In the scope of Islamic insurrection, how much did World War 1 change the game? How is that influence still felt today?

I am currently reading Scott Anderson's "Lawrence in Arabia", a terrific book so far.

In it, a part of Germany's strategy in the war was to create Islamic insurrection in the Near East. At worst, the other European powers are given another headache to worry about. At best, the Suez Canal is destroyed and supply lines are cut off.

How much did Germany's actions during the war affect Islamic upheaval in the course of history? And if it wasn't for Germany's manipulation, would we have as much Islamic upheaval today?

1 Answers 2014-02-05

Did professional assassins exist in medieval Europe? If so, where would they be trained? How would one become an assassin?

4 Answers 2014-02-05

How did Napoleonic era Naval Officers stay fit?

From reading the delightful historical fiction novels of Forrester and O'Brian I've noticed the naval officers (Midshipmen, Lieutenants, and even Captains) regularly lead raids into enemy territory as well as cutting-out and boarding operations. How did these officers maintain the level of physical fitness necessary to accomplish these tasks? It seems they did not do manual labour like the enlisted men - did they exercise instead?

1 Answers 2014-02-05

Questions about the Ancient Greek Economy

I've been looking to get a more finely-textured view of the ancient Mediterranean economy, particularly in the Hellenic period, but not exclusively. The FAQ has lots of questions about ancient Greece, but surprisingly few that deal explicitly with economy. So, here we go:

  • What was the basis for the ancient Greek economy? What were the main productive units? Family farms, large estates, market-driven plantations? I know that barley and livestock were major products--from the excellent question about Greek food earlier today--but did they have to import food? How important was fish in their diets?

  • Materials: What were the main building materials? Was wood a scarce commodity (reserved for ships, perhaps)? Were stone or marble common for buildings other than large monuments and public structures? Were iron and bronze in widespread use, or reserved for military purposes? I assume that wool and leather were their main cloth-like materials; were there others?

  • Currency and banking: Is it roughly true that each city minted their own coins, while Athenian currency was sort of a default standard? What metals did they use? Where did the minerals come from?

  • Internal divisions of labor: How was labor divided within the family and/or polis? Were there certain jobs or professions reserved for men and women? How important was slavery? Do we have any good ideas what the slave-free demographics were?

  • External divisions of labor: We know that maritime trade was important, but exactly what was being traded? Different regions must have produced or specialized in different things, or else there's not much point in trading, right?

Sorry for so much, but I've been looking for good sources on Greek economy for my students, and most of what I find is quite limited. I'd love a sort of general overview, but sources specific to particular aspects would also be wonderful.

Also, finally: One Big Question that I think would be useful and that might help guide answers is this: Does it make sense to think of the ancient Greek world as a "Free Market"?

4 Answers 2014-02-05

Were there linguistics prescriptivists in Ancient Rome?

I'm entertained by the idea of Cicero waggling his finger at the stylistic "errors" of lesser speakers and writers.

1 Answers 2014-02-05

Could Native Americans be considered communists?

I overheard somebody say that this weekend and thought "oh that's goofy, I'll post it to /r/badhistory. Then they said I had to have proof it's bad history, so after a quick google search I couldn't find anything. So was the guy actually right or is he as stupid as I thought?

2 Answers 2014-02-05

Why didn't the german destroy auschwitz at the end of WW2?

A workmate asked me that today...

The question is - auschwitz is a smoking gun for the nazis' cruelty, why didn't they bother to destory it before the allies have arrived?

1 Answers 2014-02-05

Why would Jesus's followers make a religion after they knew their God was dead?

2 Answers 2014-02-05

How common were spies in Medieval Europe? How were they recruited? What was their general duty? Are there any cases of double agents?

2 Answers 2014-02-05

When did the religious class in Iran form?

As user Keyilan mentioned in the recent AMA on early and medieval Islam, Islam does not really have a religious class. But Iran seems to be the exception.

From my own knowledge, it seems like this class has existed since the Qajar era.

When did this class form? When did this class become politically powerful?

1 Answers 2014-02-05

How was cavalry armed at the start of World War I

Watching the film war horse recently, it depicted British cavalry armed with Swords and Pistols for the Officers. I had thought that all British servicemen would have carried Rifles even the cavalry.

So at the beginning of the war what would the typical cavalry soldier be armed with?

1 Answers 2014-02-05

What drives an arms race?

Any book recommendations would be appreciated.

1 Answers 2014-02-05

If I lived in the times of kings and queens of Europe, what job could I have taken that would have allowed me to raise a happy family no matter who took power?

1 Answers 2014-02-05

Can anyone tell me about this?

I have some type of document from the cold war period. Its entirely in Russian so I'm not sure what it says. It was found on an old soviet submarine. I can post pics if you want me to. Thanks!

1 Answers 2014-02-05

Did building a snowman have any kind of documented cultural origin, or was it just a spontaneous thing we started doing one day?

2 Answers 2014-02-05

Before the system broke down, how effective was enforcement of the parole system in the American Civil War?

As far as I can tell, the American Civil War was one of the last major wars where prisoners could reasonably expect to be paroled shortly following their capture (although I've read of limited uses as late as World War II). For instance, I've been reading about the Gettysburg Campaign, and during Stuarts raiding in late June, he captures a wagon train, and paroles the prisoners that same day.

So anyways, parole was basically a promise not to rejoin the fight. Make that promise, and you can go on your way. But I know that this promise wasn't always kept, since I've read explicit references to various men who were paroled and returned to their units immediately. I know that there were exchanges of names to end parole, but did this actually account for all returnees?

So what I'm wondering is, how frequent was this reneging on parole? Did no one abide by it, or was it generally respected?

If you did rejoin, and were captured again, assuming you weren't a notable officer, what were the chances it would be discovered you had not respected the promise of parole, given the lack of modern computer databases?

If you were found out, what fate awaited you? Imprisonment? Execution? Or just a "comon', actually go home this time" as they parole you a second time?

1 Answers 2014-02-05

Wednesday What's New in History

Previous Weeks

This weekly feature is a place to discuss new developments in fields of history and archaeology. This can be newly discovered documents and archaeological sites, recent publications, documents that have just become publicly available through digitization or the opening of archives, and new theories and interpretations.

So, what's new this week?

4 Answers 2014-02-05

Did Ukraine hold a referendum on joining the EU?

Ok this is rather more recent history,but still, I belive what we are seeing is history in the making now. I belive all countries wich joined or wanted to join the EU held a referendum beforehand. But I don't recall hearing this happening in Ukraine. Why?And did it also happen to other countries that they joined the EU without the population voting on it?

1 Answers 2014-02-05

Confucianism and China

How did Confucianism contribute to the stagnation of Chinese society when especially compared to the West?

If Confucianism was not responsible, why did China stagnate so much?

2 Answers 2014-02-05

Were all of the buildings on the Athenian Acropolis painted?

I am doing a presentation for my world history class on the topic of the Acropolis, and I would like to include images of how the buildings would have really looked (i.e. brightly painted and decorated). I have found a few representations of the Parthenon and how it probably looked but I am having trouble finding anything concerning other buildings such as the Temple of Athena Nike, the Propylaea, the Erechtheion, etc. Would they have been painted like the Parthenon and are there any representations of them? Any help would be greatly appreciated. Thanks!

1 Answers 2014-02-05

What happened to the French soldiers after Germany took over France in ww2?

We're they held as prisoners, executed, or did they have to join the German military?

1 Answers 2014-02-05

Why are New York and London the global centers of finance?

Is there a well-understood historical reason for this? Why not Paris or Boston or Lisbon or Alexandria or Rome or any number of other large, important cities?

4 Answers 2014-02-05

If I'm a Medieval German king, how would I go about forging an alliance with a neighboring kingdom?

1 Answers 2014-02-05

Was there ever a "Final Solution" planned for the Japanese in WWII?

I know this sounds crazy, but hear me out.

There was a significant level of exterminationist sentiment among Americans towards the Japanese (10-20% of Americans thought that all Japanese should be killed). Many US military leaders used genocidal language ("Kill all Japs", etc.). But people say a lot of things and the war in the Pacific was particularly brutal, so this was probably just tempers running high. But the US military also plans for lots of contingencies that never occur. For example, I've heard we had plans in case we get invaded by Canada (this may be apocryphal but you get the point).

So, my question is: Did the US military ever plan for the contingency that the Japanese would never surrender and would "need" to be exterminated?

1 Answers 2014-02-05

What was the typical diet of someone living in Ancient Greece?

what would you eat for breakfast, lunch, supper if you were...

a peasant

middle class (merchant)

wealthy upper class

nobility

Do Greeks today eat any of their dishes?

3 Answers 2014-02-05

7129 / 7255

Back to start