Can WW1 and WW2 be seen as one single, huge war, with a 20 year ceasefire?

It seems as ww2 couldn't have happened without ww1. Can they be considered as one huge, seemingly never ending conflict that went on for over 30 years? (1914-1945)

2 Answers 2014-04-02

I have a somewhat different question from the usual one about the consequences of the destruction of the Library of Alexandria

Sorry for being sort of mysterious in the title, I couldn't find a way to phrase it in 300 characters that seemed elegant enough to make sense.

So basically there's a lot of rhetoric thrown around about how the destruction of the Library of Alexandria "set us back" by some amount of time, or resulted in the loss of ancient secrets that would have been important to know, or something like that. If you do a search in /r/AskHistorians you can find a lot of questions about these consequences and whether or not they were legit.

A recent comment in /r/BadHistory made me wonder, though, just when and how did people start being convinced that this was the case? In /u/Imxset21's words, where did the "muh lost knowledge" meme originate? Some comments in that thread suggest Edward Gibbon as a possible starting point but I'd be really surprised if he was the first to insist on it.

TL;DR: When and why did people first start claiming that the loss of the Library of Alexandria "set us back"?

5 Answers 2014-04-02

Assess Hitler's role in the Nazi state between 1933 and 1939.

1 Answers 2014-04-02

Did the idea of showers come about after indoor plumbing or before? What were people's thoughts on switching from taking baths to showers?

1 Answers 2014-04-02

Origin of the word "cuckhold"

In various books that I have read, mostly about English society, I come across the word/phrase "cuckhold" as in 'he was cuckholded". Anyone know the origin of this word/phrase?

1 Answers 2014-04-02

Did the NAACP have ties to communist Russia?

I'm reading Stephen Whitfield's "A Death in the Delta, The story of Emmett Till" right now and Whitfield states over and over again that the white southerners felt that the NAACP was funded by the Russians to help break down American society, he however does not state whether this was the case or not. I find it hard to believe that its true, but if it is, it sounds like it could be an interesting story. Whether it be small donations here and there or whatever.

1 Answers 2014-04-02

To what extent was Nazi Germany a totalitarian state?

1 Answers 2014-04-02

Why did the 1st Crusaders believe it was their duty to go on Crusade?

It's more understandable why the later Crusades took place as they felt they had to protect a holy land that had been created in the 1st Crusade, but what made the 1st Crusaders feel it was their duty to start it off?

1 Answers 2014-04-02

How long has "Spying" been a thing?

Do we have an oldest known example of spying in an official capacity?

1 Answers 2014-04-02

anyone know where the surname "zargol originated, and if related to vlad the imapler

All we have is family folk lore, no records only listings for zargos in the us. Was there an original this has bad been?

1 Answers 2014-04-02

How did the Rich store their wealth in the days before digital currency and modern banks?

Even up to the 19th century where banks did exist, wasn't this risky depositing a lot of money and to have only a written account? What if it was lost or the bank just claimed they 'lost it'? Before these times weren't these types of issues more prevalent? I mean where is the local noble supposed to keep it? In a box?

3 Answers 2014-04-02

How did Augustus maintain control of the army so well?

I understand that he demobilised it and paid out lots of money and settled veterans, but how did he deal with all those scattered armies left from the civil war? It seems like such a massive undertaking. How did he make sure there were no revolts? I understand he himself wasn't an especially great commander so did the loyalty come just from promises of money and land?

1 Answers 2014-04-02

Who came up with the name 'Reddit' and what does it mean?

1 Answers 2014-04-02

Did trans-oceanic trade occur before the discovery of America?

I was talking to a friend and he mentioned that some mummies were found that had traces of tabacco in their bodies. That would mean that long distance trade occurred long before the 15th century. Wikipedia seems to present some evidence.

If so, what was America called before discovery? By the natives and by the traders.

1 Answers 2014-04-02

Why did American Football move away from Rugby's form of tackling to a more head on collision style? Was there a paticular team/individual that dominated using this style and thus codified it?

1 Answers 2014-04-02

How did Hiroshima and Nagasaki recover into the cities they are today after the atomic bomb?

Pretty straightforward question as I always wondered how these cities recovered. If I recall correctly, there was literally nothing left after the atom bomb, but both cities are still thriving today. How did this come about and how did people get over the stigma of atomic radiation?

2 Answers 2014-04-02

If I was an average American citizen, either Northern or Southern, how strongly would I really feel about slavery in 1850's America?

2 Answers 2014-04-02

What exactly were the Opium Wars about?

I am fairly confused as to why the wars between Britain and the Qing Dynasty broke out. Was it simply a matter of China not wanting to trade with Britain? And a bit of a side question, but was all this Opium being used in Britain?

2 Answers 2014-04-02

What is the largest unit to ever disguise themselves as the enemy successfully for a military operation?

We have all seen movies where a handful of soldiers disguise themselves, and I read that during ww2 a group of german panzer tanks were disguised as usa wolverines (or hellcats?) but were captured. What was the largest group to disguise themselves as the enemy successfully?

2 Answers 2014-04-02

Why are so many historical battles so stupid in retrospect? Examples in text

2 Answers 2014-04-02

Why did Franco and his fascist Spain not join the Axis powers in World War 2?

1 Answers 2014-04-02

Carthage and child sacrifices

What's the consensus on this among historians? I read Carthage Must Be Destroyed by Richard Miles and he puts it down as Roman propaganda, but I've also read that he can be a bit biased. Is it the sort of thing we'll never know for sure or is it a well accepted idea that some dispute?

1 Answers 2014-04-02

What made post World War 2 Russia powerful?

I've been doing a lot of research for a term paper I'm writing on the Cold War, and one thing that's been coming up at lot is how Russia emerged from the Second World War as a leading power that was contending with the US. How is this the case? From what I know of WW2 Russia it was a shitshow: Russian infrastructure was awful (barely had functional roads and stuff), the Russian army was poor and ill equipped (soldiers were made to share rifles), and generally Russian people seemed to be poor. How is it that Russia came out of the war as a dominant power when nations like Great Britain, which had been globally dominant and had a vast prestigious empire, became middling powers?

Sorry if this is badly worded and informal by the way, I'm really tired right now and have been working all day :(

1 Answers 2014-04-02

The beginnings of the nuclear era

A history teacher of mine in high school gave us an interesting lecture about the development of nuclear weaponry and power once. There were to claims that I found really interesting, but have not been able to verify through my internet searches.

The first, was that there was the day after the trinity nuclear test there was a cryptic message sent to president truman that said something to the effect of: "Works better than we imagined;The hand of god has touched the earth". Did he just make that up?

Also, the idea that in the 40s scientists thought that nuclear power would make energy so cheap that the cost would essentially be negligible.

1 Answers 2014-04-02

How did last names develop in different countries around the world?

1 Answers 2014-04-02

6909 / 7255

Back to start