When was the last time a head of state led troops into battle?

3 Answers 2015-01-21

Did Europeans recognize Byzantium as the Roman Empire?

I know that Byzantium is actually just the Eastern Roman Empire and the true continuation of Rome, but what did the other European kingdoms think of it? It would seem that the HRE would argue that they were the real Roman Empire. Did European states recognize that Byzantium was the Roman Empire? If not, what did they address it as?

3 Answers 2015-01-21

How did ancient navies feed the 100+ rowers on their ships? What living quarters did they have?

I'm guessing they just didn't go out at sea for very long, but even a week of that many people in a wooden crate must have been difficult to manage. How did they do it?

9 Answers 2015-01-21

How did the Christian Church enforce its fourth century ban on Egyptian script? Have any other languages been purposefully "killed?"

3 Answers 2015-01-21

I've read a lot about British intelligence in WWII, but that is limited to SOE, Bletchley, and the XX network, but what about SIS specific operations?

What were some Secrete Intelligence Service operations in WWII? I am aware of the SOE and their insurgency, reconnaissance and demolition/sabotage operations (such as the operations in France, the assassination of Reynard Heydrich and the raid on the Norwegian heavy water plants), and the work of the Special Liaison Unit disseminating Ultra intercepts, but what other SIS operations were there?

1 Answers 2015-01-21

Generally speaking, are recent translations better than old ones?

1 Answers 2015-01-21

What was the importance of the locations of Alsace, Chateau Thierry, Soissons, and Meusse-Argonne in WWI?

I found a bracelet in a coin jar previously owned by my recently passed grandfather. It is made out of 3 French coins that were engraved on the back. The engravings list those locations, the years 1918-1919, and the words "US Army" and "Army of Occupation." From those years, I can assume that this is from WWI but I want to know what the US had to do with these events and what the effect was on the war.

1 Answers 2015-01-21

How long has the modern idea of a "band" that plays music existed?

1 Answers 2015-01-21

In many stories about early suburban life, there's often the mention of a milkman bringing dairy to the house in the morning. When did this stop becoming a thing, and why?

1 Answers 2015-01-21

What are some examples of European Kings misusing the Divine Right of Kings?

1 Answers 2015-01-21

In the late Qing dynasty, what were their obstacles towards westernization? Why did they failed to fully commit to westernization?

I'm also interested in knowing their economic situation, I've read somewhere that Qing was actually quite rich. Was this true? Did they had the economic means of doing that.

I know they tried to also set up western style officer training as well, but how effective was it? Was this training extended towards the soldiers?

Finally, was the administration system to blame? Did it cause problems towards westernization as well?

This is a lot of question, so feel free to answer them partially if you can.

1 Answers 2015-01-21

Regarding Serbia's Involvement With The Assassination of Franz Ferdinand

I apologize if this has been rehashed to death by now, but I'm confused on a particular topic. Every discussion I've seen online (either here on reddit or other WWI-themed sites) definitively states that the Serbian government had no links to the assassination attempt. However, I feel like I've gotten conflicting information from my reading. In the first chapter of Max Hasting's 1914, he discusses a certain higher-up in the Serbian military as being one of Princip's contacts in Belgrade. (I wish I could remember the individual's name but I don't have the book in front of me right now). If I recall correctly, most damningly, this military bigwig was the one that supplied Princip and his outfit with the guns they were supposed to use in the assassination.

So where am I going wrong on this one? As always, thank you for your replies, kind AskHistorians users.

1 Answers 2015-01-21

I came across a copy of an 8th century German epic poem published in Germany in 1945, either right after the war or in its final moments. It tells the tale of a father and son who meet on a battlefield and honorbound to fight. What allegorical meanng ds ths hv, cnsdring th tme at whch it was pblshd?

Sorry for the wonky title, I ran out of room and the question wouldn't have made sense if I removed whole words.


I came across a copy of the Lay of Hildebrand, published in 1945 in Halle, which is on old German epic poem. From wiki:

The opening lines of the poem set the scene: two warriors meet on a battlefield, probably as the champions of their two armies.

As the older man, Hildebrand opens by asking the identity and genealogy of his opponent. Hadubrand reveals that he did not know his father but the elders told him his father was Hildebrand, who fled eastwards in the service of Dietrich (Theodoric) to escape the wrath of Otacher (Odoacer), leaving behind a wife and small child. He believes his father to be dead.

Hildebrand responds by saying that Hadubrand will never fight such a close kinsman (an indirect way of asserting his paternity) and offers gold arm-rings he had received as a gift from the Lord of the Huns (the audience would have recognized this as a reference to Attila, whom according to legend Theodoric served).

Hadubrand takes this as a ruse to get him off guard and belligerently refuses the offer, accusing Hildebrand of deception, and perhaps implying cowardice. Hildebrand accepts his fate and sees that he cannot honourably refuse battle: he has no choice but to kill his own son or be killed by him.

They start to fight, and the text concludes with their shields smashed. But the poem breaks off, not revealing the outcome.

Wiki goes on to say that other versions of the poem indicate that the son attempts a treacherous attack after signaling his surrender, and the father is then honor-bound to kill him.

Is there some significance in this being published right after the war (or in its last months, I'm not sure when exactly it was published)? It seems that a poem like this, published so soon after a devastating loss, must have some sort of allegorical purpose... but I can't decipher what it is. Should we be reading Germany as the treacherous son, who backstabbed (barbarossa) his opponent, and is now destined to dishonorable defeat? Is it less overt, and just trying to frame the war as an epic tragedy? Is it trying to rally Germans to fight to the death? That the war was inevitable? Am I just reading too much into this, and there was no allegorical intent, and it was just an entertaining story?

1 Answers 2015-01-21

In terms of percentages, how did British casualties for Junior Infantry officers and Junior enlisted infantry compare during WWI?

I just finished reading "Tolkien and the Great War" by John Garth, and he points out a quote by Tolkien that says that all but one of his close friends were killed during the war. This got me thinking: were junior officers hit harder than their enlisted counterparts? If they were higher, how did this impact the middle and upper classes of Great Britain? What about the other major belligerents?

3 Answers 2015-01-21

Who is the most influential person in history?

1 Answers 2015-01-21

In World War II, what if Germany had never declared war on the US following Pearl Harbor?

2 Answers 2015-01-21

How was the Soviet Union united and administered as an entity?

Was it similar to how the UK is administrated? Was there different laws and autonomous legislative bodies?

1 Answers 2015-01-21

Was Newtonian physics all known or taught in China 170 years ago?

EDIT: should say "AT all known"

1 Answers 2015-01-21

What discoveries were made in ancient times? How did civilizations react to these discoveries?

1 Answers 2015-01-21

Who owned more, the contemporary "1%", or the aristocracy of the past?

1 Answers 2015-01-21

How significant a menace were pirates in the golden age of piracy?

In their heyday in the Golden Age of Piracy, how significant a menace were pirates? I.e. what percentage of government revenues for England, France, Spain, Portugal or the Netherlands would have been lost to piracy? Were they ever a financially existential threat to colonial regions?

1 Answers 2015-01-21

Is there a Colonial Americanist/New England specialist here (grad student or professor) who would be willing to discuss books with me?

I'm a graduate student and I'm feeling a bit lost with my research topic. If anyone here has formal training (graduate level) I could really use some help. I'm constructing a survey of scholarship on women's bodies in early New England and I have a few questions about crafting such a large project.

1 Answers 2015-01-21

Why did people back in the 1950s think that in he year 2000 there would be flying cars and jetpacks, etc?

Whenever I watch a old vision of the future from the 1950s the always seem to think the year 2000 will have Jetpacks, flying cars, hover boards, super tall skyscrapers, space stations, moon and underseas bases, food pills. Domesticated robots, and a wide variety of other gadgets. Why was this vision of the future back in the 1950s so common?

4 Answers 2015-01-21

Louis Riel Treason Charges?

For a report, we have to defend/"prosecute" Louis Riel, and to do this I would need to know what the treason charges were, where etc. but I can't seem to find anything on this topic.

Source would be lovely too.

2 Answers 2015-01-21

What is the historical consensus on Russian poet Sergei Yesenin's death?

I know that there are suspicions that he didn't commit suicide, but was murdered on the orders of someone in the Communist Party, but is this hypothesis taken seriously?

1 Answers 2015-01-21

5873 / 7255

Back to start