How historically accurate was The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly?

Some additional questions,

  • How was is viewed at the time of release?

  • How did politicians, activists, commentators, etc view it, or try and use it?

Thank you guys so much for looking at this question, I'm having a hard time finding any info on this classic movie. My usually good google skills are failing me, as all I can find other than wikipedia and IMDb are top ten lists, or articles using "The good, the Bad, and The Ugly" as an expression. Ask Historians is a fantastic resource and I figured you could help more than /r/movies, which didn't help much.

1 Answers 2014-11-24

How developed were Baltic countries in interwar period? Could they be compared to Scandinavian countries?

By "interwar" I mean between in period between WWI and WWII

Especially, I am interested in comparison to other northern european countries (Norway, Sweden, Finland) in economic, cultural and social aspects.

Thank you!

1 Answers 2014-11-24

Is there evidence of early military tests with jet aircraft being flown by test pilots in gorilla suits?

This was a claim I remember from my High School Aviation class, and possibly a few other places. The idea is that other pilots might see a propeller-less airplane being flown by a gorilla. They wouldn't tell anybody, because everyone would think they're crazy.

This seems like a myth. Fighter cockpits are cramped places as they are without wearing a gorilla suit, and you'd have to be flying pretty close to see what the pilot looks like.

1 Answers 2014-11-24

Why are there so many names that start with "Mac" (Macbeth, Macduff) in shakespearean literature?

I'm reading Macbeth right now and it struck me as odd. Was that a popular naming convention back then?

1 Answers 2014-11-24

Would a caveman, on an average day, have a nutritionally perfect diet? If not, why wouldn't cavemen's digestive systems evolve until they were perfect?

New to this - let me know if there's a better place for prehistory questions!

1 Answers 2014-11-24

How long have drinking games been around? Any interesting ones from pre-modern times?

3 Answers 2014-11-24

What happened to Austria-Hungary at the end of the First World War?

I am aware of what happened to Germany, their Spring Offensive failed, leaving the allies to either march into Germany or sign an armistice, and the latter occurred in the Treaty of Versailles, which started a slippery slope into the Second World War.

It seems that all the history lessons I have had on the actual war itself and the end of it involves only France, Britain and Germany. I have no idea of any major battles involving Austria-Hungary since the Russians left the war in 1917.

What I certainly don't understand is how they disappeared off the face of the Earth at the end of the war. I know that there were several ethnic minorities around Austria-Hungary at that time, do they have anything to do with it? Or was it just another clause in the Treaty of Versailles?

2 Answers 2014-11-24

What are some good sources on life in palatinate (HRE) during the 1450-1500s for an amateur.

Im reading a chronicle about the history of the city where i live in (its called the "Dochnahl") that ranges from 58 CE to about 2k. But its mostly consisting of major political events regarding or affecting the region or the city. Does anybody have some more books to recommend that describe everyday live?

1 Answers 2014-11-24

What are the differences between ancient Norse and Germanic cultures?

It could be a stupid question but arn't they basically the same? Why is there even a distinction? I mean both had the same religion, origin etc.

2 Answers 2014-11-24

Questions regarding 1920s currency?

Hello Historians and History Addicts,

I have just a few questions regarding the legal tender of the 1920s, which I know was a time of hyperinflation and the tossing around of money like it was nothing. But my question more has to do with the money itself.

1st: What would be considered a large sum of money in that time? Like to have in a bank account?

2nd: Can anyone direct me to a site that has pictures of both the front and the back of legal tender notes? I tried searching on Google, but I had a tough time finding what I was looking for.

3rd: Any sort of interesting information you may have on 1920s money that you're just itching to tell me, I'm all ears.

Thank you so much for reading this post and I wish you all well.

Sincerely, Jacob S. Tucker

1 Answers 2014-11-24

How far back in time would I have to go before I could no longer communicate verbally with anyone on earth assuming I only speak English.

1 Answers 2014-11-24

Why did early firearms replace the bow?

It seems that early firearms were inaccurate unreliable and slow. How was it that they so quickly replaced the bow? It seems like the would both be used in mass for zone fire, with the bow being able to fire faster.

I understand that early firearms have an armored piercing capability which is a good argument supporting firearms, but then why is it that bows never made a comeback when armies stopped using armor on general infantry, such as in revolutionary times? I feel that an army armed with bows would devastate enemy formations armed with muskets firing at 3 shots per minute.

Edit: grammar

1 Answers 2014-11-24

Has a pope ever led an army into battle?

2 Answers 2014-11-24

History of Energy?

Looking for sources/books on energy history, just read Daniel Yergin's The Prize and I loved it, is there any other reccomendations/must reads when it comes to energy history?

1 Answers 2014-11-24

History of political slander?

What are some of the earliest accounts of political slander from political rivals or other dissidents in human history? As to what I mean by this, think modern American political ads in ancient form ("Caesar is a tyrant who will burn Rome to the ground for his brash actions in Gaul", etc).

1 Answers 2014-11-24

How did the number of draftees change as the Vietnam War went on?

As the war went on, more men were drafted. However, I'd like specific figures if that's possible. Internet research has yet to yield any results, I'm trying to get a scope on how the number of draftees in Vietnam fluctuated as American involvement in the theater increased.

1 Answers 2014-11-24

How did the U.S. Supreme Court come to solidify it's power as "the third branch of government"? What was it like before then?

Early in the history of the country, the U.S. Supreme Court did not wield as much power of judicial review and influence the American political and social landscape as it does today. We all know Marbury vs. Madison, helped establish it's independance, but it still did not hold the power that it would later in cases like Brown v. Board for example.

In fact, it seems almost like it was for years the weakest of the three branches, but now its decisions are waited on with baited breath by the media and government to dictate future policy and legislation. How did it exactly get to that point, and what was it like before it had established itself?

1 Answers 2014-11-24

Why was the US Army base Fort Worden named after Navy Rear Admiral Worden?

Fort Worden is apparently the only US Army base to ever be named after a Navy officer, one John Lorimer Worden, commander of the Monitor in the US Civil War. The reasons why are possibly lost to history. Any military history buffs out there who might possibly know why?

One supposedly plausible answer is that a president of the day belonged to a secret society (presumably in Washington DC) where they were having a meeting or panel and Worden's name was tossed into the hat as they were discussing historically relevant names to use in naming things. I'm not sure of the name of this society, but the time frame would have been late 1800s, pre-dating Fort Worden itself by an appropriate amount of time.

Warning: This question may actually be unanswerable. It has puzzled professional historians.

1 Answers 2014-11-24

Were cars always able to drive all year round in all sorts of weather?

Could you only drive in perfect weather conditions at first? As in were cars able to operate in the rain or snow from the very beginning? If not, what innovations helped cars become a weather resistant?

1 Answers 2014-11-24

Shield wall primary sources

Can anyone recommend some good primary sources that demonstrate use of shield walls in combat? I don't really know when shield wall use was at it's peak, but any sources from around this area will be really helpful. Thanks!

1 Answers 2014-11-24

How did the suffices (or suffixes) denoting the various languages and ethnic/national heritage developed?

In contemporary English, there are major suffix groups for languages, each tend to predominate a geographic region. the most common is "-an" such as German, Italian, Russian, etc. This is found globally but tend to predominate in Europe and Africa. The "-ish" is also very common, eg. English, Spanish. The "-ese" group tend to be predominant in Asia, eg. Chinese, Japanese. Then there's the "-i" group, eg. Hindi, Bengali. There are more, but you get the picture. This did not even include ones without suffices such as French and Greek.

Along the same note, how did the national or ethnic terms develop? Eg. why are people from Israel called Israelis and not Israelians?

1 Answers 2014-11-24

Why did Emperor Joseph II of austria "order that bodies should be buried in unmarked graves, without coffins or embalming"

I got this from a Wikipedia article about where Mozart was buried. I was wondering why he did this. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/St._Marx_Cemetery

1 Answers 2014-11-24

How would post-war law enforcement in the 1870s handle the killing of a Confederate colonel?

I'm the midst of a history-inspired collaborative fiction (roleplaying) game in which a North Carolina wilderness confrontation results in the death of wealthy aristocrat who was a Confderate colonel just a few years back. It wasn't exactly cold-blooded murder, but neither was it a fair standoff -- he died with a bible in his hand, not a gun. The shooters trek overland and out of state. The victim's relatives witnessed the act and carry the body back into Raleigh, and would tell the story to authorities in the most onerous light.

In the 21st century, DNA would be collected, facial recognition software employed, FBI databases updated, alerts sent out to local PDs, etc.

What would have happened in 1875ish?

2 Answers 2014-11-24

What was life like for Roman Catholics in the UK after King Henry VIII separated the English Church from Rome?

I have read that many were hunted down and executed. Did that happen to all Roman Catholics in the UK? Or just the priests/other religious (e.g. nuns, brothers/monks)?

Were there areas where they were tolerated?

1 Answers 2014-11-24

Is Ancient Greece considered western and Byzantium eastern?

In a lot of my history classes Ancient Greece is always referred to as the cradle of western europe, but when we refer to byzantium it is always called eastern europe. Wouldnt Byzantium be considered the cultural successor of Graeco-Roman culture rather than HRE/Germanic tribes or the Gauls?

So to clarifiy my question is why isnt western europe classified as the germanic and gaullic tribes in antiquity and HRE and France in medieval, and eastern europe as Graeco-Roman in antiquity and Byzantium in medieval.

Am I missing something here in the way it was explained to me?

2 Answers 2014-11-24

6070 / 7255

Back to start