Is Ronald Grigor Suny a trust worthy source?

I'm reading Stalin : Passage to revolution right now and this book hard core reads like it's singing stalins praises. I looked a bit into Suny and couldn't find much aside from some people saying hes a historical revisionist so I'm having trouble trusting this book. If he is untrustworthy what are some alternatives to this book that are more trust worthy

1 Answers 2021-04-29

What are some Millitary doctrine or field regulations manuals somewhere between napoleanic wars and ww1 era. Need for research.

So I've read fredrick the great on the art of war, articles on maneuver warfare, and air land war but I'm not sure if there is anything around turn of the 20 century that can be used for my research. I'm writing a book of a world were lack of resources has led to regression in technology but no break military thought or theory. I want to create a believable military structure. I was hoping there existed something like in air land war where roles and positions of different unit were given. I did some extensive study on artillery units and the crew names but then decided I didnt want regress far enough that flying batteries would still be viable. Even though I do love the idea of setting zachery Taylor's in a dystopian future. But anyway I just meant I now some structure and existed I just want to find a source to pull ideas from. Like was there an officer or nco who over saw the horses and what he called. Thank you. I'd hope maybe other would be interested in this type of thing and it's not posted in the wrong spot.

2 Answers 2021-04-29

Why did the City of New York (Manhattan) develop faster and more prosperously than Brooklyn or Staten Island?

If I understand correctly, what made New York City -- all five boroughs -- as wealthy as they are today is the natural harbor.

What I'm struggling to understand is why Manhattan was where people were drawn to. If the harbor is indeed the sell, why not Brooklyn or Staten Island, something closer to the ocean? Why sail a ship all the way into the harbor to Manhattan when you could stop in Bay Ridge, Staten Island, or even Long Island more quickly?

2 Answers 2021-04-29

How and when did the omelette became such a common food?

For example you have the Japanese Tamagoyaki, the Itallian Frittata, the french Omelette, Chinese Egg foo yung and all of them are variations of fried, beaten eggs. How did this happen?

1 Answers 2021-04-29

Japan and Germany alliance in WW2

I'm Japanese and never really got this part of history but was Japan secretly scared of Hitler and the Nazis and that's why the Japanese became Nazis? The reason I ask is because Japan is such a small country its hard to believe that they were any real threat to any nation? Also its pretty weird to me that Japan would join Hitler just to launch a suicide attack that made the USA join the war ?? Also I saw some information online that said Japan allied itself against the USA during WW2 because it was afraid that the USA was pushing democracy through the east and eventually to Japan itself, but after Japan lost the war and rebuilt itself its now one of the most Democratic and culturally "western" Asian country's around which is exactly the opposite of what japan wanted and the reason they were enemies with the united states ???

2 Answers 2021-04-29

How well did Black Americans integrate into Liberia in the 19th and early 20th century? How were they received by Native Liberians?

2 Answers 2021-04-29

What was Brittany's relationship to France in the middle ages? Is there a clear year where it became part of France or did it slowly merge? At what point was it unquestionably part of France?

I was trying to figure out the answer and I found these maps that would suggest that they merged in the 9th century. But then I was reading about various Conans of Brittany who seemed to be independent Dukes? What is the deal with this?

Merovingian dynasty - Merovingian dynasty - Wikipedia

Francia at the death of Pepin of Heristal, 714 - Charlemagne - Wikipedia

Carolingian empire 843 888 - Territorial evolution of France - Wikipedia

2 Answers 2021-04-29

From a modern perspective, the humor in Looney Tunes/Merrie Melodies seems to be far ahead of its time and more similar to modern surreal/absurdist humor than anything released in the 40s/50s. What was the contemporary reaction to it? Did audiences at the time understand it?

I grew up on Looney Tunes in the 90s and it always made sense when compared to other 90s/2000s cartoons like Spongebob and Animaniacs that make use of some really surreal humor, but looking back at it it's nothing like any other pieces of comedy between that and now. The timing and pacing of its jokes, the sharp satire, and absurdism don't really match Silly Symphonies (which it's obviously mocking) or any cartoons I've seen of that era.

Did audiences of the time really get "Yankee Doodle Daffy" or "Corny Concerto"? Were they perceived as silly children's cartoons, or did adults understand their satirical value?

1 Answers 2021-04-29

Mobutu gave an interview in which he said "we are not Europeans or westerners. We are bantus..., democracy can be applied, but not to the letter like in the West. Respect given to a chief is sacred". Did African dictators see themselves more as traditional chiefs and not servants of the people?

Link to the interview

To elaborate, I want to know how much did the concept of traditional chiefdoms play a role in the creation of dictatorships in Africa.

1 Answers 2021-04-29

"The Dutch East India Company (VOC) is the first multinational corporation." Is this statement accurate or anachronistic?

VOC is established in 17th century. In popular talk it has been described as the world's first multinational corporation (e.g. PBS). Considering capitalism changed from time to time - is the statement accurate or anachronistic? How close VOC was to MNCs we know today?

1 Answers 2021-04-29

Thursday Reading & Recommendations | April 29, 2021

Previous weeks!

Thursday Reading and Recommendations is intended as bookish free-for-all, for the discussion and recommendation of all books historical, or tangentially so. Suggested topics include, but are by no means limited to:

  • Asking for book recommendations on specific topics or periods of history
  • Newly published books and articles you're dying to read
  • Recent book releases, old book reviews, reading recommendations, or just talking about what you're reading now
  • Historiographical discussions, debates, and disputes
  • ...And so on!

Regular participants in the Thursday threads should just keep doing what they've been doing; newcomers should take notice that this thread is meant for open discussion of history and books, not just anything you like -- we'll have a thread on Friday for that, as usual.

8 Answers 2021-04-29

How was PTSD/battleshock perceived and dealt with in the ancient and medieval world? On the opposite foot, how were those warriors or leaders who had a lust for blood and warfare perceived?

1 Answers 2021-04-29

The British East India Company was one of the richest companies in human history. So why did it not end up using its riches to rebel against Great Britain and become a fully independent state during the 19th century?

1 Answers 2021-04-29

What is the difference between fascism and nazism.

Fascism and nazism seem to be used interchangeably, but are there any differences between these ideologies?

1 Answers 2021-04-29

When viewed with hindsight, the Finnish civil war was an absolute and partly incompetent disaster for the rebel side, yet there must have been a plan for it. What was it, how did the red side think they might win or capture power, and how and when did it go so horribly wrong?

As far as I know, the rebellion was a planned affair, and as with many failed rebellions. No one was really prepared for a civil war, it was supposed to be relatively bloodless and a quick coup, but I do not know almost anything about the offical plan of action so to speak. What was supposed to happen according to their plan when the red lantern was raised in Helsinki, 28th of January?

1 Answers 2021-04-29

How was fresh meat kept from spoiling before the invention of refrigeration?

1 Answers 2021-04-29

Japanese castles seem to be built as a series of layers of earth held in with retaining walls, whereas European castles tend to have freestanding walls even if built on a hill. What led to these styles of fortification design being so different? Was one markedly more labour-intensive than the other?

3 Answers 2021-04-29

Fake Christian relics seem to be quite prolific in Medieval Europe. What happened to them? Have any examples survived to the modern day?

1 Answers 2021-04-29

In the Satyricon, one of the dishes is "Ram's Vetches." Whats a Vetch?

I found some plants with that name but that doesn't seem right. Is it an older name for an animal part?

1 Answers 2021-04-29

Having booby-trapped temples and tombs seem to be a common movie trope, but do we know of cultures actually taking such step to protect their sacred grounds?

1 Answers 2021-04-29

If I was British in 1776, would I have been filled with rage to point of self sacrifice and join the army because the American colony wanted independence? Or was I compelled by other reasons?

1 Answers 2021-04-29

Primary source suggestions

What are some good free primary sources on the Silk Road(something like Zhang qian) and maybe about the spread of Buddhism and Hellenism?

1 Answers 2021-04-29

Why was there a rapid increase of English sports in France after the Franco-Prussian War?

After France was defeated in 1870, the country saw a huge spike in English sports. Why? Especially since both countries were not on the friendliest of terms at the time.

Why too we’re they English sports and not German sports?

Were there any further implications of the adoption of English sports for the country?

1 Answers 2021-04-29

Why did more East Germans attempt to cross the Berlin Wall instead of the Inner German Border?

I'm currently reading 'Checkpoint Charlie' by Iain MacGregor and there is one question that I have that is bothering me.

So West Berlin was effectively 'walled in' by the Berlin Wall. This kept people from East Berlin and East Germany from entering West Berlin, where they would be able to live freely (or fly/train from there to West Germany). My question is this: As the Berlin Wall was so heavily guarded, why didn't people in East Berlin (or East Germany more generally) just go to the border of East/West Germany...which I would assume is less heavily guarded given the length of the border? Or was the "Iron Curtain" border between East/West Germany just as heavily guarded and physically restrictive as the wall in Berlin? Did as many people make an attempt across this border as they did across the Berlin Wall? Why or why not?

Thanks in advance.

1 Answers 2021-04-29

The rise and fall of the Hippie Trail

In the sixties and seventies thousands of westerners travelled 'the overland' from Europe through the Middle East to India (and beyond).

I'm having trouble coming up with a single coherent question but if anyone could address any of the following:

  • Who were they?

  • Was there an inciting person or incident that started it off?

  • What were they looking for and did anyone find it?

  • Why did it end (Iranian revolution? Invasion of Afghanistan?)

  • Were there any long-term effects either "back home" or on the countries on the trail?

Thanks!

1 Answers 2021-04-29

729 / 7255

Back to start