Some questions about medieval warfare for a novel.

Hey I'm thinking about writing a fantasy novel and I would like it to feel authentic, so I would really appreciate if you could answer at least some of these questions.

Here's some information about the book: It takes place in fictional world, but it would resemble mostly the Europe in the 13th-14th centuries. It would take place in a country caught between a conflict of two large alliances: United kings of the north and the imperials of the south.

  1. How would country like this prepare for a larger war that could endanger their freedom? For example would they somehow draft and train peasants or would they just go with what they already have on reserve.

  2. In this world the northern kingdoms would be a bit poorer and they couldn't afford as good equipment as empire has, but they have high morale and the population is rather harsh and strong. So what kind of a tactics and weaponry would they use to fight well equipped imperial conquers?

  3. How were the battles fought and what decided who won? Did they just clash each others until the the others felt like they can't win anymore?

  4. How much morale would affect the outcome of a battle? In this world the northerners are mostly the defending side and they will do anything to protect themselves from the "big bad empire" and the imperial soldiers are far away from home fighting a war that they don't really care about. Does this give a significant advantage to north?

  5. If a two armies of 10 thousand men would meet in battle how large would the casualties be on average? If I have understood right most of the casualties come when the others decide to retreat, so the losing side would face much larger casualties, right?

Ps. Sorry for possible spelling errors. English isn't my native language, but I tried to write as cleanly as possible. pss. Sorry for apologizing for bad English.

1 Answers 2015-08-19

Habsburg inbreeding: did it advance medicine in specific ways?

The Habsburg tendency to inbreeding is well-known and they did this over centuries. Given that they are from a very powerful and wealthy dynasty, did their inbreeding foster the development of specialized medicine to address the problems caused by inbreeding?

Thanks in advance for your answers!

1 Answers 2015-08-19

[HOME] If I was a neutrial, middle class 30 year old, father of a boy and a girl, living in Moscow when Nazi Germany is defeated and Stalin is in full power. What would my family go through in the next 20 years?

1 Answers 2015-08-19

Does anybody know where to find a translation for the elegy composed on Llywelyn ap Gruffudd (Llywelyn the Last Prince of Wales)'s death?

Llywelyn ap Gruffudd, the last semi-independent ruler before Edward the First (of Braveheart fame) conquered Wales, was killed in combat in 1282.

On his death, a poet named Gruffudd ab yr Ynad Coch composed an elegy for Llywelyn, but I've only been able to find a (Middle?) Welsh source on Wikisource.

Does anybody know of an English translation? I've looked extensively and can't find any, and the reason I'm asking is apparently the Welsh people at the time found the elegy incredibly moving and poignant, so I'd like to understand it more

1 Answers 2015-08-19

In the Bible, kings sometimes offer someone "whatever you ask, even up to half of my kingdom." Do we know of anybody who called them on that?

5 Answers 2015-08-19

Rome was Greek city (Undisputable PROOF)

1 Answers 2015-08-19

When did the Fridge become common-place in the home and what was its impact on domestic life?

3 Answers 2015-08-19

Was the Dalai Lama's Tibet a Theorcratic Regime?

The Dalai Lama is obviously often revered as a wise man of peace. If one hears him talk this seems rather obvious. However I have heard it said that when the Dalai Lama still were in Tibet before the Chinese came, it was actually a theocratic regime where the rulling religious class severely mistreated the population. Accusations of torture, starvation and gauging eyes have been made by people like Christopher Hitchens (who has an obvious anti religious sentiment which might influence what he says).

My question is, how did the religious class treat the Tibetan people before China? How common were these practices if there is any truth to them and what would a citizin of Tibet have to 'do' to suffer such a fate?

1 Answers 2015-08-19

When exactly conquest and genocide of Native Americans ended?

I know that so called Indian Wars were fought for over 300 years but when did the conquest and genocide ended? In 19th century, 20th century?

1 Answers 2015-08-19

When the English Royal Family changed their name from Saxe-Coburg Gotha to Windsor, how did they land on that particular name?

1 Answers 2015-08-19

I am an individual living in Ravenna on the year 530 to 550. How different would my life be pre-Gothic War and after the Gothic War?

Would there be a difference between Ostrogothic rule in Ravenna and Byzantine rule in Ravenna?

1 Answers 2015-08-19

How were Vietnamese-Americans treated during the Vietnam War?

By Vietnamese-American I mean any people of Vietnamese descent living in America during this time period.

1 Answers 2015-08-19

Why Didn't the Byzantine Empire Try to Take Back Anatolia When it Was Divided?

During the 1300s, why didn't the Byzantine Empire conquer the numerous weak beyliks on their border? Wasn't this territory considered Byzantine by the Byzantines? What was going on that prevented them from doing so?

1 Answers 2015-08-19

Tongue splitting

  1. How far back does the act of splitting your tongue, at the tip, go? I imagine it could of been a powerful statement among tribes, as well as anybody I guess. Just wondering after seeing the process on a show. 2) What are the more unique body modifications that used to take place or still do?

1 Answers 2015-08-19

Can someone date this pottery I found in Crete?

I was swimming at a beach in Ammoudara, near Heraklion, Crete and often scan the ground and shift through the rocks. I found this shard which seems to be made out of a ceramic type material. I was wondering if its recognizable from any period or just some recent garbage. If its not that simple, I was wondering if anyone knows where I can take it to get looked at. Thanks!

http://imgur.com/a/JgkM6

3 Answers 2015-08-19

Are there any first hand sources of the experiences of encircled army formations from pre-gunpowder battles?

I was looking for something on what the Romans who were surrounded at Cannae experienced and did, as the outer ranks were gradually destroyed, up until the end of the battle.

Any other pre-gunpowder battle where an army was trapped in a pocket, actually. I am curious if they built up impromptu HQs, collected wounded, planned breakthroughs, or generally acted in a manner similar to the massive encirclements on the WW2 eastern front.

1 Answers 2015-08-19

I've heard that concrete was lost for hundreds of years after the ancient Roman empire fell. Are there any technologies we know existed hundreds of years ago, but we still can't recreate today?

10 Answers 2015-08-19

After Japan surrendered following the attacks on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, how did other major countries respond to the United States' possession and use of nuclear bombs?

2 Answers 2015-08-19

Why is most of the history we are taught political history?

3 Answers 2015-08-19

Is Norman Cantor's In The Wake of The Plague credible?

I just bought this book for 20 USD. I find it very interesting so far, but it tends to wander a lot. However, I noticed he talked about the ring around the rosies rhyme. He mentions that it was made to help cope with the horrors of the 'pestilence', while I always heard it was about how people attempted to ward off the plague. Many others also say it is historically inaccurate. Especially on amazon, where most ratings are 1 star. Is it?

2 Answers 2015-08-19

When did it become standard for salt and pepper to be dinner-table staples?

Where does that come from?

1 Answers 2015-08-19

Where there any legal implications to the North Hollywood Shootout?

1 Answers 2015-08-19

While reading Genghis Khan: His Life and Legacy (Paul Ratchnevsky) I noticed the author making two casual references to Chinese farmers growing, "Maize" in the 13th century. How is that possible?

That is well before the Columbian Exchange, right? So how can they be growing maize in the Jin Dynasty? Is it some sort of old world maize or is this just an oversight by the author/editor? If it is some sort of old world maize, how does it compare to modern corn? Is it still around, who ate it etc.?

I'm somewhat suspicious of this book because I've found a handful of typos (one really funny one turned, "...people of Han." into, "...people of Ham.") and I'm wondering if there was just some bad editing going.

1 Answers 2015-08-19

Why are British territories usually marked in red or pink?

It seems that most maps that show British territories or former colonies are marked with red or pink. I was reading this Wikipedia article here about Cecil Rhodes and it mentioned that even a century ago British possessions generally were marked in red or pink. What is the reasoning behind this?

2 Answers 2015-08-19

Immigrant soldier impact for the north in the civil war?

Was watching the opening sequence to Gangs of New York, the Irish immigrants coming off the boat, to the enlistment stations, to the returning coffins. I know this was done for dramatic affect, but it got me thinking. I've done quite a bit of research on Irish history, but little on the Irish involvement in the civil war. I know there were some prominent Irish regiments, but how much of a factor was the immigrant enlistment, if anything?

1 Answers 2015-08-19

5058 / 7255

Back to start