How reliable is Victor Hugo's account of the battle of Waterloo in Les Misérables?

I'm reading Les Misérables at the moment and the first book of the second volume (about 200 pages into my edition) is an account of the battle of Waterloo. Can this be taken as historically accurate text? Thanks very much!

4 Answers 2015-08-20

When/Why did the word Gay become associated with Homosexuality?

Because even early 1900's songs and plays used gay commonly to mean happy; content.

1 Answers 2015-08-20

Can someone explain the titles of the French nobility for me? Especially after the fall of the Second Empire and up to the First World War

I'm currently reading Marcel Proust's "In Search of Lost Time" and I'm a bit confused about all the titles and how they rank. There are barons, princes/princesses, comtes, vicomtes, marquises and dukes. What do they all mean? In the book they seem almost to regard each other as equal and reserve only special regard for people directly related to royalty.

As a follow-up question: could you please explain something about what happened to them? Why did they loose their influence on French politics?

Edit: Can I sneak in another question? Could you guys tell me a bit about the whole "Salon" culture during that time period?

2 Answers 2015-08-20

Question about origin of the myth of the undead/living dead

TL;DR at the bottom.

This may be the wrong place, if it is, I am sorry. I will have to write a research paper this semester for my Medieval and Modern Apocalypse class. Considering zombies usually go hand in hand with the apocalypse, I am thinking of writing about the true origin of the myth. Tentatively, the topic will be on the origin and evolution of the myth of the undead.

So far, I have found that the evolution of the myths have come from a few different places. Vampires seem to have come from European sources with some examples found here. On the other hand, zombies seems to have more of an African origin as shown here. I am just wondering if the Book of Revelations is a common origin for vampires and zombies. If so, is there some point where a splitting point occurs to differentiate the two. From what I understand, there is a mention in the Book of Revelations about people coming back to life and feasting on the living. This could apply to vampires or zombies and would seem like a common origin for the two. As with all stories, as it is told more, the story itself begins to change and could possibly account for the differences between the two.

TL;DR: Does anyone know of any other sources (other than the book of Revelations) where vampires and zombies may have come from a common origin. If so, is there a documented splitting point where the two become separate myths?

4 Answers 2015-08-20

Theory Thursday | Academic/Professional History Free-for-All

Previous weeks!

This week, ending in August 20 2015:

Today's thread is for open discussion of:

  • History in the academy

  • Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries

  • Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application

  • Philosophy of history

  • And so on

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

1 Answers 2015-08-20

Is there precedent for a candidate like Trump?

1 Answers 2015-08-20

What are the major civilian plane crashes in history? What was the first major one? How have they changed the way we fly?

3 Answers 2015-08-20

Would Australia have been nuked, had the Cold War escalated?

I was reading a great book called On the Beach by Nevil Schute where nuclear war escalated between the superpowers but Australia was not directly attacked.
Do we know if the Soviets had plans to attack Australia or would it have been logistically too complicated or otherwise unnecessary?
Similar question about South America as well- I was thinking if some bigger countries managed to escape the inferno, would they become the new superpowers?

3 Answers 2015-08-20

Why are so many theaters called 'Strand'?

A quick google shows Strand theaters in California, Massachusetts, Manhattan, Maine, Michigan, Plattsburgh, Louisiana, New Jersey, and more. Many of them are old - early 20th century or so, from what I can see online and from my experience going to some of them.

Were they all originally franchisees or part of a chain or something? Or is calling a theater 'Strand' simply tradition - and if so why?

4 Answers 2015-08-20

How do different wars "rang" in deadliness?

1 Answers 2015-08-20

After the battle of Manila Bay many nations such as Germany were waiting on the sideline to swoop in and take the philippines. What was Germany's plan for the Philippines had the US refused to establish there?

1 Answers 2015-08-20

When did green and purple become the unofficial secondary color palette used in Halloween decorations and motifs?

Orange, black, and yellow (in that order) comprise the primary Halloween palette (in the U.S., anyway). Purple/green may be less obvious to people who don't think about this sort of thing, but it's ubiquitous these days, just walk down the Halloween decoration or card aisle at any Walmart. I remember these colors being used as early as the mid-70s, with green perhaps most common as witches' skin and purple for night sky. I'm wondering how far back these design conventions go.

2 Answers 2015-08-20

How instrumental was Malta towards the Allied victory of the North African Campaign during WWII?

As a side question, what how important was the campaign in general? Was the Axis defeat a significant setback for them?

1 Answers 2015-08-20

WWII and Reinforced Units.

I've been reading a lot about individual battles fought by US troops during WWII and come across numerous references to reinforced units at pretty much every level from company through division and even a few corps, often with (Reinforced) after the unit name. It seems to occur most often in the Pacific and Marine units, especially are rarely listed without the qualifier. I had assumed they were just over-strength units meant to absorb casualties, but now I'm wondering if they weren't just units that had assets from a higher organization attached. What are these referring to specifically?

2 Answers 2015-08-20

When the United states was founded, were there other countries that could be called "free" at that time?

4 Answers 2015-08-20

Did the Hundred Years War abruptly end because of the internal strife in England?

I couldn't find this in the FAQ but did the Hundred Years War abruptly end (in 1453) because of the War of the Roses or were there still small-scale invasions to the French mainland?

2 Answers 2015-08-20

Why do some states manage to achieve a powerful level of unity across vast territories (e.g. China, Russia), while others splinter and destabilise? (e.g. the Balkans, Baltics)

In particular, how did Imperial China and later Republic of China manage to achieve unity across such a large and diverse geographical area? What factors allow a single nation state to endure at such immense scale, while others fail to achieve stability and cohesion despite being much smaller?

1 Answers 2015-08-20

Have bodily functions always been funny across history and cross culturally?

1 Answers 2015-08-20

What was life like on both sides of the wall during the 33-year long Siege of Ceuta?

Thanks to a recent post at /r/Badhistory, I just heard about the [Siege of Ceuta](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Siege_of_Ceuta_(1694-1727)) between 1694 and 1727. How did a generation-long siege affect the people living inside the city? How easy was it for them to travel into and out of Ceuta? How did they sustain themselves? While the daily life of the people within the city is my main interest here, I'm also curious what life was like day-to-day for the Moroccan forces outside of the city. Was there a permanent force stationed outside Ceuta that developed into its own siege-oriented community or were fresh forces constantly being deployed to the area to relieve those who had been fighting for a while?

2 Answers 2015-08-20

Do we know of anyone actually being tied up and left on the railroad tracks?

Pretty straightforward - Do we have any documented cases where a person was hogtied or otherwise bound and then secured to the traintracks? Or is this just a complete fiction?

1 Answers 2015-08-20

Are there any valid historical documentaries still being made?

I love learning about history for fun and like watching documentaries but it seems like every documentary produced in the last 10 years is always full of action, intense narrating, inaccuracies, and over-the-top reenactments.

I recently tried watching Mankind: The story of us all from the History Channel and it was completely terrible.

At one point they talked about the Vandals raiding Rome to kidnap the Empress and pillage just because. They didn't mention that the Empress herself requested they come to Rome and depose the new Emperor that murdered her husband and in exchange there would be a political marriage.

The point at which I had to shut it off was when they said that the Vikings lifted Europe out of the dark ages. All they mentioned was that they were great explorers and colonized. Not once did they mention Charlemagne and his contributions to western civilization.

Anyways, I'm finding it hard to find good quality documentaries about history, doesn't matter the time period. I just want to learn.

Can you guys recommend any quality ones?

2 Answers 2015-08-20

What other dating systems were widely used other than B.C. and A.D.? When were those systems replaced?

Particularly how did they measure time in China and Japan before European influence.

2 Answers 2015-08-20

How realistic is the battle in this anime?

I heard that this anime is the most realistic that portray medieval battles.

Here is the scene.

Ignore the witches, girls with brooms. I just want to focus on the armies itself.

1 Answers 2015-08-20

What was the best place for Irish people to immigrate to from the Victorian Era to the start of World War 1? What was life like there?

Basically I'm writing a story about a fantasy Irish guy and would like to get some knowledge on this topic.

I can't really make everything painfully realistic because that would put my readers off. On the other hand I want to show the contrast between my character and the characters of the "wonderful" medieval setting.

1 Answers 2015-08-20

Did the Kievan Rus take part in the Crusades?

I've heard that the Kievan Rus was the largest country in Europe at the time, but did they take part in the Crusades? If not, what were they up to around that time?

1 Answers 2015-08-20

5054 / 7255

Back to start