Combat traumas and PTSD in members of the SS and the Wehrmacht involved in the executions of civilians and POW's

Hello r/AskHistorians! You are really a wonderful resource as a sub, found many answers to my random questions just by searching, even though Reddit search is an odd tool. Thank you all for the in depth and well versed answers. Kudos to the mod team for keeping all discussion civil and academic.

I was wondering, are there any recorded instances of PTSD and other combat traumas in the Wehrmacht and the SS men involved in daily executions, like the Einsatzgruppen, camp guards, units involved in anti-partisan roles on the Eastern front and Yugoslavia, or the average G.I. that shot war prisoners on his immediate superior's orders. How were these conditions handled in the military bureaucracy of Nazi Germany? Can safely assume it was handled differently at the start of the war, or in the beginning of the Eastern invasion, then in was in late 1944/5.

Found a similar question asked 8 years ago, where some of you gave pretty good insights on the matter. Supposed it will be fruitful to ask this question again, maybe more resources have become available online or there are some new people on this subreddit that will give their more insight on it. I will be also grateful if you can recommend some in-depth books on this topic.

Thank you all, and keep up the good work.

1 Answers 2021-11-27

I was reading a research paper on early modern China, and the author made a side comment that the British found the cure for scurvy in 1747, but that Portugal had discovered it “much earlier,” with no explanation. When did Portugal discover it, and how didn’t their ally, Britain, find out?

Pretty much what the title says. The research paper was on nutritional deficiencies in early modern China, and it made the comment in the section about scurvy in China. No sources were provided, and the author made the comment quickly and then went straight back to talking about China, so no other info was provided.

It was a scholarly paper though, so I’m assuming the author is correct and knew what they were talking about.

1 Answers 2021-11-27

What led to the collapse of the Ming Dynasty? Why was the Manchu Qing the one to replace it?

1 Answers 2021-11-27

How did the Italian banks of the early renaissance make such fantastic profits?

Listening to a lecture on the Medici family by William Landon, he mentioned two figures that made me wonder what kind of terms their bank, and more broadly, what types of financial instruments the 15th and 16th century italian bankers offered. And what types of legal guarantees they had.

The figures that sparked my interest were that the Medici bank was founded around the beginning of the 15th century with 8000 florins. And then towards the end of the 15th century, Lorenzo de' Medici went through the accounts of their banks and figured out that they had spent 600.000 florins on public works and sponsoring artists (this would imply the net worth of the banks books being several times larger than that figure). This massive multiplication of their fortune seems incredible to me, so I hope someone could shed some light on how these banks operated to generate so much money in such a relatively small time frame.

1 Answers 2021-11-27

Why was the German Empire so successful scientifically?

In the time from 1901 to 1914 People from Germany won 4 Noble Prizes in Medicine, 6 Prizes in Physics, 7 Prizes in Chemistry and 3 Prizes in Literature. People all over the continent came to Germany to study. Technologically, they had an edge over almost everyone. How did this edge come to be and what, if anything, happened to end it?

1 Answers 2021-11-27

Swedish borders in the 14th century

I'm working on an essay about the evolution of the national borders of Sweden between the 13th and 20th centuries, and for some reason I am really struggling to find any reliable sources that discuss the territories that belonged to Sweden in the 14th century, especially before the country joined the Kalmar Union. Does anybody know where I could find such sources, or could tell me more about how the borders were drawn back then? Thanks!

2 Answers 2021-11-27

It’s often said that Queen Elizabeth the first could speak Italian. But Tuscan wasn’t standardized until well after her death. What dialect did she speak?

Or, what language? Venetian is clearly a different Language to Sicilian, so did she speak Tuscan at all?

1 Answers 2021-11-27

The Offa Dinar is a coin minted in the name of an eighth century Anglo-Saxon king that is a copy of the Arabic dinars of caliph Al-Mansur, complete with a (messed-up) inscription in Arabic on one side. What was the purpose of the king of Mercia modeling coins on Abbasid dinars?

Here's the coin.

1 Answers 2021-11-27

Did Shakespeare really invent all those words and phrases, or were they commonly used in his day and he was just the first one to write them down?

1 Answers 2021-11-27

How did the US reach the conclusion that use of nuclear weapons would lead to MAD, while the Soviets concluded they could use tactical nuclear weapons without it escalating to full scale nuclear war?

1 Answers 2021-11-27

Menstruation protection in the realy ages

So I'm a viking nerd, i know clothes ment alot to people during the early ages, you only had a set up or so. I'm also female, witch means once a month I will bleed. Every woman on earth knows the fear of blood and white clothes. Linen and wool is the fabrics we have found clothes made of in the viking age and medival europe, we found out what kind of clothes they wore. Panties wasn't really a thing. And tampons are modern. How did women protect clothing from the blood? A rag of wool in your pants sounds wastefull and not to comfortable. washing your underdress, which you often slept in everyday do not sound sustainable, especially here in Scandinavia where we have winter/snow 5 months/year. Any thoughts or ideas?

1 Answers 2021-11-27

The Netherlands is famous for reclaiming large tracts of land from the sea. But where did they get all the soil? It's flat land which is already under sea level, and by default has a shortage of land/soil already

2 Answers 2021-11-27

I teach on land seized from Coast Salish and Chinook peoples. Kids always want to know “how they did x or y”. What are good resources to learn what their everyday life was like? (Routines, families, sleeping, sport, etc.)

Edit: Our school does do work with native tribes and we have elders come every year. I’m asking for resources to supplement that, because my personal relationship isn’t (yet) one where I am comfortable asking them to do much labor for me

7 Answers 2021-11-27

Primary Source concerning Nazis burning/destruction of art

Ive got a history presentation coming up with the topic "Art and culture under the Nazi rule" and we must present and analyse at least one primary source. I figured, a good one would be Hitlers original command to round up and/or destroy all the art he perceived as degenerate. Is it known when he first issued such a decree? Was it a letter to Goebbels, a speech, some other form of command? I dont really know how to search for a primary source online and what keywords to use. Do any of you know of a good primary source concerning this topic? Or is there a website that compiles many primary sources and stuff like that? Either way, Ill be thankful for any info :)

1 Answers 2021-11-27

Atkinson's WW2 "Liberation Trilogy" - Can anyone please suggest similar books?

I am finishing Rick Atkinson's books about the Western Front in WW2 (The Liberation Trilogy). I would love to read other works written in a similar style, in particular about these subjects:

  • the Spanish Civil War
  • Stalingrad and more generally the Russian Front in WW2
  • the Resistance in Europe in WW2
  • the Vietnam war

I found The Liberation Trilogy easy to read, reach in details and anecdotes that make the main characters come to life. I am looking for books that are both well-researched and well written.

Thanks in advance for your suggestions!

1 Answers 2021-11-27

How exactly did Greek myths get passed down through the generations?

Was there some kind of religious text where the official versions of the stories were recorded? Was it all oral tradition? Were there different versions regionally? Did the stories change as they were passed down?

2 Answers 2021-11-27

Saturday Showcase | November 27, 2021

Previous

Today:

AskHistorians is filled with questions seeking an answer. Saturday Spotlight is for answers seeking a question! It’s a place to post your original and in-depth investigation of a focused historical topic.

Posts here will be held to the same high standard as regular answers, and should mention sources or recommended reading. If you’d like to share shorter findings or discuss work in progress, Thursday Reading & Research or Friday Free-for-All are great places to do that.

So if you’re tired of waiting for someone to ask about how imperialism led to “Surfin’ Safari;” if you’ve given up hope of getting to share your complete history of the Bichon Frise in art and drama; this is your chance to shine!

1 Answers 2021-11-27

Why does my Jewish family traditionally get Chinese food on Christmas?

Probably and easy answer, but I come from a Ashkenazi Jewish family on my mothers side. Every Christmas they/we either go out to or order in Chinese food. How and why did this tradition start? It’s also popularized in media and television.

1 Answers 2021-11-27

The Tse Tse fly has been cited as the main culprit behind the relative civilizational backwardness of Sub Saharan Africa. Did any methods of fighting the Tse Tse fly exist before the modern era?

I'm aware of the achievements of Sub Saharan Africa - I also know It was a handicapped rather strongly due to the tse tse fly killing of livestock. No livestock means less energy available

1 Answers 2021-11-27

The Phoenicians colonized the Mediterranean world, and many modern cities still bear Phoenician names. But how come their ruins are so lackluster for poor, at least compared to their Greek and Roman counterparts?

The Phoenicians seem to be one of the most influential people of the Mediterranean world; yet they lack a sense of art or unique architecture in my opinion (compared to the Greeks and Romans). Is it just survival bias, where what survived of their civilization isn’t great to our eyes?

2 Answers 2021-11-27

A truthful, unbiased, accurate telling of U.S. history

I am looking for a book that is as neutral as possible in the telling of American history. I want to know about things that aren't necessarily taught in school without a political bias. Thanks

1 Answers 2021-11-27

Why do librarians choose to include pseudohistorians like Gavin Menzies and Erich von Daniken in library history sections? I know that there’s a general opposition to the specter of book-banning, but can’t they critically choose to spend their limited budgets on actual history instead?

Also: do book sales factor that much into curation considerations?

4 Answers 2021-11-27

Could it be that the reason that we know less or little about some historical civilizations is general lack of interest or lack of archeological funding or resources for historical research?

"Resources" in meaning that governments or institutions are just uninterested to provide money, funding or resources for historians, archeologists and anthropologists who conduct research about said historical civilizations

1 Answers 2021-11-27

How true is this meme in ancient context? Ive seen this meme linked to modern day (post Great Depression), but if it were a true social cycle (fashion/womans rights/etc) we should have seen this cycle many times over by now. So, historically, were there any "chad times=cringe men?" (Link inside)

And here is the meme

1 Answers 2021-11-27

What was the governing structure of the Roman Empire and how stable was it?

I have been having trouble finding actual information regarding this. I have heard of Rome being a Republic at one point? It is always referred to as an Empire ruled by the Caesars? Also, a lot of people seem to believe it to be the penultimate Empire that only collapsed because it just got old. So, I would like to have some real information and details to go off of. Was it really all that stable? WAS it ever a Republic? Did it have an Imperial structure, and if so, did it overtake the Republic or was the Republic made part of it?

I apologize in advance if this is a difficult one to answer, but finding answers on my own has been a pain.

1 Answers 2021-11-27

447 / 7255

Back to start