Was it considered normal or morally accepted for a 37 year old man to marry a 14 year old girl in the mid 1800s?

2 Answers 2014-10-28

Did civilizations conquered by the Romans retain their culture?

Let's say that during the reign of Augustus, if I were to go to Gaul would the cities/people appear more Latin or Celtic? I know that Greek culture most certainly survived well into the late empire, but what about other cultures like Dacian, Celtic, Thracian etc.?

1 Answers 2014-10-28

Why is the song, "Entrance of the Gladiators" so commonly associated with the circus?

1 Answers 2014-10-28

Are there any other eras in which people used to dress up like (or even live like) other eras, other than their own at the time?

1 Answers 2014-10-28

What did the Native women and children in the colder areas of North America do in the winter?

2 Answers 2014-10-28

What happened to the Communist and Socialist monuments in East Germany after German Reunification?

2 Answers 2014-10-28

In light of Pope Francis's recent decree regarding evolution and the Big Bang, what are some other major papal decrees which affected the direction of the Catholic Church?

I know that there is the 20 year rule on this sub, but I was hoping to get some historical context of the significance of Pope Francis's decree stating that the theory of evolution and the Big Bang do not contradict religious dogma (article can be found here). The article mentions Pope Pius XII opening the door to this, so I was hoping to get more background on that as well as other examples which marked a complete shift in the way the Catholic Church interprets the Bible.

Another interesting aspect of Pope Francis's decree is that it pretty much directly contradicts the teachings of his predecessor. So I'm also curious as to other historical decisions by popes which were similarly contradictory to the teachings of the previous pope. Is such a contradiction a rarity amongst popes? And if so, what are some important historical examples of this.

Hopefully this question is still within the bounds of the rules of the sub. Just to clarify, I'm looking for some historical context in which to frame Pope Francis's declaration rather than a discussion about how important the decision will be for the Church moving forward.

Edit: After reading the response from /u/Domini_canes I figured I would rephrase my question. As others have pointed out, the "contradiction" has been a bit overstated by the article. However, I'm still interested in various shifts in policy that may have happened in the past which re-aligned the Church in any number of ways. What were some of the reasons behind the shift in policy? How did people react to those changes? Has there ever been an instance where a pope condemned a previous pope for effecting one of these shifts? Have there been any instances where a pope was the major reason behind why a shift in policy occurred?

While I understand the article may be a bit hyperbolic on the importance of this single event, those were the types of questions I began wondering about after reading the article. The two examples given by /u/Domini_canes were exactly the type of thing I was looking for, so if there's any confusion as to my original inquiry you can use his post as a bit of a guideline.

3 Answers 2014-10-28

To what extent can the problems in the Middle East be attributed to its colonial history from the last 100 or so years?

1 Answers 2014-10-28

How bureaucratic was the Byzantine Empire?

I often hear things referred to as Byzantine, especially in reference to tax codes. The dictionary definition described Byzantine as meaning "highly complex or intricate and occasionally devious".

What about the Byzantine government made it especially bureaucratic, in terms of its tax laws and otherwise? How do those things compare to other contemporary empires like the Holy Roman Empire? And if anyone knows, how does this compare to earlier tax systems under ancient empires like the Romans or Greeks?

1 Answers 2014-10-28

Looking for secondary sources on treatment of women in hospitals in early 20th century America

I'm doing a research project assessing the historical accuracy of the show Boardwalk Empire. One of the themes I will be looking at specifically is the status of women and in Boardwalk Empire there is much focus on a Catholic hospital that has quite backward views on pregnancy, prenatal care, birth control etc. I'm basically looking for some secondary sources, or indeed any primary source material people may have access to on this .

1 Answers 2014-10-28

Are there any sources giving the army compositions at the Battle of Clontarf?

1 Answers 2014-10-28

Can some one Help with my John Adams speech?

1 Answers 2014-10-28

Do Poles indentify as Germanic or Slavic?

2 Answers 2014-10-28

How was masturbation perceived throughout history. Today we hide it, was it always the case?

1 Answers 2014-10-28

What became of the prisoners, both Allied and Axis, after the battle of Stalingrad?

1 Answers 2014-10-28

When did certain fruits and vegetables, such as pumpkins, become associated with autumn?

1 Answers 2014-10-28

When did the "full breakfast" become prominent on the British Isles? Why didn't it become prominent on the continent?

3 Answers 2014-10-28

Lynchings in America

August 1930, Marion, IN two young African Americans were broken out of a jail, beaten, and hung outside the downtown courthouse. Author of the book A Lynching in the Heartland claims that this is "an ordinary place in time".

How accurate is his claim and how do we account for the fact that a crowd of Marion citizens, consisting of both men and women, committed these crimes?

Thank you guys so much! :)

2 Answers 2014-10-28

Food Historians on The Great British Bake Off

My wife and I are watching The Great British Bake Off and we have to ask....are there really food historians? If so what do they do? And how do you make a living as one?

It may seem a silly question but we are dying to know.

EDIT: Just to say thanks for the responses. This is exactly why people love AskHistorians.

2 Answers 2014-10-28

I'm kinda interested in the Middle East and how conflicts have arisen in it... maybe more informed members of reddit can help me understand better? I'm especially interested in how old issues have had an impact on the Middle East - hopefully this will be a meaningful discussion of some sort.

1 Answers 2014-10-28

Were places like New Jersey, New York, New South Wales, etc. so named because of a resemblance in climate/topography to Jersey, York, Wales, etc., or because the original settlers were from those regions of the British Isles?

6 Answers 2014-10-28

Tuesday Trivia | Primary Sources: Official Records

I love doing primary source themes, letters, maps, artifacts, audio/video, newspapers, and paintings and photographs, history is full of so many records. But until now all these Tuesday Trivia records have been missing something: that smell of bureaucracy, of sweaty underpaid clerks and iron gall ink, these haven’t been OFFICIAL documents.

So let’s get some red tape wrapped around these pillars of learning. Please share an interesting historical record made by a government or other official body, like entries from the census, laws, court cases, birth certificates, death certificates, baptismal certificates, marriage certificates, whatever.

As usual I’ll share a few websites you may find interesting:

  • Assyrian State Archives
  • Papyri.info, digitized papyri, not totally translated
  • UK Data Archive, requires an approved account, for something a little more casual try BBC Domesday Rebooted
  • Fedstats.gov, recently this thing moved I see, but this is the general clearinghouse website for all US statistical data made by the government. Mostly only reference librarians know about it as far as I can tell, so congrats, you’re now in on a major librarian secret. For unprocessed open datasets go to data.gov, and if you just want to cut to the meat of the matter go to census.gov for processed census information
  • US Codes, Statutes, Regulations, and Federal Case Law
  • IFES Election Guide, has results for past elections including total turnout of the population, like so, unfortunately only goes back to the late nineties so not valid under our 20-year rule, but I love this site so I thought some of you might get a kick out of it anyway.

4 Answers 2014-10-28

When did serial killers first appear?

I'm assuming it varies geographically and culturally, so multiple answers and the relevant context would be wonderful! Thanks.

1 Answers 2014-10-28

What happened to ethnic Romans after the collapse of the Western Roman Empire?

After the collapse of the Western Roman Empire, what became of the Roman citizens? Did they remain in Italy, or did they to some other places? Could we say that no "true" ethnic Romans exist today, and are just diluted with other ethnicities?

2 Answers 2014-10-28

How far back does the term "baby" for a romantic partner go?

When you think about it, it's a weird thing to call a someone you are having sex with. Or would like to be having sex with. Is it a fairly modern usage?

I would love to be shown early examples in poems, songs, etc. I'm mostly referring to the English language, but other languages would be interesting as well.

2 Answers 2014-10-28

6162 / 7255

Back to start