Who chooses or how exactly does a knight obtain a coat of arms?

1 Answers 2014-01-04

Why did Japan not get split up after WWII?

Korea and Germany were split between US and Russia - Why did this not happen to Japan?

4 Answers 2014-01-04

I have read the Kingdom of France was "superior in feudal standing" to the Kingdom of England in the middle ages. How did other polities rank in this standing, and what would determine their place?

While researching the Royal Arms of England, I have read that Edward III of England placed the fleur-de-lis in the 1st and 4th quarters as France was "superior in feudal standing" to England, and thus its symbol was higher placed than the English three lions. Where did other major polities in this period rank? I assume the Holy Roman Empire was first, being an empire, but what about the Kingdoms of Castile, Portugal, Italy, Germany, Poland, Lithuania, Hungary etc? How commonly agreed was the list and what determined it? If it changed over time, I am most interested in the Hundred Years' War era.

1 Answers 2014-01-04

[Q] Casual writing hands 14c.-20c. (follow up from /r/calligraphy)

I am attempting to locate information regarding non-business, casual correspondence, and every-day writing styles. The sort of writing that would have been used for today's Post-It notes, grocery lists, and short letters to a close acquaintance.

So far popular hand progression is along the lines of: Spencarian(~1850-1925), Palmer method(~1894-1950), Zaner-Bloser(~1904-), Round Hand (England c. 17thC), Secretary (~1500-1600), Copperplate/English round(~1500-1800s), then D'Nealian cursive(~1978-).

I cannot find any record or mention of say, how to print legibly when writing home to your parents. I also have a hard time believing that someone would write a grocery list in Spencarian script.

What I am trying to find is what did the common person use to communicate while the upper society was using those calligraphic hands? In what hand did people write quick notes to themselves when style wasn't such a matter?

I am focusing on dates which are just before, and following, the distribution of the printed page, since literacy would no longer be reserved for royalty, and secular, persons. Any information between the years 1400 - 1900 would be helpful.

Thanks!

(*This had been previously submitted to /r/calligraphy with recommendations to submit here.)

[Edit1: I received a PM which pointed me towards: "The Universal Penman". c1743. George Bickham. Which looks fantastic for the mid 1700s reference!)

1 Answers 2014-01-04

Is there any way to determine how fast important news got around Europe in the 15th and 16th century? E.g. how long it took for the news of Columbus discoveries to reach other royal courts and/or scholars? Or other parts of the world like India/China/Japan? Months, years or decades?

1 Answers 2014-01-04

Pied-Noir, Algerian and Harki Memoirs.

Could anyone point me in the direction of any published material that looks at memoirs of pied-noirs and/or Harkis that left or even remained in Algeria post-1962? Similarly, if anyone could point me in the direction of any high profile cases of French and/or Algerian naturalisation? Any response will be greatly appreciated. Thank you!

1 Answers 2014-01-04

What does Aristotle have to do with Black History?

I have an assignment in my Black History class to do a presentation, the subject of which is Aristotle. We haven't talked about Aristotle in class, or even his time in history, so I'm trying to figure out what angle to come at this from.

I do not mean to ask to have my research don for me, I just want to understand how I might approach Aristotle from a Black History perspective.

Was Aristotle black?

Is he the proponent of slavery that he seems to be?

Am I missing something?

Thanks in advance for any direction you can provide!

3 Answers 2014-01-04

The Stalin Note and USSR proposal to join NATO. Were they serious, and if so, how were those viewed on both sides ?

So, a comic popped up in a subreddit (edit because the mods of the subreddit in question asked me to remove the link to the subreddit and comic). I didn't know or remember anything about those events, so after reading a bit about it, I have a few questions :

1 Answers 2014-01-04

I have ancient sword on which something is written in Arabic or Persian which I am not able to decode.I need help...I can send pics of that sword.

2 Answers 2014-01-04

Was the territory of Königsberg/Kaliningrad ever claimed by other nations or political groups after 1945?

1 Answers 2014-01-04

Which historical events caused Renaissance in Venice?

I can only find the Ottoman Empire being a trade partner of Venice to be an influential event.. Are there more events? Thanks in advantage

1 Answers 2014-01-04

In an AskScience thread, they discuss how music notation is mathematic in nature. Is there a direct correlation to the popularity of the 12-tone musical scale and the historic rise of calculus?

They both reached prominence mainly in the 17th-18th century and peaked during the Enlightenment.

Here's the AskScience explanation of how music is related to math.

1 Answers 2014-01-04

I always hear about how Northwest Pacific Indians had an interesting economic system. What was it actually like?

I know this subreddit is for detailed, in depth answers. This should be good. If I need to narrow it down, I would use the tlingit as the example.

2 Answers 2014-01-04

Is sleeping beside my charging cell phone then carrying it around in my front pocket every single day and night going to have negative radiation effects on me over the span of, essentially, a lifetime?

1 Answers 2014-01-04

Has the famous Hannibal "Cannae" maneuver been successfully done in modern times?

And has it ever been done where the victors were so out numbered? i.e. Hannibal: ~25K, Rome: ~90K. Losses on the Roman side were ~70K.

3 Answers 2014-01-04

When the Moors controlled Spain, was there much intermingling between the Spanish and the Moors? Were their many marriages between the two?

1 Answers 2014-01-04

Saturday Reading and Research | January 04, 2014

Previous

Today:

Saturday Reading and Research will focus on exactly that: the history you have been reading this week and the research you've been working on. It's also the prime thread for requesting books on a particular subject. As with all our weekly features, this thread will be lightly moderated.

So, encountered a recent biography of Stalin that revealed all about his addiction to ragtime piano? Delved into a horrendous piece of presentist and sexist psycho-evolutionary mumbo-jumbo and want to tell us about how bad it was? Need help finding the right book to give the historian in your family? Then this is the thread for you!

6 Answers 2014-01-04

How accurate is "Blackadder Goes Forth"?

The BBC TV comedy, Blackadder Goes Forth is a very widely known depiction of World War I from the British side.

I've heard that historians of the time consider it to offer a somewhat unhelpful perspective. What does it get right, and what does it get wrong?

(I was surprised not to find this mentioned on the wiki of common questions.)

4 Answers 2014-01-04

How was General Dumas (a black French general during the Revolutionary and Napoleonic wars) seen by the French and the other European nations at the time?

Do we also have examples of racist propaganda aimed against him or was his colour of skin not seen as such a big deal as it would have been in, say, mid 19th century America? Was the French population and French soldiers accepting of having a black general or are there examples of soldiers or officers refusing to serve under him?

1 Answers 2014-01-04

What was Byzantium's relationship with western Europe both immediately after the fall of the western empire and later on?

Sorry in advance if my question has numerous historical errors in it. I'm really not familiar with this period of history and would like to learn more. Also this is my first post, so I apologize if I say or do anything wrong.

What was western Europe's general perception of the eastern empire after the fall of the west? Were they glad to be rid of them? Did they feel abandoned? This goes for both people who would have been considered roman citizens immediately after the fall and the feudal states that would soon develop. Other than the ruins left behind, were people even aware Rome existed in a few generations? If so, did they see roman times as "The good old days" or as a weak, broken state they were glad to be rid of? Were they aware of its eastern continuation?

And what was Byzantium's view of the west? Were they happy to not have to deal with it anymore? Preferring their eastern territory and greek culture over the ways of the old western rome? Did they view them as territories that were rightly theirs and would eventually return to the fold? Were there any attempts to retake the old empire and how did the locals feel about it? Thanks in advance for the answers!

2 Answers 2014-01-04

I recently found that there are some (highly controversial) claims that Jesus (of christianity) was fathered by a Roman Legionary named Panthera/Pantera/Pandera. What is the modern perspective on this and if it's bogus, who do historians think was the real father?

I have searched the commonly asked questions and there doesn't appear to be anything on this particular issue.

In summary, what I'm asking:

  • What do modern historians think about the claims that Jesus was fathered by a Roman legionary with some variation on the name 'Pantera'?
  • What's the source of these claims? I've heard James Tabor cited Celsus, but I don't know anything about either. Are there any other sources? Are there any problems with the sources for this claim?
  • If Pantera wasn't the father, are there any other hypotheses on who was?

2 Answers 2014-01-04

What sort of government where the conspirators of the 20 July Plot to kill Hitler planning on implementing, and what were their plans for gaining peace with Nazi Germany's enemies and the territory they'd gained?

4 Answers 2014-01-04

What if Adolf Hitler has done things differently.

Update: Please do not comment. I have moved the post to the correct sub.

Let us consider a scenario where Hitler did not invade Poland and did not kill the Jews, instead focused on building army, technological advancements, roads, industries and created jobs for everyone. Basically equal opportunity regardless of race/religion. No alliance with Japan either.

In such a scenario USSR, US, UK, Germany and Japan would've always stayed in a state of cold-war, one waiting for the other to make a mistake. Do you think things would've been different ? Or we would've had WW2 no matter what.

Asked this question of /r/AskHistorians and I was redirected here.

1 Answers 2014-01-04

What would have happened if Adolf Hitler had done things differently < more in description>

1 Answers 2014-01-04

I am currently working on a thesis about Marcion of Sinope's Gospel of the Lord. Does anyone know if there is an English translation of Theodor Zahn's "Geschichte des neutestamentlichen kanons"?

If anyone could help me with finding a translation of the text, I would greatly appreciate it. I found one of his works with an English translation ("Introduction to the New Testament"); however, I have not found one for this article. I apologize if this is the incorrect subreddit to post my question: I am not certain of where else to post it. Thank you so much for your assistance.

Here is a link to the version I found, if that helps: http://books.google.com/books?hl=en&lr=&id=-SI2AQAAMAAJ&oi=fnd&pg=PA409&dq=theodor+Zahn&ots=9L3-8S-E1u&sig=sqPJnobhwdHLRxuZPOVeULUPgPo#v=onepage&q=theodor%20Zahn&f=false

2 Answers 2014-01-04

7243 / 7255

Back to start