Hi guys, I'm a little obsessed with bronze age near east, but I'm having trouble conceptualizing the layout of ancient cities. If you know of any good maps that show the organization of the city, or floorplans of buildings, I would really appreciate it.
If anyone is knowledgeable about the organization of bronze age Mesopotamian cities, I'd also love to hear about it!
1 Answers 2015-10-07
Like conventional machine guns being field mounted for use as anti-air or tanks being kinda parked in place for extended periods for use as base defense or as a basic form of self-propelled artillery? This thought mainly came about when I was playing Battlefield 1942, (Not the best source by any means, just where I got the idea from) and saw tanks parking or, well staying relatively stationary using their machine guns (The ones above the hatch, not coaxial machine guns) to shoot at planes, mainly on maps like Kharkov where there was a complete lack of proper anti-aircraft and very few machine gun armed vehicles total, I believe the only things with machine guns where the APC's and tank's hatch/top mounted machine guns, and although I can't properly speak for the German side, mainly playing as the Soviets, I've seldom seen anything with a machine gun rolling out on Kharkov, mostly seeing Tigers and Kubelwagens. Another note is that while this is more rare I have seen more static-ly placed tanks being used for base defense, usually when all the areas a tank can normally go are being harassed by Tigers. I've also seen the hatch/top mounted machine guns of Shermans (presumably of the Firefly variety) being used in anti-aircraft roles on maps such as Gazala. Sorry if the semi-ramble about Battlefield 1942 is unhelpful....
1 Answers 2015-10-06
Many years ago I read an article saying that rates of violence (both 'criminal' and state-sanctioned) had decreased steadily over time (since, I believe, the 1400s). I can't remember the name of the article, the author, or which societies he was examining, but it got me thinking.
1 Answers 2015-10-06
[deleted]
1 Answers 2015-10-06
[deleted]
1 Answers 2015-10-06
I'm watching a documentary that says the SS began to imprison political enemies in Dachau in 1934. Is it known if any of the initial batch of prisoners survived until the end of the war?
1 Answers 2015-10-06
So on the Wikipedia page for flag of Morocco, they list this flag as one used in the early 20th century. I take issue with this, after doing no insignificant amount of research, I cannot find any real sources that describe that flag.
The source that Wikipedia provides is the "Nouveau Petit Larousse Illustre, 1924" the problem with that is that that couldn't possibly be the Moroccan flag in 1924 as the flag was officialy the five pointed star version by the 7th of November, 1915 (the translation of the relevant part of this Dahir (royal decree) is: "We have decreed to distinguish our flag by ornamenting its center with the Seal of Solomon with five branches, of green colour") This is clearly describing the current Moroccan flag, so the 1924 Larousse must be mistaken.
This website also describes a six pointed star and cites another Larousse, this time from 1934. My issue with this source is the same. If there ever was a window for there to be a six pointed star, it was between 1912 (the beginning of the protectorate) and 1915 (the establishment of the modern pentagram flag).
Some websites will tell the story like this: In 1912, Moulay Yusuf (the new king, as his brother had abdicated after signing the treaty making Morocco a French protectorate) put a six pointed star on the Moroccan flag, in 1915 -prior to sending Moroccan troops to fight in WWI- the protector-general of Morocco, Hubert Lyautey forces Yusuf's hand and makes Yusuf proclaim the 7th of November decree. The websites that repeat this story universally have one source (which quotes another source) a 2005 article from TelQuel by a Lamia Bouzbouz which claims the following (translated):
"According to Moroccan historian Rachid Sbihi, the pentagram was imposed on the Sultan Moulay Youssef by General Lyautey in 1915 when this latter was preparing to bring the Moroccan contingent to Europe to fight on the French front. "By the way, the question is why did Lyautey decide, at that precise moment to change the six pointed star into a five pointed one. We unfortunately do not have available a precise answer", he explains"
Once again however, I find this source inadequate because this Rachid Sbihi fellow does not seem to have ever published anything, the only mention of him online is when he is being quoted in this same article.
A Mr. S. Mitchell claims in this website that "By 1915, Morocco changed rule, and Mulay Yusuf reigned over the country. It was Yusuf who decided the Seal of Solomon had to be on the flag. The seal was green and reflective. It was of an interlaced pentangle or star. The pentangle is considered a form of occult law. The Seal of Solomon was a six-pointed star originally (before the 1900s) and was also known as the Star of David. During World War I, the flag underwent another change from the six-pointed star to a five-pointed star, thus the pentangle" but this guy has his dates all wrong, claiming that it was a six pointed star before the 1900s when there is no other source that even begins to hint this.
In her book “Moroccan Feminist Discourses (2014)” Fatima Sadiqi writes: “It is also interesting to note that until the beginning of the last century, the star on the Moroccan flag had the form of the six pointed star of David” This is the first academic source I could find mentioning a six pointed star, but unfortunately Mrs. Sadiqi is not a historian and I am unsure of how much credence to lend her regarding this matter.
¬ TL;DR: Do you know of any primary sources for the flag of Morocco in the time period between 1912 and 1915?
Bonus: This Picture and This Picture seem to be from the same book but attest to different Moroccan flags. Can anyone tell from the pixels and having seen a lot of shoops in their time whether one of them was modified?
1 Answers 2015-10-06
More to the point, when did Frankish/French self-identity become widespread across France, ahead of regional identities/allegiances.
1 Answers 2015-10-06
1 Answers 2015-10-06
5 Answers 2015-10-06
American breakfast foods: ie eggs, sausage, bacon, hashbrowns/potato variants, pancakes etc.
1 Answers 2015-10-06
Different phrasing: did the Puritan era (roughly 1620-1750) leave any outstanding influence on the United States as it emerged (1750-1800)?
1 Answers 2015-10-06
I know that it was fairly close after being put to a vote - I think younger people preferred Bonn and older people liked the nostalgia of Berlin, although it was a bit tainted by certain history. How did this process play out to what we have today (something like 50% of government staff in each city?).
2 Answers 2015-10-06
I'm asking because I saw a throwaway reference to this in a documentary about the Tocharians mummies in China. Happy halloween!
Edit: wiki mentions the "Witches of Subeshi...4th or 3rd century BCE), who wore 2-foot-long (0.61 m) black felt conical hats with a flat brim" and gives this footnote.
1 Answers 2015-10-06
I tried googling to see if I could find any evidence to support this statement but I haven't turned up anything. However I can see how using google to scour history to find evidence of this might be a bit difficult. I didn't want to write this statement off as rhetoric. Im curious if there is any truth to it at all.
1 Answers 2015-10-06
Did the movie invent the idea of three wishes? Were people outside the Middle East familiar with the idea of genies before 1992?
1 Answers 2015-10-06
2 Answers 2015-10-06
I've been looking and have never been able to find it. Since it was largely pushed around by Moscow, how did it work? And did they draw a historical distinction at all between the East part of Germany during WWII and the West part during WWII? I know there was no separation during the war, but I figured they might have tried to portray West Germany in a bad light anyway.
1 Answers 2015-10-06
I know that Columbus set sail on 1492 to the new world. Columbus led his three ships - the Nina, the Pinta and the Santa Maria. But I want to know what the discovery of America led to the Native Americans. What they went through, being pushed away from their land. Overall the affects of colonization of Native Americans. If someone could give me some few pointers or some outside sources in which I can research on, that would be nice. A timeline of important events happening to the Native Americans would be very helpful.
1 Answers 2015-10-06
It seems that 476-1000 was a fairly bad time to be living in western Europe considering migrating barbarian tribes and the absolute collapse of half an empire occurred during this time why is referring to it as a "dark age" not acceptable
2 Answers 2015-10-06
Thank you kindly for any responses. I looked in the FAQ but any recommendations were about languages.
2 Answers 2015-10-06
Learning about history in the American education system, we learned about the history of American slavery as if it was a closed story. Slavery began when Europeans went to Africa (and other places) and decided that these natives would make great slaves, so they brought them back with them. Slavery existed way back in the day in places like Rome and Egypt, but then it didnt' really exist between then and the 15th century or so. There was a 400 year mistake made by the human race that eventually led to abolitiion (and of course, the continued problems of modern human trafficking, but that's not the point I'm talking about here).
My understanding of human nature and the arc of history suggests that couldn't be the case. I doubt that explorers who made it to Africa came up with the idea of slavery out of whole cloth when they got there. What is the history of European slavery from the fall of the old Empires through the Age of Exploration?
1 Answers 2015-10-06
I was just mulling over; for all that America is relatively driven by it's founding father's mythology, I don't recall seeing any reputably sourced quotes from any of the founders re: the second amendment. This seems especially odd, given the number of gun control debates there have been.
So- what was the earliest restriction on private firearms ownership in America after the Constitution was the law of the land? How was it received, what were the consequences, was it challenged on Constitutional grounds, etc.
Thanks!
1 Answers 2015-10-06
I understand that a sword or similarly shaped bladed weapon had many advantages when it came to personal defence, but I wonder if they were really used as ubiquitously on the battlefield as Hollywood would lead me to believe.
In my (admittedly limited) experience in mock-battles, I've found that an organised group will almost always be more effective with weapons that are specialised to their battlefield role such as pikes, bows, etc, than with swords, and I wonder if this is indicative of how wars were actually carried out, or if I'm missing something.
Understand, I'm not asking about skirmishes or groups with limited organisational support (in which I can absolutely see the value in having a decent all-rounder weapon like a sword - since you never really know what kind of a situation you're going to find yourself in), I'm asking specifically about organised/regimented armies.
2 Answers 2015-10-06
We have many accounts of Conquistadors first seeing the cities of Mesoamerica and the Andes, and marveling at what they experienced. But are there any accounts of the reverse, of Native Americans first traveling to Europe and reacting to what they saw?
We know that that there quite a few natives went to Europe, such as Pocahontas and Garcilaso de la Vega, but I couldn't find any accounts on what they actually thought of what they saw. Were they amazed? Curious? Disappointed? Do any accounts survive of such first encounters?
1 Answers 2015-10-06