AMA: We are the Staff from Menokin (a National Historic Landmark). AMA!

Introduction: We are the staff of Menokin - a historic ruin located in Virginia's rural Northern Neck. Menokin, the home of Francis Lightfoot Lee (a signer of the Declaration of Independence) is a National Historic Landmark, and, like our country, built on the contradictions of slavery. Menokin is one of the best documented 18th centuries houses in the United States. Today we will be answering questions about our historic preservation work, the home and land, and the past occupants including the enslaved people. You can also learn more about Menokin at our website (www.menokin.org).

The staff answering questions today are:

Sam McKelvey - Executive Director

Juliana Grassia - Director of Visitor & Community Engagement

Alice French - Director of Education & Programming

Clarissa Sanders - Development Coordinator

If you want to learn more about our individual backgrounds, check out our bios (https://www.menokin.org/our-team-board)

We are really excited to be answering your questions, so go ahead and ask us anything!

14 Answers 2021-07-12

Why is organized crime such as Yakuza still thriving but Al-Capone style Italian mob disappeared?

1 Answers 2021-07-12

Letters and Numbers on an Army Helmet Liner?

So I recently came into possession of a Cold War Era M1 helmet. The liner of said helmet has three markings on it all in white paint: Front: A Right-side: 13 Back: 3

What does ANY of that mean?

1 Answers 2021-07-12

Was the Nazi invasion of the USSR doomed from the start?

Over the years I've had discussions with a few people about the Eastern Front in the Second World War. Some of those I've spoken with have asserted that Operation Barbarossa was always doomed to fail because of a combination of:

  • the Soviets' sheer numerical superiority
  • the savage nature of the Russian winter
  • the impossibility of conquering enough of the USSR before December 1941 (which I'm told was an objective that was fundamental to the German war plan - they hadn't made preparations for a winter campaign because they believed they could rapidly occupy the European USSR and the Caucasus)

From reading Beevor's Stalingrad and from watching the Battlefield documentary on the same subject, I know that if the Nazis had won the famous battle it would have secured them access to the mineral wealth of the Caucasus and freed up forces to advance on Moscow and I believe that at one point the Nazis had occupied 90% of the city. Based on this fact it seems to me that rather than being doomed to failure the Nazis came perilously, frighteningly close to winning the war on the Eastern Front and if not occupying the entire USSR then at least removing it as a strategic threat for years to come.

I would therefore be very interested to read the opinions of any historians with a detailed knowledge of this period in history. To be clear, I very much hope that the Nazis were always doomed to fail in their conquest of the Soviet Union and that it wasn't simply sheer weight of numbers that won out for the USSR in the end.

1 Answers 2021-07-12

How did ancient Greeks reconcile their martial and powerful female deities (Athena, Artemis) with the fairly restricted and certainly non-martial role that women had in Greek life?

Athena is a literal goddess of war and Artemis is a goddess of the hunt - these seem to be fairly oxymoronic pairings of gender and occupation compared to the stereotypical women in Greek life. Was there contemporary commentary on this? Did any women attempt to emulate these goddesses and seek martial glory?

1 Answers 2021-07-12

Coastal versus open sea sailing ships

In the ancient world, what was the difference between ships considered suitable for sailing along the coast or up rivers, versus those considered suitable for crossing the open Mediterranean?

Of course, navigation was also an issue, but here I'm only talking about the ships themselves. How did the largest, most seaworthy ship considered suitable for e.g. sailing up the Nile, compared to the smallest, cheapest ship considered suitable for sailing across to Italy?

1 Answers 2021-07-12

I've heard before that armies in China would get involved in some form competitive maneuvering. Did this happen? What was the purpose of this kind of thing? Intimidation?

1 Answers 2021-07-12

How Much Larger of an Unprofessional Army Can a Professional Army Realistically Take On?

So, as far as I'm aware a well-trained, veteran, professional army has a significant advantage over an army which is made up primarily of levies or fresh recruits.

But I was wondering how much this advantage realistically is in numbers. All else being equal (so the same types of troops, not cavalry vs. infantry or something, no huge disparity in technology where one side has gatling guns and the other is using spears) historically how large an army of inexperienced soldiers can a professional army generally take on? Two times as many? Three times? Four times?

I'm primarily looking for specific historical examples of this happening (a smaller veteran and/or professional army beating a larger non-professional army or army of fresh recruits) and the respective army numbers involved. The larger the disparity in the example, the better. I'm especially interested in the extremes, though more average ones are also welcome.

Thank you in advance. =)

Edit: I just wanted to clarify that I know there is no perfect scenario here. There will always be other factors involved. Ideal examples are the ones that are as even in ways other than numbers and professionalism as possible, obviously. But I know that one which comes down solely to training and professionalism probably isn't around. Hopefully though by seeing many examples I can look at these examples all in closer detail, see what other factors played a role (which will tend to be different for different examples) and kind of try to sift them out that way and get a vague idea what the comparative advantage is.

1 Answers 2021-07-12

Given that Muslim ruled kingdoms on average were more tolerant towards the Jewish community than their Christian counterparts, why is there no significant Jewish population in any Muslim majority country today?

It seems like that Jewish communities flourished much more in Christian run realms despite the discrimination they faced. How can this be explained?

According to https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jews "Regions with significant populations", of the 22 countries listed, there is only a single Islam majority country (Turkey, rank 21) that host a Jewish community >15000 people.

1 Answers 2021-07-12

A question about succession in the Roman Empire: why did Tiberius have Germanicus assassinated?

I’m watching the Roman Empire documentary on Netflix, and it mentions that Tiberius wanted his brother (and heir) Germanicus killed so that his own son could inherit the throne.

How did succession work in the Roman Empire? Why didn’t it just go to his son automatically, but instead to his brother?

1 Answers 2021-07-12

Our grandparents constantly told us as children that it's rude to put your elbows on the dinner table. Where did this seemingly random yet ubiquitous table etiquette rule come from?

1 Answers 2021-07-12

How does an Empire conquer lands without leaving their own lands defenseless?

I'm not knowledgeable when it comes to stuff like this. I find history quite fun to learn. Although, I don't really get that much into details. I've read events and watched documentaries about Empires conquering lands with huge amount of soldiers numbering sometimes up to 100 thousand. That's quite a lot of soldiers. What's the process behind this?

1 Answers 2021-07-12

A common image of an angel is that of a winged being while that of a demon is that of with bat-like wings and horns. However, Biblical texts do not describe these beings like these so how did this common portrayals come into being?

If my understanding is correct, there are different hierarchies of both angels and demons.

Angels are depicted in strange ways because of having many wings at a time but also having many halos of fire but no human body.

Demons are portrayed in a variety of different ways and there were different depictions and hierarchies of demons like the Seven Princes of Hell.

But Biblical texts do not describe these beings the way we know today so where did these portrayals come from and why did they stick?

1 Answers 2021-07-12

I located my great great great grandfathers Mexican War Pension Index

And have a question. It is dated 1887 Aug 13. States his service was with Browns Co 2 Texas Cav.

Can’t find anything on it. Does anyone have any info on where they may have served and doing what?

1 Answers 2021-07-12

Did northern Europeans have an equivalent to Native Alaskan Mukluks (thick winter boots)?

Whenever I see something like historical viking boots they seem to be pretty thin, so I was wondering what more northern people wore during winter? What are they called if they did?

1 Answers 2021-07-12

How to did US troops in sustained combat deal with the 1944 Presidential election?

1 Answers 2021-07-12

Caracalla made every free male a citizen of the Roman empire, enfranchising millions of people. Did he do this primarily to increase tax revenue? How much money are we talking here? Did the enfranchisement "dilute" the Roman brand and remove the incentive of military service for citizenship?

1 Answers 2021-07-12

What about the admission of Missoui to the union made it so controversial that southern slaveholding interests threatened disunion and civil war over it?

1 Answers 2021-07-12

Food and Alcohol on the Midwestern Frontier (1830-1880s Iowa)

Let's say I'm a recent immigrant farmer settling in the new territory-turn-state of Iowa (USA) in the 1830s-1880s, from northern Germany (Schleswig-Holstein) or Ireland.

What kind of beer did I brew? Did I distill liquor, what kinds? Did I convert my grain to liquor to sell at the market?

What kind of food preservation did I do? What kind of sausages and ham did I make? Potted or canned meat? Canned or candied fruit, preserved vegetables? Would they have known about nixtamalization of corn?

Ice houses used for food storage were a technology that flourished for a while, can anyone point me towards more information on that?

1 Answers 2021-07-12

Girlfriends grandfather is in this photo taken decades ago. Eastern Europe is most likely the region. We don't know much about him. Wondering if anyone can identify the uniforms and help us figure out where this might have been taken?

https://i.imgur.com/sIMKpHn.jpg

2 Answers 2021-07-11

My father grew up in New York City in the 1960s, and tells stories about visiting a futuristic automatic cafeteria or “automat,” which was basically a room-sized vending machine for full cooked meals. What accounted for the rise and fall of the automat, and what was a typical meal like?

1 Answers 2021-07-11

Where was the Kriegsmarine on DDay?

1 Answers 2021-07-11

In translations of William of Malmesbury's "Gesta Regum Anglorum" the English of 1066 are described as being heavily tattooed. But what word or words does Malmesbury use in the original to describe the body art?

Given that the word "tattoo" is relatively modern, and the lack of plausible finds of tattooing equipment of the era, I'm wondering what the description of the tattoos given by Malmesbury in the original actually was? I'm struggling to find a (legible) non translation of Gesta Regum Anglorum".

1 Answers 2021-07-11

When did we start separating history and legends?

So I've recently heard that it's really hard to research ancient kings and heros because legends and history were written down together, as being one and the same thing, legendary characters and events being treated as if they were real and written into records of real events. When did this stop? When did we start writing down what happened for real separate from myths, legends and religion?

2 Answers 2021-07-11

How did conceptions of the Chinese tributary system differ between the political elite of China and those of the tributary states?

1 Answers 2021-07-11

616 / 7255

Back to start