Has there ever been a time period where social conservatives were "on the right side" of history?

5 Answers 2014-06-12

Theory Thursday | Academic/Professional History Free-for-All

Previous weeks!

This week, ending in June 12th, 2014:

Today's thread is for open discussion of:

  • History in the academy

  • Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries

  • Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application

  • Philosophy of history

  • And so on

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

2 Answers 2014-06-12

Key points of Augustan foreign policy?

I feel like i've been studying nothing but this all day and I still know nothing. My lecturer got a bit distracted and just read bits of the RES GESTAE and I feel like i've missed everything important to help me understand it properly. So, what are some key points or events that can help me ground my knowledge?

1 Answers 2014-06-12

Was there a Western European, Byzantian, or Arab/Muslim military writer similar to Sun Zu in the Medieval era?

I know there were several Greek and Roman military theorists, but there must have been medieval scholars who wrote military manuals for the then contemporary battlefield for the use of archers, cavalry, infantry and siege weapons. Can someone tell me who they might have been?

2 Answers 2014-06-12

What happened to Crassus' lost legion?

I've read people that say that some of the 10,000 captured ended up all the way in China after the Parthians captured them. That's a huge distance away from Roman proper, but it's doable. Do historians accept any of these claims of the lost legion ending up all the way in the Han?

1 Answers 2014-06-12

Could anyone give me any more information on this WW2 ink stamp?

My girlfriend has recently come back from a trip to Ukraine. She knows I'm into history and specifically WW2. The markets in Eastern Europe are an amazing place to find many interesting things, such as this stamp. This is a picture exactly the same as the stamp that she brought back.

I'm aware it is a Luftwaffe stamp/seal, but I don't know exactly what it would have been used for? It is quite worn and has clearly been used a lot. Any help would be much appreciated .

1 Answers 2014-06-12

How did the Islamic world react to Galileo and Copernicus?

How long did it take for their works to get published there, was it censored, were people persecuted for promoting their ideas?

And I guess if anyone wants to answer a more general question: In general, how long did it take for the books of the scientific revolution to get translated and published in places like the Ottoman empire, and were they accepted quickly, ignored or actively suppressed?

3 Answers 2014-06-12

How shameful was illegitimacy in 20th century interwar Britain?

My grandmother, or as I knew her Nana (b. 1919), was most likely illegitimate. While her parents lived together, we believe they were never actually married, as he had already had a wife and had never divorced her. Either that or he was a bigamist. Growing up working class in London, just how shameful was something like that.

1 Answers 2014-06-12

How did the lion, an African animal, come to be so prominent in Chinese art and sculpture?

2 Answers 2014-06-12

Could the Soviet Union have done anything differently that could have lead to either it still existing today or it 'winning' the cold war? If so what would the necessary sequence of events have to be?

1 Answers 2014-06-12

Did the Royal Navy build all its ships in Britain or were any of them built in the colonies?

Just wondering if all naval vessels had to sail around the world to get to where they were supposed to be based or were they produced there? Same for the navies of the other empires?

4 Answers 2014-06-12

Where did the ubiquitous tune of the police siren come from?

1 Answers 2014-06-12

I have heard before that the President used to be very accessible to the public, citizens could just walk up to the White House and knock and request to speak with the president. How truthful is this?

And what kinds of reasons did people go speak to the president about?

6 Answers 2014-06-12

Did people ever lived in forests like Tolkien's elves?

I mean could have Tolkien taken the idea from real life? How would a forest life look like? I don't mean fur hunters or charcoal makers or loggers, I mean a full economy, with agriculture and all, is that possible in the forest? (In Europe or North America mostly but other examples are also welcome.)

7 Answers 2014-06-12

Is it true that only about 1/3 of Americans supported the war against the British in 1775?

This article is floating around on /r/todayilearned. It doesn't cite a source, nor does it specify a scope (Does the population measured include slaves? Is it limited to land-owners?). So I'm curious, do any of you have any further details regarding the 1/3?

3 Answers 2014-06-12

Would 15th century doctors know what Acid Reflux was and what caused it?

1 Answers 2014-06-12

What were the major businesses/factories/corporations in Chicago in the 1920s?

I'm specifically looking at 1927, but general-era information is good too!

1 Answers 2014-06-12

Was there any chance of "WWI" not happening or was it a foregone conclusion and the assassination of Franz Ferdinand was the spark everyone was waiting for?

I don't want to get it what if, just wondering.

2 Answers 2014-06-12

What legend about Helen of Troy is Aristotle referencing in his Ethics?

Aristotle says in Nicomachean Ethics II.9, while discussing how we must be careful to stay in the path of virtue which is the mean between two vices:

And in everything we must beware above all of pleasure and its sources, for we are already biased in its favor when we come to judge it. Hence we must react to it as the elders reacted to Helen, and on each occasion repeat what they said; for if we do this, and send it off, we shall be less in error.

What legend about Helen (I assume it's Helen of Troy?) is he referencing here? Which city's elders is he speaking of, and what did they say when sending her away?

1 Answers 2014-06-12

Besides money, how did West Germany manage to recover after WWII?

Specifically, I am wondering because I was reading about Ethiopia and its Red Terror, as well as remembering China's Cultural Revolution, both of which significantly devastated each country's ability to compete economically and technologically.

Germany not only committed genocide against a large proportion of their population, nor were they spared when it came to wartime losses, and many people, particularly prominent scientists, emigrated before, during and after the war (to the best of my knowledge).

Was their recovery to what they are today to be expected (it would not seem as such, given talk about the "German miracle"), given that the Red Terror in Ethiopia and the cultural revolution in China are both more recent events neither may have fully recovered from, or did they somehow manage to avoid the worst?

I am asking besides money, because I am wondering how they made up for what must have been a huge loss of manpower, following genocide, turmoil before and after the war, and wartime losses.

If it was just the money, how was it capable of having such an impact and are there any lessons that could be learned from that?

I do not feel wikipedia gives me an adequate picture of how Germany was able to recover as quickly as it did.

Thank you in advance!

1 Answers 2014-06-12

What is the oldest known name?

In "The Man from Earth", the protagonist claims that his name has been "Jon" since prehistoric times. What is the oldest name, when did someone use it, where were they from, and how do we know of it?

1 Answers 2014-06-12

What does the statement "Don't Tread on Me" mean and how has that meaning changed over the many years that it has been used?

1 Answers 2014-06-12

What was the legal system like in Nazi Germany? What would the proceedings in your average civil case look like? I know the People's Court was notorious for its show trials, but was procedure more normalized for non-political cases?

1 Answers 2014-06-12

How did areas such as the United States, China, and India come to have such large populations compared to Europe and other areas?

I am specifically curious about how the United States managed to so grow so large so quickly in terms of population.

3 Answers 2014-06-12

Why did the StB (Czech secret police) fake the death of a student on Black Friday? Was there really no involvement on the part of the KGB or the FBI?

edit: The title should really say CIA not FBI

This is an event that has grabbed my interest in my reading about the Velvet Revolution. On November 17th, 1989 during rising tensions within the Czechoslovakia, the police forces beat demonstrators at Wenceslas Square. It was widely reported that a student named Martin Smid was killed. However, Smid was in reality an StB agent named Ludvig Zifèák who faked his death.

Zifèák later claimed that the KGB was behind the plot, but the Czech's official report claimed that there was no outside involvement. In any case, the stunt was apparently intended to oust Miroslav Štěpán, the hardliner Communist leader, and divide the opposition.

Needless to say, the plan backfired. My question is how could the StB have miscalculated so badly? Is the tactic more easily explained if there was in fact outside involvement?

1 Answers 2014-06-12

6632 / 7255

Back to start