When the U.N. Security Council was formed, were there any consideration as to what would happen if a permanent member is the aggressor in a conflict?

1 Answers 2014-03-15

When and why did Carthage become Tunis?

I don't really have anything to say here.lol

1 Answers 2014-03-15

Was Abraham Lincoln a racist?

This question might be seen as stupid, but from what I've occasionally heard was that Abraham Lincoln, prior to his involvement in abolishing slavery, was pretty openly racist towards blacks and other minorities. I've researched this and have found some supposed quotes from Abraham Lincoln that would back this claim up, although they weren't from the most credible sources. Can some of you help me out on this one (please cite your sources as well)?

1 Answers 2014-03-14

How could D-Day ever work if the allied stumbled upon so many fortresses build into the beach?

Hi everyone,

I'm watching Saving Private Ryan and I was wondering how the soldiers that entered the beach on D-Day survived it. The way the film portrays it is that there were a lot of bunkers and machine guns firing. Now I know of my history lessons that that's true, they build bunkers on the beach.

But how could the allied win if they were being gunned down everywhere? Was it that there were so many soldiers that the ammo ran out of the Germans or were there other advantages to the allied forces.

I searched about it on /r/AskHistorians but I couldn't find this question or one that looked alike it. If it's already been asked, sorry for posting this one.

Cheers!

5 Answers 2014-03-14

Did the Incan Empire operate under a fully-fledged ideology?

I'm highly interested in Andean civilizations and I'm currently doing research for a paper on the Incan Empire. I've picked up The Last Days of the Incas by Kim MacQuarrie and have only just begun reading that, so forgive me if the information I'm after is contained somewhere therein.

The paper is focused on the philosophy the Inca state governed it's people by at it's height. I'm investigation whether or not it was developed enough (or enough information has survived) for it to be defined as an ideology in the same sense as Liberalism or Socialism.

The definition of ideology I am working with is a conception of human nature that gives a guideline for political action based on that conception. Ideally, it would touch on politics, social organization and economics and be articulated formally in some way. I'm aware the empire had no written language though they did have quipus, which I understand were used for administrative or military bookkeeping. Is it possible an ideology or sort of 'Inca Charter' could have been recorded in these somehow? Any information about it is valuable to me.

I'm also aware of the Chakana and it's supposed significance in the three affirmations, but couldn't find anything solid to that effect.

1 Answers 2014-03-14

What were the largest problems facing Ireland after the Potato Famine?

1 Answers 2014-03-14

Have there been many (any?) helo to helo dogfights?

1 Answers 2014-03-14

In *A Clash of Kings*, several knights arrange for a set of stocks to be made so men could "use" them at any time. Are there any documented cases of this happening in real life?

1 Answers 2014-03-14

Where did all the Germanic tribes come from? Before they entered the Roman Empire?

All I know about germanic tribes is that they start entering the roman empire in the first few centuries AD, but what about before then? How long had they been in Europe and how far back can signs of gemanic culutres be traced?

1 Answers 2014-03-14

How would a historical sailing ship dock at a quay?

My understanding is that ships in the age of sail (17th - early 19th Centuries) were fairly limited on what points of sail they could travel, and fairly un-maneuverable in any case: this seems like it would make it hard to sail into a lot of harbours and dock.

On top of this, once they were in the harbour, without tugboats like modern ships, how would they do they maneuver in the potentially crowded and shallow water, and then pull up alongside the quay. would there be tow boats, would they kedge into the harbour or is there some other cool technique i'm missing?

or have I got it wrong and ships would usually just anchor in the harbour, and transfer the cargo ashore in smaller craft?

1 Answers 2014-03-14

[Meta] Two things I've seen on other subreddits that I think would be great here

So I've been thinking about these for a while, and today I decided the time had come to go ahead and suggest them.

First of all, I'd like to see a system of attaching flair to specific questions, like they have in /r/askscience. Doing so would be useful for keeping the board organized and making it easy for contributors to find questions they can best provide answers for, as well as allowing all users to easily find out if their question has recently been answered, as well find related questions that might also interest them.

Second, I suggest nominations begin for a Post of the Week, after the fashion of /r/DaystromInstitute. This would allow the community to highlight particularly insightful or interesting discussions, as well as show off some of the best we have to offer here.

It is my sincere belief that implementing either of these would serve our continuing goal of making discussion on this subreddit the best and most informative that it can be.

3 Answers 2014-03-14

Do we know anything about naval trade or naval technology in the Pre-Columbian Caribbean/Gulf of Mexico?

Did the Aztecs, Mayans or Caribbean people have any naval activity more ambitious than fishing boats? Did the Central American empires conduct trade with the Islanders or with the people living in what is now the US gulf coast? Do we know what their boats looked like? Do we know if voyages across islands or to/from the mainland would have been exceptional, one off ventures or routine trips?

1 Answers 2014-03-14

Did Jack Churchill really kill a man with a longbow during WWII?

According to this thread he did, but I can't find any information about the actual event.

2 Answers 2014-03-14

Questions about Gibraltar!

How did the British come to control Gibraltar?

How important was Gibraltar to the British empire?

Did Gibraltar ever begin to decline in strategic importance?

Did the British ever come close to losing Gibraltar in a war?

3 Answers 2014-03-14

Back around 1930, who did the public and media compare Hitler with?

What was being said about Hitler by the German media and public when his name was just getting known? How about the other Europeans countries? England, France, Italy, Spain, Netherlands, Belgium. The media in that time ... before anybody knew what Hitler was about but his name was getting known. How did people write about him? And more importantly ... when Hitler became a controversial person (I guess years before 1939) ... who was Hitler compared with?

2 Answers 2014-03-14

How powerful was the senate in Rome?

follow up question:

If compared to modern politics how powerful would they be?

3 Answers 2014-03-14

Was the Black Rock in LOST a real slave ship?

1 Answers 2014-03-14

What was the scientific and cultural legacy of Achaemenid Persia?

We seem to know a lot about Greek contributions to philosophy, art and science but with the vast Persian empire existing concurrently, is there any mark they similarly left upon our culture?

1 Answers 2014-03-14

How many days/weeks would it take for the Vikings to sail and row to Britain?

3 Answers 2014-03-14

How did Cadillac become (for a time) the premiere American luxury automobile?

1 Answers 2014-03-14

The value of objects hundreds of years ago adjusted to modern currencies.

1 Answers 2014-03-14

What are some of the happiest moments in history?

“Floating Features” ride again! And it’s a sunny Friday afternoon (in this part of America anyway) so let’s get happy. The question of the day comes to us from /u/gordonz88 and is simply What are some of the happiest moments in history? Please share a happy bit of history!

This thread is not the usual AskHistorians style. This is more of a discussion, and moderation will be relaxed for some well-mannered frivolity.

What is this “Floating feature” thing?

Readers here tend to like the open discussion threads and questions that allow a multitude of possible answers from people of all sorts of backgrounds and levels of expertise. The most popular thread in this subreddit's history, for example, was about questions you dread being asked at parties -- over 2000 comments, and most of them were very interesting!

So, we do want to make questions like this a more regular feature, but we also don't want to make them TOO common -- /r/AskHistorians is, and will remain, a subreddit dedicated to educated experts answering specific user-submitted questions. General discussion is good, but it isn't the primary point of the place.

With this in mind, from time to time, one of the moderators will post an open-ended question of this sort. It will be distinguished by the "Feature" flair to set it off from regular submissions, and the same relaxed moderation rules that prevail in the daily project posts will apply. We expect that anyone who wishes to contribute will do so politely and in good faith, but there is far more scope for speculation and general chat than there would be in a usual thread.

18 Answers 2014-03-14

What happened to the Republicans after Franco's victory in 1939 and have they had any influence in Spain from 1939-1975?

I read a bit about the Spanish Maquis on wikipedia, but I find somehow hard to comprehend how strong those Anti-Franco-troops were, how they became guerilla forces or fled to France.

Was the Franco regime and its control over the population and the approach against Republican ideas after the civil war comparable to the actions of the Nazi-regime against democratic and communist people in Germany?

1 Answers 2014-03-14

How did belief in a flat Earth affect cartography?

With my rudimentary knowledge of land navigation, I know that north on a map, magnetic north, and true north are often a few degrees different - enough to get you lost if you're traveling long distances. I understand this to be caused by the curve of the planet and the actual location of the magnetic poles, but if I believed the earth was flat, wouldn't I get lost a lot?

2 Answers 2014-03-14

Foot, cubit, chi - why are these similar?

I was browsing Wikipedia to find out how long a Chinese 'chi' was, and it turned out to be 0.3-ish metres. 'Hmmm,' I thought, 'that's roughly the length of a foot!' So, then I found out that a cubit was in the same ballpark as a foot (and uses the same derivation as a chi - the length of a human forearm). Now, from what I understand, the modern foot is actually derived from an Anglo-Saxon measurement that was larger than the Roman foot.

So: Why are all these figures in the same ballpark? I get that a cubit and a chi would be similar, being based off of the same body part (albeit with regional differences), but why is a foot in the same ballpark too?

1 Answers 2014-03-14

6984 / 7255

Back to start