Why is the Qin Dynasty so influential to China despite only lasting 15 years

After the Warring States period lasted so long how on Earth did Qin Shi Huang manage to change the future of China despite holding on to victory for such a relatively short period of time. Why didn't Chinese civilization just re-collapse into smaller states again almost immediately and why did Liu Bang keep most of the reforms?

Also, is the timeline before Qin Shi Huang reliable in China? I'm having trouble working out where the mythological history and foundation stories end and the real history begins.

3 Answers 2014-10-22

How much would the average citizen of on of the East-African trading nations known about the world prior to European colonization?

How exposed to ideas from around the world would say, a trader or craftsman in say, Zanzibar, have been? How did these ideas shape the culture of East Africa?

1 Answers 2014-10-22

White Ship, 25 November 1120. Why people never bothered looking for the wreckage?

This article http://www.medievalists.net/2013/05/21/was-the-white-ship-disaster-mass-murder/ speaks of corpses being found on the shores after the wreckage, but none of them were Henry I's heir, William Adeling. The ship probably was loaded with riches from the wealth men on board, so I wonder why people never looked for them at the time. Plus, even though a long time has passed, is there any possibility there's still some wood, metal or anything like this belonging to the ship that could eventually be found and carbon dated?

1 Answers 2014-10-22

What are some examples of political compromise in American legislative history?

1 Answers 2014-10-22

What was West Germany's official policy on immigration/refugees from East Germany? Did they just take anyone and everyone who made it or did they deport some back?

2 Answers 2014-10-22

Why didn't the Sin-Tibetan languages gain any prominence in India?

Seeing as how India and China are close geographically and both boast vast ancient history why is it that their language hasn't had any direct influence on each other? Or has it and I'm not aware of it?

2 Answers 2014-10-22

In US dollars, how much damage was done to Germany, Japan, USSR, and the rest of Europe during WW2? How much did it cost to repair the damage and how long did it take before everything was up and functioning efficiently again?

1 Answers 2014-10-22

Where there any American slave owners who refused to let their slaves go following the civil war? What is the last recorded instance of American slavery?

Followup: I've heard of former slave owners who left the usa for places like Brazil where slavery was still legal-would any have taken their slaves with them?

1 Answers 2014-10-22

Why was the tomato considered poisonous, and were there any other foods that were considered poisonous, but was later discovered that they weren't?

I remember reading somewhere that the tomato was called a "Poison Apple" or "Poison Love Apple", and that there were some misconceptions about green apples.

2 Answers 2014-10-22

What are some of the most just wars (as carried out by both or either side) in the past 500 years? What factors played the greatest role in their initiation?

1 Answers 2014-10-22

I'm an undergrad: how do you find and utilize primary sources when you can't read the language?

1 Answers 2014-10-22

Why does Hokkaido have a much smaller population than Honshu, which is right next to it?

1 Answers 2014-10-22

During the days of letter writing, were there people with indistinguishable handwriting?

I am a historian, and reading 19th century/18th century handwriting can be the death of me.

This got me thinking, in the 18th/19th centuries, were there people who had awful handwriting that couldn't be deciphered by readers then?

I ask because I can read pretty much any modern english handwriting. Through proctoring tests and grading there is nothing I can't read. I suppose it is because I am used to it.

Back when, were there instances of people not being able to read each others handwriting and giving up or, because they were used to seeing the writing style, could usually decipher writing.

1 Answers 2014-10-21

When did battle flags go out of favor?

1 Answers 2014-10-21

How common was it for a peasant in medieval Europe to have met a person of a different race?

A friend and I were having this discussion of the probability that an average citizen of medieval Europe would have met a person of different race. He claims that it would be very common, as land trade routes from China and Egypt were very common. However, in my (rather shocking) defense, I talked about the "Human Museum" in Belgium in the 1800s which had Black People, suggesting that it was still rare for them to have seen one personally. To make it slightly more specific, let's consider the 1400s, and France/ HRE in our sample. Which of us would be right?

1 Answers 2014-10-21

Has the United States ever forcibly evicted or moved a population of people who were not Native Americans?

I was shocked today to learn about the expulsion of Eastern European Germans after World War II. Did the United States ever commit a similar atrocity?

3 Answers 2014-10-21

To what extent, if at all, where other countries aware of the USA's Project Manhattan?

Would Winston Churchill or any other of the Allie's leaders have been aware of the US's plans? What about the Axis powers?

2 Answers 2014-10-21

Follow up to a question I asked a year ago. If the Koran was not "translated" (interpreted) until fairly recent, and the writing of the Koran is archaic and difficult to interpret without specific knowledge of Arabic, how did anyone know what was actually in the Koran before the translations?

http://www.reddit.com/r/AskHistorians/comments/1kr9xu/i_have_read_that_the_koran_was_not_translated_and/

Especially 5-10 centuries after the Koran was written, when language evolved significantly from the time of authorship.

1 Answers 2014-10-21

in 1924 if you mentioned to someone (someone from the Anglo sphere) the words either “spaceship” or “space- alien” do you think it's likely (more than 50-50) that you would have had to explain the concept to them before going on?

3 Answers 2014-10-21

Which war/armed conflict was the most justly initiated, fought, and/or concluded?

1 Answers 2014-10-21

Why do Ultra Orthodox or Hassidic Jews dress in old timey clothing?

Also extra question: Why do mizrahi jewish temples have cool neon lights unlike the the ashkenazi ones

1 Answers 2014-10-21

Why were spikes in boxing boots an issue when kicking wasn't permitted?

I was reading the London prize ring rules which states.

'That in future no spikes be used in fighting boots except those authorized by the Pugilistic Benevolent Association, which shall not exceed three-eights of an inch from the sole of the boot, and shall not be less than one-eight of an inch broad at the point; and, it shall be in the power of the referee to alter, or file in any way he pleases, spikes which shall not accord with the above dimensions, even to filing them away altogether.'

2 Answers 2014-10-21

How would a medieval castle threaten an invading force?

I know that in the middle ages across much of Europe war consisted less of a series of battles as a series of sieges. Defenders were rarely keen on open battle unless forced or strongly in their favour.

It's a general assumption that castles had to be taken, or at least invested. Perhaps the answers are obvious, but my question is exactly why this had to be done?

Given that garrisons were generally fairly small compared to armies, what trouble would they cause if left behind? (Assumption here: how large were garrisons when reinforced in wartime?) How did a castle control the space around it? Purely by physical position (eg. right next to an important road or town)? Or by allowing a defender to project small forces to difficult places, disrupting lines of communication, etc.?

What examples do we have of castles and their garrisons causing problems for invaders after being bypassed or breaking out?

Related question: to what extent was the taking of castles symbolic, a sign of success rather than a more tangible military benefit?

1 Answers 2014-10-21

Was there any push for restoring the German monarchy after WWII? Did any of the actors involved in the drafting process of the West-German constitution consider it?

1 Answers 2014-10-21

How did the price of luxury goods, relative to average income, change over time?

This is a broad question, but I just want to get an overall feeling. Was the Orient Express price the same as Emirates first class ticket? Was the medieval spices the analog of modern lobster? The castle the same as a mansion overlooking NYC Central Park?

1 Answers 2014-10-21

6184 / 7255

Back to start