How did the major empires of the world fall (Greece, Rome, Britain, etc.) and were there similar trends in their economies that led to their downfall?

I was told by a friend that all the empires fell primarily because of a giant wealth gap in their societies that weakened them from outsiders or made the general populace rebel (usually both). Obviously he was saying this because of his political stance, so I have no idea if that claim is right, but it made me start wondering what the economic landscape was actually like for the great empires and did it play any large part in their downfall? Were there any similarities between their economies?

1 Answers 2016-01-02

Did the British / French intentionally leave 'unstable' states when decolonizing?

This comes from a friend, who claims that the British/French intentionally left a mess in the Middle East so these colonies would come 'crawling back' asking to be colonies again, after they 'realized' how hard it was to govern themselves.

E.g., Britain 'created Iraq,' where Sunni, Shiite, and Kurds would all live together knowing that it would actually be quite disasterous.

3 Answers 2016-01-01

Grandfather recently passed away and I was wondering what these WWII medals signify?

http://imgur.com/a/8TsjP

I was unable to talk to him about these before he passed (which I deeply regret) and thought I owed it to him to look more into it. I understand what the purple heart and bronze star mean, but don't have a clue for the others.

Any help or insight would be great. I apologize in advance if this is the wrong subreddit for such content.

3 Answers 2016-01-01

Were the Industrial Revolution and capitalism the result of the Trans-Atlantic slave trade?

Howdy,

I've been reading Sven Beckert's article on this topic in the Chronicle of Higher Education about the development of slavery and capitalism, in which he basically attributes capitalism, industrialisation, and the modern system of the rule of law to the institution of slavery. I was wondering what the rest of the historical community feels about this topic: is it true that slavery created both capitalism and the industrial revolution?

1 Answers 2016-01-01

Did Stalin have a secret police to watch his secret police?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2016-01-01

How could the UN command be against the Chinese in the Korean War if China was part of the UN?

1 Answers 2016-01-01

How do leaders of opposing nations know that they will be safe when visiting other nations?

Follow up question: Has there ever been an attempt by a state to assassinate a visiting foreign leader?

1 Answers 2016-01-01

What was the Byzantine Empire known as by its neighbours during its time?

I heard that the word 'Byzantine' is a modern way of referencing the Eastern Roman Empire after the West fell. What did the Sassanids refer to them as? What did the Arabs and Europeans call them? When Constantinople was conquered, did the Turks yell in joy and proclaim they finally destroyed the Roman Empire or did they call it something else?

2 Answers 2016-01-01

Did the city-states of Greece, like Sparta or Athens, have a concept of "Just War," did they fight with certain rules?

I'm currently writing a series of stories based upon the premise that the Spartans never lost a battle since the Battle of Thermopylae so I am trying to understand their concept of war better.

If they invaded another country, would they accept surrenders or kill without mercy?

Also, this is more of a religious question, but did Spartans sacrifice human lives for offerings to their Gods?

I know it's a lot to ask, but I'd love to learn more.

2 Answers 2016-01-01

Why did Turkey not take all of Cyprus?

Compared to Cyprus, Turkey is FAR stronger and it can easily spam reinforcements to the island. Despite this, the Turks only managed to occupy a third of the Island (North Cyprus), why is this? Did they not want to advance further? Was there too much international pressure? Was the Turkish advance too costly in terms of lives?

1 Answers 2016-01-01

Book/documentary about the Third Indochina War

I've seen a lot of books and resources about the first two Indochina Wars, but not much about all of the conflicts generally put under the umbrella of the Third Indochina War. Anyone know any good books or documentaries about this topic?

1 Answers 2016-01-01

Did the Soviets really intend to occupy Hokkaido after World War II?

And perhaps create their own satellite there like in North Korea and East Germany?

1 Answers 2016-01-01

Are there people that share similar genetics with the ancient Israelites/Jews?

Due to the migration of the Jews, they've largely picked up genetics of their host countries. Are there still people with similar genetics such as the Palestinians or people in that part of the world?

3 Answers 2016-01-01

Now that 1996 is fair game, what lead to the problems between Chechnya and Russia?

The First Chechnyan War ended in 1996. The history of breakaway republics from Russia has always interested me. What caused Chechnya to want to break away from Russia?

1 Answers 2016-01-01

What is a good place to find accurate historical maps with accurate political boundaries etc?

1 Answers 2016-01-01

Which Western intellectuals visited Mao Zedong?

I am watching the CNN documentaries on the Cold War. It is mentioned in the episode on China that western intellectuals came to Beijing to meet Mao? Which western intellectuals will have been to visit Mao?

1 Answers 2016-01-01

What was Stalin's reaction to D-Day?

After requesting a second front in Europe for almost 3 years, Stalin finally got his request in the form of D-Day. However, as far as I understand it, Stalin saw this as too little too late from Britain and the United States, as the USSR were already marching towards Berlin. So how did Stalin see D-Day? Was it greeted with delight as the invasion he had dreamed of? Or did he simply view it as a case of the west invading at the last possible moment, when victory was all but assured?

2 Answers 2016-01-01

Do we know the history of public nudity such as mooning, flashing, streaking, etc? When it was first used? Was there a punishment if caught? Was it meant to be serious/funny/etc? Is there anywhere it wouldn't have been considered a indecent act?

1 Answers 2016-01-01

How effective was the government in Nazi Germany

So I'm not asking if they were good or if what they were doing was right, but I'm asking for an unbiased analysis of how effective their governing system was. I saw a post earlier about erdogan citing them as being a good example of an effective government but I just want to know how accurate that statement is.

1 Answers 2016-01-01

During the eras when bugle and trumpet calls were used to relay orders, did armies ever try deception by faking the calls of the enemy to fool them into attacking or retreating or by faking their own calls to make the enemy think they were doing something that they weren't?

1 Answers 2016-01-01

When did residents of the Italian peninsula start thinking of themselves as "Italian" rather than "Roman"?

Title.

2 Answers 2016-01-01

It's the year 0 BC and I am the richest man in the Roman Empire. I want to throw the biggest party of the year, how would I go about it ?

1 Answers 2016-01-01

Why was the Dayton Peace Agreement held in Dayton?

Basically the title. Why was the agreement held in the US? Furthermore, why Dayton, and not Washington DC or New York?

1 Answers 2016-01-01

Were there PLA regulars fighting in Vietnam?

It's a fairly common story; Billy Waugh recounted fighting a force of Chinese infantry around Bong Son, and that definitely wasn't the first time I heard about the Chinese having boots on the ground in South Vietnam (I think Charlie Beckwith mentioned it in Delta Force, but I could be wrong there). The Chinese were sending massive technical and advisory aid to the North, but were there frontline combat troops in the war?

1 Answers 2016-01-01

Why did attitudes about Native Americans change from early English colonial times to Thomas Jefferson's time?

I was reading Undaunted Courage by Stephen Ambrose, and he mentioned how Jefferson, Clark, and Lewis (as well as many of their contemporaries) viewed native Americans as a sort of "noble savage," who could be "civilized" and brought into the fold of American society (as opposed to black slaves, who they saw as simply inferior). This seems to contrast greatly with the earlier attitudes of the colonists, who warred even more frequently with the native Americans and seemed to just despise them.

Am I assuming the wrong things here? Or if I'm not, what could have caused this change?

1 Answers 2016-01-01

4666 / 7255

Back to start