I just watched a particularly hand-wavy video on a conspiracy theory stating that the German Nazi regime (WWII) was an American business idea. I'm not buying it, but I don't know enough about it to dispute it point-by-point.

For reference: https://www.facebook.com/EvolvePolitics/videos/1666350230283584/

For my own part, I discredit it completely since it offers no real sources, and instead rely on weak phrases such as "there were stories of".

Obviously, I find this very hard to believe, but from past experience, I know that if I try to dive headfirst into a debate here, my lack of actual knowledge in this area will see me making a fool of myself at some point. Or I might get stumped by an argument which carries no real weight.

Question

Is there any truth to these allegations? Or more importantly, are there any particular documented proofs that would instantly discredit the video entirely?

3 Answers 2016-04-28

Is the omission of the "Slaughter of the Innocents" from Josephus' biographical account of King Herod enough to doubt the historicity of the story?

Is this omission enough to doubt the historicity of the story, or is there more evidence? Couldn't there by various reasons for the omission, thus not serving as proof for it being fictitious?

1 Answers 2016-04-28

Does the Illuminati still exist today?

1 Answers 2016-04-28

Was Mutually Assured Destruction the main thing that prevented a major war during the cold war, or was that propaganda to justify nuclear weapons.

Just saw this argument on /r/worldnews, and I wanted to see a more professional viewpoint of it. I see compelling arguments for both sides.

From what I've read about the cold war, proxy wars and spreading capitalist and communist ideas to newly decolonized states in Asia and Africa was always more important than an outright war between the two nations, especially after Stalin and Khrushchev's will for coexistence. So to me, it would look like they had no real reason to have an all out war anyway. But given the few times the USSR and America nearly went to war (Yom Kippur War, October 27 1962 incidents), it seems as if MAD played a big role in preventing these incidents become full blown wars.

But again, I'd love to see a professional's point of view here and for someone to correct me and go much more in depth, thanks!

2 Answers 2016-04-28

Were there any major technological innovations during the "Dark Ages" (500 to 1000 C.E)?

I'm specifically interested in agricultural innovations but I am still interested in other types of innovations too. Also the innovations should be in Europe, sorry for not specifying that.

1 Answers 2016-04-28

What was the average age for a bride in medieval Europe?

Was someone under 15 considered ready to consummate a marriage?

1 Answers 2016-04-28

Mourning Practices in Ancient Egypt

For the sake of narrowing things down, I'm interested in the late Bronze Age, if possible.

I'm familiar with the report by Herodotus that to mourn a cat, they'd shave their eyebrows, or to mourn a dog they'd shave their head/body. But what about to mourn a parent? Or a child? Or the pharaoh? And would there be different degrees of mourning depending on what your place in society was? That is, would a princess mourn in a different manner than a slave?

1 Answers 2016-04-28

Looking for books on the Meiji Restoration

I am trying to brush up on the Meiji Restoration and recommendations would be greatly appreciated.

1 Answers 2016-04-28

Were there any conflicts between Greeks and Phoenicians ?

2 Answers 2016-04-28

If a roman person raised their index and middle finger to form a V, would this indicate 2 or 5 of something to other romans?

1 Answers 2016-04-28

What do these symbols mean?

My grandma asked if i could find out what these symbols mean. I thought I would see if anyone here could help me out. She told me they were Mayan. Imgur

1 Answers 2016-04-28

How dangerous would someone like The Mountain from Game of Thrones be as a knight?

Would his size and strength be offset by other factors? Are there stories of similar kind of fighters, and if so, how did they fare?

2 Answers 2016-04-28

Theory Thursday | Academic/Professional History Free-for-All

Previous weeks!

This week, ending in April 28 2016:

Today's thread is for open discussion of:

  • History in the academy

  • Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries

  • Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application

  • Philosophy of history

  • And so on

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

6 Answers 2016-04-28

Did Alexander Hamilton really offer a chance to buy his silence for $8000 a month?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-04-28

Been seeing a little mouse pop up in some political cartons on the Tampico Incident I'm analyzing. What does the mouse symbolize, Mexico?

1 Answers 2016-04-28

Did Hitler plan to deport Jews to Palestine in 1932?

Ken Livingstone was just suspended from the UK Labour Party to making allegations that this was the case, in the face of a "anti-semitism" debacle within the party. Politics and allegations aside, do his claims have a historical basis? Or is it more complicated than simply "Yes" or "No"?

The allegations are currently on the front page of BBC News if anyone wants to check what he said regarding this.

3 Answers 2016-04-28

Is there any evidence supporting that the Korean and Japanese peoples were originally migrants from inland Asia with proto Sinic/Turkic/Mongolic cultures?

1 Answers 2016-04-28

Why aren't the assassinations of James A. Garfield and William McKinley discussed as much as those of Lincoln and Kennedy?

3 Answers 2016-04-28

Did members of the Irish Republican Army receive pay for volunteering?

Hi, I'm an Irish historian from Belfast who's primarily interested in studying nationalist and republican politics and groups in the North from the beginning of partition to the start of the Troublles (1922-1969).

I've met many former Volunteers in my time, but I was never able to find out if they were paid a salary.

I know that the UVF & UDA paid their Volunteers, through money from protection rackets etc, but I was wondering about the case in Republican/Nationalist groups.

1 Answers 2016-04-28

How were people not constantly dehydrated before modern plumbing?

Today we are told to drink so much water that our output is almost clear. But, this is only possible because fresh, clean water is readily available to us at any time. Even I notice I get dehydrated and fatigued easily if I don't drink more than one or two big glasses a day, even on days when I'm less active. Before the days of sanitation, I know that many people drank beer, even children, which probably only made dehydration worse. This is compounded with the fact that most people were generally much more physically active in their daily lives and wore many layers of clothing, even in hot months. How did they keep their energy levels up to do the constant work needed to survive in those days without those oversized sports bottles we have today?

3 Answers 2016-04-28

Why didn't the UK become federal?

Why have former British colonies/territories like Australia, Canada, India and the USA become federal countries while the UK itself remained unitary?

2 Answers 2016-04-28

How did soldiers clean their mail armours (chain mail)?

Was the process of rolling the armour in a barrel full of sand really used? Do we know other methods?

2 Answers 2016-04-28

Why is there a town named Essen in Germany?

Started learning German a bit ago with pimsluer, and realized you can food your food, it wasn't that funny until I realized you could food your food in a city named food

I am mostly wondering how such a bizarre name came to be, and also, if availible, the public opinion on this name, especially during the urbanization during its industrial revolution.

1 Answers 2016-04-28

What did the Industrial Revolution look like in France and England? We're there differences?

1 Answers 2016-04-28

Can someone tell me what the punic war was about??

I've gotten really into old wars and came across this war called the Punic war and wanted to know if anyone can tell me something about it?

2 Answers 2016-04-28

4317 / 7255

Back to start