What "little things" do period movies get wrong?

1 Answers 2014-03-02

When tourism in the modern sense begin? Has it always been common for people to go on 'vacations'?

6 Answers 2014-03-02

What language is more similar to Old Norse?

What language of the Scandinavian countries

(Sweden, Denmark (and Greenland), Norway, Iceland, maybe Finland)

is more similar to the Old Norse?

Not in writing (I'm pretty sure they used another alphabet), but in pronunciation and similar speech.

4 Answers 2014-03-02

I am a German citizen in 1942 and have been conscripted. What are my chances of survival?

I've been watching the movie "The Book Thief" and this question came across my mind after seeing a German woman crying when her husband was conscripted into the German army. I was wondering what his average chances to come home were, maybe even unharmed / wounded.

It seems like an obvious question to be asked here, so I've searched for a similar one, haven't found any. Reddit's search isn't too good, so please point me in the right direction if you remember a similar question asked.

2 Answers 2014-03-02

How different would Wales be today if Owain Glyndwr's guerrilla campaign against the English had been successful?

1 Answers 2014-03-02

The notion of "king" is a European concept, but what about King David? How was his position, power and role different from what westerners would understand as a king? How have western concepts distorted our undertaking of his rein and the ancient Judean state?

EDIT: So I read something in another thread and while it seemed off, I thought I might have learned something new. I got to thinking that maybe things were more complicated and interesting than I had always assumed, and since there are smart people on this sub respectful of those curious to learn I would ask about it from an angle that connected to other interests of mine--Biblical history. It seems that I misread the idea in the other sub, and I have been set straight. Things were as I had thought before. Pardon me for asking an honest, if mistaken question. Thanks to those who took the time to answer me with respect.

9 Answers 2014-03-02

Why didn't ship crews fish when lost?

I was listening to a Dan Carlin podcast, "Globalization unto Death" and he brought up an interesting point. When crews are starving, they talk about how they eat their shoes, rats, and horses but they don't try to fish. Why is that? Did they not have the nets necessary to do so? If so, did it just not occur to them or is there some logistical problem I'm not considering?

2 Answers 2014-03-02

What is a good book to read that talks about the Visigoth kingdom at the time when Toulouse was its capital ?

1 Answers 2014-03-02

Is there any record of what ancient cultures thought was happening when they created a sourdough starter?

I've always been kind of fascinated by the way ancient cultures were able to create leavened bread when it seems like culturing wild yeast is a non-obvious thing to do, particularly for a society that predates knowledge of of microorganisms. Did they have any explanation for why a sourdough starter worked? Would they have thought it was a supernatural process?

1 Answers 2014-03-02

Why is an understanding of the state of nature important to constructing strong political institutions/governments?

I am reading Machiavelli, Hobbes and Locke and just wondering why you guys think they thought it was so important to study the state of nature?

1 Answers 2014-03-02

What religion/ethnic group originally used something resembling marriage?

Most of the articles I read said that it predates recorded history, but they failed to mention what is the earliest mention of such a thing.

1 Answers 2014-03-02

I'm hoping /r/AskHistorians could help me identify what era this Soviet uniform I bought today is from. Pictures inside!

So I bought a Soviet uniform today at a flea market. I was hoping you guys could tell me how old it is and if its authentic I guess, or point me to the right subreddit because I wasn't sure where to post this. I'm not worried about how much its worth, unless its really worth something, but I assume it isn't. I am thinking that it is from the WWII era, thought I have nothing to back that up with. All of the tags are in Russian and it is a heavy material so it doesn't seem to be a costume but maybe I'm wrong. That being said, it does appear to be in really good shape for something that would be roughly 70+ years old. So the condition and also one the tags made me doubt how old it is. Please help me guys! Here are the pictures: http://imgur.com/a/lcxHF

3 Answers 2014-03-02

Who here is familiar with Farfarers by Farley Mowat? Does it belong in the same category as Gavin Menzies' books?

It certainly seems far-fetched along the same lines, but I'm not familiar enough with the era or area to be sure.

http://www.goodreads.com/book/show/74168.The_Farfarers

1 Answers 2014-03-02

Where were SS/Nazi soldiers buried and with what kind of honors?

Inspired by this album: http://m.imgur.com/a/tOdXE

My question to you is are SS soldiers (of Germany) buried in there as well? Also are their graves treated similarly to USA's Arlington? (sorry. Only example I know)

2 Answers 2014-03-02

As someone with next-to-no knowledge of early European history, what text would you recommend to get my feet wet?

I'm planning on picking up Maurice Druon's Accursed King's series, detailing the demise of the Capetian Dynasty, and realized I don't quite know a lot of early European history. I have a deep love for history, but was mostly taught American history throughout high school. What are some of early Europe's best stories and historical figures to learn about, and what texts (novels or otherwise) would you recommend to learn from?

1 Answers 2014-03-02

If President Kennedy was not assassinated would we have gone as deep into the Vietnam war as Johnson took us?

1 Answers 2014-03-02

So the Gulf War in 1990-91 began when Iraq invaded tiny neighbor Kuwait, but why did the UN, Nato, and the US feel they needed to respond with a full deployment there?

I just listened to a great podcast about Colin Powell, and it covered the Gulf War in basic detail, but then I started thinking: why did the West care about Kuwait? What was so important about that nation... was it militarily strategic? Was it economically important? Did the West respond to set a precedent of protecting the sovereignty of nations?

3 Answers 2014-03-02

What were the major causes and strategic tensions that led to the Crimean War? (1853-1856)

The relevance of this question is obvious, but I am interested in the opinions of those with some expertise in the period concerned as well as further reading beyond Wikipedia and the like. Why did Nicholas need a Black Sea fleet? Was the religious question simply a cover for a larger Russian strategic vision of the time (akin to the Great Game), and if so what was that strategic vision? Is there a Pan-Slav nationalist component to Russian action, or does that only develop in the later half of the 19th century? Any guidance would be greatly appreciated!

EDIT: For clarity, I am not necessarily asking why Russia needs warm water ports, as that should be obvious to most students of Russian History. Why Nicholas I? Why him and why then or was it simply opportunism?

4 Answers 2014-03-02

How is a historiography written?

what exactly is a historiography and how do historians write them?

4 Answers 2014-03-02

How did American slave traders acquire African slaves? Did African leaders provide their citizens to the traders? If so, are they equally culpable?

1 Answers 2014-03-02

Were slaves in the U.S ever made to construct something that still stands today?

8 Answers 2014-03-02

Why did no outside force intervene in the Soviet invasions of Czechoslovakia in 1968 or Hungary in 1956?

These seem (on the surface) similar to the existing Russian invasion of the Crimea, but what factors prevented NATO/Western involvement?

1 Answers 2014-03-02

Been reading Jane Austen's Emma; How common was it in the Regency Era to associate with those in other social classes?

In the novel, Emma is best friends with an orphan. Her governess marries a rich, older man and Frank Churchill, rich and handsome, marries a poor governess-to-be. I've always thought that this would be looked down upon at the time, but Austen's book seems to shirk that.

On another note, Emma is very independent and claims to never desire marriage. Was this independence not seen as unusual for that time?

1 Answers 2014-03-02

Wars that turned out how someone intended

Wars seem to be the ultimate throw of the dice. My own feeble knowledge covers, it seems, only wars that have ultimately surprised all participants.

Are there any wars that turned out how one of the participants planned? Policy actually successfully implemented through violence.

If there are reasons why they were able to do this, it would be interesting to know why too.

1 Answers 2014-03-02

What contributed to the Italian military's poor performance in Greece during World War II?

1 Answers 2014-03-02

7034 / 7255

Back to start