How did the Ottoman Sultan exercise his powers as Caliph after the constitutions of 1876 and 1908?

Before the two constitutions, the Ottoman Sultan was an absolute monarch along with being the Caliph. With the constitutional monarchy in place, how exactly could the Ottoman Parliament stop the Sultan from exercising his powers as Caliph to overrule them?

1 Answers 2014-06-15

Were the early christian communities "egalitarian"?

So in Timothy Paul forbids female headship at the church of Ephesus, but are there historical records of women leading christian communities in the centuries prior to the Great Schism? I've been told that in the early church, while women sometimes were church leaders and organizers, they never consecrated bread and wine. Is it historically accurate? Were women within christian communities treated differently than they were in other societies from that time? B. Ehrman says that Mary Magdalene played an important role in the spreading of Christianity in the 1st century. Why, then, we never hear about "early church mothers"?

And regarding Paul's letter to Timothy: New Testament scholar N.T. Wright says that the prohibition of female leadership aimed to solve a specific problem regarding gnostic heresies and syncretism with pagan greek cults in the church of Ephesus. Wright seems to be respected within historians, so is that view consistent with historical evidence? I've done some research in this subreddit but couldn't find specific informations.

Thanks a lot for your time.

2 Answers 2014-06-15

Did Tiger drivers ever get overconfident?

As a veteran of both World of Tanks and War Thunder, popular online tank sims, as well as a fan of a certain class of 1960s WWII movie, it seems to me like the Panzer VI Tiger has quite the mythos about it. People in both games complain about its vulnerability (given that between the two, only one has a map which actually allows the Tiger to play to its historic strengths, this is hardly surprising,) and seem to be under the impression that it should utterly dominate the battlefield regardless of circumstances.

My question is, did this mythos exist in WWII? And did it extend to the German side? Do we know of any cases of Tiger crews "going rambo" and hurling themselves into the teeth of Allied tanks? As a corollary, did they ever have any success with this 'tactic'?

3 Answers 2014-06-15

Was there a change in the plurality of the US?

I remember learning somewhere that after the US Civil War (or perhaps the War of 1812) that people started saying "the United States is" instead of "the United States are" as a result of the new unity proven in the defense against secession (or the British). I haven't seen this factoid since though. Is there any truth to the statement, is it feelgood propaganda pushed by contemporary media or modern textbooks, or is it my own creation?

1 Answers 2014-06-15

How is it the French were able to conquer Vietnam and keep it as a colonial holding for so long?

My understanding is that they actually didn't have a very large occupation force, and were rather unprepared for the rebellion, and that the rebels capitalized on this by overwhelming the increasingly isolated French outposts over time, with the outcome of the Battle of Dien Bien Phu being the end result. Despite the lack of a real investment of forces that seems to indicate they managed to hold onto it from the mid-19th century until after World War II except for the Japanese occupation, though. Why is that?

1 Answers 2014-06-15

Who led the Viking conquests of the British Isles in 865, and who were the major Viking players?

Additional questions: Did the Angles and Saxons attempt to band together to stop the Vikings in any way? How did they react?

I know this is broad, but hopefully someone can help me out!

2 Answers 2014-06-15

Is Kate Adie's *Corsets to Camouflage; Women at War* a respected work?

Inspired to ask this question by a current top post about why Shirer's Rise and Fall of the Third Reich isn't highly regarded by historians. Adie is a BBC journalist who's beat is in conflicts. Does she fall to the same problems as Adie?

1 Answers 2014-06-15

How did British civilians react to losing the Revolutionary War? How did they take the news? How was it broken to them?

4 Answers 2014-06-15

in 1714 would the most common second language in Japan be Dutch, Chinese or something else?

2 Answers 2014-06-14

What else did people drink in "wild west" saloons?

In westerns, the only drink that I've ever seen anyone get in a bar is "whiskey". I can understand that they mightn't have had beer or wine readily available, but was there anything else on offer?

2 Answers 2014-06-14

when did it first become possible for normal Japanese to buy Japanese translations of English (as in written in the English language originally, not exclusively from England) novels?

1 Answers 2014-06-14

How did societies deal with incontinent children before the advent of the diaper?

1 Answers 2014-06-14

What was society in a uproar over in earlier generations that seem silly now these days?

2 Answers 2014-06-14

Resources on the Duchy of Burgundy

I have been interested in the history of the Low Countries for a long time, and have read nearly every source I can get my hands on that pertains to them. However, one of the periods I am having trouble finding sources is the Valois-Burgundian era.

Searching /r/AskHistorians has turned up rather sparse information, including this excellent post by /u/MootMute, but I wish to get my hands on something a bit more in-depth, and finding sources in English is proving to be a bit daunting. Is anyone able to recommend any books on this period?

1 Answers 2014-06-14

How much of an impact did the American Revolution have on France and French people and did it really influence the French revolution?

1 Answers 2014-06-14

End of British and American Enmity

in 1812, British and American troops were shooting at each other. (About) hundred years later America was supplying England with weapons to fight the Germans.

When did they kiss and make up? Was it a gradual thaw or was there some particular instance where things were patched up?

3 Answers 2014-06-14

would what Plato spoke be at all recognisable/intelligible to a modern Greek (like how medieval English is confusing but still very recognisably English) or would it just sound like a totally foreign language at this point?

1 Answers 2014-06-14

What was the nature of physical training for militaries in Napoleonic times?

I was recently watching "Surviving the Cut" about ranger school, sniper school and others, and I was wondering if it has always been that harsh for military training throughout modern times. I realize this may be a stupid question, obviously military training has never been easy, but have they always had to do such terrifying stunts as highrises, freezing water, dives, 22hr days with limited calories and sleep in order to weed out weaker men. Has it always been this way, or is this kind of hardcore training a new development.

P.S. I realize that what I am describing refers specifically to special forces, but the question still stands for basic Army training etc. Was it always as hard as it is?

P.P.S. Also let me know if it's actually easier today haha

1 Answers 2014-06-14

Did Jesus Laugh?

I recently went to a talk by Mary Beard, the Professor of Classics at Cambridge. In the course of her talk she mentioned that the subject of weather Jesus laughed or not was very controversial in the Early Church. Apparently this was because if Jesus laughed then he was human, and thus not fully God. As someone who is not well versed in the early church wranglings over the trinity, could someone with more knowledge explain to me what conclusion the early church fathers came to?

3 Answers 2014-06-14

How would ancient Egyptian people have slept?

My fiancee and I were watching Joseph and the Amazing Technicolour Dreamcoat and in the song where Joseph explains the Pharoah's dreams there is the line "...all these things you saw in your pyjamas..." when referring to his dreams. Which led us to wonder how it was that the Pharoah would have slept.

Would the Pharoah have slept in a bed? What would it be made out of? Would they have worn bedclothes? Would they have needed to sleep under blankets?

1 Answers 2014-06-14

What are the origins of the modern Police force?

When I say "modern police force", I mean a group of specialized individuals who work with the public enforcing day-to-day law and performing investigations within their municipality with the authority to detain individuals involved in crime.

For example, I've heard that the ancient Romans had something akin to a police force but not quite.

1 Answers 2014-06-14

What can you tell me about this photo?

My great-great grandfather is the man on the far right

What can you tell me about this photo? I know that my great-great grandfather came over to the US from Galicia in Eastern Europe before WWI, and owned a window cleaning business in New Jersey after getting scammed out of some land.

He also told his grandchildren that he rode with Buffalo Bill before he died. Is that possible, and could I verify it somehow?

EDIT: Done some more research, apparently he moved to the US from Austria-Hungary in 1902, and his wife came over in 1903. I know they lived in New York City for a while, and then moved to Scranton, PA in either 1907 or 1908. He does not have a military past that we know of, but he was involved in fundraising for war bonds during WWI.

2 Answers 2014-06-14

Where did the stereotype of people who wear glasses being "smart" or bookish arise from? Is there evidence that only scholarly or learned people had access to or demand for eyeglasses historically?

If so, did this tradition of glasses being available or in demand only by the scholarly also crop up in East Asia, as the stereotype of the "intelligent" or "nerdy" bespectacled man or woman also seems to have heavily pervaded those cultures as well. Or is this simply a modern bleed from Western culture?

2 Answers 2014-06-14

Were there any notable Indian loyalist in British controlled India during their various independence movements? If so, what were their plans for the future of the subcontinent?

1 Answers 2014-06-14

How accurate is the Romanticized telling of the American Civil War?

When taught about the American Civil War, we were told it was very "brother against brother" and generally clean and fair. How accurate is this viewpoint of the war? Were any massacres or inhumanities committed similar to the atrocities in other civil wars throughout the world (El Salvador, USSR, Afghanistan, Mexico)? Also, how much more complex was the civil war than simple fighting about slavery, were there further ethnic or political disputes, did these lead to any dehumanization that resulted in brutality? In short, how clean was the American civil war in comparison to those in other parts of the world?

1 Answers 2014-06-14

6624 / 7255

Back to start