Question regarding medieval laws?

Obviously there WERE laws, but how one-sided were these legal systems? If you were caught stealing from a lord or king, obviously you would be severely punished.

But were the lower class protected against the higher class as well? If a landed royal or otherwise "important" person committed a crime such as rape or murder against a peasant, was there an expectation of justice?

1 Answers 2021-07-22

The Ottoman Empire was dissolved in 1922, but the Republic of Turkey wasn’t proclaimed until 1923, what was Turkey viewed as/called in that year long gap?

It seems like there’s a year long gap where there was no country in Anatolia which could really be the case right?

1 Answers 2021-07-22

Recommendations for books about the Oseberg viking ship excavation? (In English or Norwegian)

It's my understanding that the Oseberg excavation was a well documented event and very important to Norwegian archaeology. I would appreciate it if anyone could point me in the direction of further reading. I'd also be happy with any books that might aid my understanding of the Oseberg ship even if it's not the primary focus of the text.

Thanks

1 Answers 2021-07-22

AskHistorians Podcast Episode 179 - Adam Contzen's Ten Books of Politics with The Contzen Project

AskHistorians Podcast Episode 179 is live!

The AskHistorians Podcast is a project that highlights the users and answers that have helped make r/AskHistorians one of the largest history discussion forums on the internet. You can subscribe to us via Apple Podcasts, Stitcher, or RSS, and now on YouTube and Google Play. If there is another index you'd like the podcast listed on, let us know!

This Episode:

I talk with Dr. Jacob Baum, Dr. Sydnor Roy, and John T Conrad (u/EMEHISTThomas) about their project translating Adam Contzen's Ten Books of Politics. The Ten Books has never been translated out of its seventeenth-century neo-Latin, and the project is one that will be open to the public who wish to provide commentary, advice, or simply practice with untranslated Latin, as they continue to build a corpus of translation.

Anyone interest in the project is invited to reach out to

John T. Conrad: johnt.conrad@wustl.edu

Sydnor Roy: sydnor.roy@ttu.edu

2 Answers 2021-07-22

People say they want historically accurate "medieval fantasy".

How common was rape and child sex in Europe during the Middle Ages?

In a discussion regarding George R.R. Martin's work, the dubious claim was made that the seemingly excessive and gratuitous rape scenes were to paint a historically accurate picture of medieval times.

Was the average woman or child at great risk of rape?

Would this change during times of war?

For women and children captured after battle?

Were women and children at great risk of being captured after battle?

2 Answers 2021-07-22

Some have reacted to criticism of the recent space flights of Bezos and Branson by comparing it to criticism of the Wright Brothers as out-of-touch rich people who were squandering money that could be better spent on the poor...did this criticism actually exist?

1 Answers 2021-07-22

Why did the Byzantine Empire collapse so thoroughly after the sack of Constantinople?

I know that the Latin Empire, the Empires of Trebizond and Nikea, and the Despotate of Epirus all claimed to be the true successors to the Empire but I am just curious how it fragmented that heavily since at that point the Crusaders were deep in what was now very hostile territory and nearby armies could have been brought against them.

1 Answers 2021-07-22

How did one go about getting into college in the Soviet Union?

Here in Brazil we have tests, very hard ones, to get into universities; in the US they have the whole letters and interviews thing. In the Soviet Union, because of socialism and the ideal of equality, seems logical that they would try to make access to education the most democratic as possible. So how was the system to get into universities? And did any policy designed to diminish inequality in education actually work?

1 Answers 2021-07-22

What were the USA goals in opperation: Desert Storm?

1 Answers 2021-07-22

The year is 1050 AD and I’m a decently well off farmer in central Sweden. While the king and many powerful lords have converted to Christianity I still hold on to the old gods. How open can I be about my faith, and how do I go about performing my rites? Can I in any way do it out in the open?

For clarification, as I understand it at this point the majority of people living around Uppsala, where the old temple was, were still pagan. Not much further south, however, the majority were Christians, and only a minority held on to the old gods; I belong to that pagan minority. If I’m mistaken, please go ahead and correct me!

1 Answers 2021-07-22

Is there any sort of banner/symbol considered to be linked to King Arthur?

I know there’s some debate as to whether or not a real King Arthur Pendragon, even existed, or what the original legends were based on.

With that said, I was wondering if UK historians had any sort of sigil, or emblem they considered to have belonged to, or descended from King Arthur, or from any famous monarchs that may have inspired the legends?

Like something you would paint on a shield, tabard, or sow onto a banner.

1 Answers 2021-07-22

Are there any primary accounts by “ordinary people” about how the catastrophes of the Second World War affected them emotionally and psychologically?

I’m hoping to find sources like journal entries, personal reflections, opinion editorials etc.

There’s something of an apocalyptic flavour to current affairs. I’m trying to find some more personal insights into how people dealt with the emotional terror of what must have felt like the end of the world.

1 Answers 2021-07-22

How progressive on ethnic rights in the Austro-Hungarian Empire was Archduke Franz Ferdinand?

I recall reading a long time ago, that Franz Ferdinand was in favor of allowing more ethnic autonomy to non Austrians within the empire. He was also in favor of increasing their representation in their parliament. From what I understood, this was against the mainstream belief of the Austrian dominated government leaders. The writer explained this made his assassination all the more tragic because had he assumed the throne of the empire, he could have eased a lot of the ethno-nationalist tensions that caused his assassination and started the First World War.

How accurate are these assertions by the author, or am I misremembering entirely?

1 Answers 2021-07-22

Rome’s origin story, of a town founded by criminals and vagabonds, replete with constant war and duplicitous betrayals such as the Rape of the Sabine women, sounds almost barbaric compared to the proud statesmen senators in the later Roman republic. How did the romans themselves view their origin?

I would like to ask especially in the case of the titular Romulus, who was supposed to have killed his own brother in the process of the building of Rome.

2 Answers 2021-07-22

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | July 22, 2021

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history
  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read
  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now
  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes
  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

6 Answers 2021-07-22

The USSR in Central Asia?

Hello, I’ve always been curious as to why and how northern Central Asia got its borders today, And I read that the borders were redrawn by the USSR after absorbing the Khivan and bukkharan territories. I was just wondering exactly why and how the borders were redrawn? What are their purpose? How has it affected the peoples? And why exactly were these borders decided on specifically? I’ve been trying to find direct sources on the subject but I really don’t know where to look

1 Answers 2021-07-22

What was the process for enslaving someone in Ancient Rome?

I understand that most of Rome's slave population came about through conquests during wars, but that they also bought slaves from pirates, and that criminals could be enslaved.

Could just anyone kidnap a person and bring to a Roman market? Was there paperwork involved? Did some kind of database exist, or did slave owners keep documents that proved ownership of a slave?

1 Answers 2021-07-22

What were the biggest driving factors behind the bronze-age collapse?

I've read that climate change was one of the biggest factors, but a recent thread also brought up the growth in power of coastal regions over inland empires as one possible reason too.

2 Answers 2021-07-22

rabbit in the Australian diet

during the 1920s and before rabbits were a major part of the Australian diet and going out and hunting your own was fairly common (my grandfather has a photo of him and his brothers with 10+ dead rabbits) but these days I don't even know where you would get a rabbit from. what caused the decline of eating rabbits in Australia?

1 Answers 2021-07-22

How much can we trust Thucydides, really?

It's probably me reading the wrong books, but isn't his account of post-Pericles Athenian politics and Cleon in particular taken too much at face value in popular history? The way I see it, Thucydides had extremely strong motivation to depict Athenians in general and their leaders in particular in as bad light as possible, and he did portray them as both too coldly cynical (in the infamous Melian dialogue) and too fickle and passionate at the same time...

So how modern historians rate his reliability, and what would be good, layman-accessible further reading on this?

1 Answers 2021-07-22

Where did office workers in the 19th Century go to the bathroom?

So I'm reading a lot of Dickens at the moment, and one thing that stands out is the amount of office work that is done by main characters. However, one thing that's bugging me is the lack of toilets or commentary on sanitary habits. Did office workers in the 19th Century just go "excuse me boss I need to urinate" and go into the street to do it?

As my office bathrooms are like 30 seconds from my desk I would hate to have to go down a few flights of stairs to the street or ground level to take a leak - seems massively inefficient to me and a waste of the working day.

2 Answers 2021-07-22

Was Sicily under Roger II such a tolerant and mixed society?

I’m reading the very interesting Sicily by Norwich. I’m really interested in the figure of Roger II of Sicily. Was really its rule such tolerant and open to other cultures? The Palatine chamber suggest that, and also the sources that we got from the time. But I was interested in the issue and to know if there are other sources that put in doubt that narrative.

1 Answers 2021-07-22

Public notification during medieval era

I'm writing a fictitious light novel based on medieval era, perhaps around 14th century where people battled with swards, not yet with guns. In the story, a king makes an announcement throughout his kingdom. To do so, what's the natural way of the announcement?

Were notification boards/bulletin boards used?

Were messages engraved directly on wooden boards? Or some sort of papers, such as parchment, were used?

If parchment was used, was it weatherable?

Not many people around that time might be able to read written words, I guess. So they didn't use bulletin boards at all? Rather, a public servant read out a message paper in front of villagers? (Before this announcement, the public servant has to walk around the village on his horse notifying people that there will be a public announcement)

Please note that this question is for a fiction. It doesn't have to be strictly based on facts. So any suggestion that could naturally fit in the fictitious story would be fine.

Thank you!

1 Answers 2021-07-22

I am an average person living near Jerusalem during the earliest periods of the Christian church. While I am of Jewish ancestry, I also recognize Jesus Christ as the Messiah. At what point would I cease to consider myself a Jew and see myself as only Christian?

2 Answers 2021-07-22

What were the general family dynamics within imperial or aristocratic harems in fifth century China? And how did princely titles work?

During the early stages of quarantine last year, I steadily worked my way through the cdrama The Princess Weiyoung, a drama set in Northern Wei in the middle of the fifth century. It gave rise to some questions about social dynamics that the show takes for granted, but which are unfamiliar to me.

  1. A lot of the first half of the show is taken up with household politics, particularly dealing with the relationship between the first wife/her children and a concubine/her daughter. So basically: what were the general family dynamics within imperial or aristocratic harems at this time? I know that all of the children were considered the wife's children, legally, but was there any sense of the wife's biological children being higher status or more legitimate heirs?

  2. I understand that the Tuoba clan was (possibly? probably?) from Mongolia; did they have some relationship to the nomadic Rouran?

  3. While looking at the Wikipedia pages for the actual history that the show is very, very loosely based on, I saw this:

Emperor Taiwu created him the Prince of Gaoyang, but then reconsidered, believing that a princely title was inappropriate for his oldest grandson, and therefore cancelled the title—signifying strongly that he intended for Tuoba Jun to succeed him.

What is going on here? What was the meaning of princely titles, if having one made a person seem less likely to be selected as a successor to the emperor?

1 Answers 2021-07-22

602 / 7255

Back to start