[META] Can there be a weekly thread for the TV show Drunk History?

For those who don't know, Drunk History is a TV show on Comedy Central in which fairly famous actors reenact the drunk narrations of historical events. Here's Comedy Centrals blurb about it:

"Drunk History is a weekly, half-hour series where historical reenactments by A-list talent are presented by inebriated storytellers. Based on the award-winning and wildly popular web series, the show follows the drunken and often incoherent narration of our nation's history. Host Derek Waters, along with an ever-changing cast of great actors and comedians, travels from town to town across the country, presenting the rich history that every city in this land, both great and small, has to offer. Booze helps bring out the truth of our nation's history. It's just that sometimes that truth involves hitting on airport bar janitors or eating cheese fries at 4 a.m."

I only recently started watching the show and I've become a huge fan from the few episode I've watched and would love to see a thread covering the history discussed in the new episodes.

The show appears to try to be as accurate as possible. However, because the narrators are drunk and only tell a abridged version of events, I think weekly threads would be great for non-historians to ask for elaborations, clarifications, or confirmations on the facts given on the show. Historians can also chime in to clarify facts they feel where misrepresented during the show.

The next season begins on Tuesday June 24th at 10pm

3 Answers 2014-03-19

To what extent is the cliche of early 20th century leaders standing around giant maps and plotting wartime strategy accurate?

2 Answers 2014-03-19

Have prisoners ever been used in medical research experiments in Britain?

Between 1930 and 1990

1 Answers 2014-03-19

Did written language ever predate agriculture/civilization?

1 Answers 2014-03-19

Modern Languages, when did they appear?

Take English, how far back would I able to go and understand English, or say German with a modern ear? Were languages still regional up until the time of say, radio? If I went back to the time of Alfred the Great what language was the common tongue?

2 Answers 2014-03-19

Hey ask historians, can you help me identify this Soviet Pin?

I don't mean to use you guys as a lookit service, but i'm sort of at a loss. Looking through some old Soviet pins, most probably from the cold war era, perhaps a little before that, when I came across this guy.

http://imgur.com/gsrUART,6fUnnS7

I'm no eurasian history scholar, but it looks like this could be a pin dealing with Russia - Ukrainian relations from a very different time, and in light of current events, I wanted to see if anyone could possibly identify the pins origins, or maybe even just translate the letters on top.

Thanks in advance!

2 Answers 2014-03-18

Religious visions and divine revelation - how seriously have Americans treated them?

I know that the Mormon church was founded after Joseph Smith claimed to have a vision sent from God, but this is the only American event that I know of that involved a specific religious vision. How seriously did Americans take these stories of divine revelation? Today we consider most people mentally ill if they start sharing these stories. Have Americans always been skeptical of the validity of a religious vision? If a person claimed to have had a religious vision, what would be the consequences? What were the most fertile periods for people claiming to have had religious visions?

1 Answers 2014-03-18

Did contract and tort law in the early US (say, before the civil war) promote the public interest or individual rights?

3 Answers 2014-03-18

Why were ancient explorers so brutal?

e.g. I was reading this article

http://www.filmsforaction.org/kolkata/news/fdi_in_retail_who_will_it_hurt_the_most/

As often happened in those times, the Portuguese attacked, looted and set fire to the town of Calicut. The Mappila community lost the spice trade — and a whole lot more — that they had carefully built over centuries to the invaders.

Why?

Couldn't the invaders have also made use of it? Even Genghis Khan or Mahmud Ghazni, other Muslim invaders into India e.g. Were they the consequence of one-sided aggression? Why did they decide to attack a totally peaceful colony?

In another sense, isn't it such a risky exercise? Is it just materialistic greed? If that is the case, how can European invaders be blamed for wipeout of Indigenous tribes in America and Australia? Isn't this a natural way of life?

In the same way, are we affording to much respect to smaller tribal settlements when we need to expand to satisfy the 'greed' of a technologically advanced populace?

It's a very vast question, but I believe the motivations are essentially connected.

1 Answers 2014-03-18

Question about the Catherine II Manifesto on annexation of Crimea peninsula

A recent article pointed out that Crimea should return to Turkey if it declared independence.

  • What were the circumstances surrounding this agreement?

  • If Turkey were to make a claim on Crimea today, why would it be/not be a legitimate claim?

  • If Crimea declared independence during the time of Catherine the Great, how did the Ottaman Empire plan to enforce the relevant portions of this agreement?

1 Answers 2014-03-18

What ever happened to Monophysitism, and why wasn't it an issue in the West?

Why aren't Christians still debating the nature of Christ, and why did this theological debate not cause schisms in the Western church like it did in the Byzantine Empire?

1 Answers 2014-03-18

What were the early depictions of Noah's Ark like? And how did it develop into the common design we see depicted today?

It seems to me that Noah's Ark when depicted via image has a distinct look: The big bulbous-looking boat with the door on the side and a 'house' on the deck seen here. Where did this depiction come from?

1 Answers 2014-03-18

Which depiction of medieval battle is more accurate: A mass of soldiers crashing against another mass, or lots of individual one-on-one fights?

Some films show a large formation of soldiers charging toward the enemy formation, and then the soldiers at the front fight while the ones behind can't even reach the enemy. Other films show hundreds of individual fights with two or three combatants who largely ignore what is happening around them.

So which is more accurate when compared to actual medieval battles? Or did it just differ depending on the situation / terrain / leadership?

2 Answers 2014-03-18

Is anybody aware of the treaty signed between the Ottoman Empire and the Russian Empire that gave the Ottomans the right to claim Crimea if it declares independence?

Over in in /r/worldnews there is an article reporting that this treaty exists.

http://www.reddit.com/r/worldnews/comments/20qpy7/turkey_under_ottoman_empire_treaty_with_catherine/

It gives no name, just that it was signed 230 years ago. If it exists, is it in anyway enforceable or is it merely a curiosity?

3 Answers 2014-03-18

What is the earliest historical event for which we know a precise date?

Relative to the modern calendar. For instance, do we know exactly when Caesar was killed? Is there anything from hundreds of years before then that we can put a precise date on?

To be clear, it's not enough to merely label the event with a date, because I understand there have been irregularities in the convention. I want to know what is the earliest significant date for which we could, in principle, count out exactly how many days ago it was from right now.

Does the answer change if we lower our precision to just the season and year?

(Edit: I feel silly for my Caesar example, as I just remembered the "ides of March". Still, has the calendar remained consistent over that time span to the point that we can figure out when it was?)

1 Answers 2014-03-18

Was the Progressive Era, specifically from 1900-1920, effective in bringing reform at the national level?

1 Answers 2014-03-18

Which of the II World wars had a greater impact?

1 Answers 2014-03-18

Borders of Ukraine before 1918

I was wondering whether Ukraine had distinct borders before 1918 and if it did not, how did the borders during the USSR period were determined

1 Answers 2014-03-18

Are there any old treaties/agreements that can still come into play today?

Like the Ottoman Empire treaty with Catherine the Great.

1 Answers 2014-03-18

When did the shift come from treating actors/musicians like lower class citizens to celebrities emerge?

1 Answers 2014-03-18

What is the most accepted theory on aftermath of Jesus' body?

Many different theories have been brought up on the aftermath of Jesus' body including the most famous resurrection story. For the historians that believe Jesus existed, what do you think happened to his body and what historical evidence do you have to support this? Is this theory held by most historians? If so, what theory is and why?

Also as a side question, what do historians think of books by apologists on this subject such as Lee Strobel's A Case For Christ (probably not the best example but I hear of it a lot from Christians)?

Edit: I honestly don't know the answer to this. People asked for information on the historical Jesus but not about the location of his body. I have no knowledge in this issue and want to learn. Please don't down vote so much. If this has been brought up, please post a link.

1 Answers 2014-03-18

What would films "really" have looked like when they were first produced in the 1940s/50s? How much of the blurring/specks are due to degradation over time, and not the technology itself?

I was watching an old film from 1955, a "What in the World" episode from the University of Pennsylvania's Museum of Archaeology and Anthropology (some of you may find it interesting!). I couldn't help but notice all the little "defects" in the image, such as the blurring, lack of contrast, specks, lines, etc. How many of those defects are due to the film itself deteriorating over time?

Additionally, has anyone replicated and used 1950s or 1940s filming equipment today? Does anyone know what those results looked like?

4 Answers 2014-03-18

Had the Allies captured Arnhem bridge, and the tanks managed to reach it in time, would the war realistically have been any shorter?

1 Answers 2014-03-18

What made the U.S and Israel such staunch allies?

2 Answers 2014-03-18

The so-called "Judeo-christian tradition"

Hi, I've been reading in christian apologetics texts about judeo- christian tradition of European and American culture. (Politicans also like to use it.) But the same apologicians (?) say that Christianity is so different from Judaism, mainly the idea of a Messiah, and also the Law and such. But today, we always hear about judeo-christian tradition. I would like to know when this term came to use and why. Is it because post-holocaust trauma, that we have to acknowledge Jews as part of European history, which to me seems pretty inadequate as the Jews were, and still are, just a minority among plenty other cultures. Or to what extent is this term justifiable? Thank you, and I'm very sorry for my bad english, which constrains me from stating my questions properly.

1 Answers 2014-03-18

6968 / 7255

Back to start