What factors led to (why did the emperor order) the destruction of Zheng He's fleet, end of Chinese exploration, and continuation of Ming isolation in the 1400s?

1 Answers 2014-05-04

In Beyond Good and Evil, Nietzsche claims that after Plato's death, the only book found "under the pillow of his death bed" was something by Aristophanes. Is there any historical account of this, or is it pure metaphor?

1 Answers 2014-05-04

Alguien podria ayudarme a traducir estas oraciones de espanol o ingles a griego antiguo?

1 Answers 2014-05-04

Why did so many bombs not explode when they were dropped on Vietnam/Laos?

Every documentary I see talks about the huge number of unexploded bombs in Vietnam/Laos and how they are still taking lives today. How difficult is it to make a bomb explode?

3 Answers 2014-05-04

Can someone help me translating this sentences from English to ancient greek? Alguien me puede ayudar a traducir estas oraciones a griego antiguo?

I'm studying this article and I have a few to thing to do with ancient greek, I would like to have this translations. Ill atach the sentences in Spanish and english for the translation to greek. Thanks.

did you know ancient gree? will you help me translating this sentences? I can pay you threw paypal or something if you need to. I'll put the Spanish version and theEnglish version. I need it in ancient greek :/ Spoanish:

  1. Los heraldos anuncian la victoria con las trompetas
  2. La carne de los cuervos es buena para las zorras.
  3. La ciencia es un buen seguro.
  4. Los hombres justos no soportan la tiranía de los malvados.
  5. En el Olimpo de los griegos habían dioses y diosas, espíritus buenos y espíritus malos.
  6. Homero llama a Agamenón el pastor de los pueblos.
  7. En el puerto hay un santuario consagrado a las divinidades del mar.

English:

  1. The Heralds announce the victory with the trumpets
  2. The crows’ meat is good for the foxes (female foxes).
  3. The science is a good insurance.
  4. The righteous men do not support the tyranny of the evil men.
  5. In the Olympus of the Greeks had gods and goddesses, good spirits and bad spirits.
  6. Homer called Agamemnon shepherd of the people.
  7. At the port there is a sanctuary devoted to the gods of the sea.

2 Answers 2014-05-04

What were conditions like on WW1-era submarines?

1 Answers 2014-05-04

South African history - Bantu vs Khoisan conflics

Is there anyone here with knowledge/information on early South African history?

Most of what I can find relating to early cultural conflict in South Africa relates to the colonial invaders. However, I am more interested in the Bantu-speaking African invaders traveling South into the land of the Khoi and Khoisan, and what conflicts that invasion caused.

Was there a 'land-grab' or extensive conflicts when these cultures came across each other? How did it pan out?

1 Answers 2014-05-04

What question about history do you really wish someone would ask?

Welcome to another floating feature! This is a repeat of a question asked almost a year ago, but there’s more of us now, and those of us who are still around have had 11 months to sponge up new historical information, possibly without any chance to spill it all over someone, so we thought this would be a nice one to revisit.

So, what are you just dying to tell someone all about? It can be a question you’ve been tapping your toes waiting for here on the subreddit, or something you’d secretly love to yammer on about in real life. Whatever you’d like!

This thread is not the usual AskHistorians style. This is more of a discussion, and moderation will be gently relaxed for some well-mannered frivolity.

What is this “Floating feature” thing?

Readers here tend to like the open discussion threads and questions that allow a multitude of possible answers from people of all sorts of backgrounds and levels of expertise. The most popular thread in this subreddit's history, for example, was about questions you dread being asked at parties -- over 2000 comments, and most of them were very interesting!

So, we do want to make questions like this a more regular feature, but we also don't want to make them TOO common -- /r/AskHistorians is, and will remain, a subreddit dedicated to educated experts answering specific user-submitted questions. General discussion is good, but it isn't the primary point of the place.

With this in mind, from time to time, one of the moderators will post an open-ended question of this sort. It will be distinguished by the "Feature" flair to set it off from regular submissions, and the same relaxed moderation rules that prevail in the daily project posts will apply. We expect that anyone who wishes to contribute will do so politely and in good faith, but there is far more scope for general chat than there would be in a usual thread.

10 Answers 2014-05-04

Did exposure to religions of conquered states lead to converts in the home countries of European empires?

1 Answers 2014-05-04

How come Bali's population remained Hinduist while almost all the surrounding island's populations converted to Islam?

2 Answers 2014-05-04

How did 2 different populations of people with different languages communicate during their first contact?

1 Answers 2014-05-04

What do we know of Roman canals?

While rightly famous for their roads and aqueducts, how were the Romans at canal digging?

Is there evidence of Roman canals connecting rivers in Europe, or separating Britain from Caledonia (Scotland) north of Hadrian's Wall , or across an isthmus like at Corinth or the Crimea (Bosporan Kingdom)?

Could they have connected the Danube with the Rhine/Main allowing direct shipping from the North Sea to the Black Sea?

1 Answers 2014-05-04

How peripatetic were ancient and medieval monarchs?

Dear reddit historians,

I know that Charlemagne's court was peripatetic; He moved from one palace to another in his realm. I also have the general impression that many medieval European monarchs used to tour in their kingdoms to attend religious ceremonies, resolve disputes, and hear grievances.

In China, Qin Shi Huang toured in eastern China with his entourage multiple times. However, It seems to me that many Chinese emperors in later times just stayed in the palace and rarely left the capital. The emperors were often portrayed as distant and inaccessible to the common people.

My questions is in the title: how peripatetic were monarchs before modern era? How often do monarchs travel and tour around? Is being peripatetic an established form of governing in the Western tradition?

I thank you for your answers in advance.

2 Answers 2014-05-04

What was the punishment for working with witches? was it the same as punishment as being a witch? (Elizabethan Era)

Sources would be appreciated as I'm interested in this subject and want to learn more about it

1 Answers 2014-05-04

What impact did the Dred Scott ruling have on the collapse of unity between North and South and the ultimate recourse to Civil War?

The Dred Scott case was an interesting and complex one in and of itself (not least because of the involvement of Justice Taney, a wonderfully intriguing figure), but I'm most interested here in what part the ruling played in the deterioration - already well on its way I'm aware - in political and judicial cooperation between North and South and the ultimate decision to go to war. How did it exacerbate existing tensions? Did it bring anything new to the table? What impact, in any, did the politicisation of judicial and legal decisions in the Dred Scott and the slave court cases which preceded it have on increasing tensions and decreasing the likelihood of an amicable agreement being reached?

1 Answers 2014-05-04

Day of Reflection | April 28, 2014 - May 04, 2014

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Day of Reflection. Nobody can read everything that appears here each day, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

1 Answers 2014-05-04

Origin of Latin words

A lot of our words today have origins or roots in Latin. Is there any other language Latin drew from and if so how did we find out?

1 Answers 2014-05-04

Did humans eat meat regularly before they found out about fire?

This struck me while eating my beef this afternoon. How long have we been eathing meat? Raw meat isn't really easy to chew and it doesn't really taste that good, plus it has a lot higher chance to spread different types of diseases., so did we eat it even though it was raw before we found out that you can actually cook it?

2 Answers 2014-05-04

Why do PhD robes have three ermine stripes?

Follow up: are there any standards for hood colors? Or were they chosen by each institution?

1 Answers 2014-05-04

Whence does religious mythology originate?

I figured this would be a much more common question here, but I couldn't really find anything. By this, I don't mean religions which arose from other religions such as Christianity - rather, how did people come to believe in Odin, Mars, Ares, Shiva, Baal, and Yahweh? Could these have been tales of real people that came to be exaggerated over time? Were they initially conceived as stories which eventually came to be taken literally? Some of the complex relationships between Gods and religious characters seem unusually complex, and I could imagine that being the result of either cultural diffusion or actual stories being corrupted.

Which theories are generally accepted among historians, and which seem most reasonable to you?

2 Answers 2014-05-04

In american english Billion and Trillion means something different than in british english or even other languages. When and why did this happen?

Edit: To clarify i'm from Germany and here the system is a bit different.

Milliard or in german: Milliarde then Billionen has 12 zeroes. And seemingly the British also said Milliard.

3 Answers 2014-05-04

Why did the Allies land in Normandy? Surely there were other parts of the French coast that were less well defended?

5 Answers 2014-05-04

Why was the Antonine Wall abandoned so quickly in favour of Hadrian's?

It was only in service for 20 years (then briefly later under Septimius Severus, but still). What happened?

1 Answers 2014-05-04

Why is it that flying aces gain more recognition than other members of the armed forces?

I'm curious to why dogfight kills seem to matter more in public recognition than kills made by members of the other parts of the armed forces. Sure, men like Audie Murphy got fame for acts of heroism, but the word Red Baron seems more familiar than Audie Murphy and Simo Hayha (who has the world's largest count for sniper kills, using a scopeless rifle at that). Another question is, why are several flying aces of German nationality? And why don't guided missile kills matter in flying ace kills?

2 Answers 2014-05-04

What were the "Sides" of the Bosnian Civil War?

My AP Euro teacher is Bosnian and says he fought in the Bosnian Civil war of the latter 20th-century. I didn't want to ask him since that may dredge up bad memories for him.

Thanks in advance!

3 Answers 2014-05-04

6783 / 7255

Back to start