Was anything like the Warning Beacons of Gondor from The Lord of the Rings ever used in real life?

1 Answers 2015-11-07

How historically accurate is the BBC/CNN Cold War documentary series?

This one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cold_War_(TV_series)

Just wondering if it's worth watching

1 Answers 2015-11-07

When the Northern states began voluntarily abolishing slavery, was there any movement of Northern slaveowners to the South, or Northern states that hadn't yet embraced abolition?

1 Answers 2015-11-07

Why does my USMC dad hate Gen MacArthur?

My father always says the same thing whenever Douglas MacArthur is the topic; the general, "used Marines as fodder" during WWII. I haven't been able to find clear evidence that MacArthur used the Marines to his own benefit anywhere. Were there Marine suicide missions ordered under Gen MacArthur's hand?

3 Answers 2015-11-07

What has been the pace of development of communications technology, century by century?

A paper I'm reading says that computer is the fastest progressing technology in history, and "No other technology since civilization began has seen six orders of magnitude in performance price gain in 30 years."

So how fast has technology been developing? Let's limit to communications, including oral speech and forms, writing style and techniques (book binding, library, etc), printing press, telegraph, etc.

1 Answers 2015-11-07

I'm looking for good books representing England's opinion on the French Revolution. Any suggestions?

I have so far found a collection of texts (including English) from the 1790s, and Burke's Reflections on the French Revolution. I'm looking specifically for a more modern (scholarly) source for a term paper, but any suggestions are great. Thanks!

1 Answers 2015-11-07

Question about race in the 1930-1960s

So I don't know how to best explain my question but here goes.

My grandfather was born in 1923 in South. He moved up north after the being discharged from the Army in the late 40s, early 50s.

Today, in America, we have this concept of "acting like your race". e.g. "Talking black/white", "Acting white or black"

Was this concept around back in the 1930s-1960s? When I look at casual photos of my (now deceased) grandfather, he dressed like what some in 2015 would call "white". My grandfather, although black, dressed like Don Draper and had the stereotypical 1950s family. And so did a lot of older black people I have spoken to.

I hope you all can understand my question.

2 Answers 2015-11-07

With borrow words aside, are Celtic languages closer to the Germanic or Romantic tongues? And what of genetics, ancient customs, religions, and cultures?

I know that Irish and Scots Gaelic carries with it the similar notable 'ch' sound heard in German and Dutch, yet I wonder because of historical names which languages and culture the Celts were closer to. For example the people of what has become mostly France were called and considered the Gallic people, and naturally these names sound similar to the British Isles "Gael." Naturally a lot history of peoples can be derived from linguistic evolution (such as we see with Sanskrit's ancient connections to many Indo European languages). Furthermore and besides linguistics, what does DNA relativity and closeness of modern European peoples tell us?

1 Answers 2015-11-07

Were there any slaves at the signing of the Declaration of Independence or the Constitutional Convention?

I think we overlook/undervalue the contributions of black Americans during the Revolution, so I am wondering if any delegates brought their slaves with them, or if any slaves were present. And if so, do we know their role?

1 Answers 2015-11-07

Majority of ships in the modern Japanese Navy share the same name of ships in the IJN, was this on purpose as some type of heritage thing or was it just because they don't have other names to call them?

1 Answers 2015-11-07

What religion is most comparable to what the ancient Egyptians believed.

We have Catholicism, Judaism, etc. But what is pyramid era Egyptian? Zoroastrian or something? I mean, i know it's not that

1 Answers 2015-11-07

Titles of some novel set in the ancient world?

I'm current TAing a class on ancient near Eastern, Greek, and Roman history and my professor want us to give the students some antique themed novels to read over thanksgiving break. We have had Geraldine Brooks "the Secret Chord" and Mary renault's "the Persian Boy" as suggestions.

Do you guys know of any other modern series set in the ancient world that may intrigue the students?

3 Answers 2015-11-07

Explanation of a Social Democracy?

[deleted]

2 Answers 2015-11-07

How could Germany ore ww2 build such a military might if everything they did to do that was forbidden by the Treaty of Versailles?

1 Answers 2015-11-07

When (and why) did capital punishment start being carried out by lethal injection?

1 Answers 2015-11-07

Okay, why does Madagascar use Norwegian Sign Language?

Malagasy sign language is Norwegian Sign Language. Why was it introduced to Madagascar? Why not French sign language?

1 Answers 2015-11-07

What exactly is Rankean historiography(or the style of historiography pioneered by Leopold von Ranke)? Why has it been rendered obsolete/gone out of style now?(more inside).

From this article(quoting from it):

where the search for its past was sought to be secured by ‘scientific’ means. This, as in other parts of social sciences, owed its existence to thinking pioneered in Germany in the 19th century. In history, it was the historian Leopold von Ranke (1795-1886) who sought to ground history writing in unimpeachable facts based on sources as close to the event or person whose history was being written. If the relevant sources could not be found, then one could not write a ‘scientific’ history. Today, the Rankean view is considered archaic at best; at worst it is considered a positive hindrance to understanding the past.

The article: http://m.openthemagazine.com/redeeming-the-historian-from-history

1 Answers 2015-11-07

Why is the dominant language spoken in Taiwan Mandarin Chinese and not Taiwanese (or Fuzhounese)?

It seems, given the historical bad blood between the two peoples, that Taiwan's people would be less amenable to speaking the language of their Chinese cousins: Was this a conscious decision by government, or the source of cultural/economic pressures in the region? Or just for convenience sake due to a melting pot of dialects, similar to the problem China itself encountered?

2 Answers 2015-11-07

Scientists that were killed by the inquisition in the Medieval ages?

I am sorry if I have made some grammar mistakes whilst writing this post, English is not my first language, I hope I won't be attacked for this.

I was trying to look for a list of scientists killed by the inquisition on Google and in history books, but most of the results I found were from the late 15th and 16th century, which is the technically the Renaissance era. Why is that so? In my homework, I stated the fact that in the Middle ages (not renaissance, so I have to stick to my statement very strictly) people who tried to go against the ideology of the Catholic Church (study science and physics) were tortured because science was considered witchcraft.

I can't find any matching results. So, am I wrong stating this fact? When I talked to my teacher, she didn't say I was wrong, she told me that I should back my statement up with an accurate fact - name, country, the year of death.

TL;DR: I am desperately looking for information about scientists from the 13th or 14th century who were killed by the inquisition or witch hunt.

Thank you!

1 Answers 2015-11-07

Why Germany after the treaty of Brest-Litovsk don't focus on recovering their economy instead of making a new offensive in France?

After the treaty Germany had access to Ukrainian racecourses and therefore wheat and other resources.
Wasn't it better to wait 1919 for a new offensive as Otto Von Below proposed:

" Forget about the offensive and shorten the front lines as much as necessary; build Panzers throughout all of 1918 and, with your Panzer squadrons, break through all the way to the Channel coast in the Spring of 1919."

2 Answers 2015-11-07

Why did the Chetniks collaborate with the Axis during World War II?

I read that the Chetniks were Serb nationalists and mostly targeted Croats - but during the course of World War II and the Axis invasion of Yugoslavia, after initially resisting, they began collaborating with the Axis and the Independent State of Croatia, which was an Axis puppet state.

What exactly motivated them to collaborate, if their main ideology was based on Serbian nationalism?

1 Answers 2015-11-07

How do historians define "Baathism", and was it a widespread force in the Middle East? How extensive was contact and cooperation between the Syrian and Iraqi branches in power?

Keeping discussion within the twenty year rule, of course.

1 Answers 2015-11-07

HOw did the Manchu people conquer China?

2 Answers 2015-11-07

What is known about "Torture Societies" in 17th Century Russia?

I was reading Robert K. Massie's fantastic book, "Peter the Great" and I came across this passage:

Although public torture and execution were no novelty to any seventeenth-century European, what struck most visitors to Russia was the stoicism, “the unconquerable stubbornness” with which most Russians accepted these terrible agonies. They steadfastly resisted hideous pain, refusing to betray friends, and when condemned to death they went meekly and calmly to the gallows or block. An observer in Astrachan saw thirty rebels beheaded in less than half an hour. There was no noise or clamor. The condemned men simply went to the block and laid their heads in the pools of blood left by their predecessors. None even had his hands tied behind him. This incredible hardiness and unconquerable endurance of pain astonished not only foreigners but also Peter himself. Once, after a man had been tortured four times by knout and fire, Peter approached him in sheer wonder and asked how he could stand such great pain. The man was happy to talk about it and revealed to Peter the existence of a torture society of which he was a member. He explained that nobody was admitted without first being tortured, and that thereafter promotion within the society rested on being able to accept higher grades of torture.

What is known about these societies? Were they common? Why were they founded? How did they operate? Any information would be great.

1 Answers 2015-11-07

In the United States during the time of slavery did anyone argue that the use of slaves eliminated jobs that other wise would have been done by free citizens.

I understand that the work slaves did was terribly hard work. However I find it hard to believe that there were not unemployed people who would do any job they could find.

2 Answers 2015-11-07

4820 / 7255

Back to start