Why did the saber/cutlass become popular?

What was it that stopped the use of double edged swords and made single edge, curved blades become popular?

An example of this are the cutlasses pirates used in the 17th century. Why was it they didn't use double edged swords, pirates clearly would have had knowledge of them from the British empire?

EDIT:Did it have anything to do with the increasing prevalence of firearms in battle?

4 Answers 2015-07-20

How did arbitrary justice give way to more fair legal systems?

My understanding of early European law is that there were a handful of laws only that dealt mostly with serfs. Was there a time when justice was served by local lords that would 'wing it' and basically decide the verdict and punishment of any trial? In TV a common trope is the king or lord will hold court and hear grievances and then do whatever the feel like. Did this actually exist and how did this change into a codified legal system with at least an attempt at fairness?

3 Answers 2015-07-20

How exactly did divorce work in Ancient Rome?

Wikipedia is pretty vague. Was divorce easily available to all classes of people, or was it mostly for the rich? Since women could, during some periods, initiate divorce, how often did they, and did their families usually take them back or could they strike out on their own? What happened to children?

2 Answers 2015-07-20

Did members of the Varangian Guard convert to Christianity or did they retain Norse paganism while in service?

Basically, I am curious about the relationship between religions in 10th century Byzantium specifically as it pertains to the Scandinavian members of the guard.

Bonus question: are there any members of the guard that went on to become close friends of the emperor? I would be curious for any stories of specific guardsmen.

2 Answers 2015-07-20

George Washington was hugely wealthy, but the main house at Mount Vernon seems relatively small and sober compared to the comtemporary European mansions of his financial equals. Is there a reason for this?

6 Answers 2015-07-20

when did a majority of astronomers start to hypothesize ("hypothesize" not "prove") that the stars were probably many tens of thousands of times farther away than anything in the solar system? When did they start to hypothesize stars were other suns?

I was just watching this

The guy says that they first measured the distance to another star in 1838. I want to know how much of a shock the immense number they came up with would have been?

2 Answers 2015-07-20

How accurately does Dostoyevsky's Crime and Punishment depict the life of the average 19th century Russian?

Twisting up the theme, excluding the obvious moral points of focus, would a regular 19th century Russian have access to pawnbrokers? Does the sentence the protagonist gets an accurate depiction of the punishments one would receive after committing murder in the 1800s? Is his cramped conditions an accurate depiction of the citizenry of St Petersburg?

1 Answers 2015-07-20

Is it just me, or is the evidence Jesus existed as a person extremely weak?

1 Answers 2015-07-20

What did Japan hope to accomplish by attacking the United States?

What was their perceived best-case scenario? If the war had gone according to plan, is there any evidence that they hoped to invade the US, or were they just trying to end US interdiction in the Pacific. Capturing Hawaii and US territories in the Pacific doesn't seem out of the question, but a full scale invasion of the continental is another thing entirely. Would they have stood any chance of accomplishing this? Is there any record of this ever being discussed?

1 Answers 2015-07-20

What were the conditions during WW1 in the trenches on the western front.

1 Answers 2015-07-20

Which small historic detail that was back-then regarded irrelevant, has had the biggest impact on mankind in the long run?

1 Answers 2015-07-20

Where should belong Crimea historically?

3 Answers 2015-07-20

Why are the KKK members wearing Nazi Germany symbols?

http://i.imgur.com/Jm4Yr4F.jpg

1 Answers 2015-07-20

In Ambrose Bierce's 1911 book 'The Devil's Dictionary' he defines the word 'Phonograph' as "An irritating toy that restores life to dead noises." How common were negative responses like this towards the phonograph as it gained popularity?

2 Answers 2015-07-20

Is the difference in profitability vs. agriculture the only reason the Northeast became the industrial center of the U.S.?

... as opposed to the South, of course. If not, what were the other reasons?

1 Answers 2015-07-20

Do Historians consider Julius Caesar or Augustus to be the "first" roman emperor?

Sources would be highly appreciated as well if possible. Why do they consider or believe what the do and also; how many historians in general hold the same opinion?

Thank you

1 Answers 2015-07-20

How did transgender people get by in the Stone Age?

I was wondering this awhile ago, and it seemed interesting to think of how trans people were treated during the Stone Age. Were they shunned, or were they awkwardly placed into society with the same tasks, or anything else?

2 Answers 2015-07-20

Who has had the hardest and most detailed questioned answered here on AskHistorians because AskHistorians really seems like AskReddit for the pros. Wow some really deep questions here.

Just wow. This is like Ask Reddit for the people that really want to know.

1 Answers 2015-07-20

Geographic Origins of the Germanic and Celtic ethno-linguistic groups?

Hi,

So I would like to know what is the most accredited/valued theory on where Germanic and Celtic people/speakers originated. Indo-Europeans are said to have originated in the Pontic and Ukrainian steppe regions, so it could be logical to assume that both groups where from there.

However, at what location or region did both groups become linguistically separate from each other? In other words, where did the Germanics and Celtics endure their respective ethnogeneses?

Thanks

1 Answers 2015-07-20

How did the Soviets fair in the Battle of Stalingrad from an individual soldier's perspective?

I heard from some people that Soviets would charge into battle without rifles, and heard others say this is untrue, could I get confirmation?

1 Answers 2015-07-20

Which discovered documents changed our theory of an ancient time the most? How so?

1 Answers 2015-07-20

At what point did the term "World War One" become commonplace? Was it strictly after World War Two broke out/occurred or did anyone refer to it as WW1 prior to that?

1 Answers 2015-07-20

How can Tamil Eelam achieve independence? Protest? War?

1 Answers 2015-07-20

Someone I know has told me that she thinks that, had the Civil War never happened, the eventual development of mechanized farm equipment would have caused the slave-holding South to free all of its slaves of its own accord. How reasonable a hypothesis is this?

1 Answers 2015-07-20

Did Edward VIII conspire with Winston Churchill to set up a Royalist-Fascist government?

I remembered that during Edward's Abdication Crisis, there were "rumors" that Edward might try to overthrow the Baldwin government and install Churchill instead. That always sounded far-fetched until I saw him teaching his family the fascist salute. Now it doesn't sound so crazy.

What's the truth?

1 Answers 2015-07-20

5165 / 7255

Back to start