Did anybody notice when different dialects of Latin became mutually unintelligible?

With Catholic mass being held in Latin, would churchgoers ever think "Wow, this is a really outdated way of talking"? Or similarly, would the priests and monks that actually knew Latin lament the divergence of local language? Was there ever any pushback to re-standardize the language?

1 Answers 2021-05-10

Would Jesus have ever had ice in his drinks?

Would people living in warm parts of the world thousands of years ago have experience or knowledge of ice or snow? Would ice be something completely indescribable to Jesus?

1 Answers 2021-05-10

After the fall of the Habsburg Empire, the Czechs and Slovaks were amalgamated into a single state, Czechoslovakia, rather than immediately forming individual nation-states. Why? What was the historical context behind the formation of Czechoslovakia?

As I understand it, the Kingdom of Bohemia and Slovakia under the Kingdom of Hungary would have been administered separately, not to mention that until the 16th century Hungary itself was independent. Was there any sort of "national consciousness" transcending these boundaries? How did the two ethnic groups see themselves in comparison to each other and the outside world?

1 Answers 2021-05-10

if Pytheas the Ancient Greek visited the Arctic, how did a guy in a toga not freeze to death?

1 Answers 2021-05-10

Why didn't the Romans build castles?

1 Answers 2021-05-09

Why did no major trade city develop at the mouth of the Danube river?

The computer game Europa Universalis made me realize that many of the great trade cities of the world are located at the mouths/estuaries/deltas of major rivers, and nearly every major river has an entrepot at or near the mouth, from New Orleans on the Mississipi to Lisbon on the Tajus to Hamburg on the Rhine, Alexandria on the Nile, Calcutta on the Ganges and Hong Kong on the Pearl. I gather this is because they can serve as a port for goods to change from riverboat to ocean ships, as well as fortifications to defend the river and outposts for levying taxes. The Danube is one of the most important rivers in Europe, passing through productive lands, and draining a large floodplain. Why did no major city form at the mouth? Is the terrain too marshy? The harbour poorly protected? Was it vulnerable to raids from seafarers? Was the river too long for viable trade, and the Black Sea too distant and closed off to bother shipping into? Am I being too geographically determinist about a fundamentally organic and stochastic process, seeking a just-so explanation about complex, contingent historical forces that can't be explained in a falsifiable, scientific way?

Do any of these factors apply to the mouth of the Amazon or the Yellow rivers to explain more broadly where trade cities arise or don't?

3 Answers 2021-05-09

Best books on ancient Egypt? Anything helps, religion, culture, history, etc.

I just need some recommendations on some books on ancient Egypt

1 Answers 2021-05-09

Why was there no “deconfederitization” in the U.S. following the civil war, like there was “denazification” in Germany post ww2?

2 Answers 2021-05-09

Let’s say I’m a poor farmer in Spain during the 1600’s, and I decide I want to move to the New World in hope of becoming rich. What would the process be like?

1 Answers 2021-05-09

It’s common to hear about such medical practices as blood letting and using mercury for illness. Is there a general time period where doctors started to overall do more good than harm?

This could just be an assumption that there was a lot of guesswork involved in Western medicine up until a certain time period.

1 Answers 2021-05-09

To what extent did the Communists in Czechoslovakia help facilitate the transition of power during the Velvet Revolution

I realize that especially the second part of the question moves a bit into conspiracy theory, if that's not acceptable for this sub, please feel free to remove this question or tell me to remove it.

I was reading up some on the Velvet Revolution of 1989 in Czechoslovakia on Wikipedia (yeah, I know..) and two bits caught my attention (emphasis mine):

(19th November) Members of a civic initiative met with the Prime Minister, who told them he was twice prohibited from resigning his post and that change requires mass demonstrations like those in East Germany (some 250,000 students). He asked them to keep the number of "casualties" during the expected change to a minimum.

Now this really sounds like he is already accepting that the Civic Forum will prevail and even trying to facilitate an orderly transition himself. And this is on 19th November, only 2 days after the students' demonstration was attacked by the riot police. Still on the 23rd the military was said to inform the regime of "of its readiness to act".

Later on, the Wikipedia article even says (this is the conspiracy part):

Some, including highly regarded KGB defector Anatoliy Golitsyn and Czech dissident Petr Cibulka, claim the revolution was a plot by the KGB and related groups and political figures. According to such critics, the KGB instigated and used the revolution both to expand its power and to move Czech society away from Communist rule in a controlled manner that preserved KGB control over it.[citation needed]

Now, I understand that Petr Cibulka is considered to be a fringe figure today, but still.

So what I'm wondering is:

  • can we tell today to what extent did either the regime in Czechoslovakia or in the USSR understand that they are done for when things got into motion, based on what happened in Poland, East Germany or Hungary?
  • is there any evidence of quid pro quo between the Civic Forum and the communists?

Thank you!

1 Answers 2021-05-09

Is History a science?

I recently had an argument with a friend of mine on whether or not History is a science, their argument for it is that they think that History is just made up of opinions, and they also think that History does not use mathematics like other sciences do.

2 Answers 2021-05-09

According to books I read as a child, the 1857 Rebellion in India was sparked by the use of pig and cow fat in the grease for rifle cartridges, offending Muslim and Hindu troops, respectively. Were these greases used? Did they cause controversy? And how significant was it in kicking things off?

If the use of such greases was indeed not actual fact, how did the story about the grease ingrain itself so effectively in narratives of the period? Did British writers use it as a convenient means to dismiss deeper structural causes?

2 Answers 2021-05-09

Why was firing squad developed as a means of execution, instead of just one person with a gun doing the execution?

I can't find anything on this.

Back when there was beheading of guillotine, an executioner would perform the execution.

When a firing squad was introduced, there is now multiple executioners.

Why is this? The only rational explanation I can think of is that it was so those people doing the execution would be unable to confirm who did the killing blow, thus they would have an easier conscience.

Thanks.

2 Answers 2021-05-09

Why did America prioritize ending the war in the European theater more so than in Asia during WW2?

I've seen this claimed by multiple historians, but never really explained why. It's particularly confusing to me since it was Japan that attacked the U.S., not Germany.

1 Answers 2021-05-09

What were the weapons used by Boxers during Boxer rebellion?

Just 55 Days at Peking and the rebels in the film are depicted as using swords, spears and clubs as weapons. Considering the fact Chinese people invented gunpowder and used gunpowder cannons, bombs, mechanical landmines and arquebus since the Ming Dynasty, the movie appeared inaccurate for me. But I could not find any source too.

What weapons Boxers used in the Boxer rebellion? Thank you.

1 Answers 2021-05-09

Do most historians believe the Mycenaeans were Greeks?

I've seen theories that they may have been more closely related to either the Minoans or the Indo-European peoples who inhabited Anatolia at the time; hence their collapse was due to invasion by Greek-speaking peoples.

1 Answers 2021-05-09

Why did the Bolsheviks kill the whole Russian Imperial family, esp. the children, instead of sending them into exile? By 20th century standards this seems unnecessarily cruel.

1 Answers 2021-05-09

How were clocks set in the middle ages?

Wikipedia states that by the eleventh century clocks were regularly encountered in towns. But watches were developed much later.

How did they make sure the time displayed or sounded by the clocks were correct and synchronized?

Did they have tables to set them by the sun, or were they only set twice a year at equinox?

Or maybe someone from a major city would travel with a set of hourglasses?

Or would they just go buy gut, as it wasn't really necessary to know the precise time?

Thanks for any answer in advance.

1 Answers 2021-05-09

Is "Shipping" a product of modern fandom culture on the internet, or did it exist within as a phenomenon within fan circles for popular media in the pre-internet 20th century?

2 Answers 2021-05-09

Cargo: How was it transported by sea?

Time period is the 17th-18th century.

When talking about trade ships, the image one gets is a cargo hold stuffed full of barrels. Were barrels really the dominant form of storage, regardless of the goods being transported? Were they standardized in terms of shape and size like modern-day shipping containers for ease of handling and storage? Or were there different containers for different uses?

1 Answers 2021-05-09

When I look at maps of Napoleon’s conquests, it seems he mostly set up a system of puppet states to run Europe for him..... except for modern day Croatia, which he ran directly. Why?

This is what I’m referring to.

3 Answers 2021-05-09

When the policy switch with the Republicans and the Democrats on racial policy took place did voters immediately abandon their traditional party or was the voter switch gradual?

There are a lot of stubborn people in the world, so were there significant numbers of people that said ‘I’ve always voted this way so I’m going to keep doing it’ despite parties not being representative of them any more?

2 Answers 2021-05-09

Is it possible that Jesus may be an amalgamation of different preachers from that era?

I know that there was a historical Jesus, but did one person say and do everything that was attributed to him in the Bible, or could the Biblical Jesus be an amalgamation of different men? I saw someone speculate on that recently and it intrigued me.

1 Answers 2021-05-09

Sunday Digest | Interesting & Overlooked Posts | May 09, 2021

Previous

Today:

Welcome to this week's instalment of /r/AskHistorians' Sunday Digest (formerly the Day of Reflection). Nobody can read all the questions and answers that are posted here, so in this thread we invite you to share anything you'd like to highlight from the last week - an interesting discussion, an informative answer, an insightful question that was overlooked, or anything else.

3 Answers 2021-05-09

715 / 7255

Back to start