I'm a traveler in the ancient world, and I pass by the site of a major engagement several years after the fact (i.e. Teutoberg, Cannae, Mantinea, etc). Am I still able to see clear signs that a battle took place?

Beyond the experience of the participants, I imagine ancient warfare could be hell on the landscape itself, with plenty of detritus afterwards. You'd have bodies-turned-bones of men, horses, or other animals; you'd have damaged and discarded armor or other equipment; you'd have abandoned fortifications. It seems like, given a large enough battle in a remote enough location, it could be many, many years before the landscape is returned to something like a "natural" state, to the point where it would be unrecognizable to passers-by as a one-time battlefield.

Would it have been common for travelers in the ancient world to recognize and take note of old battlefields of which they had no prior knowledge? Do we have any records of ancient authors visiting such sites and seeing traces of the fight (I'm particularly interested in the Roman and Hellenic worlds, but would be interested to hear from other places/times as well)? Or would all the "stuff" on battlefields in remote or settled areas be swallowed quickly, by nature or by human endeavor?

I didn't see any old threads on this but I'm sure someone has asked this before. Sorry if this is too broad.

3 Answers 2015-11-17

What was the impact of colonial rule in Syria? Can colonial rule in Syria be considered responsible for modern social/ethnic/tribal tensions in Syria?

Want to understand if the tensions between Shia/Sunni/Alawites etc. have always been a component of Syrian history or whether these are more recent developments.

1 Answers 2015-11-17

Was the Battle of Colachel in 1741 the first instance of an Asian power defeating a European power in the history of naval warfare?

The Battle of Colachel saw the triumph of the Kingdom of Travancore led by Marthanda Varma over Dutch East India Company forces led by Admiral Eustachius De Lannoy. According to an uncited claim on Wikipedia, this was the first time an Asian country beat a European power at sea.

Is this true?

3 Answers 2015-11-17

How did Mandarin Chinese come to use the question mark (?) and what was used before to differentiate written questions from statements?

3 Answers 2015-11-17

Why are there so many names starting with "Jo"?

Hi! I live in Norway, and there's an incredibly big amount of very common names starting with Jo: Johan, Johannes, Johanne, Johanna, Jo, Jon, Joakim, Jonatan, Johar, Joseph, Joshua-

Furthermore, there are even more names common in other countries: Joe, Johnny ,Josh ,etc...

But why? Why is there such a huge amount of names starting with "Jo" specifically? And why is it so common to be named one of these names in Norway?

1 Answers 2015-11-17

How did the people of the Near East / Greeks / Romans (1000 BC - 200 AD) understand the concept of spirits?

Did they believe them to be made of "stuff"? It seems that sometimes they use the word "wind" to refer to spirits. In some Greek narratives, they behave like vapor. Did they believe them to be made of "stuff" which is unseen but physical?

1 Answers 2015-11-17

Has a canal ever been planned or attempted through the Iberian Peninsula?

1 Answers 2015-11-17

What was World War I referred to as before World War II?

Did people just call it "The World War", was it called "World War I" because they were expecting another one, or was it referred to as something else?

1 Answers 2015-11-17

New Amsterdam seems to have been somewhat of a melting pot, much like it´s successor New York. Did the colony develop it´s own (mixed) culture in her 40 years of existence? Or did it closely resemble Dutch society?

2 Answers 2015-11-17

Where the provinces critical in the the success of the Roman empire?

Did the provinces play an important part in the success of the empire?

2 Answers 2015-11-17

AMA: I’m Jim Marten, a historian who would love to answer your questions about the **social history of the Civil War era** or about the **lives of children and youth**, mainly in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries.

AMA: Good morning! I’m Jim Marten, a historian who would love to answer your questions about the social history of the Civil War era or about the lives of children and youth, mainly in the nineteenth and early twentieth centuries. I’m particularly fascinated by the ways in which war intruded on the lives of children and youth and the ways they became participants as well as victims of war. More recently, I’ve explored the ways that war affects former Civil War soldiers—a particularly timely issue in America given our ongoing wars in the Middle East.

I’ve written and edited books about: --children in wartime—for instance, THE CHILDREN'S CIVIL WAR (http://uncpress.unc.edu/books/T-274.html) and CHILDREN AND WAR

--the Civil War home front—for instance, CIVIL WAR AMERICA: VOICES FROM THE HOME FRONT.

--Civil War veterans—for instance, SING NOT WAR: THE LIVES OF UNION AND CONFEDERATE VETERANS IN GILDED AGE AMERICA (http://uncpress.unc.edu/browse/book_detail?title_id=1877) and AMERICA'S CORPORAL: JAMES TANNER IN WAR AND PEACE (http://www.ugapress.org/index.php/books/americas_corporal).

I’m professor of history at Marquette University in Milwaukee. If you want to find out more about me, you can check me out on my department’s website AT (http://www.marquette.edu/history/HistFacultyMarten.shtml).

I look forward to reading your questions!

38 Answers 2015-11-17

How did the US media and general population respond to the student protests of the 1960s? What was the dominant media narrative (praise, condemnation, discussions of free speech)? And what was the relationship between student activism and the greater civil rights and anti-war movements?

4 Answers 2015-11-17

Why was there such a quick decline in the Wermacht between 1944 and 1945?

What I'm saying is how does a country as powerful as germany lose it all within a year? It seems like they spiraled out of control very quickly.

2 Answers 2015-11-17

When, and how, did mint become the universal "fresh" flavouring for mouth hygiene products?

In the western world today mint has a near monopoly on flavouring for things like mouthwash and toothpaste, whereas for example in Asia you can easily find lemon or other flavours, and I've heard that lavender and rose were popular in Europe up until around ww2.

Does anyone have any insight as to when and how the shift to mint happened?

2 Answers 2015-11-17

France trying to introduce wolves back to england

Hey guys !

Was joking with a british guy today and remembered something I heard on the french radio a long time ago: that we were so jealous of their wool quality, due to the destruction of the Wolf in England, that our king (Louis the XIVth or close) decided to try to reintroduce wolves in England by sending them by ship. I don't recall if it was said as a mere project or as something actually done.

Now when I tried to find any proof or source, I couldn't, neither in French nor in English. So... is it bullshit ?

1 Answers 2015-11-17

Have "sex contracts" like the one between Dwight and Angela in "The Office"---in which a couple is obligated to copulate with the intent of procreation---existed at any point in western history?

[deleted]

1 Answers 2015-11-17

Was there any notion of anti-semitism during WW1? If so, did WW1 have any impact on how Jews were treated in WW2/The Holocaust?

My history course has made me curious on the status of Jews.

  • How were Jews treated before WW1.

  • How were they treated during WW1.

  • When did the these negative feelings toward Jews manifest? Any prime examples prior to Hitler's actions (deathcamps, 'Final Solution', eugenics, etc)?

1 Answers 2015-11-17

I understand that Native Americans would have been especially vulnerable to European diseases, but wouldn't the opposite have been true? Were Europeans ravaged by New World diseases? Did Native Americans really have overall weaker immune systems as history would have us believe?

[deleted]

3 Answers 2015-11-17

In several grade/high school US history courses I remember hearing that slaves could purchase their freedom. How is this possible, did many slaves manage to achieve this?

1 Answers 2015-11-17

Users of /r/AskHistorians, what are your favorite history related podcasts?

Looking for any and all history podcasts so please throw them all at me!

2 Answers 2015-11-17

What does an undergrad in history entail?

Aspiring historian here. I'm in the middle of enrolling in my last semester of classes for my AAT (education, 8-12) and wanted to pick some brains. Right this minute, my plan is to finish this degree, take enough time to pay off my car, and then go to get my BA in history. I have a lot more questions than answers right now though, and my school doesn't have a history/general social sciences advisor.

So what kinds of things should I expect going in to finish my BA? How specialized am I likely to get? (Pre-modern English history is where I want to end up eventually. 19th-20th century East Asia is a close second, but I'll work out those details along the way.) How much research is involved? What does undergrad history research even look like?

I'm dead set on what I want to do with my degree straight out the gate - I absolutely want to teach, and I absolutely want to continue my own studies for as long as I can. I just don't know if the timing is right. What do you guys think?

2 Answers 2015-11-17

What is the source on this quote from Alexis de Toqueville?

"Grant me thirty years of equal division of inheritances and a free press, and I will provide you with a Republic."

I'm trying to find this quote for an essay on "Democracy in America" and my professor gave us 5 quotes but I can't find this one anywhere in the text for the life of me. All my searching attributes this quote to him, but doesn't give a source. Some Googling hasn't turned up this quote actually appearing in "Democracy in America"

I'm confused. Can anyone here help?

What's the deal?

1 Answers 2015-11-17

Where did the word "fuck" come from?

I know this is a weird question but I started thinking, how can a word be held as offensive? What made it offensive and where did it come from? I know the question is a bit inappropriate but im still curious. Are these words just passed down and given their meaning?

2 Answers 2015-11-17

Was Louis the 14th really a dancing fanatic ?

I was sitting in art class today and we were looking over the portrait of Louis the 14th. He was all dressed up but this weird thing is he had on what looked like red high heels, a classmate of mine said that Louis was a dancer. Is this true? Was Louis the 14th known to cut the rug and dance if he wanted to?

1 Answers 2015-11-17

In the Tenth Century, how did The Church view sexual attraction within Marriage?

Say I am a King, and I happen to be attracted to my wife? If I wanted some private time with her during the day, would the church consider me sinful? What about the general public?

1 Answers 2015-11-17

4793 / 7255

Back to start