Why is Haiti so poor?

With regard to the 20 year rule, of course.

2 Answers 2014-07-07

Where did western music first get its specific pitches for notes?

It may not be western music, I'm not entirely sure. The point is though, I know a lot of global music does not rely on specific pitches, rather it's the interval that's important. In modern orchestral music though, everyone is tuned relative to i believe the piano's A3 key. While it's not always 440Hz, that's the intent.

When did they first use something like that? What was it? Is there a museum or something that has a 440hz tuning fork or similar like the metal meter bar?

1 Answers 2014-07-07

In Egyptian Mythology, how different is the average soul's journey through the underworld different from Ra's?

I've been doing some reading about Duat, and I found this website that lists the 12 gates and their guardians. However, it talks about what Ra did at each of them. Are these the same gates and guardians that average souls have to bypass?

1 Answers 2014-07-07

What is the historical evidence for the existence of Jesus of Nazareth?

Wikipedia says that there is a general consensus among historians that he existed, and so I was curious as to why this was so. What is the evidence for his existence? Other than the bible, that is.

I also wanted to know what historians thought about the bible and it's historical validity. Thanks.

1 Answers 2014-07-07

How accurate are The Baader Meinhof Complex, Carlos and Terror's Advocate? Book/film suggestions about political violence in Europe in the 70's.

I have been on a terrorism movie binge lately and would like to ask /AskHistorians about their thoughts about these movies. How to understand this phenomenon? Also, is there some truth to the thesis Christopher Hitchens defends in his review of The Baader Meinhof Complex, namely, that the most extreme of those terrorist groups, the Red Army Faction, the Japanese Red Army and the Red Brigades, emerged in the former Axis countries because the youth there felt a need to rebel against government the way their parents did not?

1 Answers 2014-07-07

How did Roman Civilians/Elite in Rome view their State's Oriental subjects?

How would Roman citizens have viewed Egyptians, or Syrians, or Palestinians or Anatolians? I ask these specifically because there exists a pretty deep seated rift between the Middle Eastern peoples and the West today, and frankly, that's all I have ever known. But towards the latter end of the Roman Empire, these lands had been a part of the Roman State for centuries. Rome even had an Arab Emperor at one point. So essentially, did Roman citizens view Egyptians and such as fellow Romans and equals, in the way citizens in a modern nation state do (in theory), or was there a degree of dissent towards accepting these peoples as 'true' Romans, and was there a marked difference between the regular civilians and elite in this regard?

1 Answers 2014-07-07

"People have gone to war for less" - What wars have been started over petty squabbles?

1 Answers 2014-07-07

What did Romans know about Rome?

That question in the title is a little simplistic and and pithy, but I'll expand on it:

Would a poor sheep herder in Gaul know the name of his emperor? Would he be able to list all the other Roman provinces? Would a farmer in Sicily be able to tell you where wars were being fought at any given time? Would a blacksmith in Syria know that Hadrian built a giant wall across Britannia? Could a kid in the city of Rome itself draw you a map of the empire?

When we learn about basic history of the Roman republic/empire, it's nearly all about the emperors, wars, rebellions, assassinations, land acquisition, and generally 'macro' level political dealings. That's understandable, since it lets you later contextualize the finer details. But I wonder, for all we know about it in hindsight, what the people of the empire actually knew, as it was happening.

(Hopefully this hasn't been answered 100 times before! I searched for similar queries and didn't find any).

Thanks!

1 Answers 2014-07-07

Why were Spanish conquistadors not plagued with Native American diseases?

Native American civilizations were drastically weakened by European diseases like smallpox that they had previously zero exposure to. Was there much of this going on in the other direction?

2 Answers 2014-07-07

Is it true that Manuel I Komnenos aided the Turks/worked against the crusaders, during the Second Crusade?

Here's the quote from the wiki article:

The main Western Christian source, Odo of Deuil, and Syriac Christian sources claim that the Byzantine emperor Manuel I Comnenus secretly hindered the crusaders' progress, particularly in Anatolia where he is alleged to have deliberately ordered Turks to attack them.

Is there any truth to this?

1 Answers 2014-07-07

How would one become a mercenary in high medieval Europe or the Islamic World? What would mercenaries do, besides fighting?

Did Christian mercenary companies every fight for Muslim rulers? Did Muslim companies ever fight for Christians?

Was it seen as shameful to fight for profit? Were mercenaries better-armed and better-trained than noble men-at-arms?

1 Answers 2014-07-07

Japan, Italy, and Germany have the three "oldest" populations. Did World War 2 have anything to do with this or is it just a coincidence?

In my Population Statistics class we learned that Japan, Italy, and Germany have the three oldest populations (A lot of old people, not as many young people, and declining populations). Does this have anything to do with either World War Two or its aftermath, or is this just a coincidence?

3 Answers 2014-07-07

In ancient societies that are traditionally nude, what was their answer to teenage spontaneous erection?

Looking at naturist brochures and a question that is asked over and over is "What do I do if the little comrade stands up"

So I wanted to find out what they used to do with the problem. Maybe there is some wisdom there.

2 Answers 2014-07-07

In the WWI Eastern Front was there a use of trenches as complex and extensive as in the Western Front ?

2 Answers 2014-07-07

Could the American Revolution have been avoided? Where would this nation be like if it was?

1 Answers 2014-07-07

Can anyone give me an example of a time when the speaker of the house and president were in opposing parties, but still worked together?

Im working on a project trying find historical examples of when the Speaker of the House and President of the United States were members of opposing parties, but still found common ground between party lines and worked together for compromise. Can anyone give me an example or quotes from either side expressing the importance of working together?

1 Answers 2014-07-07

When did western music become centered around the C major scale as opposed to the A minor scale?

When music was first discovered or invented or whatever, Am would have been the first scale, because the notes are: A, B, C, D, E, F, G. So when did people start thinking of Am's relative major, C as the "main scale" that music was centered around?

2 Answers 2014-07-07

Monday Mysteries: Solving the Mystery

The third-most-popular question ever posed on this subreddit asked what would happen if a dead body was found with evidence of foul play in the year of your specialty. While this is no longer suitable fare for a question - it breaks our rule against "in your time" questions - it is a perfect subject for our "Monday Mystery" feature.
Today, then we will be focused on the subject of "solving the mystery." How did famous detectives and investigators throughout history "crack the case?" What technological advances made their work possible?

1 Answers 2014-07-07

Medieval historians, what's your opinion on the HEMA revival movement?

HEMA stands for Historical European Martial Arts, as seen in /r/wma

2 Answers 2014-07-07

What was the communistic party like after the take over of China.

Hi,

The title of this question is a bit weird but I will elaborate here.

So, I just read The Last Manchu and I have a question about it. Near the end of the book, while he was being brainwased by the communists, it seemed like he was treated very well. For example with the treasure he had hidden which he, eventually, turned in. Later it turns out that the thought center boss guy already knew about it because other's snitched on Pu Yi and the boss guy probably also had common sense.

I don't know much about communism in the Soviet Union, but it seems that breathing in the wrong direction would already get you purged.

So, now my question. Is there a reason why Pu Yi was treated so well? Were other's also treated this well and given so many chances to change?

The obvious answer would be that he was an emperor so he got treated better because they had a plan for him. But in the end they actually used his brother as an official for the Manchu people.

One of the things I learned from the book is that the Chinese communists were pretty swell dudes, is this correct?

Thanks

1 Answers 2014-07-07

Did the First World War have any research/development projects comparable to those of the Second World War?

I mean this in the sense of something comparable to the Manhattan Project or the development of the V-2 rockets. Cheers.

2 Answers 2014-07-07

How does an old city modernize?

How does a densely populated, extremely old city become modern? By that I mean how does the city build roads suitable for cars, create a modern waste disposal system, lay down eletric lines, and so on.

Do these decisions have to be made at the governmen level, or can they happen organically?

Who loses out? Are the poor typically displaced during this process?

Obviously this is a big question, so I'd be interested in hearing about specific cities you are an expert in.

1 Answers 2014-07-07

The use of poison gas on troops in WW2

Why did the Germans not use poison gas against the Russian army, given that they regarded the Russians as subhuman, especially during the great retreat from 1943 onwards? Why did the USA not simply bomb Iwo Jima with poison gas which would have gone into the deep tunnel system and therefore have saved hundreds of America lives.

3 Answers 2014-07-07

Would a peasant from Paris and one from Regensburg understand each other in the year 700 CE? How far in the future would they have to travel to become the most diverse culturally and linguistically?

1 Answers 2014-07-07

Use of guns during the Latin American wars of independence

In his biography of Borges, Edwin Williamson notes that no guns were used in combat by either side during the Battle of Junín in 1824. Was this common in wars of this era, and what was the reason?

Edwin Williamson, Borges: A Life (2004) pp 3-4

1 Answers 2014-07-07

6550 / 7255

Back to start