Why were some medieval books so huge?

For example, see this picture of books in the archive of the Prague Castle.

2 Answers 2016-02-06

What was life like for a Germanic tribesperson in the year 0?

2 Answers 2016-02-06

What were Richard Nixon's thoughts on JFK as a president? How was Nixon impacted by the assassination?

1 Answers 2016-02-06

What is the oldest/longest running modern democracy?

What the question says really, when was the first democracy, excluding the ancient Greeks and Romans

1 Answers 2016-02-06

Looking for high grade oral tradition literature.

I'll try to be clearer. In English, for example, there agreement that Shakespeare is high grade English literature. Does anyone know of high grade works (like Shakespeare-ish or so level) that is from oral tradition? Thanks!

2 Answers 2016-02-06

What did the Eastern Front in WW2 actually look like?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-02-06

Before CREEP and Watergate, was Richard Nixon considered a good leader by most people? Was he a good president overall?

In my U.S. History class, the total coverage of President Nixon was 'he was President, then he screwed up a scandal and resigned only so he wouldn't be impeached'. Watergate is something I know more than enough about - I'd like to know about the rest of the man's presidency. Were his policies favorable to most citizens? Was he, objectively speaking (as difficult as that is to do in the charged world of American politics), a "good" president?

1 Answers 2016-02-06

I am a man in France between 1670 and 1705, and I am making ends meet by traveling to different towns and singing in pubs and armories. What songs do my audiences request the most?

Additional questions if you're willing/able:


EDIT: Apparently these are bigger stumpers than I had anticipated! Can anyone shed some light as to why these are difficult questions to answer? Are there any mods/experts here who specialize in the Baroque period in France? At this point I'm asking half for the kids and half for my own insatiable curiosity. Also, I thought up another question out of personal interest:

How am I traveling? I'm sure this would be determined by my finances/class/other factors. How much would a decent horse (get me from A to B) run me?


I also have audiences asking me to demonstrate my ability with a sword (I am very skilled in this) do I display my skills against an opponent, or is it possible to perform solo?

What is the etiquette in securing a "gig?"

I am very talented. What kind of living am I making? How much do I make in a typical night?

How long can I stay in town until my welcome is worn out?

How do I decide where to go next?

How are any of your answers changed if I am a woman?

3 Answers 2016-02-06

Why did the western powers reject the "Stalin Note" for reunification of Germany in 1952?

The USSR in 1952, via memo known as "the Stalin Note", proposed a reunification for Germany along with disengagement of superpowers from the region.

What were the reasons for the Western allied powers (UK, USA and France) rejecting this proposal?

1 Answers 2016-02-06

Minor Military Disciplinary Infractions During Antiquity

Fictional works usually represent the military forces of antiquity as very brutal. My question is whether every breach of standards was handled with a beating or was there a bureaucratic side to punishment (being written up?)

Beyond that was there a concept of 'dishonorable discharge?' Or did leaving the military on bad terms always end with "off with his head?"

2 Answers 2016-02-06

Surnames: We know surnames originated usually based on what you do, how did the surname Dickinson come about?

Hmm.

1 Answers 2016-02-06

Any info on this Nazi patch?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-02-06

During the Middle Ages, Jews were persecuted by many Christian kingdoms. Why was this even though they relatively believed in the same religion?

2 Answers 2016-02-06

Were Jews really "deeply involved" in the slave trade during the XVII - XVIII centuries?

My aunt's boyfriend is a conspiracy theorist, so obviously I take everything he claims/shares on social media with a huge grain of salt.

He's just shared a text by some "Rabby Lody Van de Kamp" that allegedly confesses the Jews' involvement in the slave trade. The piece of text, which smells of r/forwardsfromgrandma (or perhaps r/forwardsfromhitler, heh) material, can be found here.

Is there any truth to it at all?

Thank you, lovely Historians!

2 Answers 2016-02-06

How common was the use of (large) stones for cannon munitions?

There is a gif on r/gifs called Story of a Stone, iirc. It depicts a mountain gradually become smaller, and at one point is fired out of a cannon. How likely is that to have actually occurred?

1 Answers 2016-02-06

Why the "Business Suit"?

When you take a step back, business suits (and especially ties) are a very, very strange institution. Why do we have a "grown up" uniform at all? Why does it have this particular form? Why is dangling a piece of cloth from your neck considered anything other than ridiculous?

I've read the existing answers (linked in the FAQ) to questions about suits and ties. They focus on tracing the fashion precursors of the current styles of the suit. For instance tracing contemporary ties to cravats worn by Croatian mercenaries. While this is fascinating, it does not answer my question. I would like to refocus discussion on why the institution of the business suit exists and is so widespread today.

Let me be more specific. Here are the reasons that I find the very existence of business suits counter-intuitive:

(Non-functional) Unlike some uniforms (e.g., hard hat, overalls, flame-retardant suits, and even deliberately revealing "Hooters" uniforms), business suits are entirely non-functional. They are usually worn by office workers, who could do their job just as well (perhaps better) if they were wearing something else.

(Low signalling value) Often the ways people (and animals) choose to dress (or evolve to look) are designed to communicate to others who or what they are. However for a signal to have value (at least in biological evolution, which I'm more familiar with) it must be hard for at least some individuals to fake the signal. However it's easy for anyone to go out and buy a suit or to borrow one from someone else. There are services that loan good quality suits to homeless people going for job interviews. These days a suit provides as much signalling value as a little pin that says "I'm a business person!" Were suits once unattainably expensive, and so had signalling value, but now the price has dropped yet the norm persists?

(Mandatory) Some progressive companies like Google are (apparently) letting their employees come to work in neat casual attire, as long as they get the job done. However, as far as I know, most big companies in large wealthy cities still insist that their workers come dressed in a strange, seemingly arbitrary "business suit" uniform. Where it's not mandatory, my understanding is that workers are often disadvantaged by not wearing one. Given that the uniform is both non-functional and its signalling function is easily faked, the insistence that people must wear them seems especially peculiar.

(Arbitrary) Perhaps there are reasons for the particular normative form of the business suit. For instance, the presence of a tie (forbidden for women), the presence of a pointy collar, the standard colour scheme, skirt/dress style and length for women (forbidden for men), shirts must have long sleeves, etc. However to me they seem entirely arbitrary. Why not, instead, have a short sleeved shirt with collar that goes all the way around the neck, with pieces of coloured cloth hanging down the arms? If there is some historical or contemporary function to the particular form of the business suit, I would love to learn it. To be unambiguous here, I have read existing answers tracing the precursors of the current suit forms; that's not what I'm asking about. What interests me is the arbitrariness of those forms. Are they arbitrary? If so, why should something so arbitrary be so prevalent and so strictly enforced?

(Prevalence) Despite the peculiarities above, the business suit seems to be present worldwide. Business people wear it in India, Brazil, Japan, Kenya and Finland. How did something so seemingly arbitrary and non-functional come to have such widespread adoption? How does it retain its seemingly arbitrary form while migrating between cultures and generations, despite the pressures of innovation, reinvention, cultural assimilation, and historical change that buffet most other domains of human activity (e.g., architecture, decor, language, art and media, etc.)?

And so, historians, I ask you: Why the "Business Suit"?

Why is something so non-functional, with such little signalling value, something whose form is so arbitrary, nonetheless so prevalent across the world and often even mandatory?

1 Answers 2016-02-06

Did the Ancient Spartans really have homosexual relationships?

Modern academic discourse asserts that the Spartans had sexual pederast relationships but Xenophon says they never did. Because Xenophon was a primary source, shouldn't he have more credence, what do you all think?

  • for what it's worth, I don't care if they were or weren't. I just want to know the truth of the situation.

3 Answers 2016-02-06

I've read that the Lithuanian language, as well as Lithuanian mythology, are notably conservative, and closer to their Proto-Indo-European counterparts. What made Lithuanian/Baltic culture so conservative?

EDIT: /u/Masaryk has pointed out that linguistic and cultural conservatism are not linked. In that case, I'll specify that the language and mythology are specifically what interest me.

3 Answers 2016-02-06

What purpose do collars serve on clothing?

They just seem like a waste of fabric and serve no real utilitarian purpose. Granted they add style to clothing but it doesn't seem like the only reason they became popular

1 Answers 2016-02-06

Eric Schlosser says the USSR's first nuclear weapon was almost identical to the one used on Nagasaki because a 'network of Communist spies' at the Manhattan project 'simply took' the plans. Was the US atomic program really this compromised?

1 Answers 2016-02-06

I'm am looking for books about the Ustaše (Ustasha) during the Second World War that ISN'T written in Serbo-Croatian or Bosnian. Since i haven't had any luck finding one in English or Danish.

I have had a big interest in the Second World War for about 15 years, but I don't really know a lot about Pavelić's reign in Croatia or the war in the Balkans so, would you please help me on the subject matter?

1 Answers 2016-02-06

What could be considered the defining battles of the Angolan Civil War?

I'm reading a couple books about wars fought in Africa (such as the First/Second Congo War) and it touches very briefly on wars of decolonization. I'd like to learn a little more about the Angolan Civil War, since it had such an interesting Cuban intervention to it. Some book recommendations would be nice too.

1 Answers 2016-02-06

Why don't we hear about people dying of cancer in the past, but cancer takes so many lives now?

Is cancer something that has taking hold of us in the past few centuries because of our health choices? Perhaps in the past they did not know what cancer was or how to diagnose and it was just as prevalent? Perhaps because we have longer life spans?

1 Answers 2016-02-06

How much evidence is there behind Pomponius Secundus rescuing enslaved survivors of the battle of the Teutoburg Forest 40 years after the battle took place?

Tacitus wrote that after bands Chatti began raiding Roman territory around 50AD, Pomponius Secundus led a legion supported by auxiliaries to destroy them. After surrounding and defeating the Chatti, they discovered Roman soldiers who had been captured and enslaved after the battle of the Teutoburg Forest 40 years earlier.

This story has always interested me, but Tacitus was born 7 years after it supposedly happened and there isn't much I can find beyond the basics that I have provided, with some points often differing slightly. Did it happen? Could it have happened? As uplifting as the story is (I use uplifting in lack of a better word), I find it hard to believe when I would have expected it to have been documented a great deal more, instead of being briefly described by someone who wasn't even alive when it happened.

1 Answers 2016-02-06

In movies Americans are always depicted as the main sides in the Vietnam war, how much of an impact did the ARVN really play, and how would they potentially do without help of the Americans?

2 Answers 2016-02-06

4552 / 7255

Back to start