Why didn't japan Occupy Hawaii??

During the assault on pearl harbor, Japan was clearly in the advantageous position to claim a piece of U.S. territory, what I'm confused on is to why they decided to retreat and fall back, wouldn't have been better to go with the momentum and attempt an assault upon California??

3 Answers 2016-04-07

What responsibility should we assign to Eastern European, non-German, nations for the Holocaust?

1 Answers 2016-04-07

Was there any use of trenches before the gunpowder?

1 Answers 2016-04-07

What was Okinawan relations with China, Korea, and Japan like before it was annexed?

1 Answers 2016-04-07

Is there substantial evidence to support the idea that Hitler escaped to Argentina after the fall of Berlin?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-04-07

What are the Germanic names for Rome, Italy and for the Roman Empire?

If Constantinople is called Miklagard by the Norse, then what does the various Germanic languages (Norse, Swedish, Norwegian, Danish, German, Lombard, Suebi, English, Anglo-Saxon, Saxon, Frisian, Dutch, Visigothic and Ashkenazi (I know that Ashkenazi is not a German language and that their language is Yiddish. But, I am talking about German Ashkenazis)) call "Rome", "Italy" and the "Roman Empire"?

2 Answers 2016-04-07

What did Italians typically eat before the tomato and potato were brought from America?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2016-04-07

What did the proceedings of a criminal case in a British court c. 1810-1820 look like?

A book I've been reading touches on some legal matters, but kind of glosses over just what the nature of a court proceeding really was at the time. From what I did gather though, I have a few questions:

  • It seems like there were very few public prosecutors. Would a family have to pay a private prosecutor to proceed with a case in this situation? Could the entire process from indictment onwards be handled privately?

  • When it came to indictments, how often did the state actually move to do so? There was a lot of talk about "coroner's juries" indicting in homicides. There was also mention of grand juries, but would these be similar to what we have today?

  • On that note, it mentioned grand juries were usually composed of the gentry, while the petit jury was usually tradesmen and other middle-class sorts. Was this always true, and why the difference?

  • It seems like prosecution was very constrained, and that the kinds of evidence and supposition on motives and the like were simply not allowed, but again, the book was pretty vague there. So how was things like evidence, motive, and the like handled?

Anyways, this is kind of disjointed I know, and while those were some specific things I noted, really, anything about criminal procedure in the period would be of great interest.

Also a pre-emptive follow up, but how similar would it have looked to prosecution in an American court room? Had the legal systems diverged sufficiently at that point for things to have developed separately?

1 Answers 2016-04-07

Do holocaust 'revisionists' have any legitimacy with regards to arguments over the death toll?

As a disclaimer, I'm not a holohoaxer by any means and find the whole group of them pretty abhorrent. All I want to know is whether there is any truth to the claims that the 6m figure of Jews and the 11m total is too high, just so if the opportunity arises I can educate anyone spreading misinformation in real life or online.

Many thanks

2 Answers 2016-04-07

Imperial Germany's policies towards the Polish speaking minorities before 1914

Was speaking today about Imperial Germany's policies and a guy said their policies were civic based. But surely they were ethnic? He didn't say anything after but I thought it was interesting.

Forced Germanisation and the Kulterkampf laws restricted the Polish culture and language, as well as ethnic cleansing by Bismarck in the 1880s deportations. In 1908, Germany legalised eviction of Poles from their properties. Core was ethnic in my eyes.

Anyone else think civic?

3 Answers 2016-04-07

Does the concept of a "Dark Age" exist within other historiographic traditions such as in Islam and China similar to Europe? For example would the Chinese consider the aftermath of the Tang collapse to a "Dark Age" similar to how Europeans view the fall of Rome?

2 Answers 2016-04-07

In English the words "Panther" and "Panzer" are pronounced similarly. In 1944-1945 were there (m)any miscommunications or misidentifications of German tanks by Allied forces?

1 Answers 2016-04-07

Why were Japanese kimonos popular in Germany in the late 17th Century?

Here are paintings of Bach's father Johann Ambrosius and composer Johann Adam Reincken (seated at harpsichord) wearing them. Were they imported from Japan, or just imitation of the fashion? Were they stylish elsewhere in Europe during this time?

2 Answers 2016-04-07

The Bristish History or The History of England podcast

Hi, I just finished the last episode of The History of Byzantium podcast and want to continue with British history but there are two podcasts mentioned in the title. Which one would you recommend?

3 Answers 2016-04-07

Objective of US/UN counteroffensive past the 38th p. in Korea?

hey folks I'm having a hard time piecing together an answer to the above - just what exactly were the allied forces trying to do? Like, politically, what was their objective, what was their endgame

was reunification ever the explicit goal? or was it just a possibility entertained by some but never expressed? or was it just a general pursuit of the NK forces? or was there no specific objective?

1 Answers 2016-04-07

Are there any examples of typos in history? Specifically with regard to messages carved in stone.

Today's Now I Know by Dan Lewis is about a typo engraved in stone at the Lincoln Memorial (here is a link to the article). Essentially, when carving a copy of his second inaugural address into the marble, someone wrote EUTURE instead of FUTURE.

Are there any other examples of carved in stone typos like this? Places where what you're writing is meant to be permanent for everyone to see, so it's difficult to change what's been written, but you've accidentally made a typo.

1 Answers 2016-04-07

Evolution of arming/long/two handed swords. When were they used?

hello everyone

i'm somewhat aware about how there are several types of swords, how there is that oakeshott typology thingamajig and i have this very basic idea about arming swords being one handed (and used with a shield?), long swords being used with two hands (but also with one? like those dastardly bastard swords?) and two handed swords being much bigger and longer and a later addition (used by those fancy pants wearing dudes with rad colorful clothes)

my question is - how much overlap has there been, what's the "sword timeline"? with regard to western and central europe

have one handed swords been basically replaced by the long sword in warfare at some point or during some short-ish period of time, or has it been a slow, mixed process with arming and long swords existing alongside for many decades or centuries even... tell me the history of the sword! (in the outlined region and at the specified time, that is)

1 Answers 2016-04-07

How exactly did cavalry charges communicate?

So the question came to me while reading this TIL, in regards to the largest cavalry in history. 18,000 men strong, it was compared to the Rohirrim Charge in Return of The King, with only a third of the strength.

Using that video as an example....how the hell did anyone beyond the front line know what to? Théoden's giving his orders to his generals, who disperse, but there's no godly way they could relay that to their entire companies in the 2 minutes he's giving his rousing speech-and no one would be able to hear that. The horns were merely the charge order, not the specific direction.

Now granted, that's a movie. But it was reportedly based on other historic cavalry charges, and to circle back to the original point of the question-the largest one in history was three times the size of the Rohan flood. So beyond listening for a horn and charging full tilt into a wall of spears, how were any tactical decisions relayed?

Also, IE is auto-correcting Théoden's e....interesting....

1 Answers 2016-04-07

How Were Arrows Made?

I was watching this video on arrows and wondered how arrows were made in the ancient to medieval period. Since there were a fair ammount of archers on the battlefield and even more arrows, how did they manage to make them in great numbers without modern machinery?

1 Answers 2016-04-07

Wendish Prussian?

So I have been raised in Australia, our ancestors arrived from Werben in 1858. We were told we were Prussian, but now I am studying my ancestry I am told I am Wendish. Surnames are Duschka, Jakubaschk.

What is the difference? How does it fit in? Why would we have been told one not the other?

1 Answers 2016-04-07

Theory Thursday | Academic/Professional History Free-for-All

Previous weeks!

This week, ending in April 07 2016:

Today's thread is for open discussion of:

  • History in the academy

  • Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries

  • Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application

  • Philosophy of history

  • And so on

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

1 Answers 2016-04-07

Was there an female Roman "moon cult"?

During my Latin classes in high school I remember being told of an all woman cult that performed sacrificial rituals under the full moon. These rituals included luring men, having sex with them, then killing them. I can find nothing about this on google. If I search Cult of Luna I get a metal band. One wiki article for Luna mentions a moon cult, but no details. Are there any credible sources for this?

1 Answers 2016-04-07

What do Kings in the medieval times do in their spare time?

A lot of times I see a king being portrayed in the movies, they just sit on their throne in the great hall surrounded by advisors, jesters and the Queen. Is this really the case back then? Is it a common thing for kings to sit on their throne for hours and grant audience to common people?

4 Answers 2016-04-07

The Wikipedia article on the Vietnam war lists Iran as one of the nations that supported the United States during the Vietnam War, what was the extent of their contributions?

As the Iranian revolution had not yet happened, Iran was an American ally, but what did/could Iran have done during the war. Is Wikipedia mistaken? Did Iran quietly support the United States in a similar fashion as Canada? Did they send military forces? Unfortunately the article only lists Iran as a nation that supported the United States but makes no mention of them anywhere else. Thanks for any replies!

1 Answers 2016-04-07

How was the construction of medieval mega-projects like cathedrals, castles etc managed? Was there Project Managers and foremen? Would the average mason have had an idea of what the finished product would look like?

I'm asking as I'm qualified in a project management framework, and it just strikes me as such a forced, artificial, bullshit method of getting things done.

I mean take Gantt charts. I'd bet paper money not one Gantt chart was used during the construction of St. Peters Cathederal or Edinburgh Castle.

1 Answers 2016-04-07

4372 / 7255

Back to start