Why did Yugoslavia let Slovenia go?

It seems like Yugoslavia could have easily mobilized a force to crush the Slovenians, but they were content to just… let them go? Why?

1 Answers 2021-11-29

I’ve heard Irish people talk about a policy of using Irish-language instruction for English-speaking students(?) as disastrous, but I also had a professor mention that it was the gold-standard for indigenous language preservation. With exactly were these policies and their outcomes?

1 Answers 2021-11-29

Why did the Norse Viking Settlers adopt French as their language in Normandy, but Anglo-Saxon Germanic Settlers not adopt Latin as their language in Britannia?

1 Answers 2021-11-28

Prior to the abolition of slavery in the United States, were there any Black Americans that bought slaves specifically to free them?

1 Answers 2021-11-28

Can anyone decipher where exactly in Jerusalem this video is and what ethnic group of people are in the video? Thank you!

https://www.reddit.com/r/Damnthatsinteresting/comments/r4bisb/jerusalem_1897_colorized_the_closest_thing_to_a/?utm_medium=android_app&utm_source=share

1 Answers 2021-11-28

What books or websites can i get a decent chronological understanding of human history in terms of major events?

Outside of American high school history, random facts about ancient egypt, and a a little about ww1 and ww2 and various trivia on the roman emprire i really know nothing about the world other than what i randomly stumble upon on the internet but does anyone have any recommendations on how to get an advanced knowledge of world events? (Sorry if the question is dumb I’m kinda new to reddit)

1 Answers 2021-11-28

Did the 2001 film "Enemy at the Gates" popularize common misconceptions about the Red Army during World War II, such as the supposedly widespread use of "human wave" tactics and "no step back" orders?

The 2001 film "Enemy at the Gates" was quite popular. It was very good popcorn cinema and arguably remains the most popular movie about the Eastern Front of WW2.

The movie, however, vastly exaggerated the tactical and strategic shortcomings of the Red Army during that time. While "human wave" tactics and "no step back" orders did exist and were used occasionally, their usages, to my knowledge (which comes mostly from this subreddit to be fair), were very localized and not very widespread as depicted in the film. There were also not such widespread supply shortages that one man would be given a rifle with one 5-round clip and the man behind him was given another 5-round clip and told to pick up the other man's rifle should he drop dead.

Nowadays, those incorrect perceptions of the Red Army during WW2 remain very popular. So the question is then: Did "Enemy at the Gates" popularize those misconceptions? If not, then what did?

1 Answers 2021-11-28

Is there a job out there that combines History and Computer Science?

Unsure if this is the right subreddit but I'll ask anyway. Ever since I was young I've always loved learning about History yet I've always loved learning about Computer Science so I was thinking, is there a job out there that combines the two subjects? I've been wondering about this due to my homeroom teacher giving us all the assignment to think of a potential career that we'd like to do in the future.

3 Answers 2021-11-28

Cycles in history

Joe Rogan posted an image on instagram depicting the political compass with a cycle that goes like this: hard times -> strong men -> good times -> weak men -> hard times ... . My first reaction to this is that this seems quite obviously over simplistic and wrong. So my question is: Is there a cycle like this throughout history or is this just nonsense?

2 Answers 2021-11-28

Was Patrice Lumumba's assassination a success?

I'm interested in learning more about the aftermath of Lumumba's assassination in the Congo, and am having trouble finding sources. What was the political aftermath of the killing? Did the Belgians and US achieve the political goals they saw Lumumba as a barrier to? Was the assassination considered a political gain for the West?

1 Answers 2021-11-28

Why didn’t Aboriginal Australians invent agriculture? Were there any other sources of troubles for Aborigines that prevented them from discovering other technologies?

1 Answers 2021-11-28

What was so "Gay" about The Gay Nineties?

(Understanding that at that time "gay" was used in the sense of happy/jolly, not homosexual)

Where did the early twentieth century nostalgia in America for the 1890s come from? Was it simply a transposition of European nostalgia for the Belle Epoque? Or did people just really love Grover Cleveland and ragtime?

1 Answers 2021-11-28

Book recommendations covering the Spanish conquest of Mexico and the fall of the Aztec empire?

I recently returned from a trip to Mexico City, finished Buddy Levy’s classic “Conquistador”, and have become enthralled with the ancient history of Mexico as well as the modern implications of the Aztec conquest. Any book recommendations covering similar/complementary topics would be much appreciated!

1 Answers 2021-11-28

In his famous rant in the movie 'The Downfall', Hitler calls the generals 'cowards without honour', accuses them of obstructing his plans and regrets not having executed all the high rank officers like Stalin did. Was there such a tension between Hitler and the German High Command in real life?

1 Answers 2021-11-28

Give a gift of History with the AskHistorians 2021 Holiday Book Recommendation Thread!

Happy holidays to one of the most fantastic communities on the net!

It’s been a heck of a year for everyone, but perhaps we can brighten it up a bit. I figured we should run this thread a bit early, considering all the problems with shipping and stuff selling out happening right now.

Tis coming up to the season for gift giving, and its a safe bet that folks here both like giving and receiving all kinds of history books. As such we offer this thread for all your holiday book recommendation needs!

If you are looking for a particular book, please ask below in a comment and tell us the time period or events you're curious about!

If you're going to recommend a book, please don't just drop a link to a book in this thread--that will be removed. In recommending, you should post at least a paragraph explaining why this book is important, or a good fit, and so on. Let us know what you like about this book so much! Additionally, please make sure it follows our rules, specifically: it should comprehensive, accurate and in line with the historiography and the historical method.

Don't forget to check out the existing AskHistorians book list, a fantastic list of books compiled by flairs and experts from the sub. Or you can browse last years thread while we wait for new suggestions to come rolling in!

Have yourselves a great holiday season readers, and let us know about all your favorite, must recommend books! Stay safe out there!

34 Answers 2021-11-28

I read all the time about snipers with confirmed kills during war. What is the criteria for a kill to be “confirmed?” Has it ever came out that any persons “confirmed kills” were made up?

1 Answers 2021-11-28

Why were some earlier books given very long titles that almost became blurbs themselves? Or was the point that it was a blurb before blurbs officially existed on the dust jacket or back of a book?

For example: The Female Shipwright, or, the Life and Extraordinary Adventures of Mary Lacy: Giving An Account Of Her leaving her Parents disguised as a Man; Serving Four Years At Sea, And Seven Years Apprenticeship in Portsmouth Dockyard, With The Means Which Led To A DISCOVERY OF HER SEX; When she obtained her Discharge, and was Allowed a PENSION by the Government.

1 Answers 2021-11-28

Prussia was for a long time a Protestant power. However looking at Germany today the ex-Prussian lands are largely now Catholic. When and how did Prussia turn Catholic?

1 Answers 2021-11-28

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | November 28, 2021

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

2 Answers 2021-11-28

Where does the motive/trope/scene of firefighters saving cats from trees in US movies come from?🚒🌳🐱 I'm wondering 'cause it seems so unrealistic for me as an European.

Hi, last night I watched some TV and stumbeld upon an US-American movie of the last century (80s/90s I guess). In that parcticular movie firefighters were called to save a poor kitty from a tree. I realized I saw that type of scene in many US movies (more often in old ones) where the firefighters (or a superhero for example) get called to save cats from treebranches.

For me as a 20 something European this seems very unrealistic. I cannot recall any article or instance when firefighters in my country were called merely because of a cat in a tree. Is there anything/more to this cliche kind of scene or was it just a easy way to show the kindness of a superhero or the helpfullness of the protagonist in the movie? Is this still a common incident nowadays in the US or has it ever been?

Thx in advance!

Edit: As many people pointed out to me in direct messages and some comments cat saving operations from trees by firefighters are not that uncommon in Europe as well. My mistake - should've googled before. But why exactly this trope is so wide spread in mostly US movies and where it originates from is still in question. Thx again!

1 Answers 2021-11-28

The film Breakfast at Tiffany’s includes portrayals of sex work and infidelity that are a) barely disguised, and b) not particularly negative even if not very positive. How was this possible under the Hays Code?

1 Answers 2021-11-28

Bach is often taught as the Gold Standard of musical perfection, who would Bach have been taught as the Gold Standard?

Just let the uninformed and enraging title speak for itself.

1 Answers 2021-11-28

How do we know how old Gobekli Tepe is? Trying to disprove someone who thinks carbon dating is a complete sham.

Gobekli Tepe is currently dated around 12,000 years old, but someone I know is in denial of this as they believe humanity was created around 6000 years ago (Biblical chronology believer). They assert that Gobekli Tepe (and all other sites that prove human existence) dated over 6000 years are not valid as they rely on carbon dating. I'm not an expert by any means, and would appreciate any sources that prove the age of historical sites 6000+ years that do not rely on carbon dating, or how Tepe is currently being dated. Thank you in advance.

4 Answers 2021-11-28

How bad was crime in USSR?

Since we all talk about how inequality and desperation are the causes of crime like robbery and theft, was crime bad in USSR? Were stuff like pickpocketing, theft and robbery and better or worse then places like the US today?

1 Answers 2021-11-28

Is there any larger subtext to the story that, only recently, did we learn Roman hairstyles weren't wigs but were done with needle and thread?

I recently discovered the story of Janet Stephens who is a lay-person who changed the field of Roman archaeology by showing lots of hairstyles were not in fact wigs but done with needle and thread: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Janet_Stephens

I work as a journalist and am thinking of pitching this story to some places. I am curious if there is any larger subtext here, some reason that people got it wrong about wigs for so long that reveals larger information about the field of Roman archaeology. I'm just trying to find a way to situate this story into a larger story about the field.

3 Answers 2021-11-28

446 / 7255

Back to start