To what extent did Carthaginian mistakes have on Rome emerging victorious in the Punic Wars?

Hello /r/AskHistorians, for part of my college course I need to write a 4000 word Extended Essay so I chose to write it on the Punic Wars. I know this isn't a subreddit to be asking for help on homework/college work but I'm here to ask help on finding reliable primary and secondary sources on Punic Wars. I have already found a few myself (books/accounts by Polybius and Appian).

I would be very grateful if someone would be able to direct me to any more sources on the Punic Wars and/or if they are knowledgeable on said Wars what would be useful to write about.

1 Answers 2014-04-27

After taking the airfield and surrounding waters on Japanese controlled islands in WWII (like Peliliu) wouldn't it have been easier/less costly to simply siege the rest of the island rather than fight foot by foot?

I just finished watching The Pacific and this question kept coming up in my head. For most of the islands the US solders would land and take the island's airfield which was the most important reason for taking the island. While taking the airfields was costly it seemed like the most horrendous fighting came afterwards; the primarily infantry led 'eradication' of the remaining japanese deep in the island who were dug into amazing cave systems in horrible terrain.

What I don't understand is why the US forces couldn't advance just far enough to protect the air field, set up a very strong defensive line and basically just siege the Japanese until they starved. Once the US gained a foothold the Japanese armor and foot attacks seemed ineffective at breaking through a strong US perimeter and the casualty ratio was incredibly higher for the Japanese when the Japanese tried to rush US lines than vice versa. Once the US controlled the airfield the Japanese generally lost naval control of the area and any hope of resupply or air support and without those I don't see how they posed much of a threat anymore as long as they were kept bottled up.

So why did the US military have to make such costly offenses to take the rest of the island rather than just siege and slowly attrition them as they made their costly offensives into US territory or simply starved to death/ran out of ammunition? Am I underestimating how much of a threat the remaining Japanese soldiers on the island were? Would they really have been able to inflict more damage/casualties if the Americans had just played defensively once they took the airfield asset? I understand there would still be casualties in keeping them bottled up, but I find it hard to believe they would be anywhere close to the casualties suffered by going on the offensive and taking out bunker by bunker.

1 Answers 2014-04-27

Would the Greeks have known what monkeys were before Alexander's campaign in the east?

There's a bit in the 2004 Alexander movie where they imply the Greeks had never encountered monkeys before

1 Answers 2014-04-27

Question about racism in U.S. educational system

Hello /r/AskHistorians, this is my first time posting to this subreddit. I am here to ask for help with a research paper that I need to write for a college class. I know this is not the place to be asking for homework help. However, all I need help with is for someone who is familiar with the history of U.S. education to please direct me to some reliable sources which I will read an analyze, and then come here with the right questions. I have done some research but I am having trouble finding reliable sources (my research skills are not the best). So far, my actual questions would be:

How were blacks and Hispanics treated (policy wise) during the first half of the 20th century. My understanding is that Blacks were thought only capable of menial labor, and Hispanics were directed towards technical trades (car mechanics and such) and not allowed to go to university.

If someone could please direct me to the right sources I would greatly appreciate it.

I thank you all for taking the time to read this.

1 Answers 2014-04-27

Was the continental United States (or a good chunk of it) once solid forest?

I remember hearing a teacher back when I was in grade school saying something about the United States being either entirely forested from coast to coast or everything east of the Mississippi River was forest. I can't remember which was said (it was years and years ago).

I do remember him saying that it was through the westward movement of settlers, the trees were cut down and prairies were developed etc.

I never heard anything after that one time and I'm curious if there is any truth to it.

3 Answers 2014-04-27

How much percentage of the German Male population was lost by the end of world war 2? And how much did it affect the genetic demographic of Germany?

7 Answers 2014-04-27

Were there any differences in the quality, or features of segregated water fountains?

Inspired by this thread regarding water fountain segregation in the USA - I am wondering if placement, height, cleanliness, water quality, sun exposure on the side of the street, etc... were different between "white only" and "black only" water fountains.

1 Answers 2014-04-27

Are there any Persian sources detailing the events of the Greco-Persian Wars?

I was just studying for an exam for my Greek culture class, and realized that if Herodotus is the only historian who documented the events, not only does he often exaggerate, but he may be missing events that were more important on the Persian side of the war.

So are there any Persian writers who documented the events of the war? And how trustworthy would their accounts be?

1 Answers 2014-04-27

How and why did nicknames for currencies (e.g. 'buck' for USD and 'quid' for GBP) develop?

2 Answers 2014-04-27

If the Palace of Versailles was built now, how much would it cost? How long would it take?

1 Answers 2014-04-27

Are there any documented battles between Greek style Hoplite Armies (or something resembling them) and Roman javelin and sword type armies?

1 Answers 2014-04-27

What is an event that Canada has been involved in to promote global human rights between 1960 and 1990, and one event that is going on right now.

I need 2 different events for a timeline inbetween 1960 and 1990, and one recent event that has to do with Canada and promoting human rights.

Thanks!

2 Answers 2014-04-27

On a forum, a poster claimed today that all Palestinians were forced out of their country by the Israeli people at gunpoint. Is this true?

Was Palestinian land bought by the Israeli people, and did many Palestinians leave willingly, or was it all by force? This poster was saying that it was identical to the Trail of Tears.

3 Answers 2014-04-27

Why and when did it become customary for people to plant grass around their homes?

1 Answers 2014-04-27

What did pre-scientific people think of static electricity?

Especially the little zaps you sometimes get when touching certain objects or even people.

2 Answers 2014-04-27

How did people fight with scimitars?

Historically. How did someone engage in a duel wielding a scimitar? It's really hard to find an answer online about fencing techniques used with curved swords that isn't the fantastic whirling dervish technique.

1 Answers 2014-04-27

How did China's economy become so strong in such a (relatively) short period of time?

I was inspired to ask this here by the ELI5 thread about China's development. While the answers in the thread are certainly very interesting, I am curious to hear what historians and economists think about the causes of China's current position as the #2 economy in the world. Obviously, given the 20-year rule, this should be limited to pre-1994, but links to information beyond that would also be appreciated.

I am a complete novice at Chinese history and only today discovered who Deng Xiaoping is (thanks to the ELI5 thread) so I hope this question is not too obvious.

2 Answers 2014-04-27

What is the best Da Vinci biography?

I've been watching the showtime show, I know there is very little accuracy in it, but I've become pretty interested in him as a person and his life. What is best book that can teach me more about him?

1 Answers 2014-04-27

What happened to asian tribes that invaded Europe in particular the Huns and the Mongols after their conquest came to an end/was stopped? Can it be answered whether there are any significant genetic traces left of them visible in today's people appearance in Europe?

Their numbers must have been great to achieve all their victories, I'm curious how the aftermath of their invasion influenced today's demographics in Europe.

1 Answers 2014-04-27

What are some examples of "concentration camps" like those used in World War 2 and the Spanish American War?

I learned recently that Spain used 'reconcentration' camps during the war, and America had their own version of a camp in the Philippines. I'd like to know if others exist or have existed. Thank you.

1 Answers 2014-04-27

Are there any examples in history of very long-term secret strategies playing out successfully?

2 Answers 2014-04-27

Why did Inuit people decide to go and live in such harsh climates? Why would anyone migrate into a more hostile environment?

1 Answers 2014-04-27

Do we know whether our facial expressions have changed significantly in the last few hundred years?

If I rolled my eyes to Thomas Jefferson, would he know what I meant? What about the "give me a break" look? Sexy eyes?

1 Answers 2014-04-27

Did the Wright brothers and other early aviators understand the physics of flight?

I think without understanding Bernoulli's principle, wing design, etc. one could still manage to "discover" flight by experimentation. E.g. holding your hand out when traveling at speed you feel the effects of lift change as you change the angle of attack wind => your hand.

3 Answers 2014-04-27

In the Bible, Jesus tells his followers to sell their cloak to buy a sword if they didn't have one. Could a Jewish peasant just buy a sword like that?

From my understanding, around Jesus's time there was quite a bit of tension between the Jewish population in Judea and the Romans, thanks to uprisings and revolutions against the Romans by the Jews. So I imagine that the Romans would be a bit touchy about Jews arming themselves. Would Jesus's followers been able to buy swords so easily? Would they have had to visit the black market or something? And what kind of sword would they be able to buy?

2 Answers 2014-04-27

6810 / 7255

Back to start