Just saw '12 Years a Slave'... great movie, but I have a question...

In the beginning of the film, Soloman is a free man. He appears to have all the rights, privileges, respect, upward mobility and protections as his white counterparts. How historically accurate is that representation? I guess my question is, for not just Soloman Northrup, but also other free men of that time, what was it really like for them? Did they have an "equality" of sorts? Please help me grow into a better person by expanding my knowledge of history. See the movie, it's really good. (On a related side note, what kind of violin strings existed in the 1850's?)

2 Answers 2014-01-19

Help! Who's this picture for ?

1 Answers 2014-01-19

Who decided the duration of an hour, minute, and second?

Whose idea was it to split the day into intervals and decided the duration of each interval? Also how did the units for time become so universal? The hour, minute, and second are the only units to be used by every country in the world. How did this idea spread, or did every civilization come up with it on their own?

1 Answers 2014-01-19

Why did the United States fight in Vietnam? What was so terrible about communism in their eyes?

3 Answers 2014-01-19

Book recommendations on post-WWII reconstruction in Europe (West and East)?

I'm doing research for a potential thesis topic involving 20th century Poland, and am trying to get a handle on how Europe dealt with the consequences of the war (rebuilding of cities/economies/societies, emotional trauma/amnesia, the handling of war crimes, executions/expelling of minorities), and how things progressed politically (how the immediate postwar circumstances escalated into the Cold War, and what things were like behind the Iron Curtain).

I'm interested in both Western and Eastern Europe, but know next-to-nothing about the Eastern side of the story and so would love some more background information. I suppose essentially what I'm looking for are cultural and/or political histories of this period, both general and specific.

Postwar by Tony Judt, Under A Cruel Star, and Bloodlands are currently on my 'to-read' list, but are there any others I could add?

1 Answers 2014-01-19

Why were the HMS Terror and Erebus so poorly outfitted for the Franklin Expedition?

While researching the letters of Lady Franklin I came across sources claiming that the expedition had left Britain with spoiled food. It was also noted that the expeditions carried with it a large number of books and even a grand piano, seemingly taking up a large amount of usable space. What caused the ship to be outfitted in such a way that retroactively seems so poor for survival?

1 Answers 2014-01-19

How did people light cigarettes and other flammables before matches came out?

I read that the first match was invented in 1826. Historically that is pretty recent. So how did people light things such as cigarettes, torches and other things that needed lighting before that time?

3 Answers 2014-01-19

What would be a phenomenal book on Alexander the great and that time period, for someone who is college educated on the subject.

1 Answers 2014-01-18

What is the history of Veterinary Medicine?

Where did the profession of veterinary medicine come from? Can its roots be traced to that of 'human' doctors? Who would one take sick animals to before the professionalization of Veterinary Medicine?

1 Answers 2014-01-18

How did Europe develop Capitalism?

What were the factors that caused this, and why did it happen?

1 Answers 2014-01-18

Why is it that casinos are so prominent in modern Native American (American Indian?) culture?

1 Answers 2014-01-18

you know in cowboy movies everybody has a hand gun. How common was hand gun ownership in the USA of the 1890s?

5 Answers 2014-01-18

Did ancient Romans know that copper pipes would keep the people healthier?

Copper has antimicrobial properties.

Did the ancient Romans notice the health benefit or did they have other reasons for chosing copper for their pipes?

1 Answers 2014-01-18

Was the battle of Stalingrad fought primarily for propaganda purposes or for strategic purposes, or a combination of both? Basically, was it wise for either side to throw a ~million casualties into the city?

It seems the wiki entry on the battle leaves the question open to debate with this quote:

On July 23, 1942, Hitler personally rewrote the operational objectives for the 1942 campaign, greatly expanding them to include the occupation of the city of Stalingrad. Both sides began to attach propaganda value to the city based on it bearing the name of the leader of the Soviet Union. It was assumed that the fall of the city would also firmly secure the northern and western flanks of the German armies as they advanced on Baku with the aim of securing these strategic petroleum resources for Germany.[15]:p.528

4 Answers 2014-01-18

Are any narrative or opinionated views of histories accepted in academia?

Whiggish, Marxist, Hegelian, religious, essientally any history with a narrative or looking through the lens of a viewpoint seems to be very much rejected (see Howard Zinn).

Are there any acceptable historians, histories, or history books with a very strong bent accepted?

I want to figure the historian's consensus on these issues because just looking through this sub and /r/badhistory it seems as if 98% of what commoners believe about history is full of shit, 100% of what libertarians (Paul style or chomsky style) is full or shit, 85% of history books are full of shit, 75% of what's in non college textbooks is full of shit, 95% of what atheist believe about the history of Islam and Christianity is full of shit, and history believed by ideologues (hitchens, chomsky, etc) is 60-75% full of shit. What all of these things have in common is that they have a strong religious or ideological bent and want history to conform to it. Is this why post- modern, post-structuralist, post-post, anti "presentist", nihilist relativist about everything style-histories are the most popular here and in academia? Or are opinionated, moral (praising or indignant), narrative or meta narrative histories that stand their ground against post modernist ideas?

1 Answers 2014-01-18

Was the katana as high quality as people say it is?

Also, are there any examples of "better" swords?

1 Answers 2014-01-18

Could the UK have kept Hong Kong?

I was reading about the handover and how Britain had a lease on New Territories but held Hong Kong island outright, ie with no agreement to hand back after 99 years.

So, could the UK have given back New Territories but kept the island of Hong Kong and if so, why did they give it all back?

1 Answers 2014-01-18

What happened to the Allied force that landed in Russia during the Russian Civil War?

2 Answers 2014-01-18

Were slaves ever prostituted in the United States?

1 Answers 2014-01-18

How did things go down with the Paris Commune?

I'm planning on writing an Alternate History story revolving around it, and it would be eminently helpful to know how things happened in the original timeline when writing a new one. Also, is there anything you would suggest as reading for this?

2 Answers 2014-01-18

What is the origin of the sport football (soccer) and its name?

I read somewhere that the origin of the name football was because of the diameter of the ball was 1 foot (1ft). I wanted to look on the internet for more about this claim but is unable to.

there are various different sources being cited, but all of them are conflicting, ultimately saying that we cannot determine the true origin of the sport.

Is that true?

1 Answers 2014-01-18

Why didn't the Japanese destroy the Pearl Harbor oil storage?

I have read that the US Navy maintained a large oil storage facility at Pearl Harbor, about 6 months supply for the Pacific fleet. If this had been destroyed, fleet operations would have been severely restricted for months. Did the Japanese consider that this might have higher value than some other targets, and why did they decide not to attack the oil field?

1 Answers 2014-01-18

How much of a dent did Australian forces inflict upon the Japanese Navy/Army? Was it of war-changing significance or did they act as a merely auxiliary force to the U.S.?

Kind of a novice at this topic, so please forgive me if I'm insulting the Australians. It is not intended.

1 Answers 2014-01-18

Question about 17th century clothing

I'm in the middle of reading Albion's Seed, and Fisher quotes William Penn in the context of the simplicity of Quaker dress. Penn mentions "shoes and slip-slaps laced with silk or silver lace..." What in the world are slip-slaps? My Google-fu seems to be failing me. Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2014-01-18

Was anything like animal husbandry ever attempted on humans?

Slaves being the most obvious group, but I guess I don't want to limit my question. I knew slaves were sold at higher or lower prices according to physique and ability, but were there attempts to "breed out" unwanted traits like, say, aggressiveness?

1 Answers 2014-01-18

7192 / 7255

Back to start