If I were to follow the path of English through time, how far back would I have to go until my speech seems...peculiar to others? Until it gets noticeably awkward between I and another speaker? Until it becomes difficult to understand each other? Until the discussion is intelligible?

I'm an American English speaker, if that makes a difference.

1 Answers 2015-02-06

Where is the best place to learn about the Japanese immigrants in America?

I have been interested in the Japanese immigrants that came to America before/around World War II. Does anyone know where I can look to find information?

Thanks :)

1 Answers 2015-02-06

Of the three Axis powers from WWII, why is Italy generally viewed in the least negative light?

2 Answers 2015-02-06

What were the rules (or trends) of capitalization in 18th century English?

Was it just kind of like Emily Dickinson's random capitalization For Emphasis, or was it a copy of German rules (if German had rules at that time), or something else entirely?

1 Answers 2015-02-06

What is the notion of "interaction spheres" in Chinese prehistory and how did early China develop differently from Europe?

I would also like if someone could explain the ideas of diffusionism and interactionism as models for historical development.

1 Answers 2015-02-06

What is the best way to preserve a fragile historical diary?

Apologies if this isn't the kind of question this sub is for.

After my grandfather died, I inherited a box of old books. In it I found my great-great-great uncle's diary from World War I. I would love to see this information digitized/preserved, but I'm afraid to handle it too much because the pages are already yellow and thin and the binding is very loose.

What is the best way to approach this document without damaging it?

1 Answers 2015-02-06

How come the US got all the Great Lakes when the US-CA border was drawn?

Here's Wikipedia. You guys have any insight?

1 Answers 2015-02-06

Reading 1 Maccabees at the moment, and it makes mention of alleged surgery apostate Jews would undertake to "reverse" their circumcision. Did this ever really happen, and if so, what would it entail in the Hellenistic era?

1 Answers 2015-02-06

What are some (world civ?) history books that are riddled with errors?

Such as Vikings having horned helms, Macedonians not speaking Greek, the well treatment of slaves in the U.S. south, holocaust denying etc.

1 Answers 2015-02-06

Is it actually true that Benjamin Franklin was not trusted to write the Declaration of Independence because he might hide a joke in it?

I keep seeing this and I wanna know if it's acutally true.

Edit: thanks for all the replies guys, and thanks for clearing it up. I didn't think this would get this much response.

3 Answers 2015-02-06

Was George Washington formally a general during the Whiskey Rebellion

I have always assumed that George Washington stayed in Washington D.C. (tangent: what was D.C. called while Washington was president? I can't imagine it was named after him yet) while his revolutionary war subordinates led the militia against the Whiskey Rebellion rebels. Wikipedia states Washington did in fact ride out to "review the troops" at some point.

My question is, was Washington formally the tip-top general in the army with responsibility and authority over the troops (outside of his being commander-in-chief as all POTUS's are)? I am not very familiar with military hierarchy, is this question even relevant or make sense?

Thanks in advance for satiating my curiosity about heads of state personally marching out onto the battlefield (sparked by the buzz over the King of Jordan renting up^and ^taking ^a ^axillary ^support ^role ^contrary ^to ^early ^reports).

EDIT: I am a formatting newb EDIT: and again

1 Answers 2015-02-06

Camp Logan??

1 Answers 2015-02-06

Did rulers throughout time ever have protection against "magic?" If so, what is the latest practice we know of this?

1 Answers 2015-02-06

When was Seppuku actually used?

I understand that this was a form of ritual suicide reserved for instances when a Samurai or group of Samurai had fallen into enemy hands and as an alternative to being tortured to death or dying in some other less-than-honorable way. But who made this call?

Instead of retreating did someone at the front of the battle just suddenly say, "They've overtaken us! Get out those ritual daggers!"?

I just don't understand when the turning point would be between "lets take as many of them down with us" and "All is lost, lets kill ourselves."

Wouldn't the point when there was nothing else they could do to fight the enemy come after the point when they would still have the ceremonial weapon on their person?

Thanks in advance!

1 Answers 2015-02-06

Why did German-speaking nations produce so many of the world's most famous composers?

Is this due to the 18th- and 19th-Century German-speaking world simply being ahead of everyone else at music knowledge and education? Is it due to luck in terms of having fantastically talented individuals like Mozart and Beethoven? Or is it our own bias from contemporary times (or an earlier bias that we have adopted), viewing German-speaking composers as "the best" and most famous now, when other composers from other places were just as famous in their own time?

1 Answers 2015-02-06

U.S. Constitution

1 Answers 2015-02-06

Did violent riots contemporary with Gandhi also play a role in India's independence?

1 Answers 2015-02-06

What are the pros and cons of Athenian style Democracy?

My high school relative is in an AP history class and was telling me about how democracy was practiced in Athens where men were chosen at lottery to run government. Aside from the sexism part it sounded like a better system than what we have now. I am more than likely overlooking something but would appreciate any expert helping me to better understand the Athenian system and explain why perhaps it is better or worse than our modern system.

2 Answers 2015-02-06

Does anyone know of any Meta-data regarding capital punishment in England during the 18th & 19th centuries?

perhaps this belongs in /r/asksocialscience or /r/homeworkhelp, but i feel like people around here might know better. I'm just trying to identify trends in capital offenses and capital punishment overtime during the 18th and 19th century. The Old Bailey online is pretty helpful but I was wondering if anyone could point me towards some more useful sources.

2 Answers 2015-02-06

What is the modern interpretation of Chamberlain's actions pre -WW2?

I'm going through the 'Rise and Fall of the Third Reich' by Shirer, and he's just got to the summer of 1939. He poses an interesting question but chooses not really to elaborate. At this point Chamberlain has:

  • Stood by while Germany reoccupied the Rhineland
  • Stood by while Germany re-armed ahead of any change to the Treaty of Versaille
  • Stood by while Germany absorbed Austria
  • Played part in the surrender of the Sudetenland from Czechoslovakia to Germany

A policy of appeasement is suggested by the author, and it was a change in sentiment within the House of Commons and House of Lords that caused a change in policy.

At this point he reaches out to offer a great-power united front against Germany, then a pact of Mutual defence between France, Poland and the UK, and then finally a guarantee of independence to Poland directly.

All of this to a militocracy that helped chop up Czechoslovakia, with up-until-recently Pro-German, anti-Franco-Russian leaning.

Frankly, it seems like the guy got backed into a corner and then came out swinging when he realised his own political career was basically over: but I'm getting this from a 50-year old book where homosexuals are still called degenerate sexual deviants.

What're the modern interpretation of his actions? Has more information come to light vis-a-vis declassification of Russian data, etc.?

3 Answers 2015-02-06

Who were the intended targets of ocean mine fields around the British Isles in World War 2?

I saw this map in this thread yesterday. Who were the intended targets of these massive minefields? U-Boats? Surface vessels? Did the mines have a measurable impact on the conduct of the war?

1 Answers 2015-02-06

Suggestions for books on Russian history, 1890-1915?

I'm planning to write a novel that takes place in an alternative history Russia between 1890 and 1915. I want to research the true history to better tweak it, so do you have any suggestions for books I can read on this topic?

Specific topics I'm looking into:

• Russia's relationships with other countries at that time, especially Germany, Finland and Sweden

• Rise of communism in Russia

• Life in a Russian village

• Media access in Russia at that time. What newspapers were there? How good was their coverage?

• Were any industrial/factory jobs available in Russia at that time?

• Marksmanship- what were the weapons available?

• The tsar and his family. I'm already planning to read The Romanov Sisters and Former People for this, but anything else is appreciated.

• The state of medical care in Russia

Other books I'm planning to read as a general overview on culture and history: Spies and Commissars, A People's Tragedy, The Russian Revolution by Richard Pipes, Uncle Vanya by Chekhov, books on Baba Yaga, The End of Imperial Russia by Peter Waldron, and The Best of Russian Life: History and Culture.

4 Answers 2015-02-06

I would like to know the historical accuracy of this article. It seems oversimplified.

I have only lightly dipped into Crusade history, but the portrait the author paints seems inaccurate. Please, any insights or corrections are welcome.

http://www.firstthings.com/article/2009/06/inventing-the-crusades

1 Answers 2015-02-06

(WWII): Leo Major and the single-handed liberation of Zwolle (any other source beside his own account?

Hi everyone,

I learned about Leo Major's story last month and it sure is surprising. I would like to know if such a story as the liberation of Zwolle is believable, and if there is any other source than Leo Major himself? I would be interested in German sources, in particular. He did get decorated for this action (and for another crazy action in Korea), but still... it's hard to believe:

He decided to continue his mission alone. He entered Zwolle near Sassenport and came upon a staff car. He ambushed and captured the German driver, and then led him to a bar where an officer was taking a drink. Inside he found that they could both speak French (the officer was from Alsace), and Major told him that at 6:00 am Canadian artillery would begin firing at the city, causing numerous casualties among both the German troops and the civilians. As a sign of good faith, he gave the German his gun back. Major then proceeded to run throughout the city firing his machine gun, throwing grenades and making so much noise that he fooled the Germans into thinking that the Canadian Army was storming the city in earnest

... eventually, the German garnison retreated from the city. Did they really believe that the army was raiding during the night, or did they already plan to leave anyway?

As he was doing this, he would attack and capture German troops. About 10 times during the night he captured groups of 8 to 10 German soldiers, escorted them out of the city and gave them to the French-Canadian troops that were waiting in the vicinity. After transferring his prisoners to the troops, he would return to Zwolle to continue his assault.

Incredible. Would people just cheer "keep going Leo" from the sidelines as he delivered prisonners 8-10 times?

Input very appreciated.

2 Answers 2015-02-06

What kind of pay could German conscripts in WWI expect?

I've been doing a lot of reading about women entering into the German labour market during the First World War, but I'm having trouble getting any information on the kind of pay the approximately 4.5 million married women who saw their husbands go off to war might have expected them to send home? Most secondary sources I've been looking at focus on the movement of working class women from unskilled textiles/clothing, etc. manufacturing, in to skilled "men's work", but no one seems to discuss women who couldn't make such a move, how they might have survived on their husbands wages, or how they may have supplemented them. Now, obviously I'm aware of the variable spending power any such wages would have had over the course of the war, but any information would be appreciated!

1 Answers 2015-02-06

5808 / 7255

Back to start