Why does invading Russia always seem like a great idea despite the super low success rate?

2 Answers 2015-05-29

In a few IS propaganda videos I've seen, the protagonists express an extreme dislike for salafists and safawis. Is anyone able to elaborate on what these two terms mean and the beef that fundamentalist Sunnis have with them?

2 Answers 2015-05-29

In Unbroken, a movie about America POWs in Japan, they offer the main character more food & comfort in exchange for lying on the radio about how the Japanese are treating prisoners. Did that really happen to people? If "yes" what happened to guys who went along with it?

4 Answers 2015-05-29

Where there any universal documents on "human rights" prior to World War 2?

After WW2, there was the creation of the United Nations and they created a universal document of human rights and what every human has the right of, including things like "right to liberty" and "right to life"

But were there any universal documents of basic human rights before the UN was created before WW2?

1 Answers 2015-05-29

Did The civilizations of antiquity practice archaeology? Is it possible that they knew more about older civilizations than we do?

Thank you all for your responses!

7 Answers 2015-05-29

After the Titanic sank, how and when were the floating bodies recovered? Were any found very far from where the ship sank?

1 Answers 2015-05-29

In 7th century Muslims populated the Middle East - and since then the image of "Islamic Middle East" has persisted until today. But before Muslims there were Christians. Has the Middle-Eastern Christians in the long course of 7th century until today ever glorify their pre-Muslim past?

Today, among us Muslims there are people who often glorify the thirteen centuries rule of "Islamic caliphate". This glorification has resulted in various nationalist discourse in 20th century and is still constructed today. It is commonly agreed that a triumphant past under the banner of "Islamic civilization" existed (and it is a fascinating subject to inquire by itself).

Prior to Muslims' rule in 7th century, however, most of Middle East was Christian. The Christians were under the domain of Roman and Persian, two huge civilization by its own. I know there were people like Cosmas Indicopleustas or Eusebius who see Roman Empire as a civilization so great that it is believed to last until the end of time. It didn't, however - and today this Eastern Mediterranean region has always been identified as a "Muslim region".

So has there ever been a collective/historical memory of pre-Muslim past among the Middle Eastern Christians? Is something like "Nestorian Christians were the precursor of modern science!" or a more confrontational "things were better under the Romans!" ever entered popular discourse?

I'm aware that the monophysites quite welcomed Muslim's conquest in 7th century and there were lots of cooperation between Muslims and Christians in Middle East, especially in Abbasid's rule.

1 Answers 2015-05-29

Did independence movements and leaders in Africa during the decolonization period of the 1950s and 1960s have any impact on the American civil rights movement, and vice versa?

1 Answers 2015-05-29

At maximum, about how many generations could have born, lived, and died in the Roman Republic & Empire wthout being ruled under another 'country'?

1 Answers 2015-05-29

Question about viking armor

I know that not every viking could afford mail but does that mean most of them fought in their casual clothes or did they at least wear some leather? Were there any mail substitutes for poor people? Also were helmets more common in comparison?

1 Answers 2015-05-29

How long did it take for American and European churches to accept the theory of evolution?

The theory of evolution must have been hard enough to swallow for your average Joe. How long after Darwin publicized his works did it take before Western churches, protestant or catholic, accepted it as truth? Most religious communities accept the theory today, but I can't imagine it happened overnight.

2 Answers 2015-05-29

Friday Free-for-All | May 29, 2015

Previously

Today:

You know the drill: this is the thread for all your history-related outpourings that are not necessarily questions. Minor questions that you feel don't need or merit their own threads are welcome too. Discovered a great new book, documentary, article or blog? Has your Ph.D. application been successful? Have you made an archaeological discovery in your back yard? Did you find an anecdote about the Doge of Venice telling a joke to Michel Foucault? Tell us all about it.

As usual, moderation in this thread will be relatively non-existent -- jokes, anecdotes and light-hearted banter are welcome.

23 Answers 2015-05-29

562 years ago today Constantinople fell to the Turks, what what was the Catholics reaction to this and the Russians?

Even though the Catholics and the Orthodox were rivals you would think that the Christian imperial city's lose to an Islamic army would not sit well...

3 Answers 2015-05-29

Could anyone recommend info on pre 1900's outdoorsy knowledge/skills

I demonstrate (amongst other things) bushcraft at a living history museum, The time frame there goes up till 1890.
I've found some good info online but I'm always looking to find more on bushcraft, woodsy knowledge, survival, gear, experimental archeology, material culture, etc...
All media type welcome: website, videos, forums, podcast, magazines, books, whatever bring it on.

Thank you

PS: I also demonstrate trapping, fiber craft, leather craft, and recently tracking

Edit: A few clarifications
The living history museum is
Vermilionville

"...a living history museum and folklife park that promotes and propagates the cultural resources of the Acadian, Native American, and Creole people – from the time period 1765 to 1890."

It is in south Louisiana however I'm not restricted to there, I portray myself as an 18th century coureur des bois. so anything from Canada / Hudson Bay down the mississippi would be appropriate.
As for how early it goes; the Cajuns didn't get to Louisiana until 1765 but coureur des bois were in North America before them (late 1500's). And bushcraft is kinda timeless, I've even looked at info gathered from Ötzi for inspiration.

5 Answers 2015-05-29

Why do the United Kingdom and the United States of America have such a close relationship post colonial war than say the UK and Ireland?

The UK and USA are very close allies despite their history but when you look at the UK's relationship with Ireland it's not so rosey (The Troubles etc)

Why is that the UK and US have become so close, where as the UK is not so close with other countrys it once ruled?

Thank you for taking the time to comment.

4 Answers 2015-05-29

Did Francis of Assisi and Clare of Assisi have more than a spiritual relationship?

Francis was the founder of the Franciscans in the 13th century Clare of the Poor Clares (the female branch of the Franciscans). The two worked closely together and had a sort of spiritual friendship. Now I don't want to make wrong assumptions but they were both human, working closely together. It wouldn't be impossible for the two of them to form something more then a friendship.

2 Answers 2015-05-29

What were the religious beliefs of pre-Seminole Native American tribes?

I'm specifically interested in the Ais and Jaega, but how much information exists about any of them?

1 Answers 2015-05-29

Why did it take such a massive Coalition to fight Iraq in the Gulf War?

The countries in active combat were

  • Kuwait
  • United States
  • United Kingdom
  • Saudi Arabia
  • France
  • Italy
  • Canada
  • Egypt
  • Syria
  • Morocco
  • United Arab Emirates
  • Oman
  • Qatar
  • Bangladesh Kuwait
  • United States
  • United Kingdom
  • Saudi Arabia
  • France
  • Italy
  • Canada
  • Egypt
  • Syria
  • Morocco
  • United Arab Emirates
  • Oman
  • Qatar
  • Bangladesh

And non-combat support was

  •  Afghanistan
    
  •  Argentina
    
  •  Australia
    
  •  Bahrain
    
  •  Belgium
    
  •  China
    
  • Czechoslovakia
    
  •  Denmark[2]
    
  •  Spain
    
  •  Germany
    
  •  India
    
  •  Pakistan
    
  •  Netherlands
    
  •  New Zealand
    
  •  Niger
    
  •  Norway
    
  •  Poland
    
  •  Portugal
    
  •  Greece
    
  •  Hungary
    
  •  Senegal
    
  •  South Korea
    

Was the Iraqi military that big? I know they had a bunch of reserves, but this seems like way too many.

2 Answers 2015-05-29

How come Canada didn't become independent (or join the USA) after the American Revolution?

1 Answers 2015-05-29

How did Anarchist Catalonia and the Free Territory in Ukraine function exactly? Were they truly anarchist societies?

4 Answers 2015-05-29

How did shinto influence the Japanese worldview and decision making during WWII?

Hi everyone,

this is in a sense a followup question to a badhistory post that criticised the top rated post about japan mainly protecting their territorial interests in china by declaring war on the US in WW2. Most comments and answers focused heavily on the geopolitical interests and a very classical power definition. In my research about state building and economic development I have come across side notes about shintoism and how important it was in pre-1946 Japan, but mostly without any real explanation for those statements. So to my actual questions:

  • Was shinto integrated into the japanese patriotism / nationalism, and if so, how?
  • Did the religion turn into a political ideology?
  • Did shintoism influence the Japanese decision making to participate in WW2?

5 Answers 2015-05-29

What actually happened to Mesopotamia?

I've been thinking on it lately, and what I can find clarify all that much. It seems that there is a lot of muddying of waters by Islamic, Judiastic and Christian scholarly groups trying to erase the history to fit their own belief systems.

So what is the story of it? What sort of empire was it? What brought it down? And, of additional interest, where does Islam, Christianity and Judaism come into all of this?

From what I currently understand, it was an empire made of city states, like early Greece. Then the empire fell, and the city states fell to warring factions. The Persians held Baghdad and used the trade routes to secure power within the region, Israel went on a rampage, taking over as much land as possible, and a large group of old city states then formed a nation and scattered the nation of Israel.

How much of this is correct, and how much isn't?

1 Answers 2015-05-29

Was Francis Drake a pirate?

Now, as an Englishman I've always been taught about "Sir Francis Drake", but where I live now in Spain it's always "Pirata Drake". Is this a case of sore losers, or have the Spanish got a point?

1 Answers 2015-05-29

How important was Crete in the Roman empire?

It's location seems perfect for a Mediterranean empire. It's close to Greece, Asia Minor, Egypt and the Levant.
Maybe even better situated than Constantinople.
Though in my minor education about the Romans I've never read a lot about it.
Was it used as a military or administrative centre?
If not, why not?

2 Answers 2015-05-29

How did Ancient Greco-Roman civilisation become established as the unified foundation of European intellectual culture? What did different parts of Europe consider the foundation of their intellectual cultures before Classicism?

1 Answers 2015-05-29

5353 / 7255

Back to start