In just about every WWII Pacific movie, the Japanese enagage in Banzai charges, only to be mowed down. How often was this tactic actually used, and was it ever truly effective?

1 Answers 2014-04-03

Why didn't King Charles VIII of France conquer all of Italy instead of just settling for Naples? It seems that the French could have easily made Italy their own.

2 Answers 2014-04-03

Bill O'Reilly's "Killing Lincoln" has been accused of inaccuracies. In general, how serious would these accusations be in regards to its credibility?

Like, are these minor nitpicks? Is it common for history books to be hit by this kind of criticism? Or are these flaws serious enough to damn the entire project?

1 Answers 2014-04-03

Ice Cream machines onboard US Naval Vessels

My late grandfather served onboard the USS Sablefish (SS-303) during the Korean War. He told me that they used to have an ice cream machine onboard that they were able to help themselves to whenever. They also used to mess with the other sailors by putting stuff inside the machine like socks (why? no idea.) I was just wondering how popular self-serve ice cream machines were amongst US and other world's naval fleets.

1 Answers 2014-04-03

Did the Red Army have a "full-invasion" kind of reputation during WWII? If so, how did it earn it?

I read that the Germans and the Japanese would rather surrender to the western powers than to the USSR. Is this because the Red Army had a reputation of "total annihilation" or treating the defeated really bad? Or "just" because they (the Axis powers) inflicted so much damage to them they were sure the russians would seek some kind of revenge?

1 Answers 2014-04-03

Is there something similar to a Kama Sutra in Renaissance Europe?

If there isn't a massive compendium or encyclopedia of sex during that period, is there something similar where a literary work or a series of sketches by an artist describes A LOT of sex?

1 Answers 2014-04-03

In the year 1900, what countries were regarded to be the next big economic superpowers of the 20th century? Was there a consensus on which one would be the next global leader? If not, what influenced their differing opinions?

2 Answers 2014-04-03

If another World War broke out, would there be another conscription? (UK)

1 Answers 2014-04-03

If Moldova gave autonomy to Transnistria and Gagauzia by voting, why why is it impossible for Hungarians in Romania to vote on autonomy about Szeklerland?

1 Answers 2014-04-03

How accurate is the depiction of battle tactics in the TV-show Vikings?

I am not necessarily wondering how accurate these tactics were for vikings themselves but whether any of them have been used at all during the Middle-Ages.

I am going to list down the tactics I can remember:

-Two forces pushing against each other with their shields. One side would, for an instant, lift up an archer so that the archer can shoot straight into the enemy line.

-Again two shield walls pushing against one another but then one side has a row of men take some steps back only to rush into the back of their comrades. This sudden push forward would break the formation of the enemy line.

  • Two shield walls again...For an instant, the shield wall would be opened up in a location so that some enemies which stumble forward will be engulfed.

1 Answers 2014-04-03

How were Atheists treated by Greek / Romans?

Sorry for not being specific.

I meant during the time frame " BC " when both worship old Gods like Zeus. During the "Classical Period"

6 Answers 2014-04-03

What public social services existed in the eighteenth century?

Did any states or cities provide taxpayer-based services for the destitute? I recognize that this is a broad question (are schools, firehouses and libraries social services?), but I'm trying to find out if any states provided for what we'd call a 'safety net' today. Or were all orphanariums and old folks' homes run by private charities and religious organizations? Anything similar run by the state?

2 Answers 2014-04-03

History of the Internet

I have a paper on the Internet and communication and information on the internet. I was wondering if anyone can break down the history, origins and original purpose of the internet as this will serve a crucial part of my paper. I do not want to miss any major points..

So far I have:

-ARPANET was a big player in research of the Internet

-Telecommunication networks didn't like the idea of the internet at first.

-Started with Packet Switching

Any additional information will be greatly appreciated.

Much Love,

LTBASEDDAWGG

4 Answers 2014-04-03

Why is Middle-Age mostly considered as an era where people were dirty and mostly unpleasant compared to the Roman Empire period?

Hey /r/AskHistorians! This is my first post here, please point out any flaws in it.

I wondered why Middle-Age is considered as an era where people were uneducated, dirty, gross, rude and obnoxious, whereas people in the Roman Empire (for example) are considered as clean, educated, intelligent for the most part. This stereotype (is it actually a stereotype?) appears a lot when the era is depicted in entertainment shows for example, at least where I live (France).

I hope my question is clear enough.

Thanks!

3 Answers 2014-04-03

Was the Soviet naval strategy of massed anti-ship missile attacks a legitimate threat to US carrier groups?

I was reading up on the Kirov-class battlecruisers and their complement of 20x SS-N-19 Shipwreck missiles. My understanding is that the Soviets couldn't compete in the carrier game, so they decided to focus on carrier-killers. Their anti-ship missiles seem to be extremely capable.

Was this strategy a legitimate threat to the US carrier groups? What were the plans to counteract the threat?

3 Answers 2014-04-03

WW2 Historians: Why are the differences in the Tiger I's wheelset configuration?

In some pictures such as these:

http://www.fprado.com/armorsite/Tiger1-2002-Picz/Tiger1-131-Bovington-2004.jpg http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/e/e2/Zhukov_at_the_Tiger_tank.jpg http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/2/27/Bundesarchiv_Bild_101I-299-1805-12,_Nordfrankreich,Panzer_VI(Tiger_I).jpg

The wheel arrangement has the wheels set so the frontmost roadwheel is exposed, the next recessed and so on so forth.

Whereas other pictures such as these:

http://www.worldwar2aces.com/tiger-tank/tiger-tank-images/tiger-tank-07.jpg http://www.worldwar2aces.com/tiger-tank/tiger-tank-images/tiger-tank-28.jpg

Have the wheel arrangement being recessed, exposed, recessed, exposed and so on.

Were there design modifications that changed the wheel arrangement or was it just due to field modifications or simply lack of wheel doctrine in manufacture or repair?

1 Answers 2014-04-03

Theory Thursday | Academic/Professional History Free-for-All

Previous weeks!

This week, ending in April 3rd, 2014:

Today's thread is for open discussion of:

  • History in the academy

  • Historiographical disputes, debates and rivalries

  • Implications of historical theory both abstractly and in application

  • Philosophy of history

  • And so on

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion only of matters like those above, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

6 Answers 2014-04-03

What Are The Cases of Diplomatic Gifts With Significant Magnitude and Longevity of Impact?

2 Answers 2014-04-03

Previous to the Hindenburg disaster, how optimistic was the future of airships for shipping and commuting?

When I hear that when the Empire State Building was finished in 1931 with an airship tether, was that seen at the time as a gimmick?

If I were a middle class New Yorker, what were my expectations? Would I be looking forward to realistically visiting Europe on vacation once every few years? Would I be looking forward to being able to visit my brother in New Jersey more often?

1 Answers 2014-04-03

To what degree was the Chinese People's Volunteer Army (Korean War) composed of ex-Nationalist troops?

My grandfather was a former member of the Chinese Nationalist armed forces. He used to talk about how terrible life was for both the Communist and Nationalist troops. One thing he mentioned about the Chinese Communist troops that intervened in the Korean War was that a significant portion of them were ex-KMT troops that had basically been forced into the PVA. He said that it was his impression that Mao wanted to get rid of these troops of uncertain loyalty in case of a US-backed KMT counterattack, and had been given the chance to do so in Korea, where many of these ex-KMT troops would be sent in first while more loyal, elite, Communist formations would be committed after saturating the UN positions.

I used to think there was at least some exaggeration in this, but I recently read that one reason why the ceasefire in Korea took a long time to negotiate was due to a significant amount of Chinese POWs wanting to be repatriated to Taiwan, not China. Do we have any idea as to how many ex-KMT troops were involved, and whether there was any truth to what my grandfather said?

2 Answers 2014-04-03

What is the historical precedent for not allowing soldiers to be armed on military bases?

I think this just barely qualifies under the 20 year rule. It appears that the U.S. policy was instituted in 1992 as a result of DoD Directive 5210.56, signed by Donald J. Atwood, Deputy Secretary of Defense, under George H.W. Bush, (Source: The Blaze.com) but there is widespread conflicting information about this online.

I was curious about the actual motivation for this directive and also about the historical precedent. (Not wearing swords in the company of the king type of thing).

1 Answers 2014-04-03

What is the history of the United States accepting so many refugees compared to the rest of the west?

Hi! I was doing some reading on South Korea and came across the claim that South Korea has only ever granted refugee status to 60 people (I assume excepting the fact that refugees from the north are granted citizenship automatically, I think). This led me to be curious about rates around the world, and though it's pretty sticky out there (since it's hard to find data on admitted refugees without also getting general data on asylum seekers), I came across the numbers of refugees in the United States and in Europe. Since 1980, the U.S. has admitted 2,671,511 total refugees, and I've seen government websites stating that over 3 million refugees live in the U.S. (which may include assylum seekers who have not yet been granted refugee status - the phrasing is non-specific). The article also states that the U.S. accepts more than half of those refugees resettled into a third country.

In comparison, there are only 1.5 million refugees living in the E.U., Norway, and Switzerland.

The E.U. overall has a high rejection rate and low acceptance rate (65% and 15%, respectively)

So what gives? Why and how does America accept so many refugees, and why does the rest of the west not even come close?

Before anyone says that this breaks the 10 year rule, I understand that it does in some ways. But I'm interested in the historical events that got us here, not in current policy. I assume it all starts in 1980 with the Refugee Act in the U.S. But what is the U.N.'s role in this, and why is the U.S. such a unique case in the west? This has been going on for over 30 years, as far as I can tell.

2 Answers 2014-04-03

Treaty Of Waitangi

I Would Like to Know a perspective of a Historians point of view of the Treaty Of Waitangi?

1 Answers 2014-04-03

How the hell did the Manhattan project succeed?

Question says the crux.. So many countries are still trying to merely replicate what the US did almost a century ago, this is technological breakthrough on a scale too impressive to imagine! What factors allowed this success to happen?

If someone can suggest one or toe books a layman can pick up to understand this event, that'd be awesome too!

2 Answers 2014-04-03

What type of ship would Theseus have had?

All I can find on wikipedia is that Plutarch says it had thirty oars, Google didn't turn up much either.

I am assuming a trireme would have been too big to have only thirty oars, and wikipedia's list of ancient vessels is mostly Egyptian and Roman.

So, what type of ship would Theseus have had?

1 Answers 2014-04-03

6905 / 7255

Back to start