I'm playing through AC: Syndicate right now (Victorian England) and was discussing the game with my wife as a potential resource for one of her class assignments. The assignment is to come up with a potential topic for a fake class. Since talking about it I've been wondering what /r/AskHistorians thinks about the games and couldn't find much by searching.
So, how do the games stack up to the historical figures included as major characters? How well do they do at depicting specific events? How does the historian community view the games overall?
1 Answers 2016-01-24
I've been listening to Hamilton, and they frequently reference Hamilton being an immigrant from the Caribbean. He came to America as a teenager and he wasn't wealthy, so I'm guessing he would have, but was it something anyone ever commented on or wrote about?
2 Answers 2016-01-24
By standardized, what I mean is that I can reference John 3:16 and that will be recognizable to anyone familiar with the Gospels. But I'm assuming at some point, scholars would have taken the Biblical text and assigned chapters and verses to it.
A couple of other questions related to that:
is the chapter and verse structure assigned to the original languages? I'm assuming that's the case because the verses vary in length; some may be a full sentence while others are just clauses or sentence fragments.
Does the Torah follow the same chapter and verse structure that we'd find in the first books of the Christian bible? Or does it have its own indexing system?
Was this sort of indexing system used for other ancient texts?
2 Answers 2016-01-24
A few brief examples, from the testimony of Josef Kramer, Kommandant of Birkenau:
Did you prefer to be a party to wholesale murder rather than to be arrested yourself? - I did not partake in this mass murder.
Do you think that anyone is entitled to give or to execute orders for the mass murder of innocent people? - Probably there must have been somebody who issued these orders. I myself never saw them and have nothing to do with it.
I put it to you that not only were you present at these selections, but you took an active, and very active, part in making the selections yourself? - That is not true. It is a lie.
You heard witnesses here in person, one after another, and affidavits of dozens of other people read, with regard to the beatings which went on at Auschwitz. Do you say that never happened? - Yes.
Let me suggest to you that you beat so many people that you cannot remember any particular one? - I can only say I have not beaten any prisoner.
Irma Grese denied all allegations of abuse as well:
There was a lot of beating of prisoners there, was there not? - I did not see it.
I suggest this to you: that when you went out with these working parties you made a habit of beating women and of kicking them, and you enjoyed it? - And I say that you are badly informed about me, and that it is a big lie.
Gertrud Diament in her deposition said that your favourite habit was to beat women until they fell to the ground and then kick them as hard as you could with your heavy boots? - That is a lie. Perhaps it is her habit to lie.
These people knew they were being selected to die, did they not? - I did not know and the people could not have known either. Nobody knew why these selections were made.
Are you seriously asking the Court to believe that? - Yes.
Is it not right that it was quite easy to tell a selection parade because only Jews had to parade for it? - We were never told anything about it.
Throughout the testimonies, these examples seem to be common answers from former SS guards. I noticed that according to a large number of guards, they were never themselves part of gas chamber selection, it was always either someone else giving the orders for murders or beating prisoners, or it never happened to begin with, and almost all accusations of abuse by former prisoners were considered lies or exaggerations. And on top of everything, the most surprising part of all is that they seem to have zero emotional response or general remorse over what they were part of.
Have these reactions been studied at all? If so, what was the reason behind such blatant denial of wrongdoing or abuse in the camps? Was the average guard actually that naive, or were there actually very few guards who were involved with murder or abuse in Auschwitz-Birkenau?
2 Answers 2016-01-24
For those not in the know, here's the Wikipedia page on perpetual stew. The one with which I'm most familiar with is Welsh cawl, not that the recipe cited is a perpetual version.
I can think of certain advantages to a perpetual stew including:
economy
ease of cooking
However, I also presume there were certain drawbacks.
what would the effects of spoilage be? No matter how well you try and mix the ingredients in the pot, there will always be some residual food from previous days/weeks. Surely this had a spoiling point, and therefore could contaminate the rest of the batch?
if spoiling of a perpetual stew happened, how was the dish "restarted", for lack of a better word?
were there nutritive drawbacks (not every diner is guaranteed the same ratios of foods in each portion)?
I've deliberately not specified a period/place for this question. Many thanks for your input. EDIT: formatting to make bullet points work
3 Answers 2016-01-24
As thousands of Jews, ethnic minorities, and other persecuted peoples were in the camps at one time, I'm curious to know if there were any historical instances where they revolted against the Kapos or SS in the camps
1 Answers 2016-01-24
And why did they stop this? Up until 800, there were still some Popes who became Saint but that has since stopped. What happened? Why?
1 Answers 2016-01-24
1 Answers 2016-01-24
We hear lots of legends about the seven legendary kings, the founding of the city by Romulus and Remus etc. While many of these are clearly legends, do we have any historical truth as to what existed prior to the Republic? Were the kings actually real people?
1 Answers 2016-01-24
Hello. I came across this article http://blogs.denverpost.com/captured/2013/01/28/podlich-afghanistan-1960s-photos/5846/ yesterday that shows pictures of Afghanistan from the 1960's, and seem to illustrate a (relatively) progressive, functioning society of the kind we would recognize in the West.
I see compilations like this relatively frequently, and similar ones from Iran during the Shah's day which represent the country as being modernized, relatively tolerant, and not a bad place to live.
My question is, how close to reality are the pictures in these sorts of compilations? Are we seeing the lives of a small, privileged elite that lived in Kabul and/or Tehran? Or were these countries truly dynamic and (again, relatively) progressive places before being 'ruined' by religious extremism and repressive societies?
Of course I know that the Shah and the King of Afghanistan were very repressive themselves, but arguably less so then the regimes that followed them. I'm not very educated about the recent history of these regions so I'm interested to know more.
1 Answers 2016-01-24
Always wondered this but don't have ND Zemon's book at hand. Guerre lived amongst Basque and Occitan speakers, even though the trial judges and representatives from the French court likely spoke French? Are there any interesting social history details that arise from this potential dialect differences?
1 Answers 2016-01-24
[deleted]
1 Answers 2016-01-24
3 Answers 2016-01-24
I was told by family members that there were raids on homes during Leninist Russia (please excuse me if I'm using the wrong term here). They said that churches were destroyed, religious relics and icons were sold off or melted down for their gold, and priests were killed or sent to political prisons to die. Does anyone here have an expert view on these questions? Thank you in advance.
1 Answers 2016-01-24
How many republics were there in Islam and what characteristics did they have (political structure, law, etc.)?
1 Answers 2016-01-24
1 Answers 2016-01-24
1 Answers 2016-01-24
Edit: Outside the Book of Genesis
6 Answers 2016-01-24
What were their lives like during this time? Were they still treated well by their neighbors or did they face prejudices similar to what people from neighboring Asian countries faced? Did any of them side politically with Japan and turn against their home countries after Japan joined the Axis powers? Was there any state sponsored actions taken against these non-Japanese citizens?
2 Answers 2016-01-24
Having lived in Florida the past 20 yrs, I'm accustomed to mosquitos being a part of life. My question is how did native Americans that lived here deal with mosquitos being that they didn't have a concept of "indoors", aside from open air living spaces? Did they not care about getting bit or is it known if they had their own way of combating the bugs?
5 Answers 2016-01-24
I was playing Age of Mythology and had Slingers and Bowmen fighting alongside. Seems like not the best weapon, if bows can match or outdo the range, power and efficiency of slings. Slings also seem to be much older tech than bows, so why use them?
1 Answers 2016-01-24
Hi reddit! Im currently looking into communism in Russia and one thing that really struck me was Lenin's NEP as its not mentioned much in the grand scheme of communism in Russia. How impactful (generally speaking) was the NEP? If you could cite any sources used it would be greatly appreciated.
1 Answers 2016-01-24
Looking at the map set in late 1940 that would seem to me the best coarse of action. If you can't invade Britain then take over their territories within reach: Malta, Gibraltar, and Egypt.
1 Answers 2016-01-24