Asked a few days ago if it was alright to ask after good books on a particular topic, so here goes: I'm interested in the Qing dynasty, as it coincides with the period in US/European/world history I'm most interested in (I've got this strange infatuation with Queen Anne's War). Plus, we don't seem to get any education in the US on Chinese history, which seems silly to me since they're such a large nation and have been writing things down for years.
There's a book in the sidebar list on the Boxer Rebellion,and I'm currently reading a pretty interesting book on the Taiping Rebellion. I'm more interested in events before this however, maybe pre-1850? Or just a general period/dynasty book. After I feel like I've exhausted the Qing period, I hope to move into Sun Yat-sen and Chiang and Mao and the 1911-1950 period, but it seems like there's a lot of literature on that time which is a lot easier to find.
3 Answers 2015-08-14
While reading, I've come across a lot of the US State Department's concerns from the area, where they were convinced the elections would be like elections in a police state, with people being forced to vote a certain way. I also came across the Tito-Subasic Agreement, which was used to only allow Communists to run for office. However, Churchill also seems to have recognised Tito's legitimacy as an interim leader in Yugoslavia after the war, so I'm curious what the relationship of him and his actual election was. Was Tito elected in a fair election? What are some good sources to read more about the 1945 Yugoslav elections?
1 Answers 2015-08-14
Say for example, due to lack of interest, popularity, or language problems, but historians still acknowledge the topic itself as important. Another question is if so, what other language has a disproportional amount of academia on this subject? That is aside from the native language, which other language has the most studies on the subject besides English?
2 Answers 2015-08-14
Here's the graph I'm basing my question about: http://i.imgur.com/DLQfGGN.jpg
1 Answers 2015-08-14
https://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/4/4d/HRR_10Jh.jpg
This map illustrates the make up of the Holy Roman Empire and its consisting kingdoms.
However, I never really understood how you can draw such a map... I know that the Kingdom of Germany is supposed to be the former East Francia, while Italy is the former Lombard kingdom. But obviously borders changed throughout the centuries and some parts (like modern day East Germany which was Slavic territory in the Early Middle Ages) were considered to be part of th Kingdom of Germany while other parts like Bohemia seemed to be its own thing (or wasn't it? I received conflicting info on that).
I wonder how you could know which territory belonged to which kingdom. Was it maybe that when the German (Roman) king was crowned in Aachen only some lords of the empire paid homage and those and their territories were considered to be directly subordinate to the king while other lords (in Italy and Burgundy) did not recognize him as their liege as long as he did not either became king of Italy or burgundy or emperor?
Hopefully someone can get me straight on that point. Thanks
1 Answers 2015-08-14
1 Answers 2015-08-14
This is a slight crosspost from /r/classicalmusic
There is a composer I am quite fond of named Chinary Ung who left Cambodia in the '60s and has had quite a good career with much great music. Shortly after he left, Pol Pot and the Khmer Rouge rose to power, and (as far as I understand) that was the death of arts, as well as most things that weren't working in the fields, for a number of years. How has Cambodia recovered from this? Has there been a recovery of any of their folk arts? I'm assuming that there is still not much of a classical music community there, at least according to my southeast Asian friends.
1 Answers 2015-08-14
Hi r/askhistory! At my (British) school, we do an independent research project, and am thinking of choosing a topic that fascinates me in its under-reportedness- the Long War of 1591/3-1606, and its effect on the Ottoman Empire. My exact (working) title is TO WHAT EXTENT DID THE LONG WAR SIGNAL THE BEGINNING OF TURKISH DECLINE? Unfortunately, this means that research is rather hard. I managed to find SOMETHING, but it wasn't really enough, and I also found a book to buy that I have now forgotten (Somebody Taylor is the author?). I need help! Are there any good (English- I'm afraid I cant speak any other languages well enough to read an academic book) sources that you would recommend? The sources could be about the Long War in particular or just about the general decline, but any help would be much appreciated. By the way, if I am barking up completely the wrong tree, please don't hesitate to tell me- it is just an idea (and maybe suggest other related ideas?). Thank you very much everybody!
2 Answers 2015-08-14
1 Answers 2015-08-14
1 Answers 2015-08-14
I am currently starting a new project examining the construction of forts in the British North American colonies between 1689 and 1715 and I am interested in learning about the actual process of fort building, which was so extensive across early modern Europe. I'm interested in questions like: How did engineers learn to build forts? How did they recruit the labor necessary? Who labored? How did engineers and other officers acquire the necessary materials to build forts? Any replies, including those with sources, primary or secondary, would be appreciated. Thanks!
1 Answers 2015-08-14
Did the Aztec and Incan empires actually have that much gold, they never had a whole lot of metallurgical skills, but are still portrayed as having mountains made of shiney metals.
1 Answers 2015-08-14
Source for the quote is page xvi of the book, paragraph 3.
3 Answers 2015-08-14
2 Answers 2015-08-14
I think it's fairly safe to say that a highly educated person from (insert country name) has a pretty good general understanding about their country's history, or at a minimum, could look most of it up. How would an educated Roman compare? Would their knowledge be of facts, or would they "know" that Rome was founded by Romulus and Remus, sons of Mars?
1 Answers 2015-08-14
Where is this Kingdom? Who were the people? Do we know of its history or what kind of ancient rules?
2 Answers 2015-08-14
3 Answers 2015-08-14
1 Answers 2015-08-14
My understanding is that during the Industrial Revolution, it was pretty common for factory complexes to be surrounded by residential areas that were owned by the factory, and the workers would live in them. They are generally portrayed as the exemplars of authoritarian capitalism, but what were they really like? How did living standards compare to non-company towns? Did workers prefer to live in company towns or non-company towns?
1 Answers 2015-08-14
Most of what I read is based on western tradition, such as the works of Homer and other Greek and Renaissance playwrights, storytellers, and historians. But in terms of amount of content, how does western civilization hold up when when compared to Farsi, Sanskrit, and Chinese? Am I just biased because all I've ever read is about western civilization, or is the amount of evidence and heritage from Rome and Greece superior to everywhere else?
1 Answers 2015-08-14
1 Answers 2015-08-14
6 Answers 2015-08-14
I've been researching the youth counterculture movements from the 40's - 60's USSR, including the stilyagi. I'd like to find more information about the countercultures of the time, including pictures of their outlandish (in the context) fashion choices and the practice of copying Western music onto old x-ray plates to make bootleg copies. I'm particularly interested in photos or political cartoons from confirmed sources. Are there really cartoons showing the stilyagi mocked by chimps in the zoos? Is it true that a newspaper ran the slogan, "Today he listens to jazz -- Tomorrow he sells out his homeland," referring to the music-loving youth?
For the curious, here are some sources I've found so far:
Back in the USSR: The True Story of Rock in Russia. Artemy Troitsky. Boston and London: Faber and Faber. 1987. > Troitsky is the expert on countercultural music movements in the USSR. From his intro: “The bloody virus called rock music that recognises no borders has infected millions, made them shake and sweat and cry. At the recent plenum of the Soviet Writers Union some of our well-known literary figures compared rock music to AIDS, having in mind the allegedly demoralising and generally destructive effect on our youth. Yes… and the antidote has still not been found, although local experts have gone to great lengths experimenting with various drastic counter-measures. This is the chronicle of a curious epidemic that hit the USSR at least 30 years ago but continues to claim victims.”
http://www.messynessychic.com/2015/05/25/the-stylehunters-of-soviet-russia/ > A very interesting article on Messy Nessy Chic with lots of great photos. I'd like to find out who owns them, to ask permission to use them on a project, but unfortunately the trail to ownership seems to have gone cold.
http://www.openculture.com/2014/06/soviet-hipsters-bootlegged-western-pop-music-on-discarded-x-rays.html >An article featuring actual music from 'bones' records and a clip from the Stilyagi film. Again, if anyone can offer insight into how to find music from 'bones' that I can get permission to use, I'd appreciate it.
http://wanderer-records.com/wanderer.php?keyword=film&media=flexi >Wanderer Records will let you buy actual 'bones' records, for those interested in owning a piece of history.
Any help/pointers is much appreciated! Thanks.
2 Answers 2015-08-14