Putin says the Ruble will rise again. Do you know of *any* cases where a currency has been seriously devalued and then recovered to anythin near its previous value?

2 Answers 2014-12-18

Comparison of FDR, Hitler, and Mussolini eagle symbols?

I've been interested in the New Deal lately and came across a book comparing FDR's New Deal policies to the fascist policies of Mussolini and Hitler at the same time. I've yet to read the book but was instantly intrigued by the cover, which shows the three eagles together used by each of these men and so have been wondering if there has been any professional analysis or comparison done of the symbols? If so, could someone point me in the right direction? I'm looking specifically for information regarding the symbolism itself, not the policies of the governments (I will read the book for that!) Thanks!

Book cover and eagles

1 Answers 2014-12-18

How much could a viking expect to earn from a raid?

I read somewhere that a viking could expect to earn enough loot to purchase a decent sword from a single raid. How worthwhile was it to go off raiding compared to staying home for the summer and farming, fishing or plying a trade?

1 Answers 2014-12-18

Who "replaced" the Hittites after 1000BC?

I know that by the end of the Bronze Age the Hittite kingdom was destroyed, and that its destruction is credited to the "Sea Peoples," but between the end of the Bronze Age and the rise/dominance of Persia I don't really know anything about the history of that region.

Was there a successor to the Hittites - did someone conquer and set themselves up in Hattusa, or did that region just fall into obscurity and nothingness? I know of Assyria becoming strong after 1000BC and being one of (the?) opponent to the rising Persian empire, but other than that I know nothing. If anyone could shine a light on this dark age of history for me, I'd really appreciate it. Thanks!

2 Answers 2014-12-18

Thursday AMA: I'm Scott Sowerby, associate professor of British history at Northwestern. Ask me questions about seventeenth-century England!

Greetings from wintry Chicago! I'm going to start answering questions at 4 pm Central Time and will wrap up around 8 pm. My field of expertise is seventeenth-century England, especially the so-called "Glorious Revolution" of 1688-1689. A year ago I published my first book, Making Toleration: The Repealers and the Glorious Revolution, which won a prize from the Royal Historical Society in the UK. I know a lot more about the 1680s than I do about any other period, but basically anything from the Stuart dynasty (1603-1714) is fair game. I'm not an expert on the Tudors but will go there if someone really wants to! Also, I'm the Director of Graduate Studies in my department and can discuss the professional side of being or becoming an academic historian if people are interested in that.

[edit: I seem to be answering only about one question every twenty minutes--that is slower than I would have expected! I'm finding it hard to let go of my usual scholarly caution--I'm double checking all kinds of facts and statements even though I'm pretty sure that I've remembered them correctly. It's an interesting experience so far, trying to speed up my usual writing process for the demands of a real-time audience!]

[edit: Thanks, everyone, for the great questions! I'm going to call it a night, but I'll check back in tomorrow. It was fun engaging in the sort of counterfactuals and "what if" musings that would never make it through peer review at a journal. This is a great community, and I only hope that you've gotten as much out of this as I have!]

22 Answers 2014-12-18

What happened after the Anabaptist take-over of Münster in 1534?

1 Answers 2014-12-18

So what is the deal with tiki culture?

It recently occurred to me how strange the faux-Polynesian tiki culture is as a sort of amalgamation of various vaguely "exotic" items transposed on to the Pacific Islands, from fruity drinks to sweetened Chinese food to the strange twangy music that as far as I know has nothing to do with any Austronesian style or instrumentation. When and where did this strange pseudo-culture develop, and why did it become so popular?

2 Answers 2014-12-18

Was/Is Secession Unconstitutional?

I've watched CGPGrey's Can Texas Secede from the Union? video and heard various people declare that secession is unconstitutional. Unfortunately, in the video, he doesn't prove or quote from the Constitution or its amendments to show that it is indeed illegal for any state to secede from the Union.

It was my understanding that, when America was founded, it was called the "United States of America" because it was a union of countries that had a sort of alliance and mutual agreement with each other. (State = Country, as in "the Egyptian State has elected to pursue dinosaurs") The Articles of Confederation, if I recall correctly, very loosely bound these States together, ensuring each State's individual rights, while the Constitution unified and imposed more regulation on the states from the federal level.

I fail to see why it was or is unconstitutional for a state to say "we're outta here," secede, and do what they want. I'm not advocating any one State's secession (*cough* Texas *cough*), I'm just trying to understand the Constitution. At the end of CGP Grey's video, he says that after the Civil War, it was for sure illegal for a State to secede. Was there an amendment to clarify?

2 Answers 2014-12-18

Why is Portugal not a part of Spain? It seems like Spain should have naturally absorbed all of the regions on the Iberian peninsula, so how did Portugal resist their influence?

2 Answers 2014-12-18

Was there fast/street food in great cities of antiquity? Anything akin to cafes and food stands?

1 Answers 2014-12-18

What happened to the "replacement from I company" that shot Sgt. Grant in Band of Brothers?

1 Answers 2014-12-18

Bro, when did people start lifting?

I'm wondering people started lifting weights for it's own sake. It seems like people wouldn't have always known the science behind it.

4 Answers 2014-12-18

Was wheat and other farmable grain plants taller in the past?

like this picture shows it would seem that wheat was much taller in the past. Is it true or is it just artistic creativity?

1 Answers 2014-12-18

What did the CIA expect the result of The Bay of Pigs invasion to be?

With 1,500 lightly armed soldiers going against the entire Cuban military, how would the result have been anything other that total defeat? What was the plan of the CIA?

1 Answers 2014-12-18

How have different historical cultures interpreted, celebrated, or ignored birthdays?

2 Answers 2014-12-18

How was agriculture invented? Given the low amount of usable food from pre-domestication plants and the long time it takes between planting seeds and harvest, why did the first agricultural society take it up in the first place?

1 Answers 2014-12-18

How did the Mongols view sex and virginity?

In Weatherford's The Secret History of the Mongol Queens he mentions that Genghis Khan's son was accepted in court despite his questionable paternity because he was known to be the son of Temujin's wife. Was this a common sentiment? Did the Mongols have the same conceptions about chastity, monogamy, and sexuality that the West did?

1 Answers 2014-12-18

Do Signatures of Writers/Figures from Antiquity (Ancient History, e.g., Ceasar, Cicero, Alexander) Exist?

I could only think of Western figures, but I don't mean to limit the scope to that.

2 Answers 2014-12-18

did more people aged 30-60 die in the past of TB than of heart disease, cancer, etc. by a wide margin?

In historical times - namely, right through the early part of the 20th century - did more people in their 30s, 40s, and 50s die, by far, of tuberculosis than of heart disease, cancer, stroke, diabetes, etc.?

In other words, did such people die of TB way more than those other causes combined, or a little more than of those other causes combined? Or, did these people die only marginally more from TB than from any of these other causes?

1 Answers 2014-12-18

Where the columns of the Parthenon designed based on methods that only make sense for wood columns?

I will not mention she who shall not be named, but in the book The Fountainhead the protagonist Roark get's into an argument with the dean of his architectural school. At one point the Parthenon comes up and he criticizes the design, that the columns are built along the lines of wooden ones in a way to hide the joints in the wood; that they just carried over a design from one material to the next instead of fully utilizing the potential of the stone.

any truth to this, or was she who must not be named just making stuff up to fit her philosophies?

1 Answers 2014-12-18

How common was incest in small, isolated communities before the advent of cities?

Thinking about the (relatively) small communities and lack of infrastructure at and before the dawn of cities, it seems a logical consequence that chances were high all available mating partners are related, if the community continued over a long enough time-frame, which seems to be the case. Did this happen? If so, was there a measurable impact on genetic stability or diversity? If not, where is the flaw in my reasoning, or what assumption is incorrect, or what other factor have I overlooked? I am asking in the general case of communities before cities were a regional feature, not in any specific area or time-frame.

2 Answers 2014-12-18

Antony Beevor in his book, "The Second World War", states that Stalin wanted the right of transit across Polish territory for the Red Army. This was in 1939, before the Germany-Soviet non aggression pact. Why did he want that right?

1 Answers 2014-12-18

How did frontiersmen survive crossing through a freezing cold river during the winter months?

1 Answers 2014-12-18

Why did it took so long for mankind to evolve?

1 Answers 2014-12-18

How much archaeological evidence do we have of the characters from China's Three Kingdoms period?

I understand Zhuge Liang and Cao Cao wrote books and other material attributed to them, but are there things like seals of their office, or any tangible pieces of art from that time which mention the kingdoms and their leading figures?

How soon after the deaths of Guan Yu and Zhang Fei were temples erected to them?

(I'm not skeptical of their existence even though this question probably sounds like that, just interested in archaeology of the period)

1 Answers 2014-12-18

5988 / 7255

Back to start