2 Answers 2015-11-02
1 Answers 2015-11-02
So I was doing some reading in Wikipedia on Napolean and what struck me was that Napolean was said to have been fond of Muhammad even to the extent of defending him against Voltaire's play.
Could somebody elaborate on how Napolean might have read about Muhammad and his unorthodox view on Muhammad given that he lived in a time where Catholicism was pretty much opposed to Islam .
1 Answers 2015-11-02
A long time ago, I listened to a podcast where an Orthodox priest talked about the theology of divorce in the Orthodox Church. One Cardinal, Cardinal Kasper, made a statement arguing for the admiting of divorced and remarried Catholics to communion, and he appealed to the eastern tradition of allowing divorce to show some historical precedence in the church. The Orthodox priest objected to this, because he the two churches understand marriage and divorce completely differently. The west views it as a contract, that can be annulled when needed and broken(which would be bad). The eastern church says that that Yes, you can fail a marriage and be forgiven of that. And you can have a second one along with that. The ceremony for a second marriage service is a penitential ceremony, wherein the two people basically beg God to forgive them for entering into a second marriage.
Now sorry for the theologizing. I imagine that's rather unpleasant to this secular audience.
How did these two understandings develop? What happened? when did they diverge? Was there always such a division between the east and the west?
1 Answers 2015-11-02
I'm looking for literature on Ottoman perspective of the battle of Lepanto and its consequences. I also wonder how Turkish national historiography perceived this event... Anybody knows any literature on this topic? Thanks!
1 Answers 2015-11-02
1 Answers 2015-11-02
1 Answers 2015-11-02
Thinking of fancier clothing, that's a lot of layers! Did women colonizers from northern Iberia adapt their styles of dress (fabric, number of layers, etc) after living in Mexico for some time? Were there appreciable differences in regional fashion within, say, the 19th century U.S. based on dealing with a Texas or Florida summer versus northern California, or a Chicago winter?
1 Answers 2015-11-02
I got thinking the other day, with Rome having a professional standing army, could the immediate family such as the wife and young children of Roman soldiers expect any sort of aid from army if their husband/father fell in battle or were they just suddenly left to fend for themselves?
Edit: Ickk... typo in the title it won't let me fix. Should be obvious but I meant "of dead soldiers"
1 Answers 2015-11-02
Statement made in this short clip (3 minutes):
Sorry for the source(liveleak) its totally safe for work! http://www.liveleak.com/ll_embed?f=7782177782e1
Is there any evidence either side to the statement he makes?
We know the Temple in Jerusalem was destroyed by the Romans and they forbid Jews from entering. However did Jews in fact leave Palestine as a result in any great numbers(Exile)?
Edit:
There seems to be a debate more on semantics of what the video says than if anyone can actually provide evidence. Here is a transcript below for every one to read.
Transcript below for everyone to read:
Its pretty clear he was answering a question about Exile. The whole debate is about EXILE. He uses the word Expelled in the same answer. Anyone reading it in context can see that he is using Expelled and Exile interchangeably. Everyone seems to be debating semantics and no one is providing external evidence.
Start at @ 28:50 minutes
Host: ... that exile has been a recurring theme certainly in Jewish biblical history.
Sacha: Yes it certainly has. One of the things you try to do in this film is to debunk as it were the myth of exile and you are quite right to emphasis that there was actually no evidence of actual exile of jews out of Palestine as a result of the destruction of the temple and this is something which has been widely known but at the same time it seems to me that exile is not just a concept, not just a narrative for Jews or in the context of Jewish history because even if its true that the Jews were not expelled ever from Palestine I think thats probably correct certainly in the last 2000 years there were plenty of evictions and other forced wanderings on the Jewish communities of Europe....
2 Answers 2015-11-02
Which Great Khan able to exert the most control over the empire? How was such a vast and diverse territory administrated and kept pacified? How did the Mongols coordinate and supply fighting wars on multiple different frontiers?
3 Answers 2015-11-02
[deleted]
1 Answers 2015-11-02
I have a feeling it's influenced by the clan culture in the kingdom of Scotland but I can't find anything on the subject
2 Answers 2015-11-02
1 Answers 2015-11-02
On the one hand, it is argued that the reforms laid the foundations for Russian modernization, however others say he failed to truly have a de-facto impact on the nation, which would be more accurate?
1 Answers 2015-11-02
I know that the Dutch east india company was worth more, but which company had more manpower and military might, and which one had more free license from the government to do as they please?
1 Answers 2015-11-02
As far as I know Islamic countries / empires of old where named after their ruling dynasty, so why is this different with the Ottoman Empire?
1 Answers 2015-11-02
Considering with the introduction of new technologies like the helicopter and the assault rifle, were there any modifications in military tactics and army formations?
1 Answers 2015-11-02
Is there a reason or is it just a coincidence?
2 Answers 2015-11-02
It seems pretty sexist to me, why were early feminists like Emmeline Pankhurst supportive of this movement? Even in 1914 when it was considered acceptable. I understand that she also campaigned for the right to work so are these connected?
1 Answers 2015-11-02
As late as 1571, in the Battle of Lepanto, both sides relied on ships with oars. But past that point sails-only ships start taking over Mediterranean sea battles. What finally tipped the balance to sails?
2 Answers 2015-11-02
The anarcho-syndicalist CNT had more than a million members at a time when Anarchism was losing popularity to soviet style Marxism in the rest of the world. The main explanation I've seen offered is national temperament, but I'm generally reluctant to believe explanations that point solely to things like national culture.
1 Answers 2015-11-02