I've heard that many aspects of religions and rituals masked healthy practices (such as hand washing or eating better prepared meat), to what extent is this true?

1 Answers 2014-01-29

If World War 2 hadn't happened, what would the world look like today?

2 Answers 2014-01-29

What would a medieval city guard/night watch actually do?

To be specific, what would guards in a city in either: Western Europe, Southern Europe, or the Middle East do ca. 1100-1600? What were their duties?

1 Answers 2014-01-29

Have any athletes ever perished during the Olympic Games?

If so, when? Were their deaths televised? What was the reaction in their home country?

1 Answers 2014-01-29

As the Ottoman Empire expanded its territory further and further into Europe in the 15th-17th centuries, was there a sense of existential dread or fear that they were unstoppable or would conquer the rest of Christendom?

I was thinking particularly in the case of the high-water mark of their conquests, as they approached Vienna itself before they were eventually repulsed in 1683 and their European conquests began to be gradually lost.

I can imagine that in Vienna itself the mood would obviously be quite dire, but what about in other parts of Christendom? What did kings and nobles or peasants think in Rome, or Paris, or London, or throughout the rest of the Holy Roman Empire, if they thought anything at all? Was the Ottoman threat a distant one to them, something they probably just didn't see as likely to ever affect them? Or did any of them have great fear that they might be next in falling to the empire's conquests?

4 Answers 2014-01-29

What changes would we see in the U.S. if congress passed everything Obama wanted? How would things be different today?

2 Answers 2014-01-29

Has martial law ever been instated without civilian resistance?

1 Answers 2014-01-29

Films like Saving Private Ryan depict the horror of amphibious landings. What would be the process for treating casualties from the first few waves of these assaults?

In the modern world, injured troops would be evacuated by helicopter as soon as it was safe to land one. What would the process have been during D-Day or in the Pacific campaign of the Second World War. Obviously medics and corpsman would be the first line of aid for troops, but what would be the process from there, and how quickly could this be carried out?

This is somethin1g that occurred to me today and got me curious. Thanks so much

1 Answers 2014-01-29

Are people today more desensitized towards death than people in the past?

1 Answers 2014-01-29

Why did South Africa need a nuclear weapon and why did they dismantle them?

It makes sense why Britain and France, China and the other members of the nuclear club. But why South Africa? I might be wrong but it seems that they have no major powers in the region.

3 Answers 2014-01-29

The game Crusader Kings is expanding into India. In an interview, one of their designers says "(Medieval India) is such a pluralistic and tolerant society for its time" and "They were used to living together... for a thousand years, basically, in more-or-less peace." Seems suspect. Is this true?

For reference, here is the article I'm citing from.

Here's a secondary link with more detail.

EDIT: From the full context quote, "The really cool thing about India is that it's such a pluralistic and tolerant society for its time," says Fåhraeus. "Even in these medieval times with the holy warring going on in the rest of the world, these three old religions of india, the Jain, the Buddhists and the Hindus. They were used to living together, and had been living together for a thousand years, basically, in more-or-less peace."

I don't know much about Indian history, but I know if anyone made this generalization about Rome (or its opposite generalization, that the Mediterranean was living together for a thousand years in more-or-less war), my eyebrows would instantly be raised, and I would flag the claim as suspect and overgeneralized.

Or, can the claim be made that this is exactly how Medieval India was? Or is there the possibility that you can make the claim dependent upon how you frame the scale of war and piece in the region?

I was wondering if this is overgeneralization, orientalism, or in fact an arguable truth at its core.

9 Answers 2014-01-29

Were all US astronauts military officers on active duty up to some point? When did this change, and why?

1 Answers 2014-01-29

What's New in History Wednesday

Previous Weeks

This weekly feature is a place to discuss new developments in fields of history and archaeology. This can be newly discovered documents and archaeological sites, recent publications, documents that have just become publicly available through digitization or the opening of archives, and new theories and interpretations.

So, what's new this week?

4 Answers 2014-01-29

Is there an average decay time for states/civilizations?

1 Answers 2014-01-29

When and why did Irish, Poles, Italians, and other nominally white minorities get a race-lift to White?

EDIT: Aaaaand I just took a second look at the FAQ and realized that this question, or one much like it, is on that list. Whoops...

As I understand it, at one point in the US immigrants from Ireland, Poland, Italy, and other places in Europe were heavily discriminated against. But at some point, apparently in the last hundred years, most of the discrimination has disappeared and these demographics have been promoted to White or Anglo or WASP or whatever you want to call it.

When did that happen? How did that happen? Why?

I'm curious because it seems like it has a lot of relevance to the Civil Rights movement and, by extension, pretty much the entire history of America in the 20th century. But I really don't know or understand much about it.

Help me /r/AskHistorians! You're my only hope!

3 Answers 2014-01-29

How did people survive battles pre-gunpowder. Was it simply a meat grinder sort of deal where everyone at the front of the line died?

I'm not sure if this is too vague a question. I suppose it might have varied from battle to battle, century to century. But still I don't quite understand how two armies would come together and in some instances one army win so decisively . eg The battle of Agincourt or Cannae (tactics aside how were the troops in the smaller armies not be overwhelmed?) Cheers.

1 Answers 2014-01-29

What were the ranks and titles in the East India Company?

I can find titles such as Governor-General and Chairman, and there are physical embarkation lists available which include ranks and salaries, which I could go to the British Library and dig up, but I'm hoping for a quicker answer! I was wondering if anyone, by any chance, had a comprehensive list of employee titles to hand?! Were there some military and non-military ranks and titles?

1 Answers 2014-01-29

What was the purpose of the spiked finial on the tops of Pickelhaube helmets used by Germans in WW1?

1 Answers 2014-01-29

Did Jews leading up to the birth of Jesus (and perhaps Christians in the following centuries) believe the Genesis creation story to be literally true?

I hope this isn't too broad or an unanswerable question, but heres a little back story on why I'm asking this:

So last summer I started reading a bit of Genesis for the first time from the Torah. Now this particular Torah was in both English and Hebrew and had an extensive compilation of footnoted commentary from Jewish and Rabbinical scholars stretching back hundreds of years. I don't have the passage in question in front of me but from what I remember it said basically this: the Torah was written as a book of laws, as such the opening of Genesis involving the creation of the Earth is not to be taken literally, but as an expression of God's supreme authority over the universe and the laws he's passed down to the Jewish people.

So given this, did anyone take the Genesis story to be literally true? Would Christians in the first few centuries of C.E. be taught this sort of interpretation?

2 Answers 2014-01-29

Were any mainstream actors out of a job when mainstream film included audio because they had weird voices?

3 Answers 2014-01-29

How much of an effect did walled cities have on combat in WW2?

What sort of role did the medieval and early-modern era fortifications and citadels that were part of cities in Europe play when those cities became contested during the war? Did they play any part in the defence of said city, and if so, how effective were they at holding back attacking forces?

(P.S mainly directed at the eastern front, and the urban combat in places such as Poznan.)

2 Answers 2014-01-29

Medieval Naval Warfare in the Mediterranean Sea

I have found a lot of info on Naval battles in the north sea and ancient times, but I was wondering how it was different in the Mediterranean.

What were the typical naval tactics and ships used in Mediterranean?

Let's go with 1275-1350 A.D. as the time period.

2 Answers 2014-01-29

Why do English speakers spell the names of Italian cities differently than Italians?

e.g. Venice vs Venezia, Florence vs Firenze, etc. We don't do this for any other countries with Latin or Germanic-based languages, do we? So then why Italy?

2 Answers 2014-01-29

Did the Romans think of their gods as Roman gods, or as gods period? (In other words: when the Romans imposed their gods on conquered peoples, was this part of how they imposed Roman supremacy? Or could one worship the Roman gods without reference to Rome -- a universal religion, like Christianity?)

5 Answers 2014-01-29

When and why did the standard and phillips head screws both come to be as our two standard screws?

I'm sure I could have phrased that question better, regardless...

I'm curious why both of these screws exist simultaneously. They're both popular, but one of these has got to be easier to manufacture than the other, right? And wouldn't it be preferable to have only one type? And, yes, of course there are other screw types such as the star, and others, but they aren't as common. So tell me Historians, is there an interesting story to all of this? Bonus points if you tell me why it's called a "Phillips" head. (I assume it's the inventor.)

1 Answers 2014-01-29

7154 / 7255

Back to start