What was the standard Medieval European response to a heavy cavalry attack?

I was watching an Incan documentary where they mention that the Incas had no idea what a mounted soldier was, much less how to respond to an organized attack formation of cavalry units. I immediately think of pikemen as a standard defense. Any insight into how an experienced European defensive formation would look like?

1 Answers 2015-03-02

When was the nation we think of as France today created? How well has their record of war been since that point?

I keep hearing mixed opinions on this subject. Is there any definitive answer?

2 Answers 2015-03-02

In the decade following the end of Apartheid, South Africa saw the emigration of over 800,000 white South Africans. What adverse effects did this have on the country?

1 Answers 2015-03-02

when did the greek god hades become evil?

When did hades begin to be equated as evil? I'm assuming around the same time Christian mythology rose to prominence, because in grrek myths he wasn't a bad guy, just charged with keeping watch over the underworld (not hell, the realm of the dead) in order to preserve balance between life and death

1 Answers 2015-03-02

Top 3 Most underrated Roman Emperors and why?

1 Answers 2015-03-02

Would a 12th century English serf expect to ever meet the local earl in his lifetime?

In 1160, what are the chances that Alfred, an unfree serf, would personally interact with the Earl of Norfolk in his lifetime? Would the earl be personally involved in agriculture, or would that authority be devolved to his relatives and employees?

2 Answers 2015-03-02

Why did the germanic and celtic barbarians during antiquity not wear shirts and tunics into battle?

In popular culture we see a lot of barbarians, who could not afford armor like mail, fight shirtless. Is there any truth to this and if so why? Was there any advantage to being shirtless?

2 Answers 2015-03-02

De facto states?

Why does the area around Georgia, Azerbaijan and northern Iran have such a high density of de facto states?

1 Answers 2015-03-02

Just how complicit was "Shoeless" Joe Jackson in the Black Sox scandal of 1919?

Various historians have painted him as either a dumb hick who didn't realize what he was getting into, a patsy who was set up by the investigators to be a highly visible fall guy, or one of the core group of match fixers who received one of the highest payouts.

Jackson himself originally confessed to involvement, then recanted, and maintained his innocence throughout his life.

What's the truth (or as close as we can get to it)?

2 Answers 2015-03-02

How accurate is Black Sails?

I know some of the known pirates are in it, Anne Bonny, Charles Vane and so on.

but clothes? the way things was handled on the ships? Raiding? Sickness and health? drugs and alcohol? everything! Is it done right or is it something that is totally out of place?

2 Answers 2015-03-02

Napoleonic Era historians what do you think of this book ?

I am currently reading Russia Against Napoleon by Dominic Lievens. I think it's pretty good, I was just curious if somebody else has read this book and if so, how did you like it ?

2 Answers 2015-03-02

Monday Methods | Fictional Depictions

This be the 14th installment of Monday Methods, and we start this week with a question that may be slightly different to what you were expecting:

What is your response when contacted by those interested in human past data for the purposes of fictional depictions?

To elaborate, it's been my experience that quite a number of flaired users in AskHistorians have, at one point or another, been contacted by those seeking data for various projects that are better served with having accurate information about the human past. This is almost invariably for books, video games, or mods made for existing video games. The aim here is not to treat such contact as a negative, or indeed to mock anyone who has sought to contact you regarding the topic. My interest here is in how you responded when approached in this way, and, if you have anything to share on this subject, what the ultimate result was.

Here are the upcoming (and previous) questions, and next week's question is this: How do you deal with elements of your study that attract disproportionate attention?

5 Answers 2015-03-02

How did people count seconds (one mississippi, two mississippi...) in previous eras?

1 Answers 2015-03-02

Why isn't the Emperor Gallienus given more respect?

He beat back multiple invasions, He had to deal with usurpers left and right, and set up the empire so Clodius Gothicus and Aurelian only needed to walk across the goal line. (Yes, I'm simplifying reuniting the empire.) I mean Aurelian had the time to go to Palmyria and wage war. How could he have done that if Gallienus hadn't started (not finished) some sort of stability on the Danube. Anyone agree or disagree?

1 Answers 2015-03-02

Maps of China

2 Answers 2015-03-02

I am working on a paper for my upper division history class and I am looking for some help in formulating a cohesive draft.

The paper is focused on major political and social developments in France, Prussia, and Austro-hungary during the years between 1848–1851. What social and political events took place during these years, and what were the causes? Any help is appreciated, thanks in advance for your time.

1 Answers 2015-03-02

Did anyone discuss the problem of baby boomers retiring, prior to them actually doing so?

1 Answers 2015-03-02

Musket infantry tactics?

In this game I've been checking out(empire total war) the basic infantry usually only have the first 2 ranks firing and then reloading and firing again while the rest of the ranks just stand around, even if the formation is like 20 ranks deep. Would that have actually been the case in real life?

Another thing is would the infantry have used the tactic of firing and marching forward at the same time or some kind of similar tactic. ?

1 Answers 2015-03-02

How big was Vinland?

Can anyone draw the borders of Vinland on this map. I tried using this website but I'm still not sure how big Vinland was.

2 Answers 2015-03-02

Why did the USSR collapse so rapidly in the 90s?

4 Answers 2015-03-02

How did people become librarians in pre-modern times?

1 Answers 2015-03-02

The Russian Revolution: was in a Coup created by a few radical Marxist or was it a revolution in which the Russian society/culture also played a vital role?

The Russian Revolution: was in a Coup created by a few radical Marxist or was it a revolution in which the Russian society/culture also played a vital role?

This is a key question within my Soviet History class. I personally think it was primarily a coup led and controlled by the key players (Lenin,Stalin, Trotsky, ect.)

2 Answers 2015-03-02

What name did the Sassanids use for the Roman empire and/or it's people?

Thank you to any answers in advance.

Additional but not necessary questions are, what name did the Romans have for the Sassanid empire? and did these names change with time or stay the same?

1 Answers 2015-03-02

Was increasing population in the provinces a potential reason for the collapse of the western Roman Empire?

I believe I saw this argument once on the internet, that in the early Republican-era Roman Italy had a massively larger population than Iberia, Gaul or Britain, but that centuries later those regions had grown in population to the point where they could no longer be administered effectively or militarily controlled by Rome.

Is this a legitimate argument put forward by any scholars, or just something random I read on the internet?

2 Answers 2015-03-02

you know you hear old stories about women and young boys dressing up as men to join the military. During either of the world wars, or maybe even before, did any of the world powers have any official special rules for what you were supposed to do if a POW turned out to be either under 18 or women?

2 Answers 2015-03-02

5716 / 7255

Back to start