I've looked through the book list, but I was hoping for some more specific guidance. I also recently enjoyed Lawrence in Arabia, so both of my recent favorites have been semi-biographical, but also focused on some massive, transformational event in history. And a coherent narrative helps keep me interested! Any and all suggestions welcome.
2 Answers 2015-07-09
What is the history of the use of these letters? i know they were used in 1812 and the am revolutionary war but i know no specifics. Were they used after this? have they been outlawed by international treaties and across the world when did this process die out?
2 more quick questions: 1. did letters of marque and reprisal come up in the debate over iran contra/would it apply?
2 Answers 2015-07-09
Not trying to approach this as a historian so what is the best to read as a lay person as it were.
1 Answers 2015-07-09
This week, ending in July 09 2015:
Today's thread is for open discussion of:
History in the academy
Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries
Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application
Philosophy of history
And so on
Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.
1 Answers 2015-07-09
What are some definitive books (in english) for information on the Sengoku period? Also, since I'm on a Japanese topic already, what are some good resources for Japanese folklore?
3 Answers 2015-07-09
Apologies if this question is too far into "what if" territory.
3 Answers 2015-07-09
Looking at the election with our current knowledge, it's clear that Lincoln's election was the final spark that set off the civil war. Did Northern voters realize that a Lincon victory meant likely war?
2 Answers 2015-07-09
In Gibbon (yes, I know...) he says that the distinction between clergy and laity only emerged in the early Church - that it had not been a feature of Greek and Roman paganism.
How true is this? Is the distinction between laity and clergy really a distinctive feature of early Christianity without classical antecedent? Or is Gibbons oversimplifying or wrong?
If it is at least partly true, why was that the case?
1 Answers 2015-07-09
I'm currently reading The Savior Generals by Victor Davis Hanson, and the author makes several references to how Belisarius was able to win over the local populations of the regions he re-conquered for Byzantium, but Hanson does not explain how Belisarius did this. He even compares Belisarius to David Petraeus, in that both used a form of counter-insurgency tactics. But again, Hanson mostly says things like, "Belisarius won over the local population." There is no explanation of how, or to what degree, or according to whom, or if this was even a significant factor in his victories, etc.
I've read the other popular Belisarius post here, and /u/shlin28 makes a few points that contradict Hanson's argument: Belisarius could not secure the loyalties of the locals or win miraculous victories when he did not have a material/political advantage, and his seizure of Ravenna motivated Gothic nobles to fight on rather than to make peace.
So, did Belisarius actually win over the local populations in Persia, North Africa, and Italy? If he did: how did he do so, according to whom did he do so, and was it significant to the outcome of his campaigns?
1 Answers 2015-07-09
Hugh Roberts writes that
" In the Ben Barka affair of 1965-66, the leader of the Moroccan left was abducted and murdered during a visit to France as the result of a conspiracy involving a large cast of characters including French police and intelligence agents, Moroccan agents, the Moroccan interior minister and French gangsters. A few of those involved – mainly the gangsters – eventually stood trial and went to jail. Paris’s prefect of police, Maurice Papon, was obliged to resign and others, including the head of the SDECE (France’s equivalent of MI6 at the time), took early retirement."
http://www.lrb.co.uk/v37/n14/hugh-roberts/the-hijackers
So I looked up Ben Barka for clarification and the wiki article offers only theories.
1 Answers 2015-07-09
On the battlefield I know about drums and such to deliver marching orders, but large armies spread over large areas, like every huge logistical feat relies on communication, I'm interested in that side of things today.
How did armies during Revolutionary France/Napoleonic Wars communicate with allied armies? How would Napoleon know about things happening in Paris when off campaigning with his army? How did a wagon train know where to deliver X amount of food?
I know a little bit about telegraph semaphore's but those have significant drawbacks, but they do show someone was trying to do better than a coded message in a riders satchel. but just how sophisticated was communication at this time?
1 Answers 2015-07-09
How did WW2 US, British, Soviet and late German tanks compare in terms of reliability, ease of maintenance and repair, combat performance, cost and ease of production?
By late German tanks I'm referring to everything after, including the Panther.
EDIT: The guide has been moved here.
6 Answers 2015-07-09
1 Answers 2015-07-09
I'm comparing Napoleon III to Bismark and their influence on Europe leading their respective countries however I'm struggling to think of arguments for Napoleon. I first thought I could argue Napoleon was integral in ultimately unifying Italy due to the Second Italian War of Independence but that argument seems to be weak when you look at the Third Italian War of Independence which was made possible by Prussia. It seems Napoleon played a fairly weak role in Europe been disappointed by not getting any territorial gains in guaranteeing neutrality in the Austro-Prussian and been diplomatically isolated by Bismark. Is there anything notable Napoleon III did in foreign policy that was successful after the Crimean War which was influential in Europe
5 Answers 2015-07-09
My understanding is that Bulgarians migrated from Central Asia into what is basically Ukraine, then later they migrated south into modern Bulgaria. Where along this route did they lose their Turkic identity?
2 Answers 2015-07-09
There probably was no merchandise sold for Bach concerts when he was still alive, and I suspect Elvis or the Beatles also had no such thing, but by the 1980s they were abundant. So do we know who were the first to do this?
2 Answers 2015-07-09
1 Answers 2015-07-09
We just spent a week in Rhodes and found the village of Eleousa formerly known as Campochiaro. I didn't find much information about it on google except that it was built by the italians. I would love to know more about the buildings in Campochiaro. Here are pictures of the buildings: http://imgur.com/a/LlFtf
1 Answers 2015-07-09
Hey all, I've recently gotten very interested in Swedish history - specifically Sweden's time as a great power, the Northern Wars, Thirty Years War, etc.
I've trawled through several Wikipedia articles during quiet shifts at work (not many people come into the library at night...), but I like to have books. First cos I get eyestrain reading off a screen, and second cos it makes my bookshelves look more impressive.
So I was hoping I could get some suggestions for good books on that general period, but any books (from Vikings to modern day) are of interest too.
Cheers in advance!
2 Answers 2015-07-09
6 Answers 2015-07-09
As a resident of Utah, it is seems kind of strange how connected the Mormon church is to Polynesia. What's the historical reason for this?
1 Answers 2015-07-09
I work in military aviation, so accountability is pretty important whenever there's a failure that results in something fatal or could have resulted in something possibly fatal.
Not gonna lie, Apollo 13 (the movie) was on TV and I finally re-watched it. As inaccurate as it may be, it did get me thinking of the incident.
As far as I can gather from reading, it looks like it was a problem of voltage. Space technology in the US was based on 28VDC (like modern US aviation). For some reason, however, it was decided that space technology in the US should switch to 65VDC. It turns out there were some problems with fuel thermostats in that conversion (which, again, as an aviation guy, I immediately understand).
What I can't find, however, is if they ever narrowed it down to one single fuck-up. The best I can find is that the O2 tank may have been dropped, but tested good.
Any fun tidbits, stories, interviews, etc. about Apollo 13 are welcome, as are any point-outs and gripes of movie inaccuracies. /r/AskHistorians seems to be somewhat more lax in rules lately, and I'm all for encouraging it. If you have something interesting to say about this flight, feel free to say something!
[edit] Bonus points if you have anything to say about the 20amp limit that's stressed in the film.
5 Answers 2015-07-09