc) and that it has its origin long before being imposed by society or religion, but again, I couldn't find anything that can back me up on this. In my defence, the Bedouins still wear such protection so it seems logical this assumption.
More than that, the Middle East and the Arabian Peninsula were long time inhabited comparing to the Europe if we think of the human expansion (two times crossed from Africa to Asia). Also, the Arabian Peninsula and the Middle East people were being part of the same group of people, Semitic people, meaning that there are big chances of sharing the same culture in terms of what they wear. If this is not valid, the later cultures as Babylon Empire, Assyrian Empire, Hittite Empire were their neighbours or some Arabian North Peninsula were part of their land, meaning that these empires could have had a great impact in having the pagan Arabs adopting their Gods and customs. So, if their is some proof that face-veiling was something originating from this part of the world, then the Arabs would have adopted it as part of their culture (would they?)
In conclusion, although it sounds perfectly logical for me that the niqab or face-veiling was for the Arabs either a necessity or was some early cultural adoption of the oldest world's cultures found in their vicinity (hence, this region to be the first to have a face-veil), I have found 0 proof to support my assumptions. As all this is refuted by the lack of proof, I have no other way than to accept that the Greek culture was the first of practising the face-veil. Curios thing about Greeks is that, even Lloyd Llewellyn-Jones says: "Greece is to be regarded as a Western branch of the old civilizations of Hatti, Mitanni, Babylon, Assyria, and the Levant, sharing in their cerebral processes and material to such an extent that some modern hellenists are coming to regard Greece merely as a colony of the Near East.” ²²"
P.S For me, the today niqab is some combination of face protection (necessity) and religion/ culture pressure, leading it to its final form of today (a niqab + hijab = modern niqab)
Later Edit: I'm trying to find if what my interlocutor is saying (that Arabs adopted the face-veil from Greeks/ Romans) is true or that the face-veil was long time part of the Arabs heritage, from the time when they were polytheists or long time before this.
1 Answers 2021-12-14
1 Answers 2021-12-14
2 Answers 2021-12-14
It seems to me that, water purification not being what it is now until relatively recently, and ale, wine, mead, etc. being common drinks, is it unfair to look at historical decisions as being made largely by an upper / ruling class that was subsisting quite a bit on alcohol? Does this come into historical considerations at all?
1 Answers 2021-12-14
I was just watching a series on Netflix which mentioned the Weißensee Cemetery in Berlin, a massive Jewish cemetery established in the late 1800s, and containing over 100,000 graves.
This is a huge plot (over 100 acres), and in prime position in Berlin. Why didn’t the Nazis destroy and repurpose this land, considering the other atrocities they committed?
1 Answers 2021-12-14
i tested positive for covid this morning, and i’ve been thinking a lot about previous pandemics in my self isolation, how did they ever kill the viruses off?? especially the ones centuries ago when they thought it was a curse from god. like so many people lived so packed together and in such bad conditions, it’s insane that they managed to recover from things like the black death at all! like didn’t that virus in particular only last in england about 2 or 3 years? how is it that covid is probably going to last longer when we have far better knowledge of how to treat it?
1 Answers 2021-12-14
I suppose I am wondering if the outcome/response to the Hiroshima/Nagasaki atomic bombings would have been the same had they been dropped in a remote nearby location instead. Would Japan have recognised the potential of the bombs and responded the same way?
I don't know if this is a question for HistoryWhatIf, but I am mostly wondering if it was considered essential to drop the bombs on those cities as opposed to less populated area.
2 Answers 2021-12-14
In greeting/conversation, what title would Caesar's men and others have used for him? ? For example, Marc Antony would've been "General Antony" or the Latin equivalent of the time, I assume? So what would Caesar's respective title have been during his time in Gaul and prior?
1 Answers 2021-12-14
So, I have read about this story on multiple occasions in a day-to-day-calendar called "Things not listed in encyclopedias" that's actually aimed at children, which I read while breakfast. However, no sources are given. Once, a German comedian told it too.
The story goes like this:
When Max Planck discovered the effects of quantum physics for which he later got a Nobel price, he traveled through Germany and gave public speeches about it. Cars were new back then and so -- lacking a driver license and a car -- he got a driver, who would sit in the audience, listening to his talk over and over again, until he knew everything by heart.
They figured out that nobody knew how Planck actually looked like, and started to play a joke where the driver would give the speech, while Planck himself would sit in the audience with the driver's cap.
The driver knew most things by heart and also most answers to the most common questions.
Once, when giving a talk in Munich, the driver was presented a question he never heard before and said "I would've never thought that someone from the University in Munich would ask such a trivial question. My driver can answer this."
Does this story have any authenticity?
1 Answers 2021-12-14
I find these concepts easy to grasp at an extremely superficial level, and then as follow-up questions are asked it becomes increasingly difficult to summarize and explain them.
There must be a textbook, monograph, book chapter, or journal article by a medieval historian that provides the best and clearest description of Feudalism and Manorialism.
Where should one go for this?
2 Answers 2021-12-14
Just something that's always cropped up in my various readings is the fact that romanian is a romance language with some routes in Latin. Now I know about the 4th crusade that conquered the region and gave it the name Romania. However what's always puzzled me is that they were only there for one or two hundred years. Was that really enough time to ingrain latin into the local dialect so much or was there some other reason.
Thanks
1 Answers 2021-12-14
1 Answers 2021-12-14
Lamarck is best known as the butt of biology class jokes for his theory of inheritance of acquired characteristics. Often his ideas are dismissed as obviously wrong based on the observation that animals that lost a leg in life still have offspring with four appendages. Lamarck would have observed this as well, so what were his actual views on evolution?
1 Answers 2021-12-14