Were there any benefits of the Vietnam War?

1 Answers 2014-04-20

When and why did acting become a respected career?

From what I understand, acting wasn't really considered a high-class line of work in the past.

A) Is this true?

B) When and why did the attitudes change?

And as a side question: Do we know of any notable actors from the Greek and Roman eras?

1 Answers 2014-04-20

Why are there no English language surnames with "of"?

For example "John of Smithton".

3 Answers 2014-04-20

Were Australian aborigines destroyed by European diseases in a manner similar to what happened in America?

I am basing this on the book 1491, which may or may not be a valid source. (It sure is a good read, though.)

If Australian aborigines were killed by European diseases, why don't we hear much about it? If they were not, why not? Dispersion?

1 Answers 2014-04-20

For how long did Philippe Petain want France to be fascist?

I was listening to Ray Harris' History of WW2 Podcast, and Philippe Petain came across to me as purposely subverting the French war effort against Germany.

For how long had he planned to be head of Vichy France? Did he have any journals, diaries, or correspondence that indicated a desire to do this before the surrender? Is there any evidence that he was, in fact, purposely trying to make France lose to the Nazis?

1 Answers 2014-04-20

Was Jesus black or middle eastern?

We all know he wasn't white, but I hear the black Christians say he was black and the Muslims say he was middle eastern (or "brown" whatever that means).

Bonus question: why do Christians celebrate Easter even though this holiday is not to be found in the Bible?

1 Answers 2014-04-20

In the pre-Reformation era, what did the congregation look like in major European cathedrals on a typical Sunday? Holidays? Who could use them for sacraments?

I've seen a number of pictures of beautiful European cathedrals today, including Paris' Notre Dame and Florence's Duomo. I was wondering who would realistically have had access to them in the era in which they were constructed. Could you find a fairly representative sample of the city there? Would it be restricted just to the nobles/elite? Were regular services different from major holidays? Could children of the poor be baptized in these buildings?

1 Answers 2014-04-20

Books about the American anarchist movement?

Ive read "Theres power in a union" which I thought was a great book. Any other suggestions?

3 Answers 2014-04-20

When did people start to use "x" to mean anonymous or not specified (as in the Sargent Madame X portrait)?

I know that illiterate people used to sign their names with an x, but how did that come about? And when/how did it become widely accepted as the placeholder symbol (e.g., x marks the location of the treasure chest, etc.)?

1 Answers 2014-04-20

What was the religion of Carthage like?

I would really apreciate having some more information than just the wikipage.

1 Answers 2014-04-20

Were the Mongols really the unstoppable force that they are so often portrait as? Were there any inherent weaknesses in the way the Mongols waged wars?

10 Answers 2014-04-20

What destroyed Mediterranean civilization in 1400 B.C. (roughly IIRC)?

2 Answers 2014-04-20

Why do English translations of ancient texts frequency use "thou" instead of "you"

Frequently when I see ancient texts translated from languages like Hebrew, personal pronouns are rendered as "thou" or "thy" or other archaic forms. It might make sense for some religious texts as their original translations might have been done when those pronouns were still in common use, but it still seems to be done every now and then. Why?

Edit: as an example "O Osiris, everything which is hateful in Unas hath been carried away for thee; for that which was uttered in his name of evil hath Thoth come, and he hath carried it away to Osiris. I have brought that which was spoken in the name of Unas of evil, and have placed it in the palm of thy hand. The SA shall not be separated from thee, and thou shalt not be separated from it." From pyramid texts translated by E. A. Wallis Budge [1909].

The formal/informal thing makes a lot of sense. We don't normally differentiate in modern English. What are some of your opinions about doing it for aesthetic purposes?

3 Answers 2014-04-20

Are the comparisons between the Philippine–American War and the Iraq War fair?

1 Answers 2014-04-20

How common was homosexuality in ancient Greece and Rome?

1 Answers 2014-04-20

Is it widely believed that a person called Jesus existed around the 0-30 AD period? What evidence do we have?

2 Answers 2014-04-20

Day of Reflection | April 14, 2014 - April 20, 2014

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Day of Reflection. Nobody can read everything that appears here each day, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

5 Answers 2014-04-20

What are the real historical origins of Easter eggs and bunnies?

A religious friend of mine posed this question on Facebook. I'd always believed what I thought was the commonly held notion that they came from "pagan" fertility traditions. But I don't actually know the full story.

Someone posted this article in response to my friend's Facebook post. The article seems to follow the "conclusions first, then find evidence" method common to Christian apologetics, and while it looks like it contains some poor methods, I don't actually know the real answer. I hope it might be a fun topical discussion for the day today...

2 Answers 2014-04-20

What's a good book that covers the history of China in broad strokes?

After reading the historical fiction book "Under Heaven" by Guy Gavriel Kay I've found myself interested in learning more about the history of China, and imperial history in particular.

So, AskHistorians, can you recommend a good introduction to Chinese history? Either a stand-alone book or a series.

I realise this is a massive topic covering thousands of years, but I'm not looking for something that's rigorously academic. More of a "pop history" sort of thing. Accessible, reliable, well-written and with a large scope.

A good example of the kind of thing I'm looking for would be the recent History of England series by Peter Ackroyd.

8 Answers 2014-04-20

What were the maintenance requirements for a 1st or 2nd rate ship of the line whilst at sea?

Specifically the late 1700s to early 1800s European ships. What were common duties performed by the maintenance crews at sea. Is there some recommended reading material on the types of tools and techniques used by the sailors to maintain a ship?

I realize this might be a broad question, so probably limit the maintenance duties to what would keep the ship in fighting shape (gun and deck maintenance etc...) , and not so much the privy/kitchen maintenance.

2 Answers 2014-04-20

Among the crimes and vices of Emperor Elagabalus, the Roman historian Cassius Dio also lists eating flamingo brains- what is the significance of that?

2 Answers 2014-04-20

Heracles similarity to gods?

My english is not so good, but i'll try. I'm interested if Heracles can be "realted" to somekind Greek gods. For example, Hephaestus and Heracles both hathed Hera but this wasn't their blame. Are there myths/cults/rithuals about Heracles that you can relate to other gods also? Does any of his 12 labors(?) maybe relate to some other similar myths?

1 Answers 2014-04-20

Did Spartan politicians use Thermopylae as Propaganda in the ensuing years?

As it says in the title!

2 Answers 2014-04-20

you know that story about the Saxons invading because Vortigern invited them. Is that story apocryphal because it kind of sounds too ....fantasy novel to be true?

2 Answers 2014-04-20

What ancient civilization did not practice religion or a set of beliefs and why?

To include mythology system or creation story in general.

1 Answers 2014-04-20

6842 / 7255

Back to start