Hypothetically, what would happen if 130 Spanish ships invaded England, like, right now? The Spanish would win, right? Please respond.

I'm not an admiral, so I have no idea how successful this whole operation is going to be. Why did the King put me in charge again?

10 Answers 2016-04-01

Should I invade Russia?

Rhetorical question. Of course I am going to invade Russia. I will take Moscow and St. Petersburg and I will become the Emperor of all Europe. I already am, but I will be, too.

19 Answers 2016-04-01

In ancient and medieval times, did sailors and marines where any sort of armor while at sea or in battle?

It seems to me that armor would sink a man who fell in so I would imagine they might not wear any.

1 Answers 2016-04-01

[Meta] Why is the 20 year period before the present off limits for discussion? Is it too controversial?

Why is the 20 year period before the present off limits for discussion? Is it too controversial?

What follows is a hypothesis I made from seeing 22 years of history unfold around me, and which was aided with tools that I learned from a wise history teacher.


Being a historian of the present, I think, is a potentially dangerous occupation. And it has been for all of presently surviving (as of this writing) history.

History is something that wars are fought over. History is written by the victors of these wars, and the opinions of the defeated are forgotten. Wars are a battle over the psychological state of the population, including their collective memory. Present history is thus an area of strong contention, usually murderously strong contention, contention at a level that many people are willing to die for.

However, once enough time has passed, the cares of the present will have migrated far enough away from the cares of their younger selves and of their ancestors such that those past concerns are no longer objects of murderously strong contention.

My writing style is a bit dense. I apologize if this was hard to read.


Edit:

I originally came to /r/AskHistorians to ask about the history of Reddit, to ask about any historians who study Reddit, but I was unable to find justification for this type of question in the rules, hence the question at the top of this post.

2 Answers 2016-04-01

Questions About April Fools Day

Since it's April 1st today, I've been wondering about its history.

When did the concept of "April Fools Day" begin? How has it evolved over the years? What are some of the earliest documented pranks occurring on this day?

2 Answers 2016-04-01

How does a bastard, orphan, son of a whore and a Scotsman, dropped in the middle of a forgotten spot in the Caribbean by providence impoverished, in squalor, grow up to be a hero and a scholar?

4 Answers 2016-04-01

What was Roman equivalent of "Vietnam War"?

1 Answers 2016-04-01

What's up with the constant rebellions in Mesopotamia and Egypt? Why is it so hard to keep these people down?

A question for all my friends who are generals and kings. I know the Great King has so much trouble holding on to Babylon and Egypt that he even once called to glorious Athens for aid. They sent me to help him out, and I had to march around the sandy wastes for years before they finally let me go home. And he's not the first one to struggle with this, and not the last one either, as I learn. Why is it so difficult to pacify these regions? Is it just a matter of enforcing harsher discipline, like it usually is?

6 Answers 2016-04-01

Has the study of history reduced its repeatability and thereby limited its validity as a science?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-04-01

Why did other countries even bother with navies, when it was clear they couldn't come close to beating the British?

5 Answers 2016-04-01

Why was Britain the first nation to colonise Australia?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-04-01

How did criminal investigations work in the Abbasid Caliphate?

2 Answers 2016-04-01

What a bunch of rapscallions that have stumbled in here today. Tell me, why do none of your wifes excel to the standards that I do, are they weak and submissive?

I, Livia of the Claudii, Julia of the Julii by marriage, the first empress of Rome and mother of our next emperor. Great deeds did I and Gaius achieve, I became a front for women's hairstyling through my eminency. I hear nothing of the likes from other parts of the world. Do the barbarians of the North even understand what it means to be great? Do the unruly people of the East ever take a break from fighting among themselves to establish a leading dynasty?

11 Answers 2016-04-01

Did Julius Caesar consciously want to establish himself as a king? How big a threat was he to the Republic?

Gaius Julius Caesar has been given the dictatorship for ten years, and his recent deeds and words have driven me into great doubt and concern whether his motives are purely inspired by love for the state and people of Rome or whether he conspires to drive us into the indignity of monarchy and tyranny. I would appreciate some advice from friends, as if it is the case that Caesar wishes to make himself king and an Enemy of the Republic, regardless of how good his actions have been to the State - I shall have to make up my mind in what is the morally good course of action for a philosopher and a leader of the people, like me. Is it statesmanlike, when one’s country is under a tyranny, to retire to some other place and remain inactive there, or ought one to brave any danger in order to liberate it? Ought one, even if not approving war as a means of abolishing tyranny, to join up with the right-minded party in the struggle against it? What can a mere man do in this situation ^be ^it ^even ^a ^saviour ^of ^the ^Republic ^and ^abolisher ^of ^the ^wretched ^Catiline ?

I only pray for one thing: that in dying I may leave the Roman people free—the immortal gods could grant me no greater gift.

4 Answers 2016-04-01

Why is it called the "Medieval Period"?

That's it.

2 Answers 2016-04-01

History or historiography?

Is it more important to study history or historiography?

1 Answers 2016-04-01

Did girls factor into the Order of Succession at all?

Say for example there was King Bob and his wife, Queen Jill. They had a daughter, Millie, who was unmarried.

Now, say Bob and Jill both die in a sudden accident.

If Millie was a boy, she'd be the undisputed first in line to take the throne, no questions asked. But Millie is not a boy.

Does Millie still inherit the throne before Uncle Jack? If Uncle Jack gets it, then my next question is if there is literally no other male family members, does Millie become the new monarch?

Edit - Europe, Middle Ages

3 Answers 2016-04-01

What kind of Islam was Malcolm X apart of? Can you explain how it differs from popular Islam in the middle east if it differs at all?

1 Answers 2016-04-01

Has a leading (American) presidential candidate ever died during election season? How did it affect the race?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-04-01

Lets say I just came of age in the 1950's USSR and want a job. What process would I go through to get one?

Also, what would the average job for a entry level worker be and how would the pay be?

1 Answers 2016-04-01

Wildlife population and hunting during the great depression.

My great grandmother spoke of lard sandwiches and soup lines during the great depression. When I think about what I would have done during the great depression to feed my family, I immediately think I would go hunting. Is there any evidence that the population of wildlife decreased or the sale of hunting guns increased due to families hunting to survive.

Edit - In the United States

1 Answers 2016-04-01

Why did the French in 1940 not expect a German invasion through Belgium even though the Germans invaded through there in 1914?

It seems like it would be a no brainer to protect the Belgian front or at least have spotters there but that wasn't the case. How could they not at least check to make sure?

1 Answers 2016-04-01

whos the guy in this picture?

https://i.gyazo.com/thumb/1200/_2813ec657b7c27fb4883f554ebe6af85-png.jpg

1 Answers 2016-04-01

Would it have been possible to get copies of communist literature during the Red Scare.

Such as the Communist Manifesto, Das Kapital, etc. Would they be censored? I'm referring to the United States

1 Answers 2016-04-01

Hitler & Dogs

It's well known that Hitler loved his German Shepard Blondi, but did he have a particular love for dogs in general or was it just Blondi?

1 Answers 2016-04-01

4392 / 7255

Back to start