During the Mongol invasion, did any rival Steppe tribes ally themselves with settled peoples against the Mongols?

Did tribes like the Cumans or Pecheneg every ally with non-nomadic cultures to better resist the Mongols?

2 Answers 2014-05-07

The atomic bombings of Hiroshima Nagasaki?

I was reading about World War II and the thing I didn't get was that no one seemed to be bothered by the bombings. I know that the bombing stopped the war and Japan surrendered and everything but do correct me if I'm wrong, but it almost seemed like an excuse to try just test the bombs and also some racism. I know that Japan bombed Pearl Harbor but the numbers of Hiroshima and Nagasaki are staggering. 100,000s of people killed and effects of the nuclear explosion for generations. I don't get it. Every other case of terrible history gets overblown but this. Please do correct me if I'm wrong but why does every site I go to act fascinated by it and not utterly disgusted. It's is almost as if this wouldn't be the case if they thought of them as people. And I'm not trying to hate or anything. I just wanted to know if there is an actual reason or I'm just exaggerating things. Why is this so?

3 Answers 2014-05-07

What is the historical reason for France's relative openness to sex, at least in comparison to other western nations? Has France always been this sexual?

Um wow. A lot of you are a bunch of nitpicking jerks. Would the question really of been that different had I included the word "PERCEIVED". If you don't have anything to contribute get out of this thread and r/askhistorians.

5 Answers 2014-05-07

r/AskHistorians recommends quality Movies

We all know the story too well. Some poor guy sees a summer blockbuster and thinks it's a 120 minute history lesson.

What movies, well-known or otherwise, would you recommend for being of high cinematic merit while remaining historically accurate?

This sub is a true reddit gem, and I wouldn't trust another with this kind of task. Cheers.

1 Answers 2014-05-07

How did public officials, in particular government officials such as Presidents, reach the public before modern communication technology was introduced, such as the radio or television? (USA preferentially)

1 Answers 2014-05-07

Question about the use of foraging by armies.

Specifically from the later Roman periods including the invasion of Britain.

How much of an impact would foraging be able to provide? If you have 1000 men to feed, would having units gather roots and berries and such make much of a difference? Obviously an army would need grains and animals with them before going far, but i have a hard time picturing someone saying "Great! A fruit tree! We're saved!"

1 Answers 2014-05-07

How common was illegitimate birth in medieval Western Europe? Was "bastardry" a significant social inhibitor across all levels of society?

5 Answers 2014-05-07

Was General George McClellan an inept commander, slightly treasonous, or simple too timid in personality?

I am about 3/4 through the Oxford History of the US (the Civil War era) as part of my project to read the complete series, and McPherson has thus far thoroughly pointed out McClellan's blatant refusal to decimate the Army of Northern Virginia when he had the opportunity (and orders from the President). Included are McClellan's letters to his wife, as well as to other people, and it almost seems as though he hoped to wait out the war by fighting as little as possible and then allowing the South to remain an independent country.

Honestly, he seems like a traitor.

3 Answers 2014-05-07

How Accurate is HBO's Band of Brothers?

I've watched Band of Brothers through a half dozen times, because I think it's great entertainment. I've "learned" a bit about WWII from watching it, but I want to know how accurate it is. There are a few dimensions of this:

  • Macro-level developments of the war
  • Mid-level developments of Easy Company
  • Uniforms, weapons, language...
  • Interpersonal relationships between and depictions of the real people

9 Answers 2014-05-07

I'm a captured son of a noble in Ancient Rome. What's my near future like?

Looking for some background information for a novel I'm putting together. I've found plenty of fictional information but Ancient Rome is my "Hazy" area and I would love some clarification.

The more details the better. Thank you!

3 Answers 2014-05-07

Are there examples of purely ethnic prejudice in the fifteenth century or earlier?

Was ethnicity ever a source of tension before European colonialism?

1 Answers 2014-05-07

How did Medieval Islamic Empires treat women?

I know that medieval islamic societies were much more 'enlightened', educated and open minded than they are in modern times. I am curious as to how this was reflected in their treatment of women.

2 Answers 2014-05-07

A question about the use of foraging by armies.

1 Answers 2014-05-07

Did the Christians in Roman times ever interpret the verse "Render unto Caesar" as a separation of religion from the state?

The famous verse is, "Render unto Caesar the things that are Caesar's, and unto God the things that are God's." Many modern writers have interpreted this passage from New Testament as a basis for secularism in modern era.

There are various, but here's one example from contemporary scholar, Bernard Lewis,

If the idea that religion and politics should be separated is relatively new, dating back a mere three hundred years, the idea that they are distinct dates back almost to the beginnings of Christianity. Christians are enjoined in their Scriptures to "render ... unto Caesar the things which are Caesar's and unto God the things which are God's." ... it has generally been interpreted as legitimizing a situation in which two institutions exist side by side, each with its own laws and chain of authority—one concerned with religion, called the Church, the other concerned with politics, called the State.

Here's also another one from Fustel de Coulanges' Ancient City. Interestingly, he contrasts Christianity with the Roman religion (relating it to Roman state worship),

Christ teaches that his kingdom is not of this world. He separates religion from government. Religion, being no longer of the earth, now interferes the least possible in terrestrial affairs. Christ adds, “Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar's, and to God the things that are God's.” It is the first time that God and the state are so clearly distinguished. ... But now Christ breaks the alliance which paganism and the empire wished to renew. He proclaims that religion is no longer the state, and that to obey Caesar is no longer the same thing as to obey God.

It is understood that secularism is a product of modern era. But, back in antiquity, was there any interpretation from Christians that see this verse similarly to modern writers? I'm particularly interested in knowing if there was any Christians who see this verse as a contrast between Roman religion and Christianity.

2 Answers 2014-05-07

Were there any notable cases that caused the public to distrust the "insanity defense"?

It's certainly a common literary trope by the mid-20th century that pleading insanity at trial is an easy way to avoid punishment for a serious crime: the idea seems to be you will be sentenced to a mental institution and then released swiftly once "cured". That's certainly not how legal insanity works these days, but is there a historical precedent for someone successfully and outrageously gaming the system in a infamous case that led to its ubiquitous literary use, or is its prevalence simply a literary device feeding on itself?

1 Answers 2014-05-07

So looking back, did OJ do it?

1 Answers 2014-05-07

How did the Nuremberg Laws segregate the Jewish population in Germany?

1 Answers 2014-05-07

What do we know about the origin of the poem regarding the three warlords of Sengoku era Japan?

For context this is the poem I am referring to:

Oda Nobunaga pounded the rice

Hideyoshi baked the cake

and Tokugawa ate it.

Was the poem intended to be critical of Tokugawa reaping the fruit of the efforts of the other two or was it supposed to be a very concise Tl;DR of the Sengoku era?

1 Answers 2014-05-07

What went on the day UNSC voted to join the Korean War (1950)?

I read that USSR was boycotting UN due to Communist China not being recognized and they were blindsided by the outbreak of the Korean War. Kim Il-sung asked Stalin's permission to launch offensive and was most likely sharing their plan with USSR. How could USSR be unaware that a UNSC vote was being taken on UN's intervention in Korea? When the vote was cast without them, did they protest? Did USSR intentionally let UN and thus US get involved in Korean war?

1 Answers 2014-05-07

How Did the US Decide on 1,5,10,20,50 and 100 for dollars?

Why and how did they end up with those numbers? Why 20 and not 25 like the coins?

2 Answers 2014-05-07

Are town mottos purely an American concept, or do they have root in earlier societies?

Most Americans here are probably familiar with the idea of city mottos: "Welcome to Xville, the capital of Y!" Of course there are many variants, from the brilliant to, well, Albuquerque's ("It's a Trip"). I know other cities across the world have nicknames (The City of Lights, etc.), but does the idea of an official town slogan originate in America?

1 Answers 2014-05-07

Wednesday What's New in History

Previous Weeks

This weekly feature is a place to discuss new developments in fields of history and archaeology. This can be newly discovered documents and archaeological sites, recent publications, documents that have just become publicly available through digitization or the opening of archives, and new theories and interpretations.

3 Answers 2014-05-07

Was the Soviet Union as bad as it is represented?

I am an Indian and the Indian stance on Russia and the former Soviet Union has always been a friendly one.

Thus when I started getting exposed to American media and American films,television shows and books I found it understandable that USSR was shown in,shall we say not a very popular light but strangely Socialism is shown as an evil. I found that quite odd.

Historians of reddit,Explain to me was Soviet Union actually that evil or is this,for the lack of better phrase, 'An American Propaganda'?

1 Answers 2014-05-07

American forces in Africa during WW2?

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7aVgHh_Hz8I&noredirect=1

So i just watched this game trailer where it mentions how the protagonist is an OSS agent and I would like to know if this had any actual basis in historical fact.

1 Answers 2014-05-07

What do typical symbols on family crests stand for?

1 Answers 2014-05-07

6771 / 7255

Back to start