What are some traits that differentiate the writing styles of Herodotus, Thucydides and Xenophon?

Like a compare and contrast on all their writing styles like how they tell the story, themes, comments on predecessors.

2 Answers 2015-04-21

Did harsh economic sanctions help Hitler gain popularity?

I know money wasn't worth the paper it was printed on and people were starving. Did all that desperation help Hitler's rise to power?

2 Answers 2015-04-21

Did Native Americans grow beards?

1 Answers 2015-04-21

Is there a historical reason English is so quick to appropriate words from other languages?

2 Answers 2015-04-21

Hey AskHistorians, I'm doing research on Gambling in the 18th century England. Would like some insight/sources that I could use. Can you help?

Hey, title pretty much says it all. I've got to write a presentation about Gambling in 18th century england, how it affected the culture and what daily life revolving around gambling looked like. I've done some research on my own but I haven't had much luck finding proper sources on the matter. Are there any books or insight you could provide information on?

Sorry if this is inappropriate for the subreddit, if it is Feel free to direct me to the correct place.

thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2015-04-21

If engagement rings weren't a thing before the 1940s campaign to sell diamonds, what did people do when they got engaged?

Is it all the same just minus the ring part?

2 Answers 2015-04-21

Why did the Nazis and German people keep fighting after the winning was no longer an option?

I'm about to start a research paper on the "final days of Nazi Germany" and I'm just looking for some basics sources to gather more information on what besides the atmosphere of propaganda and Nazi fanaticism caused this mentality to occur.

Thanks!

2 Answers 2015-04-21

Were allied countries relieved when the U.S. joined WWII?

I've seen movies where a bunch of battered British citizens and soldiers sit around a radio waiting for news. In the movie, when the announcer says the United States has joined the war effort they cheer and look relieved. How accurate is that? Did we really make that much of a difference? Or is it just false drama thrown in by movie directors?

1 Answers 2015-04-21

Why did the Islamic religion had more strenght among muslims than catholic religion among europeans?

Also, was this strenght one of the causes of the early Ottoman and Timurid power?

3 Answers 2015-04-21

How shocking was impressionism's rise and development?

Was it seen the same way most people nowadays see extremely abstract art ("my five-year-old son could have painted this")? Were the impressionists themselves regarded the same way people regard artists today (in the sense that some people see artists negatively, that they are kind of crazy)?

1 Answers 2015-04-21

Some say Nanking had about 300000 people before the massacre during WWII therefore the estimate that 300000 died is not accurate? To what extent is this true/false?

1 Answers 2015-04-21

"In the majority of American Indian societies however, biological sex played no part in any gender variant role" I got that from wikipedia. is it a statement you would agree with?

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gender_systems

2 Answers 2015-04-21

What were trials like in the time period of your expertise?

1 Answers 2015-04-21

Looking for some periods of internal consolidation in history

1 Answers 2015-04-21

What was the historical and cultural context behind St. Paul of Tarsus' stance on hair length for Christian males and females in his first letter to the Corinthians?

This is mentioned in the Bible 1 Corinthians 11:1-16.

Something about the hierarchy of things;

God -> Man -> Woman

How Men should not have long hair or their heads covered while praying but instead have their hair short and shown. Women should not have short hair while praying and instead have long hair.

While I do see the whole hierarchy thing being a product of his time, I am curious as to where he gets this idea of hairstyles from. Is it still practised today with any relevancy to Paul's writings? Was he influenced by his surrounding culture? Was it said by a prophet before him?

I only discovered this while studying his contributions to Christianity and this caught my eye. Also please tell me if I have asked the question incorrectly or if there is another subreddit that could help.

2 Answers 2015-04-21

Were freed American slaves assigned last names, or did they choose them for themselves?

I had been taught that freed slaves "took the last names of their masters." Wikipedia says:

After emancipation, many freedmen and women took the surnames of their former owners as their own.^[citation ^needed]

I always thought this was weird -- why would you want the name of the guy who owned and likely mistreated you?

But perhaps the freed slaves didn't have a choice, and it wasn't so much "taking" a last name, as one was given to you?

1 Answers 2015-04-21

How did people in the past deal with mental illness ?

1 Answers 2015-04-21

Do we have any idea on how did humans go about discovering Bronze or Iron?

I mean the elements melt at very high temperatures that require special furnaces. What gave them the initial idea?

3 Answers 2015-04-21

Prior to the Industrial Revolution, what did you pay taxes for?

As for my understanding, prior to the industrial revolution society structures were completely different, where the community and the family took care of everything for the individual (for good and bad).
I.e., jobs, 'law enforcement', 'education', juridical system etc. The state/country/kingdom didn't really intervene on how you run your community.
So why did we (they) paid taxes to the government for? was it just as a protection service you pay today to criminals?

2 Answers 2015-04-21

How much of the modern wealth of for former colonial nations be attributed to their former colonies?

This is an argument that flares up sometimes that still causes rather heated debates. The crux of it being that the a much of wealth of modern former colonial nations, such as Britain or France, is based on the exploitation of what were at the time colonies in Africa, Asia, the Caribbean, South America. Thus my question is:

  1. how far back is it reasonable to trace wealth i.e. if an ancestor owned a lucrative sugar plantation in the Caribbean

  2. Is the argument in any way historically valid if so how if not how so?

1 Answers 2015-04-21

Is it acceptable to use the term "tribe" when discussing African history?

I took an African history class a few years back, and the TA was always upset when anyone referred to African societies as tribes. For the most part we discussed and wrote about Africa in the 19th century.

The TA said that tribe has a negative and eurocentric connotation, and she explained that it was hypocritical to label an African civilization as tribal but not any Western ones. I see her point, but I found it difficult to write about African societies without using the term. And isn't a tribe a community largely based on kinship ties or stratified and led by chiefs? - which describes in general a number of historic African communities.

Furthermore, I am studying in France at the moment, and a professor with whom I was discussing the Amerindians in Guyana also frowned on the term. He explained that in France it always bore the sense of a primitive civilization.

So, is it ever correct to use the term tribe? What about in other places or periods of history, like Gallic tribes, for instance? I'm wondering what the standard academic byline is on this.

1 Answers 2015-04-21

Why isn't New York State New Yorkshire?

When the English named New York State and renamed New Amsterdam, why did they name the whole territory New York rather than New Yorkshire, wouldn't that make more sense in British naming conventions?

1 Answers 2015-04-21

How long was the average commute for Americans before the automobile?

18th or 19th century, American cities. Also how did the mode of commute differ with regard to status. Now the poor seem to live in the cities and the well-off live in the suburbs, was that the case back then?

2 Answers 2015-04-21

Were there any records of war crimes committed by the Americans revolutionaries during their war of independence?

1 Answers 2015-04-21

What is the difference between traditional and simplified Chinese?

Not sure if this is where I should put this, but I just thought I'd ask here anyway.

2 Answers 2015-04-21

5498 / 7255

Back to start