North Sentinel Island

Hello, sorry if this does not exactly follow the post guidelines, but I was wondering some questions, such as, Who are the North Sentinel Island people? who first found them? How/when did they get to their island? What are good reasons for them being so territorial? What is their Language? Etcetera. Any information (as long as it is not something like, aliens did it) would be nice. Thank you!

2 Answers 2015-05-22

Why in some religious paintings , characters have a certain hand position ?

Their thumb touches their ring finger (e.g. Christ icones)...

2 Answers 2015-05-22

I know my great grandfather left the 1st Battalion of The Royal Scots in July 1903 at the age of 21. At what age could he have enlisted, and would he potentially have served in any conflicts?

I have a card that was given to him when he left The Royal Scots. The front of it says, "Army Form D. 402. National Association for the Employment of Reserve Soldiers, &c. Name and Description of a Man recommended for Employment". Unfortunately, this is all the information I have about his service, aside from a portrait of him in his uniform.

I'm interested in knowing at what age he most likely would have enlisted (would 18 have been standard in 1900?) and were the Royal Scots involved in any foreign conflicts during his short time in the service?

1 Answers 2015-05-22

If the previous musical eras had an unchangeable definition of (good) music, why don't we?

2 Answers 2015-05-22

Question regarding the history of Britain and its dominance through history.

Hi everyone, this is a wonderful sub and I have been a lurker for a long time but had to make an account for a question that has been nagging me for a while. My question is regarding the history of Britain. My knowledge in this sphere is rather limited but I have a friend who knows a bit more about this subject however, I disagree with some of his arguments. So hopefully, some of you can help point me in the right direction.

He argues that ever since the Norman conquest England and the amalgamation of this group with Anglo-Saxons and Celtic peoples, the combined entity has been very powerful throughout history. Now I have several issues with this statement primarily how does one define 'power', or 'history' but I would appreciate an answer that sheds some light on the question — since the Norman conquest and subsequent intermingling, how powerful the combined entity has been?

Thanks.

1 Answers 2015-05-22

Egil Skallagrímsson is reported to have killed for the first time at the age of 7, cleaving another boy's head with an axe, due to being cheated in a game. Would this be considered deviant behavior at the time (900's Iceland), or within the boundaries of acceptable behaviour?

1 Answers 2015-05-22

Why did Adlai Stevenson suggest that everyone, including himself, considered it cowardly to suggest removing missiles from Turkey in exchange for Soviet missiles in Cuba in an attempt to avert nuclear war?

His quote about his suggestion appears in the Wikipedia article :

Stevenson remarked "I know that most of those fellows will consider me a coward for the rest of my life for what I said today, but perhaps we need a coward in the room when we are talking about nuclear war."[71]

Maybe it's my lack of understanding of of the nuances of the era, but it seems to me in an effort to avert nuclear war, all options are on the table. So why would this suggestion be considered political suicide?

2 Answers 2015-05-22

Were Soviet soldiers as politically and ideologically motivated as the German soldiers?

2 Answers 2015-05-22

How was Sexuality & Gender perceived in Germany between 1920 - 1989? How did these perceptions change after world war two?

How was Sexuality & Gender perceived in Germany between 1920 - 1989? How did these perceptions change after world war two Were there differing ideas on what sexuality should be in each allied occupation zone?

I'm quite interested in how Sexual education was taught to the future nazi generations? How did this differ between boys & girls? I know girls were taught the importance of Kinder, Küche & Kirche (Children, Kitchen & Church) but how did this effect the "Gender Schema" of the era? Were there any sexual positions that were deemed more "aryan" than others? Or gave German couples a better chance of having a "completely aryan" baby?

How was pornography viewed during this time? Was it influenced by propaganda? I've also heard of the Lebensborn birth houses for unmarried women to become impregnated by specially chosen S.S. members, What exactly went on in these birth houses?

I've heard that in occupied Norway, Norwegian mothers who had German children (in these birth houses) were shunned & often raped, How true is this? Are there any accounts of this?

How true is Heinz Heger's statement in The Men With The Pink Triangle that:

Himmler directed that all gay prisoners were to make compulsory visits to the camp brothel once per week as a means of curing them of their same-sex attraction.

And to what extant can we use Heger as a reliable source when he says:

the sadism of some of the SS officers reflected repressed homosexual desires of their own.

How true do historians think this statement is especially when thinking of Heinrich Himmler? One last thing, I read that:

Lesbians were not widely persecuted under Nazi anti-gay laws, as it was considered easier to persuade or force them to comply with accepted heterosexual behaviour.

How did the Nazi's go about persuading lesbians to switch to heterosexual practices?

1 Answers 2015-05-22

If two "unrelated" people share a surname, did they inherit that name from a common ancestor, or was that name independently created.

I understand that it's certainly either depending on the individuals, but do we know which is more common? Does it differ by nationality or ethnicity?

4 Answers 2015-05-22

As what were the Eastern Romans referred to in the West?

I know that, throughout their history, the Eastern romans called themselves "Romans". I believe that's what they were called by their eastern neighbours. But what did the western peoples call them? The franks, the goths?

And throughout the years, for as long as the Eastern Roman Empire was a political entity?

1 Answers 2015-05-22

What, broadly speaking, moves a nation to become an aggressor in war?

1 Answers 2015-05-22

What is meant by this quote about King Louis XVIII and the Revolution

What were the achievements? and am befuddled by this qoute

French historian Jacques Godechot points out “The French were strongly attached to the essential achievements of the Revolution, and Louis XVIII had come back ‘in the baggage train of the foreigners’ with the last surviving émigrés who had ‘learnt nothing and forgotten nothing’ and whose influence seemed to threaten most of the Revolution’s achievements"

1 Answers 2015-05-22

After the split of Christianity from Judaism, were there ever disputes about the nature of priesthood - hereditary (Kohanim) vs. ordained?

This question stems from my reading a great (and, as far as I can tell, thoroughly researched) historical novel about a Jewish family in Switzerland; ["Melnitz" by Charles Lewinsky] (http://www.worldcat.org/title/melnitz/oclc/904268308), now available in English as I just discovered - highly recommendable!

In it, one character converts to Protestant Christianity in an attempt to be better accepted in the notoriously anti-Semitic business community while telling himself he just finds the Christian practices more "reasonable"; one of the issues being the fact that Christian priesthood is more like a job in which one can be trained, as opposed to the hereditary priesthood of the Jewish Kohanim. (He thinks of his father-in-law, Mr. Kahn [!], who strikes him as utterly un-priestly…)

This is indeed a striking difference, so I was wondering whether there were ever - be it in late antiquity, the middle ages, the 19th century, or whenever - instances of, for example, Christians using the hereditary priesthood as an example of Jewish "backwardness", or of Jews pointing to Christians' abandonment of that idea as a sign for the wrongness of their religion etc.?

1 Answers 2015-05-22

Who was the last victim to die of the 2nd world war?

A second world war bomb has been successfully removed from a beach (?) in the U.K. If it detonated, technically whoever it killed or injured would be a victim of the 2nd world war 70 years on.

This got me thinking , who was the last victim of the war? And when?

1 Answers 2015-05-22

What historical figures are not as influential as the public seems to think?

1 Answers 2015-05-22

Would the Japanese have been able to take over part of Mainland America in WWII?

2 Answers 2015-05-22

What would Don Draper's commute have been like? Ossining NY to Manhattan, 1960s - how long, how many changes of trains (if any) etc.? Why not by car?

In the TV series "Mad Men", the main character is often shown leaving home / work, and right afterwards, after a cut, arriving at work / home. How much time would he in reality have spent commuting in between these two situations?

He lives in the suburb of Ossining and is occasionally shown on some kind of suburban train - what route was that, when was it established? Would his commute have changed during the course of the events of the series (1960-1970) with new routes being established etc.?

As a European, the US strike me as very focused on cars, but some of the larger (and somewhat older cities) seem to have quite an OK public transit systems. Were there different degrees of prestiges associated with using or not using your personal car to commute at different times? Don Draper is definitely upper middle to upper class and has this huge Lincoln by season 3 (haven't watched it further, please no spoliers! :) ), but he doesn't seem to mind joining all the regular folks on that train - so would this just have taken way less time?

2 Answers 2015-05-22

Why was the train invented before horse-less land vehicles?

I mean why couldn't a train run with wheels through regular roads instead of a railroad?

2 Answers 2015-05-22

When did the use of "thou" lose its popularity?

It seems unusual to me that the informal "thou" lost its popularity and that the formal, grand "you" is now the only second person pronoun really seen in the English language. When did "thou" fall out of fashion?

1 Answers 2015-05-22

What happened in Italy itself after the fall of the Roman Empire?

We all read a lot about the structure of inter-state politics but what happened within the italian peninsula itself between the fall of rome and the renaissance, as a broad time frame.

1 Answers 2015-05-22

Have historians attempted to use modern international relations theory (mainly neorealism) to analyze ancient/medieval history?

The main one I am interested in is neorealism (Kenneth Waltz). There is strong claim that the neorealistic approach to international relations is universal. But I have mainly seen it being applied to either 19th/20th century "Great Power Politics". I am wondering if there are any books that test this claim to universalism by looking at ancient history or really anything sufficiently historical (Say < 1700 CE to draw an arbitrary line).

I think it would be interesting to analyze the Roman Republic's rise to Mediterranean hegemony or so.

1 Answers 2015-05-22

What non-European equivalents are there of Ancient Rome and Ancient Greece? Are they used in a similar way as "foundations of intellectual traditions"?

1 Answers 2015-05-22

Estates of the Realm and Astrology?

I am trying to learn more about a certain historical episode that Terence McKenna mentions in passing in his lecture "Monogamy, Marriage, and Neurosis" and possibly elsewhere.

"Astrology went through a crisis several hundred years ago where under the emergence under a new class of wealthy people, there became a demand for personal horoscopes. So astrology reconfigured its toolkit to be able to provide that."

I think in another lecture he goes into this stating that how before this period Astrology was used exclusively in statecraft, divining political destiny of nations, the health of princes and kings, and fate of the monarchy.

I'm thinking this has to do with the shifts in the "Estates of the Realm" and the political shake ups surrounding the Protestant Reformation, maybe the 30 Years War, or similar episodes. Can anyone speak to this or point me in the right direction for more research?

I've already tried /r/askastrologers and /r/terencemckenna and am getting almost zero traction on this.

Thanks and thank you to the Terence McKenna Wiki Project for helping me find the quote.

1 Answers 2015-05-22

Anyone able to suggest a book about English/British history.

Hi all,

Does anyone on here have a suggestion for a book that I want, but that I'm not sure even exists. Basically, one where the author/historian covers all eras and time periods, preferably in chronological order but, as long as all (or the majority) are covered, it's fine by me.

Obviously as it'd cover a lot of different periods, it won't be the most in-depth historical read, but, again, I'd prefer if it was more than just a basic summary that you'd find in a kids book. Just a chapter on each era (or maybe it's in a series of books).

Thanks.

2 Answers 2015-05-22

5377 / 7255

Back to start