AskHistorians Homework Question Policy Rehash

Hello everyone!

It is that time of year again, as everyone's classes start to near their conclusion, and that paper or final looms just around the corner. We've noticed a decided uptick in question that either are explicitly regarding schoolwork, or else smell suspiciously similar without disclosing it. To start off, we don't prohibit you asking questions regarding your homework here in /r/AskHistorians. Our rules state:

Our users aren't here to do your homework for you, but they might be willing to help. Remember: AskHistorians helps those who help themselves. Don't just give us your essay/assignment topic and ask us for ideas. Do some research of your own, then come to us with questions about what you've learned.

That is to say, if you are looking for help, don't make /r/AskHistorians your first stop. If you do some research, come here and be honest about what your assignment is and give us a run down of what your research is showing you so far, you'll find users here being quite amenable to lending a hand and pointing you in the right direction.

So what do good homework questions look like?

  • I'm writing an essay on the development of the bolt-action rifle, and the effect it had on warfare in the latter-half of the 19th century. I've mainly been focusing on the Austro-Prussian War, and the clear dominance that the Dreyse showed over Lorenz Rifle, and the Franco-Prussian War, where the Chassepot in turn showed itself to be superior to the Dreyse. What I'm tripping up on however is why, after its strong showing (even if the French lost) the Chassepot so quickly was regarded as obsolete. If someone could help me out here, or point me in the right direction, that would be great!

Explains what the assignment is and demonstrates that they have already done research already (although even this is on the brief side of what we'd like to see. You really should be giving us a proper paragraph or two). More importantly, it is about an explicit point of interest within the topic that they are having trouble with.

  • I'm doing an assignment about the influence of the printing press on literacy in the 15th to 16th centuries. I've read X, Y, and Z, and my thesis will most likely be ______. I'm looking for any more sources that might help me move further in my research, or that might offer a counter point to the perspective I've gotten so far. Thank you!

Asking for sources is perfectly fine, and if anything, is our most preferred type of homework question! Same as before though, make sure you are demonstrating to us your commitment and prior base of work.

And a few bad examples

  • I need to write an essay on a topic regarding the Renaissance. What should I write about?

I don't know... What did you learn about in class? What resonated with you? We can throw topics at you, but that isn't going to help you any.

  • I have an exam on 13th Century French Art coming up! What should I know about for it?

  • I'm writing an essay on the 1968 May Days in France. What points should I talk about in it?

Check your notes. Read through your text books. Check your library or an online resource such as JSTOR for useful sources. No one here is going to do your work for you. Come back when you have specific questions that remain a roadblock for you after doing research.

  • Compare and contrast the social influence of the works of Christopher Marlowe and William Shakespeare.

We have pretty good noses for homework questions, since we all had to answer them ourselves, and many of us are now in the business of writing them. This one is super obvious, but we catch many that aren't. Please, be honest and upfront. And also, Google indexes these pages. We have flaired members of the sub who found us when checking students' papers for plagiarism! So even if we don't catch you, your teacher might, and that is much, much worse!

So that's about the sum of it. As we said at the beginning, /r/AskHistorians loves to help those who help themselves, and as long as you show up here being honest about the assignment, and being clear about what you already have done and how we can assist, you'll find people eager to show you the way. But questions which do not conform to this policy will be removed.

6 Answers 2015-05-12

Why was Vercingetorix crowned at Bibracte and not Gergovia?

From what I understand, Vercingetorix was an Arverni nobleman and therefore I'd assume after his return from exile he would be crowned at Gergoiva, but he was instead crowned at the neighboring, and Roman-sided Aeudi's capital of Bibracte. Why is this?

1 Answers 2015-05-12

Tuesday Trivia | Royal Friendships

Previous weeks' Tuesday Trivias and the complete upcoming schedule.

Today’s trivia theme comes to us from /u/steveisnothappy! And it's a re-run so get some inspiration!

Please share any stories about friendships of the royal set, royal-royal friendships between kings and their peers, or a cat may look at a king and talk about royal-commoner friendships, or mix it up and take royalty a little loosely.... Kings of Rock? Kings of Industry? Whatever you've got! :)

Next Week on Tuesday Trivia: Unusual Awards, Prizes, and Accolades!

4 Answers 2015-05-12

What is the history of the gym?

In addition to general exercise like running, when did people start doing focused exercise for muscular groups? How did this became our modern gym?

1 Answers 2015-05-12

Any good non-Roman sources on the Roman military? Talking about tactics, formations, appearance, etc.

2 Answers 2015-05-12

Has there ever been a small object that has been the subject of a war or had a huge impact on the course of history (similar to "the one ring" in LOTR)?

1 Answers 2015-05-12

To the rest of the English-speaking world, "the Secret Service" is a spy agency, so how did the American presidential bodyguard get that name?

1 Answers 2015-05-12

When did Palestinians first define themselves as a specific ethnic and national group?

1 Answers 2015-05-12

Why did the pilgrim fathers settle so far north (Plymouth) where the winters made it hard for them to survive initially?

Why not settle further south?

1 Answers 2015-05-12

Did people read Shakespeare's play (or plays in general) in Shakespeare's time?

As in, read and appreciate them apart from the actual theatre? Were they printed/sold? If not, when did reading plays as works of literature became common?

2 Answers 2015-05-12

Did past painters know what they draw didn't really look like reality ? How did the "discovery" of perspective change their view, and how did people react ?

Medieval drawing look nothing like reality, for example, in opposition to later pieces. How did people react ? Did they realy think it was good ?

Also, I think Da Vinci is the one that "discovered" perspective and set it up into paintings. How did that change the world, and how did people react to the first "prespective" painting/drawing ?

1 Answers 2015-05-12

Did Congress fail to exercise its power with the Gulf of Tonkin resolution?

1 Answers 2015-05-12

In WW2, would Germany have had a better chance of winning if they had instead focused on defeating the UK, especially in the Mediterranean and North Africa, rather than invading the Soviet Union?

1 Answers 2015-05-12

[META] How does /r/AskHistorians generally view the discussion over at /r/ArtefactPorn?

Just wondering since /r/ArtefactPorn has been one of my favorite subs lately, as most of the submissions make me feel a closer bond to the past than most academic discussion could.

4 Answers 2015-05-12

Is it true the Catholic Church arranged marriages to obtain land from women land owners? (aka when did women not owning property become a thing?)

I once heard this argument and a friend of mine seemed most interested in the idea. I, however, want to ensure I have some good material to reference for her. I did some basic searching on the subject but didn't seem to find anything that seemed very solid, at least for the first question though (this was helpful.)

I'm sure this sort of thing happened at least once, but what I'm really curious is whether it was a policy, or a thing, if there were repercussions, and which source material I can recommend.

1 Answers 2015-05-12

How did ancient Greeks swear and curse?

Sex? Fecal matter? Disease? Which of the gods would they have cursed to?

2 Answers 2015-05-12

Why didn't Portugal openly assist Britain during the American War of Independence?

Recalling the Treaty of Windsor of 1386, it seems strange to me that this is a gap in an otherwise consistent Anglo-Portuguese alliance during the colonial era. (bit.do/4zLQ).

The British were then a great power and Portugal could have gained territory/resources vis-à-vis Spain's involvement in the American cause.

1 Answers 2015-05-12

What is taught about Stalin in Russia?

2 Answers 2015-05-12

Why has the military term partisan fallen out of favor?

Partisan seems to be the most popular description of irregular military forces in WW2 Europe. After WW2 it seems to me all irregular military forces are referred to as guerrillas or insurgents. Are the tactics or theory of Cold War or modern groups much different from WW2 partisans? Is calling groups guerrilla or insurgents meant to delegitamize them? Perhaps the media just prefers newer terms?

1 Answers 2015-05-12

What happened to the world's cavalries?

Did the cavalries gradually morph into a different branch of the military or did most nations eventually decide to disband them.

2 Answers 2015-05-12

What do historians mean when they say a kingdom is "destabilized."

For instance, I was reading about early Polish history on wikipedia of course. There occurred, during the reign of one of the short term Polish dukes by the name of Bezprym, a so called Pagan reaction in Poland, which "for a time destabilized the Kingdom of Poland."

What does destabilization typically mean? Is it economic means being hampered, or the political and military reach of a kingdom being weakened due to internal conflicts or perhaps logistical issues, or something completely different?

1 Answers 2015-05-12

How did the Romans feel about Hannibal?

Did they hate him like anybody who came that close to destroying your civilization, or respect him because he was able to, or somewhere in between.

1 Answers 2015-05-12

Was Stalin’s transformation of Soviet society and its economy in the 1930s a success?

3 Answers 2015-05-12

Did Roman Latin have "G" swear words? Like darn, heck, dangit, freakin, fudge, etc.? If so, what were the original Latin words and what were the G words and translations?

8 Answers 2015-05-12

Describe Trotsky's role in the power struggle

1 Answers 2015-05-12

5418 / 7255

Back to start